H. J. Fahr

Global Observations of the Interstellar Interaction from the Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX)

Whats Happening in the Heliosphere The influence of the Sun is felt well beyond the orbits of the planets. The solar wind is a stream of charged particles emanating from the Sun that carves a bubble in interstellar space known as the heliosphere and shrouds the entire solar system. The edge of the heliosphere, the region where the solar wind interacts with interstellar space, is largely unexplored. Voyager 1 and 2 crossed this boundary in 2004 and 2007, respectively, providing detailed but only localized information. In this issue (see the cover), McComas et al. (p. 959, published online 15 October), Fuselier et al. (p. 962, published online 15 October), Funsten et al. (p. 964, published online 15 October), and Möbius et al. (p. 969, published online 15 October) present data taken by NASAs Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX). Since early 2009, IBEX has been building all-sky maps of the emissions of energetic neutral atoms produced at the boundary between the heliosphere and the interstellar medium. These maps have unexpectedly revealed a narrow band of emission that bisects the two Voyager locations at energies ranging from 0.2 to 6 kiloelectron volts. Emissions from the band are two- to threefold brighter than outside the band, in contrast to current models that predict much smaller variations across the sky. By comparing the IBEX observations with models of the heliosphere, Schwadron et al. (p. 966, published online 15 October) show that to date no model fully explains the observations. The model they have developed suggests that the interstellar magnetic field plays a stronger role than previously thought. In addition to the all-sky maps, IBEX measured the signatures of H, He, and O flowing into the heliosphere from the interstellar medium. In a related report, Krimigis et al. (p. 971, published online 15 October) present an all-sky image of energetic neutral atoms with energies ranging between 6 and 13 kiloelectron volts obtained with the Ion and Neutral Camera onboard the Cassini spacecraft orbiting Saturn. It shows that parts of the structure observed by IBEX extend to high energies. These data indicate that the shape of the heliosphere is not consistent with that of a comet aligned in the direction of the Suns travel through the galaxy as was previously thought. Observations by the Interstellar Boundary Explorer have revealed surprising features in the interaction between the heliosphere and the interstellar medium. The Sun moves through the local interstellar medium, continuously emitting ionized, supersonic solar wind plasma and carving out a cavity in interstellar space called the heliosphere. The recently launched Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) spacecraft has completed its first all-sky maps of the interstellar interaction at the edge of the heliosphere by imaging energetic neutral atoms (ENAs) emanating from this region. We found a bright ribbon of ENA emission, unpredicted by prior models or theories, that may be ordered by the local interstellar magnetic field interacting with the heliosphere. This ribbon is superposed on globally distributed flux variations ordered by both the solar wind structure and the direction of motion through the interstellar medium. Our results indicate that the external galactic environment strongly imprints the heliosphere.

The Ulysses neutral gas experiment: Determination of the velocity and temperature of the interstellar neutral helium

Abstract A new technique to directly detect low energy neutral helium has been developed and successfully used in space for the first time. It makes possible the in-situ measurement of the local angular distribution of the flow of interstellar neutral helium in the inner heliosphere. Based on the transformation of a velocity distribution, using Liouvilles theorem, a straightforward model has been developed to determine, from these measurements, the flow parameters of the interstellar helium at infinity. From twelve measurements at radial distances between 1 and 5 AU, average values of the flow parameters were determined, namely: υ ∞ = 26 ± 1 km s −1 , downstream direction: λ ∞ = 72 ± 2.4°, β ∞ = −2.5 ± 2.7°, temperature T ∞ = 6700 ± 1500 K. These values are in agreement with results found by completely different methods (such as, backscattered UV-light, pick-up ions), although in detail there are significant differences.

The Heliosphere’s Interstellar Interaction: No Bow Shock

No Shock Ahead of the Sun The boundary of the heliosphere is the region where the solar wind interacts with interstellar space, and it marks the edge of our solar system. Based on observations from NASAs Interstellar Boundary Explorer, McComas et al. (p. 1291, published online 10 May; see the Perspective by Redfield) determined values for local interstellar parameters—such as speed, direction, and temperature—and show that these and other recent constraints are not consistent with a bow shock ahead of the heliosphere, as previously believed. Observations from the Interstellar Boundary Explorer are not consistent with a bow shock ahead of the heliosphere. As the Sun moves through the local interstellar medium, its supersonic, ionized solar wind carves out a cavity called the heliosphere. Recent observations from the Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) spacecraft show that the relative motion of the Sun with respect to the interstellar medium is slower and in a somewhat different direction than previously thought. Here, we provide combined consensus values for this velocity vector and show that they have important implications for the global interstellar interaction. In particular, the velocity is almost certainly slower than the fast magnetosonic speed, with no bow shock forming ahead of the heliosphere, as was widely expected in the past.

Comparison of Interstellar Boundary Explorer Observations with 3D Global Heliospheric Models

Whats Happening in the Heliosphere The influence of the Sun is felt well beyond the orbits of the planets. The solar wind is a stream of charged particles emanating from the Sun that carves a bubble in interstellar space known as the heliosphere and shrouds the entire solar system. The edge of the heliosphere, the region where the solar wind interacts with interstellar space, is largely unexplored. Voyager 1 and 2 crossed this boundary in 2004 and 2007, respectively, providing detailed but only localized information. In this issue (see the cover), McComas et al. (p. 959, published online 15 October), Fuselier et al. (p. 962, published online 15 October), Funsten et al. (p. 964, published online 15 October), and Möbius et al. (p. 969, published online 15 October) present data taken by NASAs Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX). Since early 2009, IBEX has been building all-sky maps of the emissions of energetic neutral atoms produced at the boundary between the heliosphere and the interstellar medium. These maps have unexpectedly revealed a narrow band of emission that bisects the two Voyager locations at energies ranging from 0.2 to 6 kiloelectron volts. Emissions from the band are two- to threefold brighter than outside the band, in contrast to current models that predict much smaller variations across the sky. By comparing the IBEX observations with models of the heliosphere, Schwadron et al. (p. 966, published online 15 October) show that to date no model fully explains the observations. The model they have developed suggests that the interstellar magnetic field plays a stronger role than previously thought. In addition to the all-sky maps, IBEX measured the signatures of H, He, and O flowing into the heliosphere from the interstellar medium. In a related report, Krimigis et al. (p. 971, published online 15 October) present an all-sky image of energetic neutral atoms with energies ranging between 6 and 13 kiloelectron volts obtained with the Ion and Neutral Camera onboard the Cassini spacecraft orbiting Saturn. It shows that parts of the structure observed by IBEX extend to high energies. These data indicate that the shape of the heliosphere is not consistent with that of a comet aligned in the direction of the Suns travel through the galaxy as was previously thought. Observations by the Interstellar Boundary Explorer have revealed surprising features in the interaction between the heliosphere and the interstellar medium. Simulations of energetic neutral atom (ENA) maps predict flux magnitudes that are, in some cases, similar to those observed by the Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) spacecraft, but they miss the ribbon. Our model of the heliosphere indicates that the local interstellar medium (LISM) magnetic field (BLISM) is transverse to the line of sight (LOS) along the ribbon, suggesting that the ribbon may carry its imprint. The force-per-unit area on the heliopause from field line draping and the LISM ram pressure is comparable with the ribbon pressure if the LOS ~ 30 to 60 astronomical units and BLISM ~ 2.5 microgauss. Although various models have advantages in accounting for some of the observations, no model can explain all the dominant features, which probably requires a substantial change in our understanding of the processes that shape our heliosphere.

Synopsis of the interstellar He parameters from combined neutral gas, pickup ion and UV scattering observations and related consequences

A coordinated effort to combine all three methods that are used to determine the physical parameters of interstellar gas in the heliosphere has been undertaken. In order to arrive at a consistent parameter set that agrees with the observations of neutral gas, pickup ions and UV backscattering we have combined data sets from coordinated observation campaigns over three years from 1998 through 2000. The key observations include pickup ions with ACE and Ulysses SWICS, neutral atoms with Ulysses GAS, as well as UV backscattering at the He focusing cone close to the Sun with SOHO UVCS and at I AU with EUVE. For the first time also the solar EUV irradiance that is responsible for photo ionization was monitored with SOHO CELIAS SEM, and the He I 58.4 nm line that illuminates He was observed simultaneously with SOHO SUMER. The solar wind conditions were monitored with SOHO, ACE, and WIND. Based on these data the modeling of the interstellar gas and its secondary products in the heliosphere has resulted in a consistent set of interstellar He parameters with much reduced uncertainties, which satisfy all observations, even extended to earlier data sets. It was also established that a substantial ionization in addition to photo ionization, most likely electron impact, is required, with increasing relative importance closer to the Sun. Furthermore, the total combined ionization rate varies significantly with solar latitude, requiring a fully three dimensional and time dependent treatment of the problem.

Plasma transport across the heliopause

Existing heliopause models are critically rediscussed under the new aspect of possible plasma mixing between the solar wind and the ambient ionized component of the local interstellar medium (LISM). Based on current kinetic plasma theories, effective diffusion rates across the heliopause are evaluated for several models with turbulence caused by electrostatic or electromagnetic interactions that could be envisaged in this context. Some specific cases that may lead to high diffusion rates are investigated, especially in regard to their LISM magnetic field dependence.For weak fields (less than 10−7 G), macroscopic hydrodynamic instabilities, such as of Rayleigh-Taylor or Kelvin-Helmholtz-types, can be excited. The resulting plasma mixing rates at the heliopause may amount to 20–30% of the impinging mass flow.Recently, an unconventional new approach to the problem for the case of tangential magnetic fields at the heliopause was published in which a continuous change of the plasma properties within an extended boundary layer is described by a complete set of two-fluid plasma equations including a hybrid MHD-formulation of wave-particle interaction effects. If a neutral sheet is assumed to exist within the boundary layer, the magnetic field direction is proven to be constant for a plane-parallel geometry. Considering the electric fields and currents in the layer, an interesting relationship between the field-reconnection probability and the electric conductivity can be derived, permitting a quantitative determination of either of these quantities.An actual value for the electrical conductivity is derived here on the basis of electron distribution functions given by a superposition of Maxwellians with different temperatures. Using two-stream instability theory and retaining only the most unstable modes, an exact solution for the density, velocity, and magnetic and electric fields can be obtained. The electrical conductivity is then shown to be six orders of magnitude lower than calculated by conventional formulas. Interestingly, this leads to an acceptable value of 0.1 for the reconnection coefficient.By analogy with the case of planetary magnetopauses, it is shown here for LISM magnetic fields of the order of 10−6 G or larger that field reconnection processes may also play an important role for the plasma mixing at the heliopause. The resulting plasma mixing rate is estimated to amount to an average value of 10% of the incident mass flow. It is suggested here that the dependence of the cosmic-ray penetration into the heliosphere on the distribution of reconnecting areas at the heliopause may provide a means of deriving the strength and orientation of the LISM field.A series of observational implications for the expected plasma mixing at the heliopause is discussed in the last part of the paper. In particular, consequences are discussed for the generation of radio noise at the heliopause, for the penetration of LISM neutrals into the heliosphere, for the propagation of cosmic rays towards the inner part of the solar system and for convective electric field mergings into the heliosphere during the course of the solar cycle, depending on the solar cycle variations. With concern to a recent detection of electrostatic plasma waves by plasma receivers on Voyagers 1 and 2, we come to an interesting alternate explanation: the heliopause, rather than the heliospheric shock front, could be responsible for the generation of these waves.

On the influence of neutral interstellar matter on the upper atmosphere

Neutral interstellar matter entering the solar system has been considered in respect to its influences on the upper atmosphere. Calculations show that in consequence of the focussing effect due to the suns gravitational field the incoming neutral hydrogen and helium under special, but possible conditions will represent a semi-annually varying density along the earths orbit. The particle fluxes amounting at least to some 107 cm−2 sec−1, which are connected with these density-profiles and reach the upper atmosphere, show annual periodicities and so will cause annual variations of the densities of the light, atmospheric gas constituents. Especially it is to be expected, that so produced density variations of atmospheric hydrogen are important. Temperature increases caused by the energy flux of interstellar particles should in general only amount to a few thousandths of the CIRA-temperatures.

Comparing various multi-component global heliosphere models

Context. Modeling of the global heliosphere seeks to investigate the interaction of the solar wind with the partially ionized local interstellar medium. Models that treat neutral hydrogen self-consistently and in great detail, together with the plasma, but that neglect magnetic fields, constitute a sub-category within global heliospheric models. Aims. There are several different modeling strategies used for this sub-category in the literature. Differences and commonalities in the modeling results from different strategies are pointed out. Methods. Plasma-only models and fully self-consistent models from four research groups, for which the neutral species is modeled with either one, three, or four fluids, or else kinetically, are run with the same boundary parameters and equations. They are compared to each other with respect to the locations of key heliospheric boundary locations and with respect to the neutral hydrogen content throughout the heliosphere. Results. In many respects, the models’ predictions are similar. In particular, the locations of the termination shock agree to within 7% in the nose direction and to within 14% in the downwind direction. The nose locations of the heliopause agree to within 5%. The filtration of neutral hydrogen from the interstellar medium into the inner heliosphere, however, is model dependent, as are other neutral results including the hydrogen wall. These differences are closely linked to the strength of the interstellar bow shock. The comparison also underlines that it is critical to include neutral hydrogen into global heliospheric models.

Neutral corpuscular energy flux by charge-transfer collisions in the vicinity of the sun

Charge-transfer collisions between solar-wind protons and neutral interstellar hydrogen in the vicinity of the sun have been considered. Due to the focusing effect of the suns gravitational field interstellar particles entering the solar system in free flights produce a specific density distribution in the circumsolar space. On their way from the sun to the orbit of the earth solar protons will therefore generate fast neutrals by collisions with neutral hydrogen. Depending on the position at its orbit the earth will be hit by these fast neutrals which will come down directly into the thermosphere and will produce temperature and density increases. It is shown that the corpuscular energy flux connected with these fast neutrals will have a semi-annually varying profile along the earths orbit. Interstellar particle densities of about 5 cm−3 at infinity would produce energy fluxes of the order of 0.1 erg/cm2 sec. Assuming a specific proper motion of interstellar matter surrounding the solar system we obtain a neutral corpuscular energy flux having nearly the same shape and phase as the wellknown semi-annual effect in atmospheric temperatures and densities. Collision-generated, fast neutrals reaching the earth could therefore possibly give an explanation of this effect.

On the thermodynamics of MHD wave-heated solar wind protons

It has been clearly observed by the NASA deep-space probes that the solar wind protons do not adiabatically cool as expected towards larger solar distances, but appear to be heated by non-collisional energy sources. In some papers these heating sources were directly or indirectly ascribed to pick-up ions incorporated as suprathermal ions into the background solar wind. Neutral interstellar H-atoms penetrate into the inner heliosphere and at ionization they are converted into pick-up ions. Here we do not consider how the magnetized solar wind flow incorporates these ions into the plasma bulk when enforcing their co-motion. We simply take the first step of their incorporation for guaranteed, namely the fast redistribution of pick- ups from an initially unstable toroidal to a quasistable bi-spherical distribution. The free energy lost by pick-ups during this redistribution goes into the turbulent MHD waves, and as such cascades down to the proton dissipation scale and finally is absorbed by solar wind protons. Here we investigate the thermodynamics of solar wind protons being heated by absorption of this free energy of pick-ups. In addition we also consider as a relevant and competing proton heat source the heating due to absorption of wave energy of convected MHD turbulences, showing that the latter source always dominates inside some critical solar distance, whereas the first one dominates in the outer heliospheric regions. We then solve the resulting dierential equation for the solar wind proton temperature and show in the solutions obtained that a quasipolytropic behaviour of the solar wind protons with a distance-dependent polytropic index is found. The expression for the pressure clearly shows the change from an adiabatic to a quasipolytropic behaviour with a decreasing polytropic index at increasing distances as observed by the VOYAGERs. The quantitative run of the temperature and the polytropic index with solar distance thereby is strongly influenced by the interstellar H-atom density. The (pick-up ion)-induced heating also evidently leads to a wind-asymmetric solar wind temperature distribution with higher temperatures occuring in upwind direction compared to downwind direction.