Gila Benchetrit

Breathing pattern in humans: diversity and individuality.

In adult awake human subjects at rest, there exists a diversity in the breathing pattern not only in terms of tidal volume and inspiratory and expiratory duration and derived variables (TTOT, VT/TI and TI/TTOT) but also in the airflow profile. Besides this diversity, in every recording of ventilation at rest in steady-state condition breath-to-breath fluctuations are observed in ventilatory variables. This variability is non random and may be explained either by a central neural mechanism or by instability in the chemical feedback loops. Beyond this variability, each individual appears to select one particular pattern among the infinite number of possible combination of ventilatory variables and airflow profile. This one particular pattern appears to be a relatively stable characteristic of an adult individual being reproducible in several conditions and above all, after a long period of time. Consequences of this individuality of breathing pattern are discussed with regard to the selection of control subjects for a study and also per se: are there physiological situations where differences may be observed solely because of the differences in the pattern of breathing?

Individuality of breathing patterns in adults assessed over time

Sixteen healthy adult subjects underwent two studies separated by 4-5 years to test whether their resting pattern of breathing was reproducible over time. From breath-by-breath analysis of airflow, measured with a pneumotachometer, the pattern of breathing was quantified in terms of individual respiratory variables; inspiratory time (TI), expiratory time (TE), total breath duration (TTOT), tidal volume (VT), VT/TI, TI/TTOT, and by taking TI, TE and VT all together (TRIAD). Also, the shape of the entire airflow profile was quantified by harmonic analysis (ASTER). A statistical analysis was designed to compare differences between the 1st and the 2nd recording within individuals with those differences observed between random pairs of recordings from the two studies in the same 16 individuals. It was found that all variables were significantly more similar within-individuals than between-individuals; this is best demonstrated when considering the ASTER and/or the TRIAD. It was concluded that the individuality of breathing pattern is maintained over a long period despite changes in smoking habit, weight, mild respiratory diseases, and other changes which occurred between the two studies in our subjects.

Comparison Between the Respiratory Inductance Plethysmography Signal Derivative and the Airflow Signal

The use of respiratory inductance plethysmography (RIP) for measurement of breathing is appealing not only because of its noninvasive nature but also because it provides rib cage and abdomen cross sectional area changes.

Enhanced cardiac vagal efferent activity does not explain training-induced bradycardia.

Studies of heart rate variability (HRV) have so far produced contradictory evidence to support the common belief that endurance training enhances cardiac parasympathetic tone. This may be related to the fact that most studies failed to specifically isolate the vagally mediated influence of respiration. This study used a cross-sectional comparison of endurance athletes (n=20; ATHL) exhibiting resting bradycardia and age-matched nonathletes (n=12; CRTL) to indirectly assess training effects on amplitude and timing characteristics of respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA). Continuous electrocardiogram (ECG) and ventilatory flows were recorded during spontaneous breathing (SP), as well as during breathing at four cycles less than (M4) or more (P4) than SP, to also examine potential repercussions of training on the sensitivity of the cardiac vagal responses to breathing. A fast Fourier transform procedure was used to quantify the standard spectral high-frequency (HF) and low-frequency (LF) components and a respiratory-centered frequency (RCF) component of HRV. RSA was assessed using a breath-by-breath quantification of the amplitude and timing of the maximum change in instantaneous heart rate. Under baseline SP conditions, heart rate was lower in ATHL (62.6+/-6.5 vs. 75.2+/-9 beats/min; p<0.05) while blood pressure (BP), breath cycle duration, tidal volume, and ventilatory drive were similar in both groups. HRV total spectral power density, LF, HF, or RCF was not different between groups at either the SP, M4, or P4 conditions. Changes in total breath duration similarly affected RSA amplitude in all groups, while HR and BP remained unchanged from SP. RSA phase was not affected by training status or by changes in total breath duration. RSA amplitude was negatively related to breathing frequency in all groups (p<0.05), while the mean slope of the relationship (sensitivity) was not different between groups. In as much as RSA is an adequate marker of cardiac vagal efferent activity, these results add support to a contribution of a decrease in intrinsic heart rate to explain training-induced bradycardia.

Breathing pattern in patients with Parkinson's disease.

The improvement in motor performance resulting from levodopa administration in patients with Parkinsons disease (PD) provides the opportunity to investigate ventilatory changes brought about by the disease. The aim of this study has been to investigate these changes in order to specify the mechanisms of the impairment in breathing in PD. Breathing patterns at rest were investigated in 11 patients with idiopathic PD both before (OFF) and after (ON) administration of levodopa at a dose improving their motor performance by at least 30%. Airflow (Fleisch head mounted on a mask), rib cage and abdomen movements (inductance plethysmography) were recorded in the OFF condition 1 h after subjects woke up. Subjects then received levodopa and a new set of recordings was obtained 1 h later, in the ON condition. Breath-by-breath processing of recordings was carried out, and tidal volume (VT), inspiratory (TI) and expiratory (TE) durations were measured. The main finding was a lengthening of TI resulting in a decrease in ventilation and in VT/TI, and an increase in TI/TTOT in the ON compared to the OFF condition. In the ON condition abnormal rib cage-abdomen plots patterns were found in four out of six subjects. A hypothesis on the effect of PD on breathing is proposed on grounds of normal diaphragmatic activity but impaired activity of the other respiratory muscles and more specifically the intercostal muscles.

The effects of breathing pattern training on ventilatory function in patients with COPD.

The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of a particular breathing pattern training (BPT) on forced expiratory volume during the first second (FEV1) and forced vital capacity (FVC) in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). The subjects adjusted each breath to a target breath displayed on a video screen, by using visual feedback. This target was chosen in an individual sample recorded at rest. We used a randomized, controlled group design. Twenty patients with stable COPD, FEV1 less than 1.5 liters, undergoing a traditional rehabilitation program were randomly assigned to the BPT group or to the control group. Each BPT subject underwent 30–35 training sessions spread out over four weeks, in addition to the traditional program. FEV1 and FVC were performed before and after this program. ANOVAs showed that FEV1 and FVC significantly improved in BPT subjects, with a mean percent increase of 22% and 19%, respectively. Corresponding changes in controls were not significant. This study showed short-term increases in FEV1 and FVC in COPD patients practicing BPT in addition to respiratory rehabilitation, in comparison with controls. Further studies should incorporate outcome data to clarify the mechanisms and the duration of this effect.

A program for cycle-by-cycle shape analysis of biological rhythms. Application to respiratory rhythm.

A computer program for cycle-by-cycle analysis and quantification of biological rhythms, written for an Apple II microcomputer with 48k RAM is described. The program comprises 4 steps: (1) file constitution suitable for biological data collecting; (2) signal digitalization at a sampling rate up to 1 kHz with storage in central memory; (3) determination of each cycles limits (delimitation parameters being defined by the user; following delimitation, cycles may be dropped or saved for further analyses); (4) cycle-by-cycle harmonic analysis (fast Fourier Transform algorithm). The program is written in BASIC Applesoft, hardware-dependent functions (analog inputs, graphic display and random access disk storage) are implemented in subroutines (partly assembler) which may be easily modified. The program, consisting of 4 chained procedures is run interactively, although procedure (4) may be run automatically. Analysis of human ventilatory airflow signal with this program is given as an example of cycle-by-cycle shape analysis of a biological rhythm.

Effects of resistive loading on the pattern of breathing

In order to determine changes in breathing patterns brought about by resistive loading, ventilation was recorded in 11 healthy subjects with four linear resistances (3.57, 5.75, 8.76 and 13.13 cmH2O L(-1) sec) added in a random order throughout the entire breath. At steady state, a breath-by-breath analysis of airflow was used to quantify the pattern of breathing in terms of respiratory variables: TI, TE, Tt, VT, VT/TI, TI/Tt, and by taking TI, TE, VT all together (TRIAD) and also the shape of the entire airflow profile quantified by harmonic analysis (ASTER). Group analysis using ANOVA showed significant changes in all variables. There were increasing changes with increasing loads in all variables, the smallest changes being in TI/Tt. Within to between-individual comparisons between two loads showed that only TI/Tt and the ASTER were more similar within than between-individuals for all comparisons. It was concluded that at steady state mechanisms of load compensation come into play inducing changes in the pattern of breathing proportional to the loads while maintaining some of the individual characteristics.

Calibration of respiratory inductance plethysmograph in preterm infants with different respiratory conditions

Respiratory inductance plethysmography (RIP) is a method for respiratory measurements particularly attractive in infants because it is noninvasive and it does not interfere with the airway. RIP calibration remains controversial in neonates, and is particularly difficult in infants with thoraco-abdominal asynchrony or with ventilatory assist. The objective of this study was to evaluate a new RIP calibration method in preterm infants either without respiratory disease, with thoraco-abdominal asynchrony, or with ventilatory support. This method is based on (i) a specifically adapted RIP jacket, (ii) the least squares method to estimate the volume/motion ribcage and abdominal coefficients, and (iii) an individualized filtering method that takes into account individual breathing pattern. The reference flow was recorded with a pneumotachograph. The accuracy of flow reconstruction using the new method was compared to the accuracy of three other calibration methods, with arbitrary fixed RIP coefficients or with coefficients determined according to qualitative diagnostic calibration method principle. Fifteen preterm neonates have been studied; gestational age was (mean +/- SD) 31.7 +/- 0.8 weeks; birth weight was 1,470 +/- 250 g. The respiratory flow determined with the new method had a goodness of fit at least equivalent to the other three methods in the entire group. Moreover, in unfavorable conditions--breathing asynchrony or ventilatory assist--the quality of fit was significantly higher than with the three other methods (P < 0.05, repeated measures ANOVA). Accuracy of tidal volume measurements was at least equivalent to the other methods, and the breath-by-breath differences with reference volumes were lower, although not significantly, than with the other methods. The goodness of fit of the reconstructed RIP flow with this new method--even in unfavorable respiratory conditions--provides a prerequisite for the study of flow pattern during the neonatal period.

Use of Respiratory Inductance Plethysmography for the Detection of Swallowing in the Elderly

It is essential to have a user-friendly, noninvasive bedside procedure at our disposal in order to study swallowing and swallowing disorders in the elderly in view of the frailty of this age group. In the present work, respiratory inductance plethysmography (RIP) is proposed as an appropriate clinical tool for such studies. An automated process for the detection of swallowing is used involving the derivative of the respiratory volume signal. The accuracy of the automated detection is given by the area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve and is found to be greater than 0.9. At the optimal threshold, RIP constitutes a reliable and objective bedside clinical tool for studying swallowing in the elderly, as well as being user-friendly and noninvasive. In addition, RIP can be used to monitor swallowing in order to analyze swallowing disorders and put in place medical supervision of swallowing for individuals who might aspirate.