Guido Pelletti

Micro-computed tomography of false starts produced on bone by different hand-saws

The analysis of macro- and microscopic characteristics of saw marks on bones can provide useful information about the class of the tool utilized to produce the injury. The aim of the present study was to test micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) for the analysis of false starts experimentally produced on 32 human bone sections using 4 different hand-saws in order to verify the potential utility of micro-CT for distinguishing false starts produced by different saws and to correlate the morphology of the tool with that of the bone mark. Each sample was analysed through stereomicroscopy and micro-CT. Stereomicroscopic analysis allowed the identification of the false starts and the detection of the number of tool marks left by each saw. Micro-CT scans, through the integration of 3D renders and multiplanar reconstructions (MPR), allowed the identification of the shape of each false start correlating it to the injuring tool. Our results suggest that micro-CT could be a useful technique for assessing false starts produced by different classes of saws, providing accurate morphological profiles of the bone marks with all the advantages of high resolution 3D imaging (e.g., high accuracy, non-destructive analysis, preservation and documentation of evidence). However, further studies are necessary to integrate qualitative data with quantitative metrical analysis in order to further characterize the false start and the related injuring tool.

Accuracy, precision and inter-rater reliability of micro-CT analysis of false starts on bones. A preliminary validation study

Micro computed tomography (micro-CT) has already been proposed as a useful technique for the qualitative analysis of false starts (FS) produced on human bones, although the reliability and the error rate of this technique have not been tested yet, neither for qualitative nor for quantitative assessments. The aim of the present study was to test the morphological agreement, accuracy, precision and inter-rater reliability of micro-CT analysis of FS on bones. The morphological agreement was assessed through the degree of concordance among the 3 independent blind raters in the identification of the shape of 24 FS manually produced on bones by 3 different saws (8 FS for each saw). The accuracy was calculated through the percentage of error in the automatic and manual measurement of the diameter of a reference object. The precision was calculated as CV% of multiple measurements performed by 3 independent blind raters on the reference object and one bone sample acquired 20 times. The inter-rater reliability was assessed as intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) among measurements performed by 3 independent blind raters, assessing 24 FS produced using 3 different saws. The results demonstrated that both qualitative and quantitative analysis were reproducible and robust. Micro-CT analysis showed a 100% morphological agreement, a high level of accuracy (percentage error < 0,5%), precision (CV% < 5%) and inter-rater reliability (ICC > 0.995), when FS were analyzed by forensic pathologists and/or radiologists with adequate expertise. Obviously, further validation studies are needed, including a higher number of samples produced by a wider variety of saws and multiple operators.

Methodology for the identification of vulnerable asylum seekers

Asylum seekers often experience situations of vulnerability, being frequently exposed to a heightened risk of harm, and thus require special care, support and protection. The categories of “vulnerable persons”, identified by International Legislation, and an individual’s classification as a “vulnerable asylum seeker”, have important implications in the reception procedures, in the decision-making phase and in the definition of therapeutic needs and rehabilitation. The Istanbul Protocol, the first international guideline approved by the United Nations and applied in different contexts, is not applicable for the assessment of the totality of the conditions (medical and otherwise), and therefore, the identification and assessment of conditions of vulnerability is largely delegated to questionnaires administered by non-medical personnel. The proposed methodology, based on the modificatory reworking of the Guidelines of the International Academy of Legal Medicine concerning the “medicolegal ascertainment of personal injury and damage on the living person”, takes into consideration all the medical issues relevant for the decision concerning the applicant, both in the reception procedures and in the outcome of the asylum application.

Post-autopsy computed tomography. Pros and cons in a firearm death

Many studies have focused on the importance of post-mortem computed tomography (PMCT) prior to or in substitution of standard forensic autopsies in case of firearm death. However, due to the fact that PMCT is not routinely performed in all countries, in cases of death abroad it can happen that a CT scan is performed only after a first autopsy. A case of post-mortem re-examination, including the external examination and a post-autopsy computed tomography (PACT), of a gunshot victim of homicide in a foreign country is presented, and the pros and cons of imaging in post-autopsy setting are discussed. PACT could be a tool for carrying out more complete investigations and for obtaining information on bone injuries and foreign bodies trapped within peripheral soft tissues that can be re-analyzed after the arrival of the first autopsy report. Given that the value of information derived may be strongly influenced by the previously performed autopsy, in order to process the definitive considerations it is necessary to compare and interpret the data obtained through PACT with the results of the first autopsy, and to continue the international cooperation effort and the application of international guidelines in order to share information at the repatriation of the corpse.

Sequential development of hepatocellular carcinoma and liver angiosarcoma in a vinyl chloride–exposed worker

Strong experimental and clinical evidences have definitely linked occupational vinyl chloride exposure to development of angiosarcoma of the liver. In contrast, despite the International Agency for Research on Cancer having included vinyl chloride among the causes of hepatocellular carcinoma, the association between vinyl chloride exposure and hepatocellular carcinoma remains debated. This issue is relevant, because occupational exposure to high levels of vinyl chloride may still occur. We report a unique case of sequential occurrences of hepatocellular carcinoma and angiosarcoma of the liver, in a vinyl chloride-exposed worker without cirrhosis and any known risk factor for chronic liver disease. Both the hepatocellular carcinoma and the surrounding normal liver showed micronucleus formation, which reflects genotoxic effect of vinyl chloride. Angiosarcoma showed a KRAS G12D point mutation, which is considered to be characteristic of vinyl chloride-induced angiosarcoma. This case supports the pathogenic role of vinyl chloride in both hepatocellular carcinoma and angiosarcoma development.

A homemade furnace. Influence of occupational skills in a fire-related planned complex suicide

The term “planned complex suicide” means the combination of more than one method of suicide, planned to prevent failure of the first method to ensure a fatal outcome. Professional skills and tools are sometimes used to plan and perpetrate the suicide. A case of planned complex suicide of a mechanical engineer working with furnaces in a tube factory is herein reported. The suicide was committed in a rudimental furnace set up in the victim’s apartment using his professional skills, by assembling furniture, mattresses, books and flammable liquid present in the house. Three-dimensional models of the crime scene before and after the realization of the “homemade furnace” are proposed. The discussion will focus on the importance of a comprehensive analysis of the professional background of the victim to infer the manner of death for the identification of complex and occupation-related suicides.

Medico-legal implications of toluene abuse and toxicity. Review of cases along with blood concentrations

Toluene, a liquid aromatic hydrocarbon, is one of the most widely used industrial solvents, and is present in numerous paints, paint thinners, glues and other industrial and household products. It has become the most abused solvent in the world due to its rapid effects following inhalation. However, the numerous cases of fatal and non-fatal toluene-related intoxication reported in the literature have not yet been collected and discussed in the forensic setting. In this paper we aim to provide a review of the cases of toluene abuse and intoxication and the state of the art of the forensic toxicological analysis of toluene intoxications in the living and in the dead subject, from the early identification to the medico-legal interpretation of the toxicological result. We have identified a total of 45 papers regarding different aspects of toluene abuse, and divided them into three sections, namely sampling, storage and techniques of analysis, assessment in living subjects and post-mortem assessment. This article reports toluene concentrations in blood from 202 living subjects, 23 fatal toluene intoxications and 85 toluene related deaths. Toxicological results are discussed in relation to the clinical presentation (living subjects, including impaired drivers), and the manner of death according to the medical examiner reports (post-mortem examinations). Finally, we discuss the strengths and limitations of the review.

Crime scene and body alterations caused by arthropods: implications in death investigation

The activity of arthropods on corpses has been largely investigated, since they can produce information to reconstruct the peri-mortem events. However, the feeding/movement activity of insects around the crime scene, among the clothes and on the body, can also cause some alterations that can lead to wrong reconstruction and misinterpretations. This article summarises all the post-mortem arthropods artefacts related to the scene (i.e. fly artefacts and floor stripes) and the body (i.e. skin and other soft tissue alterations, bone alterations and hair alterations) that can mislead the forensic pathologist, discussing macroscopic and microscopic findings derived from forensic casework and from experimental laboratory studies, in order to provide a useful instrument to avoid misinterpretations and evaluation errors. Finally, some procedural notes for the documentation and the interpretation of findings are proposed.

Safe drugs in drug facilitated crimes and acute intoxications in Northern Italy

Toxicological analyses are often performed in drug-facilitated sexual assaults (DFSA), when the victim shows or reports impaired consciousness and reduced ability. However, in other crimes or fatalities, especially in cases of concurrent natural disease or when another likely cause of death has been established, the involvement of drugs can be overlooked. The aim of this study is to report a series of cases of (i) victims of drug-facilitated crimes (DFC) other than DFSA and (ii) victims of acute intoxications, in which “licit” psychoactive drugs were found in blood samples, with the aim of understanding in which circumstances and to what extent prescription drugs have been used for non-medical purposes in recent Italian casuistry. Circumstantial, autopsy, and toxicological data were collected through a retrospective analysis performed between 2013 and 2017 in the Forensic Toxicology Unit of the University of Bologna. Cases of “DFC other than DFSA” and “Acute Intoxication” in which “psychoactive drugs” or “prescription drugs” or “licit drugs” were found in the blood samples of the victims were included in the study. Nine cases of DFC other than DFSA, and 11 cases of acute intoxication, were identified. Different categories of “licit” psychoactive drugs (e.g. hypnotics, antipsychotics, antidepressants, anticonvulsants) had been used to facilitate diverse types of crime (homicide, robberies, elder abuse, fatal poisoning) or acute intoxication (suicide, attempted suicide, accidental death). The circumstances of these cases, as well as toxicological findings in blood samples and other relevant forensic elements, are reported, summarized and discussed in this paper. The non-medical use of pharmaceuticals has been identified by recent forensic literature and the present study as a significant and growing phenomenon, and its implication in fatalities should be taken into consideration and accurately investigated through appropriate toxicological analysis. Our study presents an overview of the circumstances of non-medical use of prescription drugs, usually considered “safe drugs”, and their involvement in cases of DFC, suicides and accidental intoxication. In order to estimate the real incidence of these medications in DFC and acute intoxication, and thus collect more analytical and contextual data, further studies are needed, along with effective cooperation among police officers, clinicians, forensic pathologists, and toxicologists.

The Dangerous Pattern of Concurrent Use of Alcohol and Cocaine Among Drunk-Drivers of Northeast Italy

Aim To estimate the prevalence of drug and polydrug use among drunk-drivers during the driving license regranting program, in order to assess the inclusion of toxicological tests on hair and urine samples in the systematic methodology in this category of subjects. Short summary A total of 2160 drunk-drivers were tested for alcohol and drugs during driving license regranting. Thirty-one subjects showed alcohol use, 212 illicit drug use and, among these, 131 were polydrug users. Nineteen different patterns of drug and polydrug use were found. Cocaine was detected in 165 subjects. Methods The study was performed on 2160 drunk-drivers examined at Legal Medicine and Toxicology Unit of the University of Padova, in a 3-year-period (2014-2017). The positivity for one or more illicit drugs in hair or urine samples was confirmed by LC/MS and GC/MS methods. Chi-square test, Fischers exact test and Cochran-Armitage Trend test were used to study the correlation between general characteristics of the examined sample and the presence of drug/polydrug use. Results Thirty-one subjects showed alcohol use, 212 illicit drug use and, among these, 131 were polydrug users. Nineteen different patterns of drug and polydrug use were found. Cocaine was detected in 165 subjects in whom 122 showed a concurrent use of alcohol and cocaine, identified through the detection of cocaethylene in hair samples. No significant association and/or trends between drug/polydrug use and the general characteristics of the sample were detected. Conclusions The results show that drug and polydrug use among drunk-drivers should be subjected to toxicological as well as alcohological monitoring, especially in the regranting procedure. The implementation of this procedure could improve the knowledge of dimensions of the issue, providing a powerful means for the reduction of phenomenon of driving under the influence of alcohol and drugs.