Giuseppe Maddaloni

Eurocode 8 Compliant Real Record Sets for Seismic Analysis of Structures

Among all the possible options to define the seismic input for structural analysis, natural recordings are emerging as the most attractive. Easily accessible waveform databases are available and evidence shows that only a relatively limited number of criteria has to be considered in selection and scaling to get an unbiased estimation of seismic demand. Like many codes worldwide, Eurocode 8 (EC8) allows the use of real ground-motion records for the seismic assessment of structures. The main condition to be satisfied by the chosen set is that the average elastic spectrum does not underestimate the code spectrum, with a 10% tolerance, in a broad range of periods depending on the structures dynamic properties. The EC8 prescriptions seem to favour the use of spectrum-matching records, obtained either by simulation or manipulation of real records. The study presented herein investigates the European Strong-Motion Database with the purpose of assessing whether it is possible to find real accelerogram sets complying with the EC8 spectra, while accounting for additional constraints believed to matter in the seismic assessment of buildings, as suggested by the current best practice. Original (un-scaled) accelerogram sets matching EC8 criteria were found, for the case of one-component (P-type) and spatial sets (S-type), for the spectra anchored to the Italian peak acceleration values. The average spectra for these sets tend to be as close as possible to the code spectrum. Other sets, requiring scaling, have been found to match the non dimensional (country-independent) EC8 spectral shape. These sets have also the benefit of reducing, in respect to the un-scaled sets, the record-to-record variability of spectra. Combinations referring to soft soil, stiff soil, and rock are presented here and are available on the internet at http://www.reluis.it/

Shake table tests for seismic assessment of suspended continuous ceilings

After an earthquake, the failure of suspended ceiling systems is one of the most widely reported types of nonstructural damage in building structures. Since suspended ceiling systems are not amenable to traditional structural analysis, full-scale experimental testing is planned and executed. In particular, shaking table tests are performed in order to investigate the seismic behaviour of plasterboard continuous suspended ceilings under strong earthquakes. Two kinds of ceiling systems, named single frame ceiling and double frame ceiling, are tested. A steel test frame is properly designed in order to simulate the seismic effects at a generic building storey. A set of five accelerograms, used as input for the shakings, are selected matching the target response spectrum provided by the U.S. code for nonstructural components. Three limit states (occupancy, damage and life safety limit state) are considered in this study in order to characterize the seismic response of suspended ceiling systems. The tested ceilings show no damage at all intensity levels, evidencing a low fragility. Three main aspects may be the cause of this low vulnerability: (a) the continuous nature of the tested ceilings; (b) the dense steel channel grid that supports the plasterboard panels; (c) the large number of hangers that connects the ceiling system to the roof, avoiding any vertical movement of the ceilings. Finally, an interesting comparison is made with a previous vulnerability study on a different typical U.S. ceiling system.

A Note on Selection of Time-Histories for Seismic Analysis of Bridges in Eurocode 8

Eurocode 8 (EC8) allows the use of real earthquake records as an input for time-history analysis of structures. In its Part 2, the code discusses the preparation of seismic input for bridges; although referring to the same target spectral shapes of Part 1, which applies to buildings. The prescriptions are somewhat differently specified in the two drafts. However, the main requirement the chosen record set should satisfy in both cases, is the compatibility of the horizontal average spectrum with the target in a broad range of periods. The set has to be made of at least three recordings, but seven is the minimum set size to consider the mean structural response as the design value. The code, at least for bridges, seems to indicate real records as the principal source of ground-motions the practitioners should rely on; however the selection of real records is not straightforward. In another study, the authors discussed the record selection prescriptions of EC8 Part 1 with respect to the current best practice, and the actual possibility of finding real record sets compliant with EC8 spectra was investigated. This paper represents an extension of the same study to EC8 Part 2 and bridges. To this aim the European Strong-Motion Database is searched to identify real record sets matching the design spectral shapes for several hazard levels and site conditions in a broad range of periods up to 4s. It resulted that combinations well approximating the target may be found for some soil classes, at least for low-to-moderate seismicity sites and if the condition of matching specific source parameters is released and large record-to-record variability is accepted. Finally the record sets presented have been used to compare spectral compatibility prescriptions of EC8 Part 1 and Part 2, which have been found to be equivalent to some extent.

Shake Table Tests on Infill Plasterboard Partitions

Shaking table tests are performed to investigate the seismic behaviour of plasterboard partitions. A steel test frame is properly designed in order to simulate the seismic effects at a generic building storey. The tests are performed shaking the table simultaneously in both horizontal directions. At this aim the accelerograms are selected matching the target response spectrum provided by the U.S. code for nonstructural components. To investigate a wide range of intersto- rey drift demand and seismic damage, the shakes are performed scaling the accelerograms at eight different intensity lev- els. The tested plasterboard partitions exhibit a good seismic behaviour, both in their own plane and out-of-plane, showing light damage up to 0.8% interstorey drift ratio and 2g top frame acceleration. Finally, an interesting comparison of the dynamic characteristics, i.e. fundamental period and damping ratio, between the bare frame and the infilled structure is also performed using different methods.

Effect of the Seismic Input on Non-Linear Response of R/C Building Structures

The effects of the variability of seismic input on system structural response are investigated. Non linear time history analyses are performed using as input sets of accelerograms satisfying the compatibility criteria with an elastic design spectrum according to the Eurocode 8. The response of elastic SDOF systems, in terms of spectral acceleration, is analyzed; the same parameter, for corresponding non linear SDOF systems as well as ductility demand and strength reduction factors, is also discussed. The analyses are extended to a r/c multi-storey space frame, which is designed according to Eurocode provisions. The main conclusion of the paper is that, when the input is selected according to the Eurocode 8 provisions as recorded accelerograms, a “natural” mean CoV of spectra ordinates is expected; it proportionally conditions the CoV of the parameters characterising the non linear response of structures.

Shaking table tests on a full-scale unreinforced and IMG-retrofitted clay brick masonry barrel vault

The recent earthquakes in Italy demonstrated the extreme vulnerability of historical and cultural structures. Masonry vaults, which represent artistically valuable elements of these constructions, have been recognised among the most vulnerable elements. Traditional vault retrofit methods, such as buttresses or ties, are still widely adopted. These retrofit methods prevent differential displacements between vault supports (e.g., abutments, masonry piers and loadbearing walls). However, the pier differential displacement is not the only vulnerability source for vaults, and in many cases, further retrofit interventions are needed. Innovative retrofit methods based on inorganic matrixes, such as IMG, are aimed to prevent hinge mechanism failures. Such methods are suitable to be applied on vaults already retrofitted using traditional methods. The knowledge of the seismic behaviour of a vault, once the differential displacement between the supports is prevented, can be crucial to the assessment of potential further vulnerabilities of vaults already retrofitted with traditional methods. However, a deep knowledge of vault seismic behaviour is still lacking from an experimental point of view. Indeed, to date, few dynamic experimental studies have been conducted. Therefore, to investigate the seismic behaviour of masonry barrel vaults, several shaking table tests were performed on a full-scale specimen before and after the retrofit interventions. The tests investigated the main seismic properties of the tested structure and clarified the cracking mechanisms and capacity improvement due to the retrofit interventions. A comprehensive overview of the main results of the experimental tests has been presented.

Influence of earthquake direction on the seismic response of irregular plan RC frame buildings

The nonlinear response of structures is usually evaluated by considering two accelerograms acting simultaneously along the orthogonal directions. In this study, the influence of the earthquake direction on the seismic response of building structures is examined. Three multi-story RC buildings, representing a very common structural typology in Italy, are used as case studies for the evaluation. They are, respectively, a rectangular plan shape, an L plan shape and a rectangular plan shape with courtyard buildings. Nonlinear static and dynamic analyses are performed by considering different seismic levels, characterized by peak ground acceleration on stiff soil equal to 0.35 g, 0.25 g and 0.15 g. Nonlinear dynamic analyses are carried out by considering twelve different earthquake directions, and rotating the direction of both the orthogonal components by 30° for each analysis (from 0° to 330°). The survey is carried out on the L plan shape structure. The results show that the angle of the seismic input motion significantly influences the response of RC structures; the critical seismic angle, i.e., the incidence angle that produces the maximum demand, provides an increase of up to 37% in terms of both roof displacements and plastic hinge rotations.

Use of seismic early warning information to calibrate variable dampers for structural control of a highway bridge: evaluation of the system robustness

The seismic events occurred in recent years highlighted the extreme vulnerability of large part of the existing constructed facilities and the need to adopt innovative solutions to improve their seismic performance. With this purpose, the possible exploitation of a seismic early warning system (SEWS) in the framework of semi-active structural control using magnetorheological (MR) dampers is herein investigated. The main idea consists in the use of these time-varying properties devices to control an hosting structure by changing their behaviour according to an anticipate estimate, provided by the SEWS, of the peak ground acceleration (PGA) of the incoming earthquake. In this way, the dampers are able to adapt their mechanical characteristics to the specific earthquake obtaining the optimal seismic response. The present paper describes the application of this protection technique to a case-study problem, a highway bridge located in Southern California. The seismic response of the benchmark bridge is investigated by nonlinear time-history analyses by adopting 16 real earthquake ground excitations. These accelerograms cover a wide variety of magnitudes, distances to fault and soil types. Possible errors on estimation of PGA provided by SEWS and their effects on the proposed control system are also considered. The results obtained confirm that unavoidable errors in the PGA estimates provided by the SEWS do not propagate to the seismic response. Conversely, the proposed strategy turns out to damp these errors, resulting in a robust seismic behaviour of the protected structure.

Smart passive control of seismic structural vibrations exploiting early warning information

The combined use of two emerging technologies in the field of seismic engineering, apparently far each other, is focused herein. The first, semi-active (SA) control aims at smartly reduce the seismic effects induced by the earthquake on the structures; the second, seismic early warning (SEW) is instead addressed to make anticipate estimate of the intensity measures of an incoming earthquake some seconds before it strikes a given site. Current research on SEW include the anticipate estimate of the peak ground acceleration (PGA). The paper proposes the exploitation of this earthquake parameter in the framework of SA control strategies. The effectiveness of the proposed strategy is assessed and compared with other more consolidated control strategies. Possible errors on estimation of PGA provided by the SEW system and their influence on the effectiveness of the proposed control strategy are also discussed.

Structural health monitoring of existing bridges in earthquake prone areas: Laboratory validation

Road infrastructures and particularly bridges can suffer structural damage due to earthquakes threatening the efficiency of the transportation network and the possibility to ensure prompt rescue operation. This particularly applies to existing bridges, most of which have been designed and built according to outdated codes. Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) systems can support the prompt assessment of bridges after seismic events. However, reliability of modal based damage detection currently depends on the accuracy of modal parameter estimates automatically obtained from the analysis of the operational response of the monitored structure, and on the capability of the measurement system to resolve low amplitude as well as strong motions, eventually associated to saturation of sensors. In the present paper, the performance of a modal-based SHM system for existing bridges in seismic areas is assessed by shaking table tests on a 1:3 scale single span bridge representative of existing highway bridges built in the 60s in Italy. Results show that hidden damage can be identified on a remote basis, thus demonstrating the interesting applicative perspectives of modal based SHM for fast assessment of existing bridges in the early earthquake aftershock. The resilience to earthquake shaking of the SHM system has been also assessed. Finally, specific data processing procedures for earthquake response data are tested and compared with the results of laboratory measurements.