Gerrit Uilenberg

The global importance of ticks

Ticks and tick-borne diseases affect animal and human health worldwide and are the cause of significant economic losses. Approximately 10% of the currently known 867 tick species act as vectors of a broad range of pathogens of domestic animals and humans and are also responsible for damage directly due to their feeding behaviour. The most important tick species and the effects they cause are listed. The impact on the global economy is considered to be high and although some estimates are given, there is a lack of reliable data. The impact of ticks and tick-borne diseases on animal production and public health and their control are discussed.

Heartwater in the Caribbean

Abstract Cowdria ruminantium , causal rickettsia of heartwater in ruminants, was until recently only known to occur in Africa. it is transmitted by Amblyomma ticks. Amblyomma variegatum , one of its African vectors, was introduced into the Caribbean area with cattle from Senegal about 1830. Before 1900 only Guadeloupe and Antigua were known to be infested. Martinique was invaded as late as 1948. The spread of the tick accelerated afterwards, especially during the last decade. It has now been found on Guadeloupe (Grande Terre and Basse Terre), Antigua, Martinique, St. Croix, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, Nevis, St. Kitts, St. Maarten/St. Martin, Vieques, Anguilla, Marie-Galante and La Desirade. All of these islands are probably still infested today, except possibly St. Croix and La Desirade. The existence of heartwater on Guadeloupe has been suspected since 1966, and was at last confirmed in 1980, having almost certainly been present for a century and a half. A strain of C. ruminantium was isolated in 1982. Retrospectively, a bovine disease with symptoms like those of heartwater has been known on the island since 1932. Two other African infections of which A. variegatum is a vector, Theileria mutans and T. velifera , also occur in cattle on Guadeloupe. Heartwater has so far been diagnosed only in Guadeloupe and in near-by Marie-Galante. An investigation for its presence has been started on other islands where A.variegatum occurs. However, it has been shown that the American tick Amblyomma maculatum is a good experimental vector, and that A.cajennense can also transmit C.ruminantium , but probably not very efficiently. If the agent can adapt to these and other American Amblyomma species, it could spread to large areas in the western hemisphere, well outside those where the strictly tropical A.variegatum would find a suitable habitat. An assessment of the extent of this serious threat to the livestock industry of the Americas should be followed by urgent action while there is still hope of removing the danger as long as the disease remains limited to a few of the smaller islands. Apart from a survey of the distribution of the disease and Amblyomma ticks, information is needed on animal movements between islands, on migration routes of birds (hosts of immature stages), animal husbandry methods, and species and numbers of domestic animals, as well as wild hosts which may interfere with tick eradication. Severe dermatophilosis (cutaneous streptothricosis) of cattle appears to be closely linked with the presence of A.variegatum and causes high losses on the infested islands. This will make it easier to obtain the collaboration of livestock owners and authorities for eradication campaigns, even on islands where heartwater does not (yet) occur.

On molecular taxonomy: what is in a name?

Gene sequences of small portions of the genome are often used for premature detailed taxonomic changes, neglecting polyphasic taxonomy, which should also consider phenotypical characteristics. Three examples are given: (i) Recently, members of the genera Eperythrozoon and Haemobartonella have been moved, correctly so, from the Rickettsiales to the Mycoplasmatales, but were assigned to the genus Mycoplasma, mostly on the basis of 16S rRNA sequence analysis. Not only is the 16S rRNA sequence similarity between ‘classical’Mycoplasma and these species of Eperythrozoon and Haemobartonella less than that between some other well-recognised bacterial genera, but their biological differences amply justify their classification in different genera of the Mycoplasmatales. Furthermore, the move creates considerable confusion, as it necessitates new names for some species, with more confusion likely to come when the 16S rRNA sequences of the type species of Eperythrozoon, a name which has priority over Mycoplasma, will be analysed. (ii) In the Rickettsiales, members of the genera Anaplasma, Ehrlichia, Cowdria, Neorickettsia and Wolbachia are so closely related phylogenetically on the basis of 16S rRNA sequences, and for some also of groESL operon sequences, that they have recently been fused, correctly so, into one family, the Anaplasmataceae, while the tribes Ehrlichieae and Wolbachieae have been abolished. Sequence diversity within the ‘classical’ genus Ehrlichia has led to classifying E. phagocytophila (including E. equi and the agent of human granulocytic ehrlichiosis), E. platys and E. bovis in the genus Anaplasma, while others have been retained in Ehrlichia, which also includes Cowdria ruminantium. E. sennetsu and E. risticii have been transferred to the genus Neorickettsia. 16S rRNA and GroEL sequences of ‘classical’ Anaplasma and some members of ‘classical’ Ehrlichia do show a close relationship, but differences in citrate synthase gene sequences, the GC content of this gene, and sequences of the gene encoding the β-subunit of RNA polymerase, not to speak of the phenotypical differences, do not justify the fusion into one genus. Because of the phylogenetical diversity in Ehrlichia it is recommended that a new genus name be created for the E. phagocytophila genogroup (and E. platys and E. bovis). (iii) One of the conclusions of studies on the phylogeny of ticks of the subfamilies Rhipicephalinae and Hyalomminae, based on nucleotide sequences from 12S rRNA, cytochrome c oxidase I, the internal transcribed spacer 2, 18S rRNA, as well as morphological characters, is that Boophilus should be considered as a subgenus of Rhipicephalus. While Boophilus and Rhipicephalus are undoubtedly close, the obviously important morphological and biological differences between the genera Rhipicephalus and Boophilus are thus overruled by similarities in the sequences of a number of genes and this leads to considerable confusion. Polyphasic taxonomy amply justifies maintaining Boophilus as a separate genus, phylogenetically near to Rhipicephalus. This note is a plea for a cautious and balanced approach to taxonomy, taking into account molecular genotypical information, as far as is possible from different genes, as well as phenotypical characteristics.

Monitoring of naturally acquired and artificially induced immunity to #Amblyomma variegatum# and Rhipicephalus appendiculatus ticks under field and laboratory conditions

The ability of rabbits, goats and cattle to acquire immunity to the ixodid ticksAmblyomma variegatum andRhipicephalus appendiculatus was studied under laboratory and field conditions. Rabbits were successfully immunized with crude salivary gland extract (SGE) and midgut extract (ME) obtained from flat or partly fed femaleR. appendiculatus ticks. The lowest numbers of larvae were produced by females fed on rabbits immunized with unfed midgut extract. Similar reductions in larval production could be induced after three infestations of rabbits with adultR. appendiculatus. Also, successive feedings of nymphs ofR. appendiculatus on rabbits resulted in significantly reduced engorgement weights. Skin testing with SGE induced delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions, which could be correlated with immunity toR. appendiculatus in rabbits. Moreover, circulating antibodies were detected in rabbits with an ELISA using SGE ofR. appendiculatus.Immunity toA. variegatum nymphs could be induced in rabbits by repeated infestations, but this failed in goats. Immunization of goats with midgut extract from adultA. variegatum did not protect against subsequent nymphal challenge, but strong skin reactions were noticed when adults ticks fed on immunized goats. Sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of SGE and ME fromA. variegatum revealed the presence of 48 protein bands in SGE and 29 bands in midgut extract. Western blotting employing serum from a rabbit immune toR. appendiculatus recognized a number of bands in SGE fromR. appendiculatus, but also in SGE ofA. variegatum.Immunity acquired by cattle to ixodid tick infestations under field conditions was monitored by skin testing with SGE and western blot analysis. In general, cattle with the lowest tick numbers manifested the strongest delayed-type hypersensitivity responses. Finally, western blot analysis employing sera from tick-infested and tick-naive cattle could not be related to actual immune status.

Antigenic diversity of Cowdria ruminantium isolates determined by cross-immunity

Antigenic diversity in five stocks of the tick-borne rickettsia Cowdria ruminantium, the causal agent of heartwater disease of ruminants, was studied by cross-immunity trials in goats and sheep. Complete absence of cross-protection was found only between the Kümm and Kwanyanga stocks, and in all other combinations there were various degrees of cross-immunity. Immunological strain differences were more pronounced in goats than in sheep.

Ornithodoros porcinus ticks, bushpigs, and African swine fever in Madagascar

African swine fever (ASF) has recently made its appearance in Madagascar. Ticks of the Ornithodoros moubata group, considered to be O. porcinus Walton, 1962 were formerly known to occur in western Madagascar, but seem to have disappeared from that region. However, three new sites where they occur were found in the humid and cool central highlands of Anatananarivo province. These ticks are known to be efficient reservoirs and vectors of ASF and constitute a considerable complication to the control of the disease. The authors also discuss another potentially complicating factor, the presence of a species of African bushpig, Potamochoerus larvatus.

Immunization of cattle against Theileria parva bovis and their exposure to natural challenge

Theileria parva bovis isolates were tested for their immunizing capacity under natural field challenge on Willsbridge Farm in the highveld of Zimbabwe. Fifteen susceptible Sussex yearlings were immunized with the Boleni stock and 15 with a mixture of three isolates from the farm, using tick-derived sporozoite stabilates. No chemoprophylaxis was used. A dose of 0.1 ml of stabilate appeared to be safe in preliminary laboratory experiments, but the reactions were severe in the Sussex cattle and one died despite treatment. Twenty-nine immunized animals and 10 controls first experienced a mild infection, starting about 15 days after their arrival at the farm. Ten of the immunized animals and four controls had schizonts in peripheral lymph nodes for variable periods; one third of those had pyrexia. Nymphal Rhipicephalus appendiculatus ticks applied to three of the reacting immunized calves transmitted Theileria taurotragi to two animals and T. parva to a third. A second Theileria infection, due to T. parva bovis, was detected shortly after the first one. Schizonts were detected in seven out of 10 controls. Pyrexia was more severe and prolonged. Two of the controls died of theileriosis. At the same time schizonts were seen in three immune animals and eight of them had short periods of pyrexia. Intercurrent infections with Babesia bigemina, Borrelia theileri and Eperythrozoon were detected and may have contributed to the fever. Tick infestations were low during the exposure. In the second year of exposure, four out of eight new control animals had severe reactions, and one died. None of the immunized animals became ill, but one animal from the first year control group, which had not reacted previously, had clinical theileriosis. It is concluded that immunization provided an effective protection against field challenge.

Relationships between Cytauxzoon felis and African piroplasmids

A cat which had recovered from Cytauxzoon felis infection following treatment with the anti-theilerial drug, parvaquone, showed an increase in piroplasm parasitemia after splenectomy and its blood was suitable for the preparation of antigen smears for the indirect fluorescent antibody test. High levels of antibodies were found in this cat after recovery, in two other cats sub-lethally infected with piroplasms and in sera of naturally infected bobcats. Cats recovered from piroplasm infection died from cytauxzoonosis when challenged with organ material containing C. felis schizonts. Tests with piroplasm antigens and positive sera of C. felis, South African Babesia felis and African Theileria taurotragi showed no significant serological relationship between C. felis and the African parasites. C. felis was not shown to be infective for splenectomized sheep.

Ticks of the Central African Republic

A review is presented of the ticks of the Central African Republic (C.A.R.), based on unpublished data and a literature review. We consider as established in the C.A.R. two species of Argasidae (one species of each of the genera Carios and Ornithodoros) and 49 species of Ixodidae: 5 Ixodes, 11 Amblyomma, 2 Dermacentor, 9 Haemaphysalis, 4 Hyalomma, and 18 Rhipicephalus species, 3 of which belong to the subgenus Boophilus. Two of these species, one Amblyomma and one Dermacentor, may by now have disappeared from the country together with their hosts, the black and white rhinoceroses. Moreover, four other species of Ixodidae have been recorded, but are not necessarily established in the country, and 6 species of Ixodidae have apparently been reported incorrectly; the data for the occurrence of three other species of Ixodidae are uncertain. Rhipicephalus species in the C.A.R. present the greatest difficulties in identification, on the one hand because of uncertainties in taxonomy, particularly in the capensis group, on the other hand because of individual variability, which means that individual specimens cannot always be reliably identified to species. Examining the dissected and cleared gonopore structure of females helps, but is very time-consuming where large numbers are involved. Some of the species of the genus Haemaphysalis are also difficult to identify with certainty. There are only a few species of Hyalomma in the country. We revised also some old records of ticks in C.A.R., which we consider as unreliable and should be disregarded because of subsequent changes in taxonomy and nomenclature, unless the material is still available for examination.

Rupert Pegram: Thirteen years of hell in paradise. An account of the Caribbean Amblyomma Programme: Trafford Publishing, 2010, 429 pp

This book should definitely be read by the relevant authorities of donor countries, executing agencies and by decision makers, in order to avoid similar disasters in the future. The unreliability of financing field projects is terrible. At the time I worked for FAO (in the 1970s), I remember my surprise when I discovered that FAO depended on donor agencies such as UNDP and on donor countries for financing most of its field projects. Its own budget was quite insufficient! When slightly before finishing our field project on the immunisation against East Coast fever in East Africa the financing by UNDP through FAO crashed, I went begging to the Dutch Embassy in Tanzania for money, to enable us to finish the project correctly. I was lucky to obtain it! The financing of field projects by donor countries depends on the government of such countries. This is subject to change. Elections may result in a very different government, with a decrease or an increase in the budget of aid agencies. One of the consequences of the considerable extension of the European Union following the collapse of the USSR is the switch of aid money from ‘‘classical’’ developing countries to the poorer new members of the EU. And the present economic crisis has also resulted in a decrease of aid money. The regular budget that aid agencies receive from their government tends to diminish, so that for their own survival they have to look for projects which are profitable to the agency and its staff, not necessarily important for the developing country. There are even examples of transferring aid funds to other purposes, e.g. diplomatic presentation or military training, with only the remotest link to what is usually called aid, thus keeping the budget for aid funds artificially high, while diminishing the general deficit!