H. Marvin Camel

Radiation therapy alone in the treatment of carcinoma of the uterine cervix. II. Analysis of complications

A retrospective analysis was carried out on 811 patients with histologically proven invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with irradiation alone. A correlation was made of the doses of irradiation delivered to the pelvic organs with external beam and intracavitary insertions. Approximately 3% of the patients exhibited grade 2 gastrointestinal complications, and 2% developed grade 2 urinary complications; 5% of the patients developed grade 3 gastrointestinal complications, and 3% developed grade 3 urinary complications. Other types of complications, primarily grade 2, such as vaginal necrosis, pelivic abscess, thrombophlebitis, etc, were seen in approximately 5% of the patients. Thus, the total percentage of patients developing grade 2 complicatins was 10% and grade 3 complications, approximately 8%. About 25% of the patients who had complications showed more than one sequela. The most frequently observed grade 2 complications were proctitis, cystitis, vaginal stenosis, and partial small bowel obstruction which were treated with conservative management. Grade 3 complications required surgical treatment and consisted most frequently of ureteral stricture, vesicovaginal fistula, rectovaginal fistula, sigmoid stricture, small bowel obstruction, proctitis, and large rectal ulcers. The most significant factor affecting the appearance of complications was the total dose of irradiation delivered to the pelvic organs by the whole pelvis external irradiation and intracavitary insertions. With maximum total doses up to 8000 rad the incidence of grade 2 and 3 complications was less than 5%. However, with higher doses the incidence of complications increased to 10% to 15%. In patients receiving total doses of 6000 rad to the bladder or rectum, more complications were noted when only one intracavitary insertion was performed, as compared with two or three. Eighty percent of the rectosigmoid complications occurred within 30 months of initial therapy, in contrast to 48 months for the urinary complications. Patients who developed complications had survival rates comparable to those without complications. This underscores the need to rapidly institute treatment on patients who have severe injury after radiation therapy. Even though it is difficult to determine the exact total dose delivered to a specific volume within the pelvis, the current study strongly indicates that dose calculations to specific anatomical points may be reliable parameters to use in modifying treatment techniques to deliver doses of irradiation that will not exceed tolerance limits for the pelvic structures, when treating patients with carcinoma of the uterine cervix with irradiation alone.

Effect of tumor size on the prognosis of carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with irradiation alone

The authors conducted a retrospective analysis of 1178 patients with histologically proven invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with irradiation alone. The minimum follow‐up time was 3 years. The 10‐year actuarial pelvic failure rate in Stage IB was 6% for tumors less than 3 cm, 15% for tumors 3 to 5 cm, and 30% for tumors more than 5 cm (P = 0.0018). The 10‐year actuarial pelvic failure rate in Stage IIA was 10% for tumors less than 3 cm, 28% for tumors 3 to 5 cm, and 20% for tumors more than 5 cm (P = 0.09). Stage IIB unilateral nonbulky tumors (less than 5 cm) had a 20% pelvic failure rate compared with 28% for bilateral lesions and 35% for unilateral bulky tumors (more than 5 cm) (P = 0.35). In Stage IIB, pelvic failures were greater when disease extended into the lateral parametrium (30%) compared with medial parametrial involvement only (17%) (P = 0.01). In Stage III unilateral nonbulky tumors, the pelvic failure rate was 28% compared with 45% to 50% for unilateral bulky lesions (P = 0.002). Bilateral parametrial disease in Stage IIB did not increase the pelvic failure rate (21% in both subgroups) (P = 0.83), whereas in Stage III, bilateral parametrial involvement was associated with a 48% pelvic failure rate versus 28% for unilateral extension (P ≤ 0.01). Five‐year disease‐free survival (DFS) rates for IB tumors less than or equal to 3 cm was 90% versus 67% for tumors more than 3 cm (P = 0.01). In Stage IIA tumors less than or equal to 3 cm, 5‐year DFS was 70% versus 45% for tumors more than 3 cm. Patients with Stage IIB nonbulky tumors (less than or equal to 5 cm in diameter) had better 10‐year DFS (65% to 70%) compared with those with bilateral bulky tumors (45% to 55%) (P = 0.10). Stage I11 patients with unilateral nonbulky tumors had a 55% 10‐year DFS compared with 35% to 40% for bulky tumors or bilateral parametrial involvement (P = 0.002). The authors concluded that clinical stage and size of tumor are critical factors in the prognosis, therapy selection, and evaluation of results in carcinoma of the uterine cervix.

Radiation therapy alone in the treatment of carcinoma of uterine cervix I. Analysis of tumor recurrence

This is a retrospective analysis with emphasis on the patterns of failure in 849 patients with histologically proven invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with irradiation alone. In 281 patients with Stage IB tumors, the total incidence of pelvic failure was 6.4% (two without and 16 combined with distant metastasis). In 88 patients with Stage IIA, 12.5% failed in the pelvis (one without and ten combined with distant metastasis). The total pelvic failure rate in Stage IIB was 17.4% (22 without and 22 combined with distant metastasis). In 212 patients with Stage III, the overall pelvic failure rate was 35.8% (31 without and 45 combined with distant metastasis). Approximately 25% of the pelvic recurrences were central (cervix or vagina) and 75% parametrial. The overall incidence of distant metastasis was 13.5% for Stage IB, 27.3% for Stage IIA, 23.8% for Stage IIB, and 39.6% in Stage III. Higher doses of irradiation delivered to the medial and lateral parametrium with external beam irradiation and intracavitary insertions were correlated with a lower incidence of parametrial failures in all stages, except IB. In Stage IIA, medial parametrial doses below 9000 rad resulted in 10/78 = 12.8% pelvic failures, in contrast to one recurrence in 10 patients treated with doses over 9000 rad. In Stage IIB, doses below 9000 rad yielded a pelvic recurrence rate of 36/203 (17.7%) compared to 5/49 (10.2%) with higher doses. In Stage III there were 66/167 (39.5%) recurrences with doses below 9000 rad and 10/44 (22.7%) with larger doses. Statistically significant differences were observed among the Stage IIB (P = 0.02) and III patients (P = 0.005) respectively. The lateral parametrial dose also showed some correlation with tumor control, although the differences were not statistically significant. The survival in patients with Stage IIB and III was 10% higher in the patients treated with higher parametrial doses. However, the differences are not statistically significant. These results strongly suggest that higher doses of irradiation must be delivered to patients with Stage IIB and III, but improvement in tumor control must be weighed against an increasing number of complications. Factors other than the total doses of irradiation, such as the characteristics of the tumor and the quality of the intracavitary insertion influence the therapeutic results in irradiation of carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Other therapeutic approaches must be designed to improve the effect of irradiation in the tumor without further injury to the normal tissues. Hypoxic cell sensitizers, hyperthermia and high LET particles are under investigation.

Radiation therapy alone in the treatment of carcinoma of the uterine cervix: A 20-year experience

A retrospective analysis is reported on the results of irradiation alone in the treatment of 970 patients with histologically proven invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix. The development of the radiation therapy techniques, survival, pelvic tumor control, and major sequelae of therapy are described in detail. The tumor-free 5-year survival rate was 100% in 29 patients with stage IA, 85% in 312 cases with stage IB, 70% in 98 patients with stage IIA, 68% in 276 patients with stage IIB, 45% in 237 stage III cases, and one survivor in 18 stage IV patients. No pelvic recurrences or distant metastases were observed in stage IA patients. In stage IB the overall incidence of pelvic recurrences was 7.3%, in stages IIA and IIB 14%, and in stage III 37%. Distant metastases were noted in 13% of the patients with stage IB, 22% of those with stages IIA and IIB, and 32% of patients with stage III tumors. Higher doses of irradiation delivered with intracavitary insertions and extenal beam were correlated with a lower incidence of pelvic recurrences in stages IIA, IIB, and III. However, doses to point A over 7000 cGy did not improve pelvic tumor control in stage IB. Grade 2 treatment sequelae were observed in about 10% of all patients and grade 3 complications in approximately 4% of the patients with stage I and 8% in those with more advanced tumors (IIA and beyond). The need is emphasized to carefully evaluate the dosimetric aspects of new techniques, including phantom studies before they are applied to patients. A close integration of external and intracavitary irradiation will result in better tumor control and fewer complications.

Impact of dose in outcome of irradiation alone in carcinoma of the uterine cervix: analysis of two different methods

This is a retrospective analysis of 1211 patients with histologically proven invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix with a minimum follow-up of 3 years treated with irradiation alone. The pelvic failure rates by stage were 9.6% for IB, 18.6% for IIA, 23% for IIB, 41% for III, and 75% for Stage IVA disease. External beam and intracavitary irradiation doses to point A and pelvic lymph nodes were calculated. In patients with Stage IB and IIA disease there was no significant correlation between doses to these points and pelvic tumor control. In Stage IIB doses of less than 6000 cGy to point A correlated with a high pelvic failure rate (8 of 12, 66.7%) in contrast to doses of 6000 to 9000 cGy (61 of 261, 23.4%) or higher than 9000 cGy (10 of 74, 13.5%) (p less than or equal to 0.01). In Stage III the pelvic failure rate with doses below 6000 cGy to point A was 72% (18 of 25) compared to 39% (71 of 180) for 6000 to 9000 cGy or 35% (27 of 77) with doses above 9000 cGy (p less than or equal to 0.01). TDF calculation of doses was carried out. In Stage IB and IIA there was no significant correlation between TDF to point A and probability of pelvic recurrence. In Stage IIB with TDF below 135, the pelvic recurrence rate was 41.6% (20 of 48) compared to 20% (61 of 305) with higher TDF (p less than or equal to 0.01). In Stage III the pelvic failure rate was 51% with TDF below 160 (70 of 136) in comparison with 29.5% (46 of 156) with higher TDF (p less than or equal to 0.01). Grade 2 sequelae of therapy were noted in about 10% of the patients and grade 3 in 4.7% of patients with Stage IB (18 of 384), 10.2% (12 of 128) with Stage IIA, 9.3% (33 of 353) with Stage IIB, and 8.2% (24 of 293) with Stage III disease. Doses from external beam and intracavitary irradiation to the rectum or the bladder neck were calculated. The actuarial incidence of major rectal or rectosigmoid sequelae was 2% to 4% with doses to the rectum of 6000 to 8000 cGy, 7% to 8% with 8000 to 9500 cGy, and 13% with doses higher than 9500 cGy (p less than or equal to 0.01).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Irradiation alone or combined with surgery in stage IB, IIA, and IIB carcinoma of uterine cervix: update for a nonrandomized comparison

PURPOSE Definitive radiation therapy alone or combined with surgery in carcinoma of the uterine cervix yields comparable tumor control and survival in Stages I and IIA when patients are adequately treated with either modality. Our 30-year institutional experience is described. METHODS AND MATERIALS This is a nonrandomized comparison of treatment results of 415 patients with Stage IB, 137 with Stage IIA, and 340 with Stage IIB carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with irradiation alone and 197 with Stage IB, 44 with Stage IIA, and 65 with limited Stage IIB treated with pre- or postoperative irradiation and surgery. Irradiation alone consisted of a combination of external beam therapy and intracavitary insertions to deliver doses of 70 to 85 Gy to point A for patients with Stages IB and IIA disease and 80 to 90 Gy for patients with bulky or Stage IIB tumors. For patients treated with irradiation and surgery, various combinations of external beam and intracavitary therapy were used to deliver 60 to 75 Gy to point A. Surgical procedures consisted of radical hysterectomy with or without lymph node dissection in 130 patients with Stage IB, 28 patients with Stage IIA, and 10 patients with limited Stage IIB. Fifty-seven patients had total abdominal or conservative hysterectomy with or without lymph node dissection, and 3 had vaginal hysterectomy. In addition, 51 patients with Stage IIB tumors underwent pelvic lymphadenectomy after definitive irradiation. RESULTS The 5-year cause-specific survival (CSS) rates for patients with Stage IB nonbulky tumors treated with irradiation alone or irradiation combined with surgery were 90 and 85%, respectively, and the 10-year survival rate was 84% with either modality. In patients with bulky tumors (> 5 cm), the 5-year CSS rates were 61% with irradiation alone and 63% with irradiation plus surgery; at 10 years the rates were 61 and 68%, respectively (p = 0.5). For those with Stage IIA nonbulky tumors, the 5-year CSS rates were 75% with irradiation alone and 83% with combined irradiation and surgery, and 10-year CSS rates were 66 and 71%, respectively. In patients with Stage IIA bulky tumors, the 5-year CSS rates were 69% with irradiation alone and 60% with irradiation plus surgery, and at 10 years, 69 and 44%, respectively (p = 0.05). In patients with Stage IIB nonbulky tumors treated with irradiation alone or combined with surgery, the 5- and 10-year CCS rates were 72 and 65%, respectively; the corresponding survival rates with bulky tumors or bilateral parametrial involvement were 56 and 50%. Incidence of pelvic failures, alone or with distant metastasis, for Stage IB was 10% (43 out of 415) with irradiation alone and 14% (28 of 197) with irradiation plus surgery; for Stage IIA, 17% (23 out of 137) with irradiation alone and 20% (9 our of 44) with irradiation plus surgery; and for Stage IIB, 23% (88 out of 391) with irradiation alone and 29% (4 out of 14) with irradiation plus surgery. Grade 3 sequelae were comparable in both groups (irradiation alone, 5% to 11%; irradiation combined with surgery, 8% to 12%); the differences are not statistically significant. The most frequent major sequelae in 892 patients receiving irradiation only were rectovaginal fistula (13 cases, 1.5%), proctitis (10, 1.1%), small bowel obstruction (16, 1.8%), ureteral stricture (16, 1.8%), and vesicovaginal fistula (8, 0.9%). In 306 patients treated with irradiation plus surgery, the most commonly recorded major sequelae were small bowel obstruction/perforation (13 cases, 4.2%), ureteral stricture (8, 2.6%), vesicovaginal fistula (5, 1.6%), and rectovaginal fistula (4, 1.3%). CONCLUSION Irradiation alone or combined with surgery yields comparable pelvic tumor control, survival, and morbidity in patients with Stage IB, IIA, and limited IIB carcinoma of the uterine cervix.

Analysis of pelvic tumor control and impact on survival in carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with radiation therapy alone.

A total of 1054 patients with histologically confirmed invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix were treated with radiation therapy alone between 1959 and 1982. All patients are available for a minimum of 3 years follow-up. Radiation therapy consisted of external irradiation to the whole pelvis (1000-2000 cGy) and parametria (for a total of 4000-6000 cGy) combined with two intracavitary radioactive source insertions (6000-7500 cGy to point A). Patients with Stage IIB, III, and IVA have been consistently treated with somewhat higher doses of external irradiation and intracavitary insertions. A small group of 54 patients with Stage IIB or IIIB had pelvic lymphadenectomy following the irradiation (1960-1964). There was a strong correlation between the tumor regression within 30 days from completion of radiotherapy and the incidence of pelvic recurrences or distant metastases for each of the anatomical stages. The 10-year survival rate for Stage IB was 76%, Stage IIA 60%, Stage IIB 45%, and Stage III 25%. Many of the deaths were due to intercurrent disease. Thus, the 10-year tumor-free survival was 80% for Stage IB, 60% for Stages IIA and IIB and 35% for Stage III. In Stage IB total doses of 6000 cGy or higher to point A resulted in 94% pelvic tumor control. In Stage IIA, the pelvic tumor control was 87% with doses of 6000 cGy to point A or higher. However, in Stage IIB the pelvic tumor control was 58% with doses below 6000 cGy, 78% with 6001-7500 cGy and 82% with higher doses. In Stage IIIB the pelvic tumor control was 42% with doses below 6000 cGy, 57% with 6001-7500 cGy and 68% with higher doses. Tumor control in the pelvis was correlated with the following 5 year survivals: Stage IB-95% (353 patients); Stage IIA-84% (116 patients); Stage IIB-84% (308 patients); Stage IIIB-74% (245 patients). The 5-year survival for patients that recurred in the pelvis was 30% for Stage IB, about 15% for Stages IIA-B and only 5% in Stage III. Patients with tumor control in the pelvis had a significantly lower incidence of distant metastases than patients who initially failed in the pelvis (9.3% vs. 58.6% in Stage IB, 21.6% vs 52.6% in Stage IIA, 19.8% vs 16.7% in Stage IIB, and 31.2% vs 50% in Stage III). In Stage IIB the figures were 19.8% and 16.7% because the initial pelvic recurrence was frequently concurrent with distant metastases.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Clinical stage I endometrial cancer : prognostic factors for local control and distant metastasis and implications of the new figo surgical staging system

A retrospective analysis is reported in 858 patients with clinical Stage I carcinoma of the endometrium treated definitively with combined irradiation and total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (TAH-BSO) from January 1960 through December 1986. Most patients received a preoperative intracavitary insertion (3500-4000 mgh to the uterus and a 6500 cGy surface dose to the upper vagina) followed by a TAH-BSO within 1-2 weeks. Some patients received postoperative external beam irradiation (2000 cGy whole pelvis and an additional 3000 cGy to the parametria, with a midline stepwedge) when factors such as deep myometrial invasion were present. Occasionally patients were treated with a preoperative intracavitary insertion and preoperative external beam irradiation (2000 cGy whole pelvis). The 5-year progression-free survivals by FIGO (1988) surgical stage were 93% for IA, 90% for IB, and 91% for Stage IC. An analysis of multiple variables was performed to ascertain their prognostic significance. Factors that significantly affected the 5-year progression-free survivals by univariate analysis were grade (grade 1 = 95%, grade 2 = 88%, grade 3 = 73%; p less than 0.0001), histology (adenoacanthoma = 96%, clear cell = 89%, adenocarcinoma = 89%, papillary = 81%, adenosquamous = 80%; p = 0.04), lower uterine segment involvement (uninvolved = 89%, involved = 73%; p = 0.006), depth of myometrial invasion (no residual tumor = 91%, limited to the endometrium = 96%, less than 1/3 myometrial penetration = 92%, 1/3 - 2/3 = 100%, greater than 2/3 = 50%; p = 0.02), peritoneal cytology (negative = 92%, positive = 56%, p less than 0.0001), uterine serosal involvement (uninvolved = 89%, involved = 55%; p less than 0.0001), vascular space invasion (absent = 89%, present = 75%; p = 0.001), and the presence of extrauterine disease (absent = 90%, present = 64%; p less than 0.0001). A multivariate analysis of these prognostic variables showed that histological grade (p = 0.001), peritoneal cytology (p = 0.004), and uterine serosal involvement were prognostic for local failure and that peritoneal cytology (p less than 0.001), grade (p = 0.001), age (p = 0.002), and extrauterine disease (p = 0.02) were prognostic for the development of distant metastasis.

Definitive irradiation in carcinoma of the vagina: Long-term evaluation of results

A retrospective analysis of 165 patients with histologically confirmed carcinoma of the vagina is reported. Actuarial disease-free 10-year survival was: Stage 0 (16 patients)--94%, Stage I (50 patients)--75%, Stage IIA (49 patients)--55%, Stage IIB (26 patients)--43%, Stage III (16 patients)--32%, Stage IV (8 patients)--0%. All but one of the in situ lesions were controlled with intracavitary therapy. Of the patients with Stage I disease, 86% showed no evidence of vaginal or pelvic recurrence. Most of them received interstitial or intracavitary therapy or both; the addition of external beam irradiation did not significantly increase survival or tumor control. In Stage IIA (paravaginal extension) 61% of the tumors were controlled with a combination of brachytherapy and external beam irradiation. Ten of 16 Stage III tumors were controlled in the pelvis. Two of the patients with Stage IV disease had no recurrence in the pelvis with relatively high doses of irradiation. The total incidence of distant metastases was 16% in Stage I, 30.6% in Stage IIA, 46.1% in Stage IIB, 62% in Stage III, and 50% in Stage IV. The dose of irradiation delivered to the primary tumor or the parametrial extension was critical in achieving successful results. The incidence of grade 2-3 complications (12%) is correlated with the stage of the tumor and type of treatment given. More effective irradiation techniques including the optimization of dose distribution by judicious combination of external irradiation and interstitial brachytherapy will be necessary to enhance loco-regional tumor control. The high incidence of distant metastases underscores the need for earlier diagnosis and effective systemic cytotoxic agents if survival is to be significantly improved in these patients.

Carcinoma of the fallopian tube: management and sites of failure

Thirty patients with adenocarcinoma of the fallopian tube, treated between 1950 and 1981, were studied. Median age was 55 years, and mean parity was 1.3. Bleeding or discharge occurred as a presenting complaint in 47% of patients, abdominal distention or mass in 50%, and pain in 30%. Lesions were staged using a system analogous to the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) classification for ovarian carcinoma. Nine patients had Stage I disease; 11, Stage II; 7, Stage III; and 3, Stage IV. Histologic differentiation was Grade 1 in 39% of the patients, Grade 2 in 18%, and Grade 3 in 43%. Primary surgical treatment consisted of total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingectomy in 70% of the patients; 23% had more extensive surgery, whereas 13% had less extensive surgery. Three patients with Stage I tumors were treated with surgery alone, and the remainder received postoperative radiation, chemotherapy, or both. Survival was unrelated to grade, but highly dependent upon stage. Survival at 5 years was 56% for Stage I, 27% for Stage II, 14% for Stage III, and 0% for Stage IV. Four of five patients treated after surgery with a combination of cisplatin, doxorubicin, and cyclophosphamide (PAC) survived at least 3 years. Patterns of initial treatment failure showed 56% with a component of pelvic failure, 50% with a component of upper abdominal failure, and 44% with extraperitoneal metastases as a component of failure. These results suggest the need for aggressive postoperative adjuvant therapy targeted at upper abdominal and distant sites for metastasis in all lesions beyond Stage I.