H. Robert Guy

The gating mechanism of the large mechanosensitive channel MscL

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, MscL, is a ubiquitous membrane-embedded valve involved in turgor regulation in bacteria. The crystal structure of MscL from Mycobacterium tuberculosis provides a starting point for analysing molecular mechanisms of tension-dependent channel gating. Here we develop structural models in which a cytoplasmic gate is formed by a bundle of five amino-terminal helices (S1), previously unresolved in the crystal structure. When membrane tension is applied, the transmembrane barrel expands and pulls the gate apart through the S1–M1 linker. We tested these models by substituting cysteines for residues predicted to be near each other only in either the closed or open conformation. Our results demonstrate that S1 segments form the bundle when the channel is closed, and crosslinking between S1 segments prevents opening. S1 segments interact with M2 when the channel is open, and crosslinking of S1 to M2 impedes channel closing. Gating is affected by the length of the S1–M1 linker in a manner consistent with the model, revealing critical spatial relationships between the domains that transmit force from the lipid bilayer to the channel gate.

Pursuing the structure and function of voltage-gated channels

A cyclical process of experimentation and theoretical analysis is being used to develop increasingly precise models of the structure and functional mechanisms of membrane proteins. Nucleic acid sequences have been determined for several voltage-gated sodium, calcium and potassium channels from invertebrates and vertebrates and from nerve and muscle tissues. Some of these sequences have been altered using site-directed mutagenesis. Properties of channels expressed after injection of normal and altered mRNA into Xenopus oocytes have been analysed by a variety of patch-clamp techniques. Preliminary structural models based on the first sequence information on sodium channels need to be modified to account for a large amount of new data. Here, Robert Guy and Franco Conti present their current view of the activation mechanism and ion selectivity of the voltage-gated channels.

Evolutionary Relationship between K+ Channels and Symporters

The hypothesis is presented that at least four families of putative K(+) symporter proteins, Trk and KtrAB from prokaryotes, Trk1,2 from fungi, and HKT1 from wheat, evolved from bacterial K(+) channel proteins. Details of this hypothesis are organized around the recently determined crystal structure of a bacterial K(+) channel: i. e., KcsA from Streptomyces lividans. Each of the four identical subunits of this channel has two fully transmembrane helices (designated M1 and M2), plus an intervening hairpin segment that determines the ion selectivity (designated P). The symporter sequences appear to contain four sequential M1-P-M2 motifs (MPM), which are likely to have arisen from gene duplication and fusion of the single MPM motif of a bacterial K(+) channel subunit. The homology of MPM motifs is supported by a statistical comparison of the numerical profiles derived from multiple sequence alignments formed for each protein family. Furthermore, these quantitative results indicate that the KtrAB family of symporters has remained closest to the single-MPM ancestor protein. Strong sequence evidence is also found for homology between the cytoplasmic C-terminus of numerous bacterial K(+) channels and the cytoplasm-resident TrkA and KtrA subunits of the Trk and KtrAB symporters, which in turn are homologous to known dinucleotide-binding domains of other proteins. The case for homology between bacterial K(+) channels and the four families of K(+) symporters is further supported by the accompanying manuscript, in which the patterns of residue conservation are demonstrated to be similar to each other and consistent with the known 3D structure of the KcsA K(+) channel.

Magainin 2, a natural antibiotic from frog skin, forms ion channels in lipid bilayer membranes

We have examined the ion channel forming properties of magainin 2 by incorporating the peptide into artificial lipid bilayers held under voltage clamp. Magainin 2 increased lipid bilayer conductance in a concentration dependent manner with a Hill coefficient of 1.7. The magainin 2 conductance was selective for monovalent cations over anions with a ratio of 5:1 and had both voltage-sensitive and -insensitive components. Two structurally related but antibiotically less potent analogues, magainin 1 and Z-12, also increased lipid bilayer conductance with a similar ion selectivity but these peptides were less potent than magainin 2. We propose that the weak cation selectivity of the magainin channels can be accounted for by the inclusion of negatively charged lipids in the channel complex and suggest two possible structures for such a channel. The ionophoric properties of these peptides are likely to be proximal to their antibiotic activities.

A large iris-like expansion of a mechanosensitive channel protein induced by membrane tension

MscL, a bacterial mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, is the first structurally characterized mechanosensor protein. Molecular models of its gating mechanisms are tested here. Disulfide crosslinking shows that M1 transmembrane α-helices in MscL of resting Escherichia coli are arranged similarly to those in the crystal structure of MscL from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. An expanded conformation was trapped in osmotically shocked cells by the specific bridging between Cys 20 and Cys 36 of adjacent M1 helices. These bridges stabilized the open channel. Disulfide bonds engineered between the M1 and M2 helices of adjacent subunits (Cys 32–Cys 81) do not prevent channel gating. These findings support gating models in which interactions between M1 and M2 of adjacent subunits remain unaltered while their tilts simultaneously increase. The MscL barrel, therefore, undergoes a large concerted iris-like expansion and flattening when perturbed by membrane tension.

STRUCTURAL MODELS OF THE KTRB, TRKH, AND TRK1,2 SYMPORTERS BASED ON THE STRUCTURE OF THE KCSA K+ CHANNEL

Three-dimensional computer modeling is used to further investigate the hypothesis forwarded in the accompanying paper of an evolutionary relationship between four related families of K(+) sympoter proteins and the superfamily of K(+) channel proteins. Atomic-scale models are developed for the transmembrane regions of one member from each of the three more distinct symporter families, i.e., a TrkH protein from Escherichia coli, a KtrB protein from Aquifex aeolicus, and a Trk1,2 protein from Schizosaccharomyces pombe. The portions of the four consecutive M1-P-M2 motifs in the symporters that can be aligned with K(+) channel sequences are modeled directly from the recently determined crystal structure of the KcsA K(+) channel from Streptomyces lividans. The remaining portions are developed using our previously accumulated theoretical modeling criteria and principles. Concurrently, the use of these criteria and principles is further supported by the now verified predictions of our previous K(+) channel modeling efforts and the degree to which they are satisfied by the known structure of the KcsA protein. Thus the observed ability of the portions of the symporter models derived from the KcsA crystal structure to also satisfy the theoretical modeling criteria provides additional support for an evolutionary link with K(+) channel proteins. Efforts to further satisfy the criteria and principles suggest that the symporter proteins from fungi and plants (i.e., Trk1,2 and HKT1) form dimeric and/or tetrameric complexes in the membrane. Furthermore, analysis of the atomic-scale models in relation to the sequence conservation within and between the protein families suggests structural details for previously proposed mechanisms for the linked symport of K(+) with Na(+) and H(+). Suggestions are also given for experiments to test these structures and hypotheses.

Molecular genetics of the VDAC ion channel: Structural model and sequence analysis

The voltage-dependent anion-selective channel of the outer mitochondrial membrane provides a unique system in which to study the molecular basis of voltage gating of ion flow. We have cloned and sequenced acDNA coding for this protein in yeast. From the derived amino acid sequence, we have generated a preliminary model for the secondary structure of the protein which suggests that the protein forms a “β-barrel” type structure. Comparison of the VDAC amino acid sequence with that of the bacterial porins has indicated that the two classes of molecules appear to be unrelated.

A common architecture for K+ channels and ionotropic glutamate receptors?

Abstract K + channels and ionotropic glutamate receptors are thought to share a common architecture in their transmembrane pores. This oft-cited hypothesis has been derived from sequence comparisons, topology profiling and analogies to a bacterial glutamate receptor with a K + -channel pore. Although none of these arguments provides sufficient evidence for structural kinship, existing structural data and a new pedigree of bacterial glutamate receptors offer strong support. Comparisons of the patterns of pore-lining residues and mapping of functional determinants reveal extensive structural similarities, and new homologs of bacterial glutamate receptors strengthen the evolutionary link between glutamate receptors and K + channels.

The ion channel of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

A binding site for the channel-blocking noncompetitive antagonist [3H]triphenylmethylphosphonium ([3H]TPMP+) was localized in the alpha-, beta- and delta-chains of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) from Torpedo marmorata electric tissue. The photolabel was found in homologous positions of the highly conserved sequence helix II, alpha 248, beta 254, and delta 262. The site of the photoreaction appears to not be affected by the functional state of the receptor. [3H]TPMP+ was found in position delta 262 independent of whether photolabeling was performed with the receptor in its resting, desensitized or antagonist state. A model of the AChR ion channel is proposed, according to which the channel is formed by the five helices II contributed by the five receptor subunits.

On the Conformation of the COOH-terminal Domain of the Large Mechanosensitive Channel MscL

COOH-terminal (S3) domains are conserved within the MscL family of bacterial mechanosensitive channels, but their function remains unclear. The X-ray structure of MscL from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TbMscL) revealed cytoplasmic domains forming a pentameric bundle (Chang, G., R.H. Spencer, A.T. Lee, M.T. Barclay, and D.C. Rees. 1998. Science. 282:2220–2226). The helices, however, have an unusual orientation in which hydrophobic sidechains face outside while charged residues face inside, possibly due to specific crystallization conditions. Based on the structure of pentameric cartilage protein , we modeled the COOH-terminal region of E. coli MscL to better satisfy the hydrophobicity criteria, with sidechains of conserved aliphatic residues all inside the bundle. Molecular dynamic simulations predicted higher stability for this conformation compared with one modeled after the crystal structure of TbMscL, and suggested distances for disulfide trapping experiments. The single cysteine mutants L121C and I125C formed dimers under ambient conditions and more so in the presence of an oxidant. The double-cysteine mutants, L121C/L122C and L128C/L129C, often cross-link into tetrameric and pentameric structures, consistent with the new model. Patch-clamp examination of these double mutants under moderately oxidizing or reducing conditions indicated that the bundle cross-linking neither prevents the channel from opening nor changes thermodynamic parameters of gating. Destabilization of the bundle by replacing conservative leucines with small polar residues, or complete removal of COOH-terminal domain (Δ110–136 mutation), increased the occupancy of subconducting states but did not change gating parameters substantially. The Δ110–136 truncation mutant was functional in in vivo osmotic shock assays; however, the amount of ATP released into the shock medium was considerably larger than in controls. The data strongly suggest that in contrast to previous gating models (Sukharev, S., M. Betanzos, C.S. Chiang, and H.R. Guy. 2001a. Nature. 409:720–724.), S3 domains are stably associated in both closed and open conformations. The bundle-like assembly of cytoplasmic helices provides stability to the open conformation, and may function as a size-exclusion filter at the cytoplasmic entrance to the MscL pore, preventing loss of essential metabolites.