Gilles Marchal

Prolonged Persistence of Substantial Volumes of Potentially Viable Brain Tissue After Stroke A Correlative PET-CT Study With Voxel-Based Data Analysis

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSEnThe existence in humans of brain tissue at risk for infarction but potentially viable (eg, the penumbra) remains unproven. One retrospective operational definition of such tissue includes its final infarction despite a relatively preserved or even normal cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen (CMRO2) in the early hours after stroke onset. Although previous positron emission tomography (PET) studies identified tissue whose CMRO2 declined from the acute to the subacute stage, in principle compatible with deteriorating penumbra, they all lacked a coregistered CT scan mapping of final infarct and an objective three-dimensional PET data analysis, while many patients were studied in the subacute (up to 48 hours) phase. We have evaluated whether tissue with CMRO2 ranging above a threshold for presumably irreversible damage in the first 18 hours of middle cerebral artery territory stroke, but below it in the chronic stage, could be retrospectively identified within the final infarct volume.nnnMETHODSnOur data bank comprises 30 consecutive patients with first-ever middle cerebral artery territory stroke prospectively studied with PET within the first 18 hours after clinical onset; the 15O equilibrium method was used to measure cerebral blood flow and CMRO2. All survivors with the following criteria were eligible for the present study: (1) technically adequate chronic-stage PET performed in the same stereotaxic conditions, (2) coregistered CT scan also performed in the chronic stage, and (3) an infarct of sufficient dimension (>16mm diameter) on late CT. Corresponding CT scan cuts and PET slices were exactly realigned, and the outlines of CT hypodensities were superimposed on the corresponding CMRO2 matrix. Infarcted voxels with CMRO2 values less than or greater than 1.40 mL/100 mL per minute (ie, the generally accepted threshold for irreversible damage) were automatically identified and projected on matrices of all other PET parameters and for both PET studies.nnnRESULTSnEight patients (mean age, 78 Years) were eligible for the present study. The acute-stage PET study was performed 7 to 17 hours after stroke onset and the chronic-stage PET 13 to 41 days later. Within the final infarct, mean CMRO2 fell significantly from the acute- to the chronic-stage PET study (P<.001). Eventually infarcted voxels with acute-stage CMRO2 values above the threshold were found in each of these eight patients; they were most often situated near the infarct borders and constituted 10% to 52% (mean, 32%) of the final infarct volume. The acute-stage CMRO2 in these voxels ranged up to 4.13 mL/100 mL per minute but fell below 1.40 mL/100 mL per minute in 93% of them at the chronic-stage PET. in 7 of 8 patients the acute-stage mean cerebral blood flow ranged from 10 to 22 mL/100 mL per minute, and the mean oxygen extraction fraction was markedly increased (>0.70) in these voxels, consistent with a penumbral state.nnnCONCLUSIONnIn a strictly homogeneous sample of prospectively studied patients, we have identified, up to 17 hours after stroke onset, substantial volumes of tissue with CMRO2 well above the assumed threshold for viability that nevertheless spontaneously evolved toward necrosis. This tissue exhibited penumbral ranges of both cerebral blood flow and oxygen extraction fraction and thus could represent the part of penumbra that might be saved with appropriate therapy.

Early Postischemic Hyperperfusion: Pathophysiologic Insights from Positron Emission Tomography

Early postischemic hyperperfusion (EPIH) has long been documented in animal stroke models and is the hallmark of efficient recanalization of the occluded artery with subsequent reperfusion of the tissue (although occasionally it may be seen in areas bordering the hypoperfused area during arterial occlusion). In experimental stroke, early reperfusion has been reported to both prevent infarct growth and aggravate edema formation and hemorrhage, depending on the severity and duration of prior ischemia and the efficiency of reperfusion, whereas neuronal damage with or without enlarged infarction also may result from reperfusion (so-called “reperfusion injury”). In humans, focal hyperperfusion in the subacute stage (i.e., more than 48 hours after onset) has been associated with tissue necrosis in most instances, but regarding the acute stage, its occurrence, its relations with tissue metabolism and viability, and its clinical prognostic value were poorly understood before the advent of positron emission tomography (PET), in part because of methodologic issues. By measuring both CBF and metabolism, PET is an ideal imaging modality to study the pathophysiologic mechanism of EPIH. Although only a few PET studies have been performed in the acute stage that have systematically assessed tissue and clinical outcome in relation to EPIH, they have provided important insights. In one study, about one third of the patients with first-ever middle cerebral artery (MCA) territory stroke studied within 5 to 18 hours after symptom onset exhibited EPIH. In most cases, EPIH affected large parts of the cortical MCA territory in a patchy fashion, together with abnormal vasodilation (increased cerebral blood volume), “luxury perfusion” (decreased oxygen extraction fraction), and mildly increased CMRO2, which was interpreted as postischemic rebound of cellular metabolism in structurally preserved tissue. In that study, the spontaneous outcome of the tissue exhibiting EPIH was good, with late structural imaging not showing infarction. This observation was supported by another PET study, which showed, in a few patients, that previously hypoperfused tissue that later exhibited hyperperfusion after thrombolysis did not undergo frank infarction at follow-up. In both studies, clinical outcome was excellent in all patients showing EPIH except one, but in this case the hyperperfused area coexisted with an extensive area of severe hypoperfusion and hypometabolism. These findings from human studies therefore suggest that EPIH is not detrimental for the tissue, which contradicts the experimental concept of “reperfusion injury” but is consistent with the apparent clinical benefit from thrombolysis. However, PET studies performed in the cat have shown that although hyperperfusion was associated with prolonged survival and lack of histologic infarction when following brief (30-minute) MCA occlusion, it often was associated with poor outcome and extensive infarction when associated with longer (60-minute) MCA occlusion. It is unclear whether this discrepancy with human studies reflects a shorter window for tissue survival after stroke in cats, points to the cat being more prone to reperfusion injury, or indicates that EPIH tends not to develop in humans after severe or prolonged ischemia because of a greater tendency for the no-reflow phenomenon, for example. Nevertheless, the fact that the degree of hyperperfusion in these cat studies was related to the severity of prior flow reduction suggests that hyperperfusion is not detrimental per se. Preliminary observations in temporary MCA occlusion in baboons suggest that hyperperfusion developing even after 6 hours of occlusion is mainly cortical and associated with no frank infarction, as in humans. Overall, therefore, PET studies in both humans and the experimental animal, including the baboon, suggest that hyperperfusion is not a key factor in the development of tissue infarction and that it may be a harmless phenomenon when it occurs in the acute setting. However, an important issue that needs to be resolved by future studies with respect to EPIH relates to the possible occurrence of selective neuronal loss, as opposed to pan-necrosis, in the previously hyperperfused tissue.

Sequential Studies of Severely Hypometabolic Tissue Volumes After Permanent Middle Cerebral Artery Occlusion A Positron Emission Tomographic Investigation in Anesthetized Baboons

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSEnIn the positron emission tomography literature, markedly hypometabolic brain tissue (oxygen metabolism < 1.3 to 1.7 mL.100 g-1.min-1) has often been equated with irreversible damage in the human brain. By serial positron emission tomography measurements, we investigated the temporal evolution of the volume of severely hypometabolic brain tissue after permanent middle cerebral artery occlusion in anesthetized baboons with, as a perspective, the development of rational therapeutic strategies.nnnMETHODSnSeven anesthetized and ventilated baboons underwent sequential positron emission tomography examinations with the 15O steady-state technique before and 1, 4, 7, and 24 hours and 14 to 29 days after occlusion. In each baboon the infarct volume was calculated by quantitative histological procedures after 19 to 41 days of occlusion.nnnRESULTSnThe sequential measurement of regional oxygen metabolism demonstrated an extension (for > or = 24 hours) of the volume of severely hypometabolic tissue as defined by both absolute and relative metabolic thresholds, and this profile of evolutivity is observed no matter the threshold used. Mean (+/- SEM) infarction volume of 2.4 +/- 0.6 cm3 was comparable to a tissue volume with oxygen consumption < 40% of contralateral metabolism. The volume of hypometabolic tissue was essentially stable at the 1-, 4-, and 7-hour postocclusion studies, increased markedly at the 24-hour study point, and increased even further in the chronic-stage study (on average, 17 days after occlusion). The tissue that eventually displayed a severely hypometabolic state at the final measurement showed a significant decrease of oxygen metabolism and cerebral blood flow at each time analyzed. In that tissue, the oxygen extraction fraction increased significantly at 1 hour (although not thereafter).nnnCONCLUSIONSnThe extension of severely hypometabolic volume after middle cerebral artery occlusion reinforces the concept of a dynamic penumbra and suggests the existence of a relatively large window of therapeutic opportunity in which it may be possible to develop neuroprotective strategies. Our study suggests that maximum infarct volume is determined at some time between 24 hours and 17 days after permanent middle cerebral artery occlusion in anesthetized baboons.

Healthy aging, memory subsystems and regional cerebral oxygen consumption

The present study was designed to search for concomitant age-related changes in memory subsystems, defined according to current structural theories, and resting oxygen consumption in selected brain regions. We have investigated a sample of subjects between 20 and 68 years of age and strictly screened for their good health. We applied in the same subjects a battery of neuropsychological tests selected to investigate several memory subsystems, and high-resolution positron imaging with stereotaxic localization to study a purposely limited number of cerebral structures, selected on a priori hypotheses to match the different memory subsystems. Our results showed significant age-related changes in performance on some tests, consistent with the literature, including an increase in semantic memory and a decrease in both working memory (central executive system) and verbal episodic and explicit memory. There was also an age-related linear decrease in global brain oxygen consumption which regionally reached statistical significance for the neocortical areas and the left thalamus. There was a limited number of significant, age-independent correlations between the raw psychometric test scores and resting regional oxidative metabolism. Consistent with our present understanding of the functional anatomy of memory, the Associate Learning scores (verbal episodic and explicit memory) were positively correlated with left hippocampal and thalamic metabolism. The positive relationships found between right hippocampal metabolism and performance in the Associate Learning and the Brown-Peterson tests were less expected but would be consistent with findings from recent PET activation studies. The results from this investigation are discussed in the light of current knowledge concerning the neuropsychology and the neurobiology of both aging and memory.

Predictive Value of 99mTc-HMPAO-SPECT for Neurological Outcome/Recovery at the Acute Stage of Stroke

Background and Purpose: Combined perfusion and oxygen metabolism PET imaging is highly predictive of spontaneous outcome after middle cerebral artery (MCA) stroke, independent of clinical scores, but whether the assessment of perfusion alone by SPECT provides similar information remains unclear. We have assessed the prognostic value of 99mTc-HMPAO-SPECT at the acute stage of stroke. Methods: Twenty-seven first-ever nonhemorrhagic MCA territory stroke patients were prospectively studied 4–20 h (mean: 12 h) after onset with 99mTc-HMPAO-SPECT. None was part of a therapeutic trial or received thrombolysis. Neurological deficits were quantified at admission and 2 months later with Orgogozo’s MCA scale. SPECT images were visually classified by 3 independent observers into one of three patterns, as follows: pattern I = marked and extensive tracer hypofixation; pattern II = moderate and/or focal hypofixation with or without combined hyperfixation, and pattern III = normal or increased uptake without hypofixation. In addition to this visual analysis, we also calculated a voxel-based ‘hypoperfusion score’, an index of severity × extent of hypofixation according to Mountz’s method. Results: There was a good intra- and interobserver agreement. After consensus, 9, 14 and 4 patients were classified in patterns I, II and III, respectively. These patterns had a significant predictive value for raw outcome but not for percentage recovery (p = 0.008 and p = 0.127, respectively). Thus, all patients in pattern III had a good outcome, while most (but not all) patients in pattern I had a poor or intermediate outcome; pattern II patients were more evenly distributed among outcomes. Hypoperfusion scores were highly significantly positively correlated with both 2-month outcomes and percentage recoveries, even after controlling the predictive value of day 0 MCA scores by partial correlations. Comments: We found that SPECT had a significant added predictive value even when compared to admission neurological scores. Although less accurate than PET, 99mTc-HMPAO-SPECT may help to predict spontaneous individual neurological evolution, especially whenever perfusion images are normal or show an increased tracer uptake without associated hypofixation.