Graham M. Teasdale

ASSESSMENT OF COMA AND IMPAIRED CONSCIOUSNESS: A Practical Scale

Abstract A clinical scale has been evolved for assessing the depth and duration of impaired consciousness and coma. Three aspects of behaviour are independently measured—motor responsiveness, verbal performance, and eye opening. These can be evaluated consistently by doctors and nurses and recorded on a simple chart which has proved practical both in a neurosurgical unit and in a general hospital. The scale facilitates consultations between general and special units in cases of recent brain damage, and is useful also in defining the duration of prolonged coma.

Early surgery versus initial conservative treatment in patients with spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral haematomas in the International Surgical Trial in Intracerebral Haemorrhage (STICH): a randomised trial

BACKGROUND Spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral haemorrhage accounts for 20% of all stroke-related sudden neurological deficits, has the highest morbidity and mortality of all stroke, and the role of surgery remains controversial. We undertook a prospective randomised trial to compare early surgery with initial conservative treatment for patients with intracerebral haemorrhage. METHODS A parallel-group trial design was used. Early surgery combined haematoma evacuation (within 24 h of randomisation) with medical treatment. Initial conservative treatment used medical treatment, although later evacuation was allowed if necessary. We used the eight-point Glasgow outcome scale obtained by postal questionnaires sent directly to patients at 6 months follow-up as the primary outcome measure. We divided the patients into good and poor prognosis groups on the basis of their clinical status at randomisation. For the good prognosis group, a favourable outcome was defined as good recovery or moderate disability on the Glasgow outcome scale. For the poor prognosis group, a favourable outcome also included the upper level of severe disability. Analysis was by intention to treat. FINDINGS 1033 patients from 83 centres in 27 countries were randomised to early surgery (503) or initial conservative treatment (530). At 6 months, 51 patients were lost to follow-up, and 17 were alive with unknown status. Of 468 patients randomised to early surgery, 122 (26%) had a favourable outcome compared with 118 (24%) of 496 randomised to initial conservative treatment (odds ratio 0.89 [95% CI 0.66-1.19], p=0.414); absolute benefit 2.3% (-3.2 to 7.7), relative benefit 10% (-13 to 33). INTERPRETATION Patients with spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral haemorrhage in neurosurgical units show no overall benefit from early surgery when compared with initial conservative treatment.

EBIC-Guidelines for Management of Severe Head Injury in Adults

SummaryGuidelines for the management of severe head injury in adults as evolved by the European Brain Injury Consortium are presented and discussed. The importance of preventing and treating secondary insults is emphasized and the principles on which treatment is based are reviewed. Guidelines presented are of a pragmatic nature, based on consensus and expert opinion, covering the treatment from accident site to intensive care unit. Specific aspects pertaining to the conduct of clinical trials in head injury are highlighted. The adopted approach is further discussed in relation to other approaches to the development of guidelines, such as evidence based analysis.

Prognosis of Patients with Severe Head Injury

The relationship between clinical features of brain dysfunction in the first week after severe head injury and outcome 6 months later has been analyzed for 1000 patients. Depth of coma, pupil reaction, eye movements, and motor response pattern, and patient age prove to be the most reliable predictors. The degree of brain dysfunction changes markedly soon after injury, and more reliable predictions of outcome result when assessment is based on the best level of functioning recorded in each early epoch. Predictions based on very early assessment are, therefore, often unduly pessimistic. Individual predictions of outcome, based on a large data bank, provide a powerful tool for assessing the relative efficacy of alternative treatments.

ASPECTS OF COMA AFTER SEVERE HEAD INJURY

Features of coma during the first week after sever head injury were analysed in 700 patients. Coma is best defined as inability to obey commands, to speak, or to open the eyes. If eye opening is omitted from the definition then some less severly affected patients will be included in the early stages, the duration of coma will be overestimated, and in the later stages the distiction between coma and other unresponsive states may be blurred. Other features which correlate with responsiveness (as judged by motor response, speech, and eye opening) are pupil reactions and eye movements; respiratory abnormalities are less common and less closely related to other aspects of severity. A rigorous fefinition of coma is necessary for valid commparisons between individual patients and between different series of patients with head injury. This is essential for the assessment of alternative management regimens and for establishing predictive criteria.

Antifibrinolytic treatment in subarachnoid hemorrhage.

We enrolled 479 patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage in a multicenter, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial to determine whether treatment with the antifibrinolytic agent tranexamic acid improves outcome by preventing rebleeding. At three months there was no statistical difference between the outcomes in the tranexamic acid group and the control group. Of the 173 patients who died, 84 had received tranexamic acid and 89 placebo (95 per cent confidence interval for the difference in mortality rate, -6 to 11 per cent). Similarly, when analysis was restricted to patients with an angiographically demonstrated aneurysm, there was no significant difference between the groups. This absence of effect was not due to a lack of antifibrinolytic action, since the rate of rebleeding was reduced from 24 per cent in the control group to 9 per cent in the tranexamic acid-treated group (chi-square = 18.07, P less than 0.001), but resulted from a concurrent increase in the incidence of ischemic complications (15 per cent in the control group and 24 per cent in the tranexamic acid group; chi-square = 8.07, P less than 0.01). We conclude that until some method can be found to minimize ischemic complications, tranexamic acid is of no benefit in patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage.

BRAIN LESIONS DETECTED BY MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING IN MILD AND SEVERE HEAD INJURIES

50 patients were studied by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) within one week of a head injury. Abnormalities indicating primary brain damage were found in 46 patients, almost twice as many as with computed tomography. Cortical contusions were the most common finding, irrespective of the effect of injury on the level of consciousness. Intracerebral lesions were seen only in patients who had lost consciousness and were present in 29 of 42 patients whose consciousness was still impaired on arrival at hospital. Lesions in the deep white-matter of the cerebral hemispheres were seen in 15 patients; they were significantly more frequent in patients in coma but were also seen in patients who had lost consciousness for no more than 5 min. The findings indicate that lesions in the cerebral hemispheres may be the primary factor in traumatic unconsciousness. MRI studies may also clarify the sequelae of head injuries.

Nimodipine and the haemodynamic and histopathological consequences of middle cerebral artery occlusion in the rat.

The effect of the administration of nimodipine (1 μg kg−1 min−1), initiated 5 min after occlusion of a middle cerebral artery (MCA), upon cerebral haemodynamics ([14C]iodoantipyrine autoradiography) and neuropathological outcome (volume of histologically ischaemic tissue) was investigated in anaesthetized rats. Measurements were made of the level of local CBF (LCBF) in a total of 37 neuroanatomically defined areas, either ipsilateral or contralateral to the occluded vessel, and the autoradiograms were examined using a new approach to quantitative densitometry that employed a frequency distribution analysis of the CBF in sections of the brain at different coronal planes. Both methods of analysis showed that nimodipine, administered after the ischaemic event, did not modify the pattern of CBF distribution after MCA occlusion. The extent of ischaemic brain damage was determined by histological examination. There was no evidence that the extent of ischaemic damage, either in sections at eight different coronal planes or in overall volume, was significantly different in animals that received nimodipine from that observed in animals that received only the vehicle used to dissolve the drug. The lack of cerebral circulatory and neuropathological alterations when nimodipine administration is initiated after occlusion of the MCA is contrasted with the higher levels of LCBF and the reductions in the volume of ischaemic tissue that were found when nimodipine was administered before occlusion of the artery.

Neurosurgical management of cerebellar haematoma and infarct.

The clinical features, treatment, and outcome were reviewed for 48 patients with a haematoma and 71 patients with an infarct in the posterior fossa in order to develop a rational plan of management. Clinical features alone were insufficient to make a diagnosis in about half of the series. Patients with a haematoma were referred more quickly to the neurosurgical unit, were more often in coma, and more often had CT evidence of brain stem compression and acute hydrocephalus. Ultimately, 75% of the patients with a haematoma required an operation. By contrast, most patients with an infarct were managed successfully conservatively. Early surgical management in both cerebellar haemorrhage and infarct (either external ventricular drainage or evacuation of the lesion), associated with early presentation and CT signs of brain stem compression and acute hydrocephalus, led to a good outcome in most patients. Of the patients with cerebellar haematoma initially treated by external drainage, over half subsequently required craniectomy and evacuation of the lesion; but, in some cases, this failed to reverse the deterioration. In patients with a cerebellar infarct, external drainage was more often successful. The guidelines, findings, and recommendations for future management of patients with posterior fossa stroke are discussed.

Traumatic Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: Demographic and Clinical Study of 750 Patients from the European Brain Injury Consortium Survey of Head Injuries

OBJECTIVE Previous reports identified the presence of traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage (tSAH) on admission computed tomographic (CT) scans as an independent prognostic factor in worsening outcomes. The mechanism underlying the link between tSAH and prognosis has not been clarified. The aim of this study was to investigate the association between CT evidence of tSAH and outcomes after moderate or severe head injuries. METHODS In a survey organized by the European Brain Injury Consortium, data on initial severity, treatment, and subsequent outcomes were prospectively collected for 1005 patients with moderate or severe head injuries who were admitted to one of the 67 European neurosurgical units during a 3-month period in 1995. The CT findings were classified according to the Traumatic Coma Data Bank classification system, and the presence or absence of tSAH was recorded separately in the initial CT scan forms. RESULTS Complete data on early clinical features, CT findings, and outcomes at 6 months were available for 750 patients, of whom 41% exhibited evidence of tSAH on admission CT scans. There was a strong, highly statistically significant association between the presence of tSAH and poor outcomes. In fact, 41% of patients without tSAH achieved the level of good recovery, whereas only 15% of patients with tSAH achieved this outcome. Patients with tSAH were significantly older (median age, 43 yr; standard deviation, 21.1 yr) than those without tSAH (median age, 32 yr; standard deviation, 19.5 yr), and there was a significant tendency for patients with tSAH to exhibit lower Glasgow Coma Scale scores at the time of admission. A logistic regression analysis of favorable/unfavorable outcomes demonstrated that there was still a very strong association between tSAH and outcomes after simultaneous adjustment for age, Glasgow Coma Scale Motor Scores, and admission CT findings (odds ratio, 2.49; 95% confidence interval, 1.74–3.55;P < 0.001). Comparison of the time courses for 164 patients with early (within 14 d after injury) deaths demonstrated very similar patterns, with an early peak and a subsequent decline; there was no evidence of a delayed increase in mortality rates for either group of patients (with or without tSAH). CONCLUSION These findings for an unselected series of patients confirm previous reports of the adverse prognostic significance of tSAH. The data support the view that death among patients with tSAH is related to the severity of the initial mechanical damage, rather than to the effects of delayed vasospasm and secondary ischemic brain damage.