Gerardo A. Gomez

Preventable trauma deaths: Dade county, Florida

We reviewed 1,201 trauma deaths that occurred in Dade County, Florida, in 1982 in order to evaluate the need for an organized trauma network. There were 715 deaths (59.5%) at the scene. Of the remaining 486 patients who were transported to hospitals for treatment there were 240 central nervous system (CNS) deaths and 246 non-CNS deaths. Fifty-two (21.1%) preventable non-CNS trauma deaths were identified out of the 246 non-CNS deaths. The lack of an appropriate surgical procedure or a delay to surgery accounted for 82.7% of the preventable deaths. The preventable non-CNS death rate was 12.1% at the then functional Level I hospital and 26.4% at the other 22 hospitals (p less than 0.01). The ISS scores were similar for both the functional Level I hospital and the other hospitals. A trauma network involving seven hospitals is currently being established in Dade County, Florida. Applying the 1982 data to these hospitals reveals a preventable non-CNS death rate of 12.1% for the Level I hospital, 21.5% for the six planned Level II hospitals, and 30.0% for the other 16 hospitals. We conclude that: the severely injured should be triaged directly to trauma centers, and there is a need in Dade County, Florida, for an organized trauma system.

Fatal Blunt Aortic Injuries: A Review of 242 Autopsy Cases

OBJECTIVE To characterize fatal blunt aortic injury (BAI). METHODS A retrospective chart review of 242 cases of fatal BAI in patients who underwent an autopsy at our institution between 1984 and 1997 was performed. Comparisons were made for statistical differences using the z-test. RESULTS Two hundred forty-two cases of fatal BAI were reviewed, making this the largest BAI autopsy study to date. Mechanisms of BAI included driver/passenger in motor vehicle crash (MVC) (68%), pedestrian versus MVC (17%), and motorcycle crash (8%). When comparing the mechanisms in the time period 1984 to 1988 to the time period 1989 to 1997, only the pedestrian versus MVC mechanism was significantly different (12% vs. 23%, p < 0.05). MVC direction of impact included head-on (45%), lateral (35%), and complex (20%). Two thirds of the victims sustained head injuries, rib fractures, and/or hepatic trauma. Only 58% of the victims had the classic isthmus laceration. There was one preventable death secondary to delay in diagnosis. CONCLUSION BAI is not limited to frontal impact crashes; there should be a high index of suspicion of BAI in lateral impact crashes as well as pedestrian versus MVC mechanisms. Nonisthmus and complex aortic lacerations are common in fatal BAI. Finally, BAI is a highly lethal injury with few preventable deaths in this series.

Surgical cricothyroidotomy in trauma patients: analysis of its use by paramedics in the field.

OBJECTIVE To analyze the indications for and the success rate, complications, and neurologic outcomes of surgical cricothyroidotomy when performed in the field by ambulance paramedics. METHODS The ambulance and hospital records of all trauma patients on whom a surgical cricothyroidotomy was attempted in the field by ambulance paramedics over a 5-year period were reviewed. A telephone survey of survivors was used to assess long-term complications and neurologic outcome. RESULTS Surgical cricothyroidotomy was attempted on 50 patients, or 9.8% of those requiring definitive airway control. The most common indications were clenched teeth, blood or vomit obscuring visualization of the upper airway, severe maxillofacial injuries, and inaccessibility because the patient was trapped. Airway establishment was successful in 47 patients (94%). Major complications occurred in 2 patients (4%), where inadvertent dislodgement of the tube developed, requiring replacement. No patient developed significant subglottic stenosis. Nineteen patients (38%) survived and no patient died because of an inadequate airway. Evaluation of neurologic outcome revealed 12 patients (63%) with no significant deficits, 3 (16%) with moderate disability, 2 (10%) with severe disability, and only 2 in a persistent vegetative state. CONCLUSIONS Surgical cricothyroidotomy can be performed on the critically injured patient in the field by ambulance paramedics with a high success rate and a low complication rate. The use of surgical cricothyroidotomy should be included in airway protocols for well-trained, ambulance Advanced Life Support paramedics.

Selective use of computed tomography and diagnostic peritoneal lavage in blunt abdominal trauma

The purpose of this study was to attempt to identify those blunt trauma patients in whom expensive diagnostic studies such as computed tomography and diagnostic peritoneal lavage are unnecessary to exclude intra-abdominal injury. The medical records of 1096 blunt trauma patients evaluated at an urban level I trauma center were reviewed. Because of the urgent need to exclude intra-abdominal hemorrhage in patients with hypotension (blood pressure < 90 mm Hg), and the difficulty in obtaining reliable information from abdominal examination in patients with Glasgow Coma Scale scores < 11 or spinal cord injury, 140 patients meeting these criteria were reviewed but excluded from statistical analysis. Six groups of major associated injuries felt to be potential risk factors for the prediction of intra-abdominal injury were analyzed in the 956 remaining patients. Only two of these potential risk factors, namely chest injury (p = 0.0001) and gross hematuria (p = 0.0003) attained statistical significance. All of the 44 significant intra-abdominal injuries occurred in the group of 253 patients that had either an abnormal abdominal examination, one of the statistically significant risk factors, or both, for a sensitivity of 100%. Of the 703 patients with a normal abdominal examination and no risk factors, none had a significant abdominal injury, for a negative predictive value of 100%. This study suggests that patients with either an abnormal abdominal examination or one of the two statistically derived risk factors require adjunctive diagnostic evaluation with diagnostic peritoneal lavage or computed tomography scan to exclude intra-abdominal injury.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Diagnostic peritoneal lavage in the management of blunt abdominal trauma: a reassessment.

In order to reassess the value of diagnostic peritoneal lavage (DPL) in patients with blunt abdominal trauma, we conducted a prospective study over a 15-month period involving 138 patients. There were 29 (28.3%) patients with positive DPL and 103 (71.7%) with negative DPL in this series. Of the 29 patients with positive DPL, 28 (96.5%) were found to have significant intra-abdominal injuries; 27 by exploratory laparotomy and in one case at autopsy. One patient with a grossly positive DPL had a negative exploratory laparotomy (3.4% false positive rate). All 109 patients with negative DPL were admitted. In only one case a significant intra-abdominal injury was demonstrated (0.9% false negative rate). The overall mortality in this series was 11.6% and there were no complications related to the DPL. Our results suggest that DPL is indeed an accurate indicator of significant intra-abdominal injuries in patients with blunt abdominal trauma.

A prospective evaluation of field categorization of trauma patients

We prospectively evaluated the efficacy of comprehensive field triage in 8,891 trauma patients transported to trauma centers in Dade County, Florida, over a 1-year period ending in September 1986. There were 5,685 males (63.9%) and 3,206 females (36.1%) with a mean age of 32.4 +/- 18.4 years. The overall accuracy for identifying severe injury for the entire group was 30.2%. A Trauma Score less than or equal to 12 was the most accurate predictor of severe injury. Of 669 patients in this group, 617 (92.2%) sustained severe injury and 361 died (54.0%). High-speed (greater than 40 m.p.h.) motor vehicle accident was the most common reason for triage; however, of 2,277 in this group 201 patients (9.0%) had severe injury and four patients (0.2%) died. Only nine deaths (0.9%) occurred in 1,004 patients with penetrating trauma whose Trauma Scores were greater than 12. Of the 8,891 patients 4,791 (53.9%) had moderate to severe injury. The overtriage rate was therefore 46.1% using this field categorization system.

Public hospital-based level I trauma centers: financial survival in the new millennium.

BACKGROUND The medical benefits of trauma centers have been well documented; studies have reported substantial financial losses attributed to trauma care. This study demonstrates the dependence of Level I trauma centers on Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) governmental funds and tax dollars. Furthermore, specific injury groups have greater dependence on these funds. METHODS Records of 553 trauma patients admitted to a public urban Level I trauma center during a 6-month period were reviewed. Patients were grouped according to blunt, penetrating, and thermal injuries. Data for each group included charges, costs, payments, and the source of reimbursement. Profit and loss margins were compared with and without government funds. RESULTS With diminished DSH funds and tax dollars, a net loss over

Suspected vascular trauma of the extremities: The role of arteriography in proximity injuries

2.1 million was incurred. The greatest disparity originates from Medicaid, self-pay, and prisoner patient groups. Inclusion of government funds provided a positive return of over

Retrohepatic vein injuries: experience with 20 cases.

600,000. CONCLUSION The financial stability of urban public Level I trauma centers without additional funding is tenuous because of a high proportion of uninsured and underinsured patients. Government tax dollars and DSH funds are required for their continued solvency.

The use of segmental anatomy for an operative classification of liver injuries

We reviewed 72 patients with penetrating trauma to the extremities who underwent arteriography for proximity injury only. None of the patients had clinical evidence of vascular trauma. There were 62 males and ten females, with a mean age of 29.9 years. Gunshot wounds were the most common cause of injury (91.7%) and the thigh was the most common site of injury (47.2%). A normal arteriogram was found in 55 of 72 patients (76.4%). The remaining 17 patients (23.6%) had arteriographic abnormalities that did not warrant surgery. Only one patient was explored (1.4%) for spasm of the popliteal artery. No vascular injury was found at surgery. This study suggests that routine arteriography in proximity injury only may be unnecessary and that these patients could safely be admitted to the hospital for a 24-hour period of observation.