Gary Ezzell

Genetic and geometric optimization of three‐dimensional radiation therapy treatment planning

The thesis of this report is that potentially useful treatment beams can be chosen based on geometric heuristics and that a genetic algorithm (GA) can be constructed to find an optimal combination of beams based on a formal objective function. The paper describes the basic principles of a GA and the particular implementation developed. The code represents each plan in the population as two paired lists comprised of beam identifiers and relative weights. Reproduction operators, which mimic sexual reproduction with crossover, mutation, cloning, spontaneous generation, and death, manipulate the lists to grow optimal plans. The necessary gene pool is created by software modules which generate beams, distribute calculation points, obtain clinical constraints, add wedges, and calculate doses. The code has been tested on a set of artificial patients and on four clinical cases: prostate, pancreas, esophagus, and glomus. All demonstrated consistent results, indicating that the code is a reliable optimizer. Additional experiments compared the results for a full set of open beams to the geometrically selected set and the GA code with simulated annealing. Geometric selection of beam directions did not significantly compromise optimization quality. Compared to simulated annealing, the genetic algorithm was equally able to optimize the objective function, and calculations suggest it may be the faster method when the number of beams to be considered exceeds approximately 70.

Dosimetric improvements following 3D planning of tangential breast irradiation.

Abstract Purpose: To evaluate the dosimetric difference between a simple radiation therapy plan utilizing a single contour and a more complex three-dimensional (3D) plan utilizing multiple contours, lung inhomogeneity correction, and dose-based compensators. Methods and Materials: This is a study of the radiation therapy (RT) plans of 85 patients with early breast cancer. All patients were considered for breast-conserving management and treated by conventional tangential fields technique. Two plans were generated for each patient. The first RT plan was based on a single contour taken at the central axis and utilized two wedges. The second RT plan was generated by using the 3D planning system to design dose-based compensators after lung inhomogeneity correction had been made. The endpoints of the study were the comparison between the volumes receiving greater than 105% and greater than 110% of the reference dose, as well as the magnitude of the treated volume maximum dose. Dosimetric improvement was defined to be of significant value if the volume receiving > 105% of one plan was reduced by at least 50% with the absolute difference between the volumes being 5% or greater. The dosimetric improvements in 49 3D plans (58%) were considered of significant value. Patients field separation and breast size did not predict the magnitude of improvement in dosimetry. Conclusion: Dose-based compensator plans significantly reduced the volumes receiving > 105%, >110%, and volume maximum dose.

Preliminary results of a hyperfractionated dose escalation study for locally advanced adenocarcinoma of the prostate

The objective of this study was to build on our experience with 3-D conformal radiotherapy (CRT) by using a hyperfractionated dose escalation scheme to maximize the therapeutic ratio between improved local control and reduced morbidity in patients with locally advanced prostate cancer. Twenty patients with locally advanced (T3, T4) adenocarcinoma of the prostate were treated with a hyperfractionated radiotherapy schedule. All fields were designed with a conformal therapy based beams eye view, 3-D planning system. The pelvic lymph nodes received 1.8 Gy/day to a total dose of 45 Gy in 5 weeks. Using partial transmission blocks, the prostate and periprostatic tissues received 1.3 Gy twice daily (minimum interval of 6 h) to a total dose of 78 Gy in 6 weeks. The dose was chosen by calculating the biologically effective dose (BED) which would produce the same effect in late reacting tissue but an increase for the tumor as our standard dose of 69 Gy delivered in 1.8-2.0 Gy fractions. The alpha/beta chosen for late damage was 3 Gy and 10 Gy was used for the tumor. All 20 patients completed the planned course of treatment. Although an increase in the tumor BED would be expected to result in increased acute effects, no significant worsening of acute side-effects was observed compared with standard treatment. All patients had only mild (Grade 1) rectal or bladder toxicity during treatment. One patient had an exacerbation of diverticulitis during treatment requiring hospitalization for antibiotics but completed treatment on schedule.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Larynx motion associated with swallowing during radiation therapy

PURPOSEnA basis is presented for predicting the reduction in radiation dose to the larynx attributable to swallowing during radiation therapy treatment.nnnMETHODS AND MATERIALSnLaryngeal movement associated with swallowing can occur during radiation therapy even when the patients head is immobilized. Data on the extent and timing of laryngeal motions and the frequency of swallowing were used to predict the effect such motion would have on accuracy of radiation dose to the larynx.nnnRESULTSnIn a nontracheostomized adult the larynx elevates approximately 2 cm during a swallow and moves anteriorly less than 1 cm. The normal frequency of swallowing in the supine position is once every 1-2 min. During therapy, the likelihood of a swallow occurring during an irradiation interval depended on the duration of the interval. For irradiation intervals less than 2 min long the ratio of number of swallows to number of intervals was 0.27. For irradiation intervals between 2-3 min long the ratio was 1.76. Based on conservative estimates of radiation field dimensions, larynx motion, and incidence of swallowing, the reduction in radiation dose attributable to swallowing during treatment would be approximately 0.5%.nnnCONCLUSIONnWith small fields the total dose is only decreased by 0.5% with swallowing, so the change in the total dose is insignificant.

Afterloading high dose rate intracavitary vaginal cylinder

PURPOSEnTo design an afterloading vaginal cylinder application appropriate to treat the vault with high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy after prior total abdominal hysterectomy.nnnMETHODS AND MATERIALSnA vaginal cylinder was designed and built using nylon and source loading channels positioned for source movement for HDR vault and vaginal brachytherapy. The channels are positioned to treat a broader isodose surface and to avoid the end effects of linear source brachytherapy. The central channel allows an applicator tube to be advanced beyond the end of the cylinder to treat a tented vault or a cervical stump (or uterus). Additional peripheral sources can be added to allow vaginal wall plaque therapy.nnnRESULTSnThe application allows vault, vault plus proximal vagina, or vault plus entire vagina therapy using HDR. The isodose surface treated is controlled by source positioning and dwell times.nnnCONCLUSIONnThe HDR cylinder has wide potential usability for uterus or cervix therapy as both low stage and operable endometrial carcinomas are now usually treated by surgery.

A manual algorithm for computing dwell times for two-catheter endobronchial treatments using HDR brachytherapy.

A method has been developed to permit the calculation of dwell times for endobronchial high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy treatment using two catheters, without using a dedicated treatment planning system. Worksheets were developed to guide a user through manual calculations, and a computer program was written to automate the process. This empirical algorithm produces dose distributions that are clinically safe and reasonable. The total dwell times match those predicted by individually optimized distributions to within a few percent. The method has been used most frequently as a quality assurance check on optimized plans produced by a commercial treatment planning system, but it can serve as a back-up method should the commercial system fail. [Worksheets with example calculations may be retrieved using anonymous ftp from the American Institute of Physics, Electronic Physics Auxillary Publication Service (EPAPS).]

Practical aspects of transmission cord blocks in radiotherapy

We present the advantages of using partial transmission cord blocks throughout treatment, as opposed to adding full-thickness blocks near the end. Such blocks reduce the risk of block omission or mispositioning and require less total time for construction. We also present an argument for the existence of an optimal width for cord blocks used in mediastinal treatments. A figure of merit has been derived which quantifies the tradeoff between narrow blocks, which increase the variation in dose across the block shadow and the risk of positioning errors, and wide blocks, which may unnecessarily shield potential tumor sites. For 60Co, 4- and 10-MV beams, the figure of merit peaks at block widths of 2.0-2.5 cm at the level of the cord. Effective transmission data for cord blocks constructed of cerrobend are given for those three beams. Quality assurance studies show that transmission through cerrobend blocks can be controlled to the required precision.

Tangential Irradiation of the Intact Breast: The ABC of the Technique

This paper describes in detail the setup of breast irradiation using an isocentric tangential technique. This setup method does not require any special devices or calculations beyond simple arithmetic. We will discuss some of the practical problems and pitfalls that result from the oblique incidence of the radiation beams and the slope of the chest wall and provide possible solutions.

Limitations of the straight-line assumption for endobronchial HDR brachytherapy treatments

It is useful to expedite high dose rate brachytherapy endobronchial treatments by using standardized dwell weights and worksheets, avoiding computerized planning where possible. Such methods assume the treatment catheter is straight. This study uses inverse-square considerations to quantify the curvature that invalidates the straight-line approximation. The ratio of the distance between end dwell positions and the active length can be used as a measure of the curvature. The variation in mean dose and maximum dose at the prescription points is presented as a function of active length and curvature, allowing the planner to determine quickly when a pre-treatment computer plan is necessary.

Transmission blocks: clinical and biological rationales.

This paper describes the clinical and biological rationales for the use of transmission blocks. Clinical advantages over the use of full-thickness blocks applied part way through the course of therapy include the use of only one set of fields, blocks, and beam calculations, and less complex chart recording. There is a net saving in time required for the preparation and treatment of the patient. There is also a quality assurance advantage since the impact of a potential error in block positioning is reduced. In terms of biological advantages, it is demonstrated that the linear-quadratic iso-effect model can be applied to predict an improvement of up to 10% in the therapeutic ratio if transmission blocks are used instead of full-thickness blocks.