G. Scott

A prospective, double-blind trial of electrical capacitive coupling in the treatment of non-union of long bones.

Twenty-three patients who had an established non-union of a long bone were entered into a prospective, double-blind trial in which electrical capacitive coupling was used for treatment. Twenty-one patients completed the study: ten who were actively managed and eleven who were managed with a placebo unit. The non-union healed in six of the ten patients who had been managed actively but in none of the patients who had been managed with the placebo unit. This difference in the rates of healing between the actively managed and the placebo groups is highly significant (p = 0.004).

EARLY RADIOLOGICAL OBSERVATIONS MAY PREDICT THE LONG-TERM SURVIVAL OF FEMORAL HIP PROSTHESES

We reviewed a consecutive series of 527 uninfected hip replacements in patients resident in the UK which had been implanted from 1981 to 1993. All had the same basic design of femoral prosthesis, but four fixation techniques had been used: two press-fit, one HA-coated and one cemented. Review and radiography were planned prospectively. For assessment the components were retrospectively placed into two groups: those which had failed from two years onwards by aseptic femoral loosening and those in which the femoral component had survived without revision or recommendation for revision. All available radiographs in both groups were measured to determine vertical migration and examined by two observers to agree the presence of radiolucent lines (RLLs), lytic lesions, resorption of the neck, proximal osteopenia and distal intramedullary and distal subperiosteal formation of new bone. We then related the presence or absence of these features and the rate of migration at two years to the outcome with regard to aseptic loosening and determined the predictive value of each of these variables. Migration of > or = 2 mm at two years, the presence of an RLL of 2 mm occupying one-third of any one zone, and subperiosteal formation of new bone at the tip of the stem were predictors of aseptic loosening after two years. There were too few lytic lesions to assess at two years, but at five years a lytic lesion > or = 2 mm also predicted failure. We discuss the use of these variables as predictors of femoral aseptic loosening for groups of hips and for individual hips. We conclude that if a group of about 50 total hip replacements, perhaps with a new design of femoral stem, were studied in this way at two years, a mean migration of < 0.4 mm and an incidence of < 10% of RLLs of 2 mm in any one zone would predict 95% survival at ten years. For an individual prosthesis, migration of < 2 mm and the absence of an RLL of < or = 2 mm at two years predict a 6% chance of revision over approximately ten years. If either 2 mm of migration or an RLL of 2 mm is present, the chances of revision rise to 27%, and if both radiological signs are present they are 50%. If at five years a lytic lesion has developed, whatever the situation at two years, there is approximately a 50% chance of failure in the following five years. Our findings suggest that replacements using a limited number of any new design of femoral prosthesis should be screened radiologically at two years before they are generally introduced. We also suggest that radiographs of individual patients at two years and perhaps at five years should be studied to help to decide whether or not the patient should remain under close review or be discharged from specialist follow-up.

Number of Polyethylene Particles and Osteolysis in Total Joing Replacements: A Quanatitive Study Using a Tissue-Digestion Method

Our aim was to analyse the influence of the size, shape and number of particles on the pathogenesis of osteolysis. We obtained peri-implant tissues from 18 patients having revision surgery for aseptically loosened Freeman total knee replacements (10), Charnley total hip replacements (3) and Imperial College/London Hospital double-cup surface hip replacements (5). The size and shape of the polyethylene particles were characterised using SEM and their concentration was calculated. The results were analysed with reference to the presence of radiological osteolysis. The concentration of polyethylene particles in 6 areas with osteolysis was significantly higher than that in 12 areas without osteolysis. There were no significant differences between the size and shape of the particles in these two groups. We conclude that the most critical factor in the pathogenesis of osteolysis is the concentration of polyethylene particles accumulated in the tissue.

The size and shape of particulate polyethylene wear debris in total joint replacements.

Abstract Osteolysis induced by wear particles has been recognized as one of the major causes of long-term failure in total joint replacements. However, little is currently known about the exact nature of particles, as the particles are too small to be characterized by light microscopy. In this study, ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) particles retrieved from ten cases (six cemented and four uncemented) for Freeman type conforming tibiofemoral total knee replacements (TKRs), three Charnley total hip replacements (THRs) and five Imperial College/London Hospital double cup surface hip replacements for aseptic loosening were extracted using a high-performance method with ultracentrifugation and characterized by scanning electron microscopy. The equivalent circle diameter (ECD) of all 18 cases ranged from 0.40 to 1.15 μm (Mean ± SE = 0.70 ± 0.05 μm, median = 0.67 μm). The aspect ratio was 1.50 to 2.04 (Mean ± SE = 1.75 ± 0.04, median = 1.73), and roundness was 1.24 to 2.34 (Mean ± SE = 1.61 ± 0.07, median = 1.65). The numbers of particles were 5.2 × 108 to 9.17 × 1010/g tissue (Mean ± SE = 1.42 × 1010 ± 5.41 × 109/g tissue, median = 7.04 × 109). The number of polyethylene (PE) particles/g tissue in TKRs was significantly larger than that in THRs (1.04 × 1010/g tissue and 2.16 × 109/g tissue respectively, median. p = 0.03, Mann-Whitney U test). Unstable fixation of the tibial PE component might account for the accumulation of a large number of PE particles in the interface tissue.

Wear particulate species and bone loss in failed total joint arthroplasties

The aim of this study was to evaluate the relative contribution of polyethylene, metal, and polymethylmethacrylate (cement) particles to the overall bone loss in aseptic loosening. Twenty-four interface tissues with adjacent bone were obtained during 17 revision total joint arthroplasties (11 hips and six knees). Osteoclasts and macrophages were identified immunohistochemically on the bone surface. The length of the bone surface in contact with these cell types was measured and analyzed with reference to the particulate species present within the fibrous interface. The presence of abundant polyethylene particles significantly increased the proportion of the bone surface in contact with macrophages but did not have a significant influence on that of osteoclasts. Osteoclastic bone resorption was significantly more extensive in the presence of metal particles. In contrast, the presence of cement particles did not have a significant influence on macrophage or osteoclast coverage of the bone surface. These results highlight the significance of polyethylene particles in macrophage recruitment and subsequent osteolysis and suggest a different mechanism of bone loss related to metal, namely mediation through osteoclastic activities. The relative contribution of cement particles was negligible and needs reevaluation in light of evidence provided by others.

RADIOLOGICAL AND SURVIVAL COMPARISON OF FOUR METHODS OF FIXATION OF A PROXIMAL FEMORAL STEM

We compared the radiological appearances and survival of four methods of fixation of a femoral stem in 538 hips after follow-up for five or ten years. The fixation groups were: 1) press-fit shot-blasted smooth Ti-Al-V stem; 2) press-fit shot-blasted proximally ridged stem; 3) proximal hydroxyapatite (HA) coating; and 4) cementing. Survival analysis at five to ten years showed better results in the HA-coated (100% at five to six years) and cemented stems (100% at 5 to 6 years) than in the two press-fit groups. There was a higher mean rate of migration in the smooth and ridged Ti-Al-V shot-blasted press-fit groups (0.8 mm/year and 0.6 mm/year, respectively) when compared with the HA-coated and cemented prostheses (both 0.3 mm/year). More radiolucent lines and osteolytic lesions were seen in the press-fit groups than in either the HA-coated or cemented implants, with a trend for a lower incidence of both in the HA compared with the cemented group. Proximal osteopenia increased in the press-fit and cemented prostheses with time, but did not do so in the HA group. There was a higher incidence of resorption of the femoral neck with time in the cemented group than in the other three. We conclude that the HA and the cemented interfaces both provide secure fixation with a trend in favour of HA. The cemented prosthesis meets the suggested National Institutes of Health definition of ‘efficacious’ at ten years.

Should the cement mantle around the femoral component be thick or thin

We have compared the survival and radiological outcome at ten years after total hip replacement using two techniques for preparing the femoral canal. The same prosthesis was used throughout and all operations were performed by the same surgical team. In technique 1 the canal was over-reamed by 2 mm and in technique 2 it was reamed to the same size as the prosthesis. Technique 1 was performed on 92 patients and technique 2 on 97 patients. The survival at ten years was 97.2% (90.6 to 99.2) for technique 1 and 98.8% (92.9 to 99.8) for technique 2. Vertical migration was greater in technique 1 (1.8 mm versus 1.0 mm at five years; p = 0.36). There were significantly more lytic lesions and radiolucent lines at five years (p = 0.0061) with technique 1. We conclude that technique 2 is not worse and may produce better long-term results than current teaching suggests.

NUMBER OF POLYETHYLENE PARTICLES AND OSTEOLYSIS IN TOTAL JOINT REPLACEMENTS

Our aim was to analyse the influence of the size, shape and number of particles on the pathogenesis of osteolysis. We obtained peri-implant tissues from 18 patients having revision surgery for aseptically loosened Freeman total knee replacements (10), Charnley total hip replacements (3) and Imperial College/London Hospital double-cup surface hip replacements (5). The size and shape of the polyethylene particles were characterised using SEM and their concentration was calculated. The results were analysed with reference to the presence of radiological osteolysis. The concentration of polyethylene particles in 6 areas with osteolysis was significantly higher than that in 12 areas without osteolysis. There were no significant differences between the size and shape of the particles in these two groups. We conclude that the most critical factor in the pathogenesis of osteolysis is the concentration of polyethylene particles accumulated in the tissue.

Design Considerations and Life Prediction of Metal-on-Metal Bearings: The Effect of Clearance

BACKGROUND Clinical observations suggest that metal-on-metal arthroplasties that have been implanted for more than twenty years do fail. It is proposed that there are not two, but three distinct phases of wear life for any metal-on-metal implant system: bedding-in, steady state, and end point. In this study, we asked two questions: can we explain late failure due to wear, and will there be a late failure mechanism due to a change in the frictional torque? METHODS In order to characterize wear failure, an analysis was made of five retrieved metal-on-metal couples that were mapped with use of a roundness machine. A geometrical model was developed on the basis of these observations, and wear at the end point was calculated. The literature on first-generation metal-on-metal implants retrieved for aseptic loosening was reviewed to assess the agreement with the retrieval findings as well as the wear model. RESULTS A wear patch of an appreciable and constant size could be measured in all five retrieved couples. The end point of revision was observed to occur when the wear progression reached a contact area corresponding to approximately 75% of the projected diameter of the ball. The wear volume was calculated from the geometry. The available literature describing the wear characteristics of retrieved bearings after successful clinical use showed good agreement with the calculated wear model. CONCLUSIONS During the implant life of long-term successful metal-on-metal devices, a wear patch develops, as evident from retrieved failed devices. Failure often occurs through loosening, and the observed wear patch is similar in size for devices measured by us and for those described in the literature. We hypothesized that failure by loosening occurs through the accumulation of wear, which eventually leads to high friction within the bearing and increased torsional forces across the joint and its fixation.

The Medial Rotation total knee replacement A CLINICAL AND RADIOLOGICAL REVIEW AT A MEAN FOLLOW-UP OF SIX YEARS

We describe the survivorship of the Medial Rotation total knee replacement (TKR) at ten years in 228 cemented primary replacements implanted between October 1994 and October 2006, with their clinical and radiological outcome. This implant has a highly congruent medial compartment, with the femoral component represented by a portion of a sphere which articulates with a matched concave surface on the medial side of the tibial insert. There were 78 men (17 bilateral TKRs) and 111 women (22 bilateral TKRs) with a mean age of 67.9 years (28 to 90). All the patients were assessed clinically and radiologically using the American Knee Society scoring systems. The mean follow-up was for six years (1 to 13) with only two patients lost to follow-up and 34 dying during the period of study, one of whom had required revision for infection. There were 11 revisions performed in total, three for aseptic loosening, six for infection, one for a periprosthetic fracture and one for a painful but well-fixed replacement performed at another centre. With revision for any cause as the endpoint, the survival at ten years was 94.5% (95% CI 85.1 to 100), and with aseptic loosening as the endpoint 98.4% (95% CI 93 to 100). The mean American Knee Society score improved from 47.6 (0 to 88) to 72.2 (26 to 100) and for function from 45.1 (0 to 100) to 93.1 (45 to 100). Radiological review failed to detect migration in any of the surviving knees. The clinical and radiological results of the Medial Rotation TKR are satisfactory at ten years. The increased congruence of the medial compartment has not led to an increased rate of loosening and continued use can be supported.