Gary W. Haller

Thymic Transplantation in Miniature Swine. II. Induction of Tolerance by Transplantation of Composite Thymokidneys to Thymectomized Recipients

Previous studies in our laboratory have demonstrated that the presence of the thymus is essential for rapid and stable tolerance induction in allotransplant models. We now report an attempt to induce tolerance to kidney allografts by transplanting donor thymic grafts simultaneously with the kidney in thymectomized recipients. Recipients were thymectomized 3 wk before receiving an organ and/or tissues from a class I-mismatched donor. Recipients received 1) a kidney allograft alone, 2) a composite allogeneic thymokidney (kidney with vascularized autologous thymic tissue under its capsule), or 3) separate kidney and thymic grafts from the same donor. All recipients received a 12-day course of cyclosporine. Thymectomized animals receiving a kidney allograft alone or receiving separate thymic and kidney grafts had unstable renal function due to severe rejection with the persistence of anti-donor cytotoxic T cell reactivity. In contrast, recipients of composite thymokidney grafts had stable renal function with no evidence of rejection histologically and donor-specific unresponsiveness. By postoperative day 14, the thymic tissue in the thymokidney contained recipient-type dendritic cells. By postoperative day 60, recipient-type class I positive thymocytes appeared in the thymic medulla, indicating thymopoiesis. T cells were both recipient and donor MHC-restricted. These data demonstrate that the presence of vascularized-donor thymic tissue induces rapid and stable tolerance to class I-disparate kidney allografts in thymectomized recipients. To our knowledge, this is the first evidence of functional vascularized thymic grafts permitting transplantation tolerance to be induced in a large animal model.

Tolerance to solid organ transplants through transfer of MHC class II genes

Donor/recipient MHC class II matching permits survival of experimental allografts without permanent immunosuppression, but is not clinically applicable due to the extensive polymorphism of this locus. As an alternative, we have tested a gene therapy approach in a preclinical animal model to determine whether expression of allogeneic class II transgenes (Tgs) in recipient bone marrow cells would allow survival of subsequent Tg-matched renal allografts. Somatic matching between donor kidney class II and the recipient Tgs, in combination with a short treatment of cyclosporine A, prolonged graft survival with DR and promoted tolerance with DQ. Class II Tg expression in the lymphoid lineage and the graft itself were sequentially implicated in this tolerance induction. These results demonstrate the potential of MHC class II gene transfer to permit tolerance to solid organ allografts.

Histocompatible miniature swine: an inbred large-animal model1

Three herds of miniature swine, each homozygous for a different set of alleles at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), and five intra-MHC recombinant strains, have been reported by the authors’ laboratory. One herd (SLAdd) was selected for further inbreeding to achieve a histocompatible line. It has undergone seven additional generations of sequential brother-sister or father-daughter matings (termed G7). To determine the level of histocompatibility of these animals, the authors performed skin and heart transplantation without immunosuppression. In contrast to MHC-matched, minor antigen-mismatched animals that rejected skin in 11 days (median survival time [MST], n=6) and hearts in 35 days (MST, n=4), G7 animals accepted skin for greater than 340 days (>340, >448, and >677 days) and hearts for greater than 265 days (>265 and >269 days). Nevertheless, rejection of second grafts could be induced by sensitization, indicating that weak minor antigens remain, requiring further inbreeding to achieve full histocompatibility. We conclude that G7 animals are sufficiently inbred to accept first set skin and heart grafts indefinitely.

Treatment of cyclosporine-related adverse effects by conversion to tacrolimus after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND Cyclosporine (CsA)-associated side effects include nephrotoxicity, hypertension, neurological disorders, and hyperlipidemia. A considerable share of early and long-term posttransplant morbidity is likely to be drug related. METHODS In 31 patients with stable graft function, conversion from CsA to tacrolimus was implemented due to nephrotoxicity (n=19), hypertension (n=9), and neurological disorders (n=8). RESULTS Three months after conversion, a response was evident in 26 patients (84%), whereas 5 patients (16%) were nonresponsive. In 13 of 19 patients (68%) suffering from nephrotoxicity, serum creatinine levels decreased significantly from 2.0+/-0.5 mg/dl to 1.5+/-0.4 mg/dl (P<0.005), whereas in 6 of 19 patients (32%) no improvement was observed. Antihypertensive therapy was reduced in six of nine patients and neurological disorders improved in six of eight patients. When analyzing all patients, average levels of cholesterol and triglycerides were significantly lower after conversion when compared with at the time of conversion (P<0.05) CONCLUSIONS Conversion to tacrolimus reduced drug-related side effects in the majority of patients, while graft function remained stable. Conversion to tacrolimus may be considered for CsA-related side effects as a potential beneficial approach.

Naturally Developing Memory T Cell Xenoreactivity to Swine Antigens in Human Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes

Naturally developing xenospecific Abs are well-documented barriers to xenograft transplantation in humans, but whether analogous xenoreactive T cell immunity develops is not known. We used an enzyme-linked immunospot assay to determine the frequency and cytokine profiles of xenoreactive PBLs from a panel of human volunteers. Because naive T cells produce only IL-2 in short term culture, IFN-γ production by this approach is a measure of a memory immune response. Stimulation of human PBLs or purified T lymphocytes with stimulator cells from inbred swine revealed a high frequency of IFN-γ producers with 5-fold fewer IL-2 producers. In contrast, lymphocytes obtained from neonatal umbilical cord blood contained swine-specific IL-2 producers but few IFN-γ producers, which is what one would expect to find with a naive phenotype. Moreover, PBLs from adults with a history of abstention from pork consumption responded to swine cells with a significantly lower frequency of IFN-γ producers than PBLs from adults with unrestricted diets did, suggesting that pork consumption may result in priming of swine-specific T cell immunity. Our findings provide the first evidence for naturally occurring xenospecific T cell immunity in humans. The detected strength of this memory response suggests that it will present a formidable barrier to transplantation of swine organs.

MHC Alloantigens Elicit Secondary, But Not Primary, Indirect In Vitro Proliferative Responses

The relative contributions of direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition to graft rejection remain controversial. Recent reports suggest that the indirect pathway may play a prominent role in both acute and chronic allograft rejection. Such studies suggest that MHC-derived allopeptides are more immunogenic than those derived from minor histocompatibility or other nominal Ags. The aim of this study was to characterize the immunogenicity of MHC alloantigens in MHC-defined miniature swine via primary and secondary MLR culture assays. APCs were selectively depleted from either responder or stimulator cell populations to specifically analyze direct and indirect proliferative responses, respectively. Radio-resistant cytokine secretion and subsequent backstimulation of responder cells was eliminated by using stimulators that were either lysed or unresponsive to the responder MHC haplotypes. When the effect of backstimulation was eliminated from MLR culture assays, indirect proliferative responses were not observed among naive responders. Only after in vivo priming of responder animals could indirect proliferation be detected. These data do not refute the potential importance of indirect allorecognition in graft rejection. However, they suggest that MHC-derived alloantigens behave similarly in vitro to minor histocompatibility Ags, with comparable immunogenicity. These data also suggest that the MLR culture assay does not accurately reflect the importance of indirect mechanisms that have previously been reported in experimental models of graft rejection. A greater understanding of the indirect pathway and the associated immunogenicity of MHC allopeptides has the potential benefit of enabling the development of therapeutic interventions to prevent or halt allograft rejection.

Peripheral regulation of graft-versus-host alloreactivity in mixed chimeric miniature swine.

Background. Despite the presence of circulating donor-derived T cells during the induction of mixed chimerism across MHC barriers in miniature swine, severe graft-versus-host disease was avoided in the majority of animals. In this study, we investigated the possible roles of recipient and donor lymphoid populations in the regulation of donor-anti-recipient alloreactivity. Methods. Mixed chimerism across a full MHC-mismatch barrier was established in miniature swine using a high-dose allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell protocol. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from mixed chimeric swine were co-cultured with naïve donor-matched responders and naïve recipient-matched stimulators in mixed lymphocyte reactions. Results. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from mixed chimeras inhibited donor-anti-recipient proliferation. This suppression was radioresistant to 25 Gy. Suppression of donor-anti-recipient alloreactivity was not observed in mixed lymphocyte co-cultures when donor-derived cells were added in the absence of recipient-derived cells. Conclusions. These results suggest an association between the presence of an active and relatively radioresistant cell population, demonstrable in vitro, and the regulation of graft-versus-host disease across MHC barriers in mixed chimeric miniature swine.

Regulated Expression of an MHC Class II Gene from a Promoter-Inducible Retrovirus

Specific immune tolerance to fully allogeneic kidney grafts can be achieved in a miniature swine transplantation model by retrovirus-mediated transfer of allogeneic MHC class II genes into bone marrow cells (BMCs) of recipient animals. Graft survival correlated with transient expression of the somatic transgene (Tg) in the induction phase of tolerance. With the aim of investigating the effects of timing and threshold levels of Tg expression on induction of hyporesponsiveness to the grafted tissues, two recombinant retrovirus constructs containing the tetracycline binary regulatory system were used to achieve conditional expression of either the green fluorescent protein (tetGFP) as a control, or the porcine MHC class II DRbeta chain (tetDRB). Effective downregulation of GFP gene transcription was demonstrated in transduced murine fibroblasts after doxycycline treatment, leading to a > 90% reduction of GFP fluorescence. Similar diminution of the DRB gene transcription was achieved in transduced pig endothelial cells (ECs). Drug-dependent downregulation of DRBc gene expression in SLAd pig ECs coincided with complete inhibition of allogeneic activation of anti-class IIc-primed SLAd T cells. These in vitro results suggest that the binary tetracycline retrovirus system may also be adequate to regulate MHC class II Tg expression in vivo.

Autologous graft-versus-host disease in a porcine bone marrow transplant model

Background. Autologous graft-versus-host disease (autoGvHD) has been reported in patients and can be induced in rodents by syngeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) and a brief administration of cyclosporine A (CsA). To our knowledge, there is no previous large-animal model for this phenomenon, nor is there a model in which autoGvHD occurs spontaneously after autologous bone marrow transplant (autoBMT) in the absence of CsA induction. During our studies of autoBMT in miniature swine, performed without CsA treatment, we noted the frequent occurrence of a rash consistent with autoGvHD. We hypothesized that the extent of peripheral blood contamination of the bone marrow (BM) inoculum before transplant may have correlated with the incidence of such autoGvHD. Methods. Retrospective analysis of the prevalence of autoGvHD in swine was carried out in all animals that had become engrafted after autoBMT in our laboratory. Subsequent prospective experiments attempted to induce autoGvHD by transplanting autologous BM enriched with autologous peripheral blood into lethally irradiated animals. Results. Our data showed that autoGvHD frequently occurs in swine after autoBMT, with the most severe cases of the disease occurring in animals with the highest levels of peripheral blood contamination of the BM inoculum. Furthermore, mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) against self antigens were positive only in animals affected by autoGvHD. Conclusion. These findings provide the first evidence for autoGvHD without the use of CsA in a preclinical BMT model. The role of autologous T cells needs further delineation but may help to explain the occasional occurrences of autoGvHD that have been reported in humans after autoBMT.

Assessment of transduction rates of porcine bone marrow.

Although drug resistance is commonly used as an indicator of gene transfer in various cellular contexts, the assessment of drug resistance is often imprecise and over-estimated. To measure accurately transduction efficiencies of the retroviral-mediated transfer of genes encoding the neomycine phosphotransferase (Neo(r)) and porcine major histocompatibility (MHC) class II in pig bone marrow cells (BMC), the fraction of targeted progenitors was evaluated by both colony-forming unit granulocytes/macrophages assays (G418r CFU-GM) and by PCR analysis of the transgenes (Tg). Transduced and untransduced BMC were selected at different concentrations of G418 and revealed high individual variability of drug sensitivity. Comparison of the results obtained by estimating the CFU frequency and the PCR assays on drug-resistant colonies demonstrated a marked overestimation of BM transduction rates when determined by G418 resistance alone, because only approximately one-third of individual colonies were positive for both the Neo(r) and the class II Tg. Because this discrepancy is likely to affect the overall assessment of transduction rates using drug resistance markers, our data attest for the need of a combination of molecular assays to determine transduction efficiencies accurately.