G.R. Kerr

Pain relief and quality of life following radiotherapy for bone metastases: a randomised trial of two fractionation schedules

BACKGROUND The optimum dose and fractionation schedule for the palliative irradiation of painful bone metastases is controversial. PURPOSE To compare the efficacy, side-effects and effect on quality of life of two commonly used radiotherapy schedules in the management of painful bone metastases. MATERIALS AND METHODS In a prospective trial, 280 patients were randomised to receive either a single 10 Gy treatment or a course of 22.5 Gy in five daily fractions for the relief of localised metastatic bone pain. RESULTS Response rates have been calculated from 240 assessable treated sites of pain. The overall response rates were 83.7% (single treatment) and 89.2% (five fractions). The complete response rates were 38.8% (single treatment) and 42.3% (five fractions). The median duration of pain control was 13.5 weeks (single treatment) and 14.0 weeks (five fractions). None of these differences was statistically significant. There were no differences between the groups in the effect of treatment on a variety of quality of life parameters. CONCLUSIONS It is concluded that a single 10 Gy treatment is as effective as a course of 22.5 Gy in five fractions in the management of painful bone metastases.

Low dose preoperative radiotherapy for carcinoma of the oesophagus: results of a randomized clinical trial

One-hundred-and-seventy-six patients with potentially operable squamous cell carcinoma or adenocarcinoma of the middle or lower thirds of the oesophagus were randomly assigned to preoperative radiotherapy or surgery alone. Patients assigned to the radiotherapy arm received 20 Gy in 10 treatments over 2 weeks, using parallel opposed 4 MV beams. The preoperative radiotherapy was not associated with any significant acute morbidity or any increase in operative complications. The median survival of the overall group of 176 patients was 8 months, and the 5-year survival was 13%. There was no significant difference in the survival of the 90 patients who received preoperative radiotherapy and the 86 who were managed by surgery alone. Proportional hazards analysis identified lymph node involvement, high tumour grade and male sex as significant adverse prognostic features, but the treatment option assigned had no prognostic significance. It was concluded that low dose preoperative radiotherapy offered no advantage over surgery alone.

Long-term survival of patients with breast cancer: a study of the curability of the disease.

A retrospective analysis was made of 3878 cases of breast carcinoma first seen in Edinburgh from 1954 to 1964. During this time there was a policy to treat breast cancer by simple mastectomy and x-ray therapy, and over 90% of cases classified as international stages I and II were so treated. The mortality in these women was compared with that in an equivalent normal population using Scottish national age-specific death rates. For every year of follow-up within 20 years of initial treatment there was an excess mortality from all causes. There was an overall excess mortality of 58% among patients with breast cancer 15-20 years after initial treatment, and 20 times more deaths occurred in this period from breast cancer than in a normal population. For patients disease-free after 15 years there was still a 28% excess mortality from all causes. Factors known to be of major prognostic significance for five-year survivorship had less influence than might have been expected when the ratio of observed to expected deaths was considered for longer periods of follow-up. The effect of clinical staging (I, II, or III), though initially marked, largely disappeared by the 10th year of follow-up, and after allowing for age there was no evidence beyond 10 years of an effect on survival of the original stage of the disease. Similarly, the effect of tumour size on survival disappeared after 10 years. Women who were premenopausal at presentation still had a significant excess of deaths in the fourth quinquennium of follow-up. In the menopausal and postmenopausal groups combined there was still a small non-significant excess of deaths from all causes after 15 years but this almost disappeared when patients who had already relapsed were excluded. In terms of overall mortality only patients who have undergone the menopause before presentation and who are disease-free 15 years after primary treatment may prove to be cured by conventional techniques such as simple mastectomy and postoperative radiotherapy.

Similar decreases in local tumor control are calculated for treatment protraction and for interruptions in the radiotherapy of carcinoma of the larynx in four centers

PURPOSE Data on patients with cancer of the larynx are analyzed using statistical models to estimate the effect of gaps in the treatment time on the local control of the tumor. METHODS AND MATERIALS Patients from four centers, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Manchester, and Toronto, with carcinoma of the larynx and treated by radiotherapy were followed up and the disease-free period recorded. In all centers the end point was control of the primary tumor after irradiation alone. The local control rates at > or = 2 years, Pc, were analyzed by log linear models, and Cox proportional hazard models were used to model the disease-free period. RESULTS T stage, nodal involvement, and site of the tumor were important determinants of the disease-free interval, as was the radiation schedule used. Elongation of the treatment time by 1 day, or a gap of 1 day, was associated with a decrease in Pc of 0.68% per day for Pc = 0.80, with a 95% confidence interval of (0.28, 1.08)%. An increase of 5 days was associated with a 3.5% reduction in Pc from 0.80 to 0.77. At Pc = 0.60 an increase of 5 days was associated with an 7.9% decrease in Pc. The time factor in the Linear Quadratic model, gamma/alpha, was estimated as 0.89 Gy/day, 95% confidence interval (0.35, 1.43) Gy/day. CONCLUSIONS Any gaps (public holidays are the majority) in the treatment schedule have the same deleterious effect on the disease free period as an increase in the prescribed treatment time. For a schedule, where dose and fraction number are specified, any gap in treatment is potentially damaging.

Results of radical radiotherapy of squamous cell carcinoma of the oesophagus

A retrospective study was undertaken of 444 patients who were referred with squamous cell carcinoma of the oesophagus during the period January 1956 to December 1974 and who were treated by radical radiotherapy. The overall crude survival rate at 5 years was 9.0% which is similar to the results of most series reported from other centres and compares favourably with the results of radical surgery. The crude 5 year survival rate was 5.7% for males and 11.6% for females, a significant difference (P less than 0.05). Survival is analysed in terms of sex, site, size and histological grade. Patients (males and females) with the best 5-year survival rates had tumours no more than 5.0 cm in length (11.9%) or confined to the cervical oesophagus (18.9%). Histological grade appeared to have no influence on prognosis. The principal morbidity associated with radical radiotherapy is fibrous stricture formation. This occurred in 43.7% of the patients but was usually effectively managed by bouginage.

Combined radiotherapy and surgery: local control and complications in early carcinoma of the uterine cervix — the Villejuif experience, 1975–1984

From January 1975 to December 1984, 441 patients were treated by combined radiotherapy and surgery at the Institut Gustave Roussy (IGR) for Stage IB (288) and II (proximal) (103) carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Standard treatment consisted of pre-operative utero-vaginal brachytherapy (60 Gy) using a mould technique followed by a colpo-hysterectomy and external iliac lymphadenectomy. Overall 5 year actuarial survival for the whole population was 87% and disease-free survival 85%. Loco-regional relapse occurred in 23 patients (5%). Of these, 12 were central pelvic failures, 8 regional failures and 3 combined central and regional failures. There were 36 systemic relapses (8%) of which 12 relapsed concurrently in the pelvis. Five year actuarial pelvic disease-free, disease-free and overall survival was 87, 85 and 87%, respectively, for the whole population. 340 patients developed one or more complications [Grade 1: 198/441 (44%), Grade 2: 121/441 (27%) and Grade 3 or 4: 21/441 (4.7%)]. Five year actuarial survival for the whole population was poorer for histologically node positive than for node negative (89 vs. 55%, p less than 0.0001). Pre-operative brachytherapy followed by surgery can provide good local control with acceptable morbidity in early cervical cancer.

Mammostrat as a tool to stratify breast cancer patients at risk of recurrence during endocrine therapy.

IntroductionPatients with early-stage breast cancer, treated with endocrine therapy, have approximately 90% 5-year disease-free survival. However, for patients at higher risk of relapse despite endocrine therapy, additional adjuvant therapy, such as chemotherapy, may be indicated. The challenge is to prospectively identify such patients. The Mammostrat® test uses five immunohistochemical markers to stratify patients on tamoxifen therapy into risk groups to inform treatment decisions. We tested the efficacy of this panel in a mixed population of cases treated in a single center with breast-conserving surgery and long-term follow-up.MethodsTissue microarrays from a consecutive series (1981 to 1998) of 1,812 women managed by wide local excision and postoperative radiotherapy were collected following appropriate ethical review. Of 1,390 cases stained, 197 received no adjuvant hormonal or chemotherapy, 1,044 received tamoxifen only, and 149 received a combination of hormonal therapy and chemotherapy. Median age at diagnosis was 57, 71% were postmenopausal, 23.9% were node-positive and median tumor size was 1.5 cm. Samples were stained using triplicate 0.6 mm2 tissue microarray cores, and positivity for p53, HTF9C, CEACAM5, NDRG1 and SLC7A5 was assessed. Each case was assigned a Mammostrat® risk score, and distant recurrence-free survival (DRFS), relapse-free survival (RFS) and overall survival (OS) were analyzed by marker positivity and risk score.ResultsIncreased Mammostrat® scores were significantly associated with reduced DRFS, RFS and OS in estrogen receptor (ER)-positive breast cancer (P < 0.00001). In multivariate analyses the risk score was independent of conventional risk factors for DRFS, RFS and OS (P < 0.05). In node-negative, tamoxifen-treated patients, 10-year recurrence rates were 7.6 ± 1.5% in the low-risk group versus 20.0 ± 4.4% in the high-risk group. Further, exploratory analyses revealed associations with outcome in both ER-negative and untreated patients.ConclusionsThis is the fifth independent study providing evidence that Mammostrat® can act as an independent prognostic tool for ER-positive, tamoxifen-treated breast cancer. In addition, this study revealed for the first time a possible association with outcome regardless of node status and ER-negative tumors. When viewed in the context of previous results, these data provide further support for this antibody panel as an aid to patient management in early-stage breast cancer.

Radiotherapy for pituitary adenomas: long-term efficacy and toxicity

BACKGROUND Radiotherapy for pituitary adenomas is an effective treatment but remains controversial due to toxicity concerns. MATERIALS AND METHODS A retrospective audit of patients referred for radiotherapy during 1974-2003 was conducted, the case records were examined and data linkage to cancer registry and hospital discharge records was performed to assess the overall survival (OS), progression-free survival (PFS) and late effects (hormone deficiency, reduced vision, second cancer and stroke). RESULTS Three hundred and eighty-five patients had radiotherapy (median 45 Gy). The OS was 74% and 49%, PFS was 97% and 96%, at 10 and 20 years, respectively. No specific factors influenced local control. Additional hormone deficiencies occurred in 19% (ACTH) and 26% (TSH). Actuarial rate optic neuropathy at 10 years was 0.8%. Seventy-eight patients had a stroke, a RR for a matched Scottish population of 1.45 (CI 1.05-1.18, p=0.03) men and 2.22 (1.56-3.08, p<0.01) women. Four intra-cranial tumours were identified; 20-year actuarial risk 1.9% (CI 0-2.6%), a RR of 5.65 (0.53-20.77, p=0.10) men and 9.94 (0.94-36.56, p=0.04) women. CONCLUSIONS This treatment is effective with good local control rates at 20 years. A significant proportion developed hypo-pituitarism. The risk of optic neuropathy was low but risk of stroke increased, particularly in women who had slight increased risk of intra-cranial tumours.

ADVERSE EFFECT OF TREATMENT GAPS IN THE OUTCOME OF RADIOTHERAPY FOR LARYNGEAL CANCER

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE A correlation has been demonstrated between unplanned prolongation of radiotherapy and increased local relapse. This review was performed to assess the importance of overall time on the outcome of curative radiotherapy of larynx cancer. MATERIALS AND METHODS Retrospective analysis was performed of 383 patients with laryngeal cancer managed by elective radiotherapy between 1976-1988 in the Department of Clinical Oncology, University of Edinburgh, Western General Hospital, Edinburgh All cancers were confirmed histologically to be squamous cell carcinomas. All subjects received radiotherapy in 20 daily fractions (except Saturdays and Sundays), employing individual beam direction techniques and computer dose distribution calculations. Main outcome measures were complete resolution of the cancer in the irradiated volume; local relapse; survival and cause-specific survival rates. RESULTS Radiotherapy was completed without any unplanned interruption (28 +/- 2 days) in 230/383 (60%) of patients. A statistically significant two-fold increase in local relapse rates was observed when treatment was given in 31 days or more. There also was a statistically significant four-fold increase in laryngeal cancer deaths when the treatment time exceeded 30 days. CONCLUSIONS In patients with laryngeal cancer, accelerated repopulation of cancer cells probably occurs after the start of radiotherapy. When the overall treatment time is 4 weeks or less, gaps at weekends are not detrimental. However, long holiday periods or gaps in treatment longer than 4 days increase the risk of laryngeal cancer relapse and cancer-related mortality. Significant gaps in treatment should be avoided. If treatment has to be prolonged, additional radiation dose should be prescribed to compensate for increased tumour cell proliferation.

Incidence of second brain tumours after pituitary irradiation in Edinburgh 1962–1990

Two hundred and ninety-six patients irradiated for pituitary adenoma in Edinburgh between 1962 and 1990 were reviewed. The number of subsequent tumours was noted. The expected incidence of tumours was estimated, based on data from the Scottish Cancer Registry, for an age and sex matched population. One malignant brain tumour was found; the expected incidence was 0.3 (95% CI 0-12). One meningioma was reported. Thirty non-CNS tumours were found, compared with an expected incidence of 17.5 (95% CI 12-26). We see no reason at present to alter our practice as a result of radiation induced neoplasia in this group, although close follow-up continues.