G. M. Pesti

A comparison of methods to estimate nutritional requirements from experimental data.

1. Research papers use a variety of methods for evaluating experiments designed to determine nutritional requirements of poultry. Growth trials result in a set of ordered pairs of data. Often, point-by-point comparisons are made between treatments using analysis of variance. This approach ignores that response variables (body weight, feed efficiency, bone ash, etc.) are continuous rather than discrete. Point-by-point analyses harvest much less than the total amount of information from the data. Regression models are more effective at gleaning information from data, but the concept of “requirements” is poorly defined by many regression models. 2. Response data from a study of the lysine requirements of young broilers was used to compare methods of determining requirements. In this study, multiple range tests were compared with quadratic polynomials (QP), broken line models with linear (BLL) or quadratic (BLQ) ascending portions, the saturation kinetics model (SK) a logistic model (LM) and a compartmental (CM) model. 3. The sum of total residuals squared was used to compare the models. The SK and LM were the best fit models, followed by the CM, BLL, BLQ, and QP models. A plot of the residuals versus nutrient intake showed clearly that the BLQ and SK models fitted the data best in the important region where the ascending portion meets the plateau. 4. The BLQ model clearly defines the technical concept of nutritional requirements as typically defined by nutritionists. However, the SK, LM and CM models better depict the relationship typically defined by economists as the “law of diminishing marginal productivity”. The SK model was used to demonstrate how the law of diminishing marginal productivity can be applied to poultry nutrition, and how the “most economical feeding level” may replace the concept of “requirements”.

Effect of citric acid, avilamycin, and their combination on the performance, tibia ash, and immune status of broilers

The aim of this study was to determine the effect of the supplementation of an organic acid (citric acid), antibiotic growth promoter (avilamycin), and their combination for a period of 35 d on the growth, feed efficiency, carcass yield, tibia ash, and immune status of broilers. One hundred sixty 1-d-old broiler chicks (Hubbard Classic) were randomly distributed into 4 groups with 4 replicate cages having 10 birds in each. A corn-soybean-based diet was used as the basal diet (control). The basal diet was supplemented with an organic acid (citric acid, 0.5%), an antibiotic growth promoter (avilamycin, 0.001%), and their combination in other groups. The highest BW was attained in citric acid-fed chicks (1,318 g), which was significantly (P < 0.05) higher than control chicks (1,094 g) or avilamycin-fed chicks (1,217 g). The combination-fed chicks showed similar weight (1,246 g) as citric acid- or avilamycin-fed chicks (P > 0.05). Total feed intake was higher in citric acid-fed chicks compared with antibiotic-supplemented chicks. The addition of citric acid improved feed conversion efficiency (g of weight gain/ kg of feed intake) significantly (P < 0.05) compared with control chicks or its combination with avilamycin. Higher carcass weights were found in chicks fed the combination diet. Supplementation of citric acid increased tibia ash percentage significantly (P < 0.05) compared with controls. Addition of citric acid reduced the pH of the formulated diets. An improvement of immune status was detected by densely populated immunocompetent cells in the lamina propria and submucosa of cecal tonsils and ileum and also in the cortex and medulla of bursa follicles in citric acid-supplemented chicks. Supplementation of citric acid at 0.5% in the diet had positive effects on growth, feed intake, feed efficiency, carcass yield, bone ash, and immune status of broilers. Therefore, citric acid might be a useful additive instead of antibiotic growth promoters such as avilamycin, considering performance and health status of broilers.

Dietary interrelationships among arginine, methionine, and lysine in young broiler chicks.

Since excess dietary lysine (Lys) can increase the chicks arginine (Arg) requirement and excess Arg can increase the chicks methionine (Met) requirement, experiments were conducted to test the hypothesis that responses to dietary Lys and Met are also interrelated. Day-old Ross x Ross chicks were fed a maize-soyabean meal-based diet supplemented with four levels of L-Arg (0, 5, 10 or 20 g/kg), factorially arranged with four levels of supplemental DL-Met (0, 1, 2 or 3 g/kg). Three replicate pens of ten chicks each were randomly assigned to each treatment and fed for 14 d. An increase in Arg in the diet caused growth and feed-intake depression (P=0.0001), but increasing Met in the diet enhanced growth and feed intake (P=0.0001). Arg toxicity was dependent on the Met level of the diet (Arg x Met interaction; P=0.0153). Experiment 2 was conducted to study interrelationships among Arg, Met, and Lys. Eight treatments were factorially combined: two levels of supplemental L-Arg (0 or 10 g/kg), two levels of supplemental DL-Met (0 or 2 g/kg), and two levels of supplemental L-Lys (0 or 6 g/kg). Six replicate pens of eight chicks per treatment were used. A three-way interaction among Arg, Met, and Lys was observed for body-weight gain and feed intake (P<0.023). As expected, kidney arginase activity increased as dietary Lys increased (P=0.0004). No interactions were found for kidney arginase activity. Muscle creatine increased when chicks were fed the higher Arg (25.2 g/kg) diet (P=0.0047). A three-way interaction among Arg, Met, and Lys was found for muscle creatine (P=0.0075). Excess dietary Lys depressed muscle creatinine concentration, but only in the presence of the lower concentrations of Arg and Met. To conclude, an interrelationship among Arg, Met, and Lys was demonstrated, and it was probably related to creatine biosynthesis.

The effects of growth rate on leg morphology and tibia breaking strength, mineral density, mineral content, and bone ash in broilers

Fast-growing broilers are especially susceptible to bone abnormalities, causing major problems for broiler producers. The cortical bones of fast-growing broilers are highly porous, which may lead to leg deformities. Leg problems were investigated in 6-wk-old Arkansas randombred broilers. Body weight was measured at hatch and at 6 wk. There were 8 different settings of approximately 450 eggs each. Two subpopulations, slow-growing (SG; bottom quarter, n=511) and fast-growing (FG; top quarter, n=545), were created from a randombred population based on their growth rate from hatch until 6 wk of age. At 6 wk of age, the broilers were processed and chilled at 4°C overnight before deboning. Shank (78.27±8.06 g), drum stick (190.92±16.91 g), and thigh weights (233.88±22.66 g) of FG broilers were higher than those of SG broilers (54.39±6.86, 135.39±15.45, and 168.50±21.13 g, respectivly; P<0.001). Tibia weights (15.36±2.28 g) of FG broilers were also greater than those of SG broilers (11.23±1.81 g; P<0.001). Shank length (81.50±4.71 g) and tibia length (104.34±4.45 mm) of FG broilers were longer than those of SG broilers (71.88±4.66 and 95.98±4.85 mm, respectively; P<0.001). Shank diameter (11.59±1.60 mm) and tibia diameter (8.20±0.62 mm) of FG broilers were wider than those of SG broilers (9.45±1.74, 6.82±0.58 mm, respectively; P<0.001). Tibia breaking strength (28.42±6.37 kg) of FG broilers was higher than those of SG broiler tibia (21.81±5.89 kg; P<0.001). Tibia density and bone mineral content (0.13±0.01 g/cm2 and 1.29±0.23 g, respectively) of FG broilers were higher than those of SG broiler tibia (0.11±0.01 g/cm2 and 0.79±0.1 g; P<0.001). Tibia percentage of ash content (39.76±2.81) of FG broilers was lower than that of SG broilers (39.99±2.67; P=0.173). Fast-growing broiler bones were longer, wider, heavier, stronger, more dense, and contained more ash than SG ones. After all parameters were calculated per unit of final BW at 6 wk, tibia density and bone ash percentage of FG broilers were lower than those of SG broilers.

The Effect of Several Organic Acids on Phytate Phosphorus Hydrolysis in Broiler Chicks

Supplementation of some organic acids to a P-deficient diet has been shown to improve phytate P utilization. Two experiments were conducted from 0 to 16 d in battery brooders to determine the effect of various organic acids supplementation on phytate P utilization. In both experiments, birds were fed P-deficient corn and soybean meal-based diets. In experiment 1, citric acid, malic acid, fumaric acid, and EDTA were supplemented. Experiment 2 had a 2 x 2 factorial design with 2 sources of Met, 2-hydroxy-4-(methylthio) butanoic acid (HMB) and dl-Met, with or without 500 U/kg of phytase. In experiment 1, the addition of citric, malic, and fumaric acids increased percentage of bone ash, but only the effect of citric acid was significant. The addition of citric and malic acids also significantly increased the retention of P and phytate P (P<0.05). In experiment 2, the addition of phytase to the diet significantly increased 16-d BW gain, feed intake, percentage of bone ash, milligrams of bone ash, phytate P disappearance, and decreased the incidence of P-deficiency rickets. Methionine source did not affect 16-d BW gain, feed intake, feed efficiency, milligrams of bone ash, or P rickets incidence. However, the birds fed HMB had a higher percentage of bone ash and phytate P disappearance compared with the groups fed dl-Met only when phytase was added to the diets. The additions of citric acid and HMB improved phytate P utilization. However, the reason why some organic acids are effective whereas others are not is not apparent.

Evaluation of the fixed nitrogen‐to‐protein (N:P) conversion factor (6.25) versus ingredient specific N:P conversion factors in feedstuffs

BACKGROUND The crude protein (CP) of feedstuffs is important as an indicator of essential and non-essential amino acids for livestock. The protein (P) level needs to be known accurately, to minimize the feeding of excess nitrogen (N) and to reduce N pollution. Laboratory methods for determining N content report N from amino acids, but also N from ammonia and from non-amino acid sources. The determined CP based on 6.25 × N level typically overestimates the true protein of feedstuffs. RESULTS Determined ingredient-specific N:P conversion factors k(A) , k(P) and k were not equal to the standard 6.25 factor. The k(A) had the highest value in all ingredients, which leads to the estimation of specific crude protein (SCP), which is closer to true protein (the summation of the total amino acid residues from amino acid analyses). The SCP(k(A) ) was lower than CP and true protein in all ingredients, demonstrating that CP might overestimate the actual protein in feedstuffs. CONCLUSION Based on data from 677 feedstuff samples from 2009, it is concluded that the mean k(A) should be 5.68 for corn, 5.64 for soybean meal, 5.74 for corn DDGS, 5.45 for poultry by-product meal and 5.37 for meat and bone meal.

The response of male broiler chickens to diets with various protein and energy contents during the growing phase

1. In two trials each using 2 400 male broilers, the regression of body weight on the linear effects of dietary protein, energy and age, the quadratic effect of age, and their interactions, accounted for approximately 99% of the observed variation during the growing and finishing period (3 to 8 weeks of age). Increasing either dietary protein or energy content significantly increased body weight. 2. The regression of food consumption on the linear effects of age, protein, energy and protein X energy interaction, and the quadratic effect of age accounted for 94% of the observed variation. The regression of food utilisation on the linear effects of protein, energy, and age and the quadratic effects of dietary protein and age accounted for 97% of the observed variation. Food consumption and efficiency were dependent on both dietary protein and energy, increasing with increases in either dietary protein or energy content. 3. The regression of fat in the dressed carcass on the linear effects of protein, energy and age accounted for 19% of the observed variation. Carcass fat increased with increasing age and dietary energy, and decreased with increasing dietary protein. 4. Although body weight, food consumption and utilisation were significantly different between trials, the proportion of carcass fat was not.

Evaluation of corn distillers dried grains with solubles as an alternative ingredient for broilers

The effects of graded levels of corn distillers dried grains with solubles (DDGS) were investigated as a partial replacement for sources of protein, energy, and other nutrients for broilers when the digestible amino acid balance was maintained. Zero, 8, 16, and 24% DDGS were incorporated into isonutritive diets at the expense of corn, soybean meal, and dl-Met. Poultry oil, l-Lys, and l-Thr additions increased with increasing levels of DDGS. Diets were each fed to 36 Cobb 500 straight-run broilers in 6 floor pens in 2 experiments. In experiment 1, broilers fed ≥8% DDGS showed increased BW gain compared with those fed the control diet during the 0- to 18-d starter period (P = 0.0164) but were almost identical in BW at 42 d (P = 0.9395). The only difference at 42 d was in the carcass fat composition of female broilers: percentage of fat pad decreased with increasing DDGS level (P = 0.0133). Corn DDGS reduced the pellet durability index. However, the pellet durability index was not related to growth or feed utilization. In experiment 2 at 42 d, broilers fed all levels of DDGS showed increased BW gain compared with those fed the control diet. Broilers may perform well when fed properly balanced feeds containing up to 24% DDGS despite reduced pellet quality.

Phytate and other nutrient components of feed ingredients for poultry

Samples of feed ingredients were collected from poultry feed mills in the United States and Canada: corn (133), soybean meal (114), corn distillers dried grains with solubles (DDGS; 89), bakery by-product meal (95), wheat (22), wheat middlings (31), canola meal (21), and wheat shorts (15). The samples were assayed by standard wet chemical techniques for CP, fat, neutral detergent fiber (NDF), acid detergent fiber, calcium, phosphorus, phytate phosphorus, and ash. There was considerable variation found in most of the ingredient components. Forty-two of the 64 CV were above 10.0%. The calcium contents of the ingredients were the most variable, followed by the fat contents. The CP contents were the least variable. There were some fairly consistent relationships observed across samples; in general, acid detergent fiber and NDF were positively correlated, as were ash and mineral levels. Crude protein and fiber levels were positively related, except for wheat shorts, but the relationships were not strong. Phytate P was found to be positively related to ash and total P, as expected, except for corn DDGS. The fat content of corn was found to be negatively related to the NDF content. Significant (P < 0.004) linear regressions were found between phytate P and total P for corn, soybean meal, bakery by-product meal, wheat, wheat middlings, and wheat shorts. The average nonphytate P content of the ingredients was 49.8%, ranging from 38.8% for wheat middlings to 73.2% for DDGS. The phytate P content of wheat and wheat by-products could be predicted from their proximate compositions, with coefficients of determination in excess of 0.740. Predictions for the other ingredients were not as good.

Maximizing profit in broiler production as prices change: A simple approximation with practical value

Time-varying energy and protein levels in broiler feed raise profit considerably above feeding at constant levels. To accurately set profit-maximizing levels of feed ingredients, nonlinear biological response functions are employed. Nonlinear programming allows solution for optimal energy, protein, and ingredient levels for given prices, but may be too complex for industry-wide use. However, separable linear programming can approximate the optimal solution without significant loss of profit. Linear programming is common in broiler feed formulation, so producers can adopt this technique with existing technology. The potential increase in profits might well ensure the economic survival of marginal firms. ©1994 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.