H. Ongun Onaran

Where have all the active receptor states gone

Defining G protein-coupled receptor ligand efficacy and biased agonism in precise chemical terms is one challenge posed by the current structural data that exists for this receptor family. Concepts classically used for understanding enzymes and other nonreceptor proteins may lead us in the right direction.

What is biased efficacy? Defining the relationship between intrinsic efficacy and free energy coupling

A G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) is only biologically active when associated with a transduction protein, but it can also switch function by interacting with different types of transduction proteins. Biased agonism arises when the ligand induces the receptor to engage distinct transduction proteins with different efficacies. We briefly review the concept of ligand efficacy, from the classical empirical idea to the current mechanistic views of allosteric regulation in proteins. A combination of these theoretically distinct ideas and methodologies allows us to distinguish true ligand bias from divergences of signalling caused by the system. We also demonstrate a rigorous mathematical connection between the intrinsic efficacy of classical receptor theory and the energetic effect that makes a ligand capable of stabilizing receptor-transducer association in the ternary complex model. This relationship unifies different definitions of efficacy and provides a rational basis for quantifying biased agonism.

Cell Contact-dependent Functional Selectivity of β2-Adrenergic Receptor Ligands in Stimulating cAMP Accumulation and Extracellular Signal-regulated Kinase Phosphorylation

Background: β2-Adrenegic receptor (β2-AR) mediates cAMP accumulation and ERK phosphorylation via different transducers. Results: Some β2-AR ligands selectively activate cAMP and ERK responses in HEK-293 cells. Selectivity is cell contact-dependent. Conclusion: β2-AR stimulates ERK phosphorylation by cAMP-dependent and Gi/Go-mediated pathways. Cell contact inhibits the cAMP-dependent pathway. Significance: Cell adherence/contact is an important modulatory factor in biased signaling by GPCR ligands. Activation of β2-adrenegic receptor (β2-AR) leads to an increase in intracellular cAMP and activation of ERK. These two signals are activated by the interaction of the receptor with different transducer partners. We showed that the intrinsic activities of β2-AR ligands for stimulating cAMP production and ERK phosphorylation responses in HEK-293 cells were not correlated. The lack of correlation resulted mainly from the discrepancy between the intrinsic activities of two groups of ligands for these two responses: The first group consisted of clenbuterol, cimaterol, procaterol, and terbutaline which acted as full agonists for cAMP production but displayed very weak effect on ERK phosphorylation. The second group comprised adrenaline and noradrenaline which displayed higher intrinsic activity for the ERK phosphorylation than for the cAMP response. Thus, both groups behaved as functionally selective ligands. The functional selectivity of the first group was observable only in adherent cells when confluence was approximately 100%. When cell-cell contact was minimized either by decreasing the density of the adherent cells or by bringing the cells into suspension, the first group of ligands gained the ability to stimulate ERK phosphorylation without a change in their effect on cAMP production. In contrast, selectivity of the second group was independent of the adherence state of the cells. Our results show that the inherent “bias” of ligands in coupling a G protein-coupled receptor to different transducers may not always be revealed as functional selectivity when there is a “cross-talk” between the signaling pathways activated by the same receptor.

Ligands Raise the Constraint That Limits Constitutive Activation in G Protein-coupled Opioid Receptors

Background: Native subtypes of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR) show different levels of constitutive activation. Results: Using a BRET assay to detect receptor-G protein complexes, we find that constitutive activation causes a uniform reduction of the apparent efficacy of all ligands. Conclusion: An intramolecular energy barrier separates constitutive from ligand-regulated activation. Significance: The data suggest that GPCR activation involves both cooperative and anticooperative components. Using a cell-free bioluminescence resonance energy transfer strategy we compared the levels of spontaneous and ligand-induced receptor-G protein coupling in δ (DOP) and μ (MOP) opioid receptors. In this assay GDP can suppress spontaneous coupling, thus allowing its quantification. The level of constitutive activity was 4–5 times greater at the DOP than at the MOP receptor. A series of opioid analogues with a common peptidomimetic scaffold displayed remarkable inversions of efficacy in the two receptors. Agonists that enhanced coupling above the low intrinsic level of the MOP receptor were inverse agonists in reducing the greater level of constitutive coupling of the DOP receptor. Yet the intrinsic activities of such ligands are identical when scaled over the GDP base line of both receptors. This pattern is in conflict with the predictions of the ternary complex model and the “two state” extensions. According to this theory, the order of spontaneous and ligand-induced coupling cannot be reversed if a shift of the equilibrium between active and inactive forms raises constitutive activation in one receptor type. We propose that constitutive activation results from a lessened intrinsic barrier that restrains spontaneous coupling. Any ligand, regardless of its efficacy, must enhance this constraint to stabilize the ligand-bound complexed form.

Systematic errors in detecting biased agonism: Analysis of current methods and development of a new model-free approach

Discovering biased agonists requires a method that can reliably distinguish the bias in signalling due to unbalanced activation of diverse transduction proteins from that of differential amplification inherent to the system being studied, which invariably results from the non-linear nature of biological signalling networks and their measurement. We have systematically compared the performance of seven methods of bias diagnostics, all of which are based on the analysis of concentration-response curves of ligands according to classical receptor theory. We computed bias factors for a number of β-adrenergic agonists by comparing BRET assays of receptor-transducer interactions with Gs, Gi and arrestin. Using the same ligands, we also compared responses at signalling steps originated from the same receptor-transducer interaction, among which no biased efficacy is theoretically possible. In either case, we found a high level of false positive results and a general lack of correlation among methods. Altogether this analysis shows that all tested methods, including some of the most widely used in the literature, fail to distinguish true ligand bias from “system bias” with confidence. We also propose two novel semi quantitative methods of bias diagnostics that appear to be more robust and reliable than currently available strategies.

Role of α-adrenoceptors in the effects of buspirone and 5-carboxamidotryptamine in rabbit isolated thoracic aorta

1. The role of alpha-adrenoceptors in the vascular effects of buspirone (BUS) and 5-carboxamidotryptamine (5-CT) was investigated in rabbit thoracic aorta. 2. Buspirone produced a concentration-dependent contraction. The non-selective 5-HT1 and 5-HT2-receptor antagonist methysergide and the 5-HT2 receptor antagonist ketanserin did not alter the contractile effect of buspirone. However, the competitive antagonist of alpha 1-adrenoceptors, prazosin, shifted the concentration-response curve of buspirone to the right without changing the maximal response. 3. Benextramine tetrahydrochloride monohydrate (BHC), a noncompetitive antagonist of alpha 1-adrenoceptors, inhibited the contraction induced by buspirone in a noncompetitive manner. After pretreatment with two different concentrations of BHC, the estimated apparent dissociation constants of buspirone were found to be identical. 4. In addition, buspirone antagonized the concentration-response curve of phenylephrine again showing a similar dissociation constant, suggesting a partial agonistic action of buspirone at the level of alpha 1-adrenoceptors. 5. The concentration-response curve of 5-HT showed two components in the thoracic aorta obtained from reserpine treated and untreated animals as verified by different pD2 values. The second component was observed with relatively higher concentrations of 5-CT and could be blocked by prazosin or BHC. Neither of these compounds altered the first component. After Pretreatment with BHC, the first component of 5-CT was competitively antagonized by methysergide and ketanserin, having pA2 values of 8.81 and 9.1 respectively. 6. These results suggest that the contraction induced by buspirone is mainly mediated by alpha 1-adrenoceptors, while the higher concentrations of 5-CT caused contraction via alpha 1-adrenoceptor stimulation in addition to its 5-HT2 agonistic effect.

Kinetics of antagonism at histamine-H1 receptors in isolated rabbit arteries

Kinetics of antagonist-induced decrease of histamine-H1 receptor-mediated steady-state responses in isolated rabbit arteries were studied in the presence of histamine-H2 receptor antagonist famotidine. Data were fitted using a model which describes competition kinetics at the receptor level. Estimated rate and equilibrium constants were evaluated for their dependence on tissue, agonist and antagonist concentrations, using (+)-brompheniramine as antagonist. In large arteries (thoracic and arcus aorta), rate constants were observed to be modified by agonist and/or antagonist concentrations, suggesting a diffusion-controlled process. In relatively small (common carotid and iliac) arteries, estimated equilibrium constants (and consequently the rate constants) were found to diverge despite the invariance of equilibration times between arteries, leading us to include the effects of spare receptors in our evaluation. A model describing the effects of receptor reserve on the estimated equilibrium dissociation constant was developed and stimulated and the results then compared with those that had been experimentally estimated. The reserve hypothesis was experimentally verified in common iliac artery (where EC50 ≪ KA) using the irreversible antagonist phenoxybenzamine. A rationalized rule for the optimization of experimental design for in-vitro disequilibrium-competition experiments was proposed. Common carotic artery was found to be favorable for the present design in view of its reserve properties. In addition, competition reaction seems to be the rate-determining step in this artery. Rate and equilibrium constants of mepyramine, (+)-brompheniramine, diphenhydramine and antazoline were therefore determined in the common carotid artery and were compared with those obtained from independent experiments. Results suggest that the estimated parameters reflect drug-receptor interaction.Kinetics of antagonist-induced decrease of histamine-H1 receptor-mediated steady-state responses in isolated rabbit arteries were studied in the presence of histamine-H2 receptor antagonist famotidine. Data were fitted using a model which describes competition kinetics at the receptor level. Estimated rate and equilibrium constants were evaluated for their dependence on tissue, agonist and antagonist concentrations, using (+)-brompheniramine as antagonist. In large arteries (thoracic and arcus aorta), rate constants were observed to be modified by agonist and/or antagonist concentrations, suggesting a diffusion-controlled process. In relatively small (common carotid and iliac) arteries, estimated equilibrium constants (and consequently the rate constants) were found to diverge despite the invariance of equilibration times between arteries, leading us to include the effects of spare receptors in our evaluation. A model describing the effects of receptor reserve on the estimated equilibrium dissociation constant was developed and stimulated and the results then compared with those that had been experimentally estimated. The reserve hypothesis was experimentally verified in common iliac artery (where EC50 ≪ K A) using the irreversible antagonist phenoxybenzamine. A rationalized rule for the optimization of experimental design for in-vitro disequilibrium-competition experiments was proposed. Common carotic artery was found to be favorable for the present design in view of its reserve properties. In addition, competition reaction seems to be the rate-determining step in this artery. Rate and equilibrium constants of mepyramine, (+)-brompheniramine, diphenhydramine and antazoline were therefore determined in the common carotid artery and were compared with those obtained from independent experiments. Results suggest that the estimated parameters reflect drug-receptor interaction.

Long and short distance movements of β2-adrenoceptor in cell membrane assessed by photoconvertible fluorescent protein dendra2–β2-adrenoceptor fusion

Local movements of receptors in the plasma membrane have been extensively studied, as it is generally believed that the dynamics of membrane distribution of receptors regulate their functions. However, the properties of large-scale (>5μm) receptor movements in the membrane are relatively obscure. In the present study, we addressed the question as to whether the large-scale movement of receptor in the plasma membrane at the whole cell level can be explained quantitatively by its local diffusive properties. We used HEK 293 cells transfected with human β2-adrenoceptor fused to photoconvertible fluorescent protein dendra2 as a model system; and found that 1) functional integrity of the dendra2-tagged receptor remains apparently intact; 2) in a mesoscopic scale (~4μm), ~90% of the receptors are mobile on average, and receptor influx to, and out-flux from a membrane area can be symmetrically explained by a diffusion-like process with an effective diffusion coefficient of ~0.1μm(2)/s; 3) these mobility parameters are not affected by the activity state of the receptor (assessed by using constitutively active receptor mutants); 4) in the macroscopic scale (4-40μm), although a slowly diffusing fraction of receptors (with D<0.01μm(2)/s) is identifiable in some cases, the movement of the predominant fraction is perfectly explained by the same effective diffusion process observed in the mesoscopic scale, suggesting that the large scale structure of the cell membrane as felt by the receptor is apparently homogeneous in terms of its mesoscopic properties. We also showed that intracellular compartments and plasma membrane are kinetically connected even at steady-state.

Β2-Adrenoceptor, Gs and adenylate cyclase coupling in purified detergent-resistant, low density membrane fractions

Membrane rafts and caveolae are specialized microdomains of the cell membrane that form physical platforms for compartmentalization of signalling molecules. Here, we intended to gain insight into the consequences of caveolar localization in G protein-coupled receptor function. We analysed beta(2)-adrenoceptor signalling in purified CRLDF (caveolin-rich low density fractions) of beta(2)-adrenoceptor-overexpressing HEK-293 cells. beta(2)-adrenoceptor and Gs immunoreactivities and forskolin-stimulated adenylate cyclase activity were all detected in CRLDF obtained by the conventional raft purification method that uses Triton X-100 solubilization. However, Triton X-100 caused a complete loss of the functional coupling between beta(2)-adrenoceptor, Gs and adenylate cyclase. Therefore, we developed an optimized purification method based on n-octyl-beta-d-glucopyranoside solubilization, where the functional properties of beta(2)-adrenoceptor, Gs and adenylate cyclase were preserved in the CRLDF. Using this method, we showed that isoproterenol-stimulated adenylate cyclase activity was similar in CRLDF and bulk membrane preparations of HEK-293 cells that overexpress beta(2)-adrenoceptor or beta(2)-adrenoceptor-Gs fusion. Accordingly, treatment of cells with methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, a caveola-disrupting agent, did not affect beta(2)-adrenoceptor-induced cAMP response. Likewise, these responses were insensitive to caveolin 1 and 2 overexpression. On the other hand, methyl-beta-cyclodextrin treatment did decrease beta(2)-adrenoceptor-induced ERK phosphorylation. However, the latter effect of methyl-beta-cyclodextrin could be attributed to a non-specific effect rather than its ability to disrupt membrane microdomains. We showed that localization in the raft microdomains did not affect the signalling efficiency of beta(2)-adrenoceptor-Gs-adenylate cyclase pathway, and that methyl-beta-cyclodextrin may inhibit signalling by directly affecting the signalling system independently of its caveola-disrupting property.

Agonist‐directed trafficking explaining the difference between response pattern of naratriptan and sumatriptan in rabbit common carotid artery

Sumatriptan or eletriptan produced vasocontraction in common carotid artery (CCA) by stimulating 5HT1B receptors (see also Akin & Gurdal, this issue). Naratriptan as a 5HT1B/D agonist, was unable to produce vasocontraction in this artery, but inhibited the vasocontractile response induced by sumatriptan or eletriptan. All these agonists inhibited forskolin‐stimulated cyclic AMP production with comparable potencies and maximal responses. This inhibition was mediated by 5HT1B receptors: 5HT1B antagonist SB216641 (1 μM) completeley antagonized sumatriptan‐, eletriptan‐ or naratriptan‐induced cyclic AMP inhibition, but 5HT1D antagonist BRL15572 (1 μM) did not affect this response. Naratriptan‐induced stimulation of 5‐HT1B receptors resulted only in adenylate cyclase inhibition, whereas stimulation of these receptors by sumatriptan or eletriptan produced vasocontraction as well. Hence, we concluded that the 5HT1B‐mediated inhibition of adenylate cyclase was not a sufficient condition to couple the receptor stimulation to vasocontraction. We discussed agonist‐induced trafficking as a plausible mechanism for the observed phenomenon.