G. Di Toro

Fault lubrication during earthquakes

The determination of rock friction at seismic slip rates (about 1 m s−1) is of paramount importance in earthquake mechanics, as fault friction controls the stress drop, the mechanical work and the frictional heat generated during slip. Given the difficulty in determining friction by seismological methods, elucidating constraints are derived from experimental studies. Here we review a large set of published and unpublished experiments (∼300) performed in rotary shear apparatus at slip rates of 0.1–2.6 m s−1. The experiments indicate a significant decrease in friction (of up to one order of magnitude), which we term fault lubrication, both for cohesive (silicate-built, quartz-built and carbonate-built) rocks and non-cohesive rocks (clay-rich, anhydrite, gypsum and dolomite gouges) typical of crustal seismogenic sources. The available mechanical work and the associated temperature rise in the slipping zone trigger a number of physicochemical processes (gelification, decarbonation and dehydration reactions, melting and so on) whose products are responsible for fault lubrication. The similarity between (1) experimental and natural fault products and (2) mechanical work measures resulting from these laboratory experiments and seismological estimates suggests that it is reasonable to extrapolate experimental data to conditions typical of earthquake nucleation depths (7–15 km). It seems that faults are lubricated during earthquakes, irrespective of the fault rock composition and of the specific weakening mechanism involved.

Coseismic recrystallization during shallow earthquake slip

Solidified frictional melts, or pseudotachylytes, remain the only unambiguous indicator of seismic slip in the geological record. However, pseudotachylytes form at >5 km depth, and there are many rock types in which they do not form at all. We performed low- to high-velocity rock friction experiments designed to impose realistic coseismic slip pulses on calcite fault gouges, and report that localized dynamic recrystallization may be an easy-to-recognize microstructural indicator of seismic slip in shallow, otherwise brittle fault zones. Calcite gouges with starting grain size −1 , and total displacements between 1 and 4 m. At coseismic slip velocities ≥0.1 m s −1 , the gouges were cut by reflective principal slip surfaces lined by polygonal grains 2 + CaO. The recrystallized calcite aggregates resemble those found along the principal slip surface of the Garam thrust, South Korea, exhumed from

Aseismic sliding of active faults by pressure solution creep: Evidence from the San Andreas Fault Observatory at Depth

Active faults in the upper crust can either slide steadily by aseismic creep, or abruptly causing earthquakes. Creep relaxes the stress and prevents large earthquakes from occurring. Identifying the mechanisms controlling creep, and their evolution with time and depth, represents a major challenge for predicting the behavior of active faults. Based on microstructural studies of rock samples collected from the San Andreas Fault Observatory at Depth (California), we propose that pressure solution creep, a pervasive deformation mechanism, can account for aseismic creep. Experimental data on minerals such as quartz and calcite are used to demonstrate that such creep mechanism can accommodate the documented 20 mm/yr aseismic displacement rate of the San Andreas fault creeping zone. We show how the interaction between fracturing and sealing controls the pressure solution rate, and discuss how such a stress-driven mass transfer process is localized along some segments of the fault.

Mirror-like faults and power dissipation during earthquakes

Earthquakes occur along faults in response to plate tectonic movements, but paradoxically, are not widely recognized in the geological record, severely limiting our knowledge of earthquake physics and hampering accurate assessments of seismic hazard. Light-reflective (so-called mirror like) fault surfaces are widely observed geological features, especially in carbonate-bearing rocks of the shallow crust. Here we report on the occurrence of mirror-like fault surfaces cutting dolostone gouges in the Italian Alps. Using friction experiments, we demonstrate that the mirror-like surfaces develop only at seismic slip rates (∼1 m/s) and for applied normal stresses and sliding displacements consistent with those estimated on the natural faults. Under these experimental conditions, the frictional power density dissipated in the samples is comparable to that estimated for natural earthquakes (1–10 MW/m 2 ). Our results indicate that mirror-like surfaces in dolostone gouges are a signature of seismic faulting, and can be used to estimate power dissipation during ancient earthquake ruptures.

Dynamic weakening of serpentinite gouges and bare surfaces at seismic slip rates

To investigate differences in the frictional behavior between initially bare rock surfaces of serpentinite and powdered serpentinite (“gouge”) at subseismic to seismic slip rates, we conducted single-velocity step and multiple-velocity step friction experiments on an antigorite-rich and lizardite-rich serpentinite at slip rates (V) from 0.003 m/s to 6.5 m/s, sliding displacements up to 1.6 m, and normal stresses (σn) up to 22 MPa for gouge and 97 MPa for bare surfaces. Nominal steady state friction values (μnss) in gouge at V = 1 m/s are larger than in bare surfaces for all σn tested and demonstrate a strong σn dependence; μnss decreased from 0.51 at 4.0 MPa to 0.39 at 22.4 MPa. Conversely, μnss values for bare surfaces remained ∼0.1 with increasing σn and V. Additionally, the velocity at the onset of frictional weakening and the amount of slip prior to weakening were orders of magnitude larger in gouge than in bare surfaces. Extrapolation of the normal stress dependence for μnss suggests that the behavior of antigorite gouge approaches that of bare surfaces at σn ≥ 60 MPa. X-ray diffraction revealed dehydration reaction products in samples that frictionally weakened. Microstructural analysis revealed highly localized slip zones with melt-like textures in some cases gouge experiments and in all bare surfaces experiments for V ≥ 1 m/s. One-dimensional thermal modeling indicates that flash heating causes frictional weakening in both bare surfaces and gouge. Friction values for gouge decrease at higher velocities and after longer displacements than bare surfaces because strain is more distributed. Key Points Gouge friction approaches that of bare surfaces at high normal stress Dehydration reactions and bulk melting in serpentinite in < 1 m of slip Flash heating causes dynamic frictional weakening in gouge and bare surfaces

Mantle earthquakes frozen in mylonitized ultramafic pseudotachylytes of spinel-lherzolite facies

F. Seifert and Bayerisches Geoinstitut (University of Beyreuth); Japan Society for the Promotion of Science grant 17340159; Progetti di RilevanteInteresse Nazionale grant 2005044945 and a Progetti di Eccellenza Fondazione Cassa di Risparmio di Padova e Rovigo (CARIPARO) grant.

Record of mega-earthquakes in subduction thrusts: The black fault rocks of pasagshak point (Kodiak Island, Alaska)

On Kodiak Island, Alaska, decimeterthick black fault rocks are at the core of foliated cataclasites that are tens of meters thick. The cataclasites belong to melange zones that are regarded as paleodecollements active at 12–14 km depth and 230–260 °C. Each black layer is mappable for tens of meters along strike. The black fault rocks feature a complex layering made at microscale by alternation of granular and crystalline micro textures, both composed of micronscale subrounded quartz and plagioclase in an ultrafi ne, phyllosilicate-rich matrix. In the crystalline microlayers, tabular zoned micro lites of plagioclase make up much of the matrix. No such feldspars have been found in the cataclasite. We interpret these crystalline microlayers as pseudotachylytes. The granular microlayers show higher grainsize variability, crushed microlites, and textures typical of fl uidization and granular fl ow deformation. Crosscutting relationships between granular and crystalline microlayers include fl ow and intrusion structures and mutual brittle truncation. This suggests that each decimeters-thick composite black fault rock layer records multiple pulses of seismic slip. In each pulse, ultracomminuted fl uidized material and friction melt formed and deformed together in a ductile fashion. Brittle truncation by another pulse occurred after solidifi cation of the friction melt and the fl uidized rock. X-ray powder diffraction (XRPD) and X-ray fl uorescence (XRF) analyses show that black fault rocks have similar mineral composition and chemical content as the cataclasites. The observed systematic chemical differences cannot be explained by bulk or preferential melting of any of the cataclasite components. The presence of an open, fl uidinfi ltrated system with later alteration of black fault rocks is suggested. The geochemical results indicate that these subductionrelated pseudotachylytes differ from those typically described in crystalline rocks and other tectonic settings.

On the transient behavior of frictional melt during seismic slip

S.N. and G.D.T. were supported by a European Research Council Starting Grant Project (acronym USEMS) and by a Progetti di Eccellenza Fondazione Cassa di Risparmio di Padova e Rovigo. We are grateful to Nick Beeler (and to an anonymous referee) for their constructive reviews and their help to improve the clarity of the manuscript.

Effect of water on the frictional behavior of cohesive rocks during earthquakes

Fluid-rock interactions can control earthquake nucleation and the evolution of earthquake sequences. Experimental studies of fault frictional properties in the presence of fluid can provide unique insights into these interactions. We report the first results from experiments performed on cohesive silicate-bearing rocks (microgabbro) in the presence of pressurized pore fluids (H2O, drained conditions) at realistic seismic deformation conditions. The experimental data are compared with those recently obtained from carbonate-bearing rocks (Carrara marble). Contrary to theoretical arguments, and consistent with the interpretation of some field observations, we show that frictional melting of a microgabbro develops in the presence of water. In microgabbro, the initial weakening mechanism (flash melting of the asperities) is delayed in the presence of water; conversely, in calcite marble the weakening mechanism (brittle failure of the asperities) is favored. This opposite behavior highlights the importance of host-rock composition in controlling dynamic (frictional) weakening in the presence of water: cohesive carbonate-bearing rocks are more prone to slip in the presence of water, whereas the presence of water might delay or inhibit the rupture nucleation and propagation in cohesive silicate-bearing rocks.

Frictional properties of fault zone gouges from the J‐FAST drilling project (Mw 9.0 2011 Tohoku‐Oki earthquake)

Smectite-rich fault gouges recovered during Integrated Ocean Drilling Program Expedition 343 (Japan Trench Fast Drilling Project (J-FAST)) from the plate boundary slip zone of the 2011 Mw 9.0 Tohoku-Oki earthquake were deformed at slip velocities of 10 µm s−1 to 3.5 m s−1 and normal stresses up to 12 MPa. Water-dampened gouges (1) are weaker (apparent friction coefficient, μ*  0.1 m s−1). A significant amount of amorphous material formed in room-humidity experiments at low- and high-slip velocities, likely by comminution and disordering of smectite. Our results indicate that the frictional properties of water-dampened gouges could have facilitated propagation of the Tohoku-oki rupture to the trench and large coseismic slip at shallow depths.