Guillaume Lecointre

Repeatability of clades as a criterion of reliability: a case study for molecular phylogeny of Acanthomorpha (Teleostei) with larger number of taxa.

Although much progress has been made recently in teleostean phylogeny, relationships among the main lineages of the higher teleosts (Acanthomorpha), containing more than 60% of all fish species, remain poorly defined. This study represents the most extensive taxonomic sampling effort to date to collect new molecular characters for phylogenetic analysis of acanthomorph fishes. We compiled and analyzed three independent data sets, including: (i) mitochondrial ribosomal fragments from 12S and 16s (814bp for 97 taxa); (ii) nuclear ribosomal 28S sequences (847bp for 74 taxa); and (iii) a nuclear protein-coding gene, rhodopsin (759bp for 86 taxa). Detailed analyses were conducted on each data set separately and the principle of taxonomic congruence without consensus trees was used to assess confidence in the results as follows. Repeatability of clades from separate analyses was considered the primary criterion to establish reliability, rather than bootstrap proportions from a single combined (total evidence) data matrix. The new and reliable clades emerging from this study of the acanthomorph radiation were: Gadiformes (cods) with Zeioids (dories); Beloniformes (needlefishes) with Atheriniformes (silversides); blenioids (blennies) with Gobiesocoidei (clingfishes); Channoidei (snakeheads) with Anabantoidei (climbing gouramies); Mastacembeloidei (spiny eels) with Synbranchioidei (swamp-eels); the last two pairs of taxa grouping together, Syngnathoidei (aulostomids, macroramphosids) with Dactylopteridae (flying gurnards); Scombroidei (mackerels) plus Stromatoidei plus Chiasmodontidae; Ammodytidae (sand lances) with Cheimarrhichthyidae (torrentfish); Zoarcoidei (eelpouts) with Cottoidei; Percidae (perches) with Notothenioidei (Antarctic fishes); and a clade grouping Carangidae (jacks), Echeneidae (remoras), Sphyraenidae (barracudas), Menidae (moonfish), Polynemidae (threadfins), Centropomidae (snooks), and Pleuronectiformes (flatfishes).

The 'evolutionary signal' of homoplasy in protein-coding gene sequences and its consequences for a priori weighting in phylogeny.

To analyse independently homoplasy for the six possible types of substitution (i.e., A-G, C-T, A-C, A-T, C-G and G-T) at each of the three codon-positions of the cytochrome b gene, two approaches were used: the first is based on the consistency index which measures the amount of homoplasy, and the second is based on the saturation analysis which describes graphically the distribution of homoplasy within the taxonomic sampling. The results obtained from a data set of 32 sequences of Artiodactyla indicate that evolution of the cytochrome b is governed by differential constraints: 1) between the six substitutions-types, 2) between the three codon-positions, and 3) between the two mtDNA strands. Moreover, we find that non-synonymous sites can be more homoplastic than synonymous sites when the possibilities of substitutions are severely restricted because of the functional requirements of hydrophobicity. Most weighting schemes applied to protein-coding genes are elaborated from unjustified assumptions. We propose to weight each substitution-type at each codon-position according to its homoplasy content evaluated either with the consistency index or with an index representing the level of mutational saturation.

Total evidence requires exclusion of phylogenetically misleading data

Treating all available characters simultaneously in a single data matrix (i.e. combined or simultaneous analysis) is frequently called the ‘total evidence’ (TE) approach, following Kluges introduction of the term in 1989, quoting Carnap (1950) . However, the general principle and one of the possible procedures involved in its application are often confused. The principle, first enunciated within the context of inductive logic by Carnap in 1950, did not refer to a particular procedure, and TE meant using all relevant knowledge, rather than a combined analysis of all available data. Using TE, all relevant knowledge should be taken into account, including the fact that some data are probably misleading as indicators of species phylogeny and should be discarded. Based on the assumption that molecular partitions have some biological significance (process partitions obtained from nonrandom homoplasy or from ‘processes of discord’), we suggest that separate analyses constitute an important exploratory investigation, while the phylogenetic tree itself should be produced by a final combined analysis of all relevant data. Given that the concept of process partitions is justified and that reliability cannot be evaluated using any robustness measure from a single combined analysis, the analysis of multiple data sets involves five steps: (1) perform separate analyses without consensus trees in order to assess reliability of clades through their recurrence and improve the detection of artifacts; (2) test significance of character incongruence, using, for example, pairwise ILD tests in order to identify the sets responsible for incongruence; (3) replace likely misleading data with question marks in the combined data matrix; (4) perform simultaneous analysis of this matrix without the misleading data; (5) assess the reliability of clades found by the combined analysis by computing their recurrence within the previous separate analyses, giving priority to repeatability.

PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS OF THE MONOGENEA AND THEIR RELATIONSHIPS WITH DIGENEA AND EUCESTODA INFERRED FROM 28S RDNA SEQUENCES

Platyhelminth phylogeny is controversial. Phylogenetic analyses of the partial domain C1 and the full domains D1 and C2 (358 nucleotides) from the 28S ribosomal RNA gene for 21 species from the Monogenea, Digenea, Cestoda, and, as the outgroup, Tricladida reveal major departures from prevailing theory. The Digenea and not the Monogenea (Monopisthocotylea and Polyopisthocotylea) form the sister group of the cestodes; the Monopisthocotylea and Polyopisthocotylea are each monophyletic, but the Monogenea do not form a monophylum; the sister group of the Digenea + Cestoda is the Polyopisthocotylea; and Monopisthocotylea are the sister group of all other parasitic flatworms.

Patterns of septal biomineralization in Scleractinia compared with their 28S rRNA phylogeny: a dual approach for a new taxonomic framework

A molecular phylogeny of the Scleractinia is reconstructed from approximately 700 nucleotides of the 5′end of the 28S rDNA obtained from 40 species. A comparison of molecular phylogenic trees with biomineralization patterns of coral septa suggests that at least five clades are corroborated by both types of data. Agaricidae and Dendrophylliidae are found to be monophyletic, that is supported by microstructural data. Conversely, Faviidae and Caryophylliidae are found to be paraphyletic: Cladocora should be excluded from the faviids, whereas Eusmilia should be excluded from the caryophylliids. The conclusion is also supported by the positions, sizes and shapes of centres of calcification. The traditional Guyniidae are diphyletic, corroborating Stolarskis hypothesis ‘A’. Some results from our most parsimonious trees are not strongly statistically supported but corroborated by other molecular studies and microstructural observations. For example, in the scleractinian phylogenetic tree, there are several lines of evidence (including those from our data) to distinguish a Faviidae–Mussidae lineage and a Dendrophylliidae–Agaricidae–Poritidae–Siderastreidae lineage. From a methodological standpoint, our results suggest that co‐ordinated studies creating links between biomineralization patterns and molecular phylogeny may provide an efficient working approach for a re‐examination of scleractinian classification. This goal is important because in the evolutionary scheme proposed by Wells that presently remains the basic framework in coral studies, patterns of septal microstructures are involved. Validating from molecular phylogenies a given microstructural character state as a potential synapomorphy for a clade is the only way to include fossils in the coral classification, an approach that should allow the unity of coral classification to be maintained up to the origin of the phylum in the Triassic times.

In search of notothenioid (Teleostei) relatives

Ninety-five percent of the fish species known from the Antarctic continental shelf and upper slope are acanthomorphs, i.e. spiny teleosteans. Notothenioids (suborder Notothenioidei) are acanthomorphs and so is their sister group. Unfortunately, until recently acanthomorph intra-relationships were so poorly known that it was necessary to sample all of this diversity just to search for a single sister group relationship. Using recent advances in acanthomorph molecular phylogenetics, particular properties of separate analyses and a new protocol of dataset combination, we identified a clade that contains the sister group of notothenioids, the Percidae (perches), and a number of relatives. Among these relatives are the Serranidae (sea basses), the genera Trachinus (weeverfish), Chelidonichthys (gurnard), Scorpaena (scorpionfish), and a group composed of the Zoarcoidei (eelpouts) and the Cottoidei (sculpins) with the Gasterosteidae (sticklebacks) as their sister group. Interestingly, that clade contains 88% of the fish species found on the Antarctic continental shelf and upper slope. The interrelationships of its components and their distribution show that the Antarctic benthic fish fauna has at least three origins.

Molecular zoogeography of Antarctic euphausiids and notothenioids: from species phylogenies to intraspecific patterns of genetic variation

Published and unpublished data are used to investigate possible mechanisms of species diversification in two key groups of Antarctic organisms: the Notothenioidei and the Euphausiidae. Species distributions are mapped onto molecular phylogenies, and this evidence is interpreted in light of the various ecological and historical factors which characterize the Southern Ocean. The joint effect of diverse agents (vicariance, “jump” dispersal) appears to be determinant in several cases for species divergence. A review of results from population genetics studies, together with new molecular evidence, confirm the importance of physical barriers (oceanographic fronts) in reducing migration, thereby promoting speciation, at least in notothenioids.

Molecular evidence for the origins of Antarctic fishes: paraphyly of the Bovichtidae and no indication for the monophyly of the Notothenioidei (Teleostei)

Abstract The notothenioids are an Antarctic suborder of perciform fishes to which increasing interest is being devoted. To investigate their origin, one must address two questions. First, are Bovichtidae (Bovichtus, Cottoperca, Pseudaphritis), the sister-group of the rest of the suborder, monophyletic ? Secondly, what is the sister-group of the Notothenioidei ? These questions were addressed by determining the complete nucleotide sequence of the D2 and D8 domains of 28S rDNA (759 sites, among which 158 informative for parsimony), for 6 notothenioids and a collection of 6 outgroup taxa including the Trachinoidei and Zoarcoidei. Different outgroups (or combinations of outgroups) and different weighting schemes support the inference that Pseudaphritis is closer to the rest of the Notothenioidei than Cottoperca and Bovichtus are. Relationships of Cottoperca and Bovichtus remain unclear with respect to outgroups. Our molecular data therefore clearly show that the Bovichtidae are paraphyletic, but their relationships are not those suggested by Balushkin in 1992. Our data provide no indication of the monophyly of the Notothenioidei in its classical sense. Most of the homoplasy is due to outgroup sequences and interrelationships of outgroups are unresolved. Some morphological synapomorphies shared by Pseudaphritis and the rest of the non-bovichtid Notothenioidei are proposed, including some that were identified by Voskoboynikova in 1993.

Low Divergence in rDNA ITS Sequences Among Five Species of Fucus (Phaeophyceae) Suggests a Very Recent Radiation

Abstract. Sequences from the two ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacers (ITS1 and ITS2) were compared among five species of Fucus. Based on the present taxon sampling, parsimony analysis showed that Fucus serratus is the sister-group of the remaining Fucus species when Ascophyllum nodosum was used as an outgroup. The topology of the tree was (Fucus serratus (F. lutarius (F. vesiculosus (F. spiralis+F. ceranoides)))). The extremely low variation observed suggests a very recent radiation of the genus which supports the view widely accepted that the Fucales are among the most evolutionarily advanced of the brown algae. We further note that sequence differences between Fucus and Ascophyllum were 28%: this does not rule out the utility of ITS sequences within the Fucaceae. The very low number of informative positions allows to demonstrate empirically that distance matrix methods group on the basis of symplesiomorphies.

The Oxygen Transport System in Three Species of the Boreal Fish Family Gadidae MOLECULAR PHYLOGENY OF HEMOGLOBIN

The Arctic and Antarctic marine faunas differ by age and isolation. Fishes of the two polar regions have undergone different regional histories that have driven the physiological diversities. Antarctic fish are highly stenothermal, in keeping with stable water temperatures, whereas Arctic fish, being exposed to seasonal temperature variations, exhibit higher physiological plasticity. This study reports the characterization of the oxygen transport system of three Arctic species of the family Gadidae, namely the Arctic cod Arctogadus glacialis, the polar cod Boreogadus saida, and the Atlantic cod Gadus morhua. Unlike Antarctic notothenioids, the blood displays high multiplicity, i.e. it has three hemoglobins, similar to many other acanthomorph teleosts. In the most abundant hemoglobin, oxygen binding is modulated by heterotropic effectors, with marked Bohr and Root effects. Remarkably, in two species (A. glacialis and B. saida), the Hill coefficient is very close to one in the whole pH range, indicating the apparent absence of cooperativity. The amino acid sequences have been used to gain insight into the evolution history of globins of polar fish. The results indicate that Arctic and Antarctic globins have different phylogenies and lead us to suggest that the selective pressure of environment stability allows the phylogenetic signal to be maintained in the Antarctic sequences, whereas environmental variability would tend to disrupt this signal in the Gadidae sequences.