H. Thomas Karnes

Precision, Accuracy, and Data Acceptance Criteria in Biopharmaceutical Analysis

Accuracy and precision are the most important criteria in the assessment of an analytical method, and monitoring quality control during sample analysis is essential to ensure the validity of reported results. Various approaches to testing accuracy, precision, and quality control were applied to 10 analytes from seven chromatographic bioanalytical methods. These methods include fixed interval bias and significance testing for accuracy; fixed interval percentage relative standard deviation (%RSD) and analysis of variance (ANOVA) approaches for precision; ±20% fixed range, 99% confidence interval, multiple rules, and range chart for individuals approaches for quality control acceptance criteria. Quality control approaches were also applied to the entire run and to a bracketed approach whereby results are considered valid only if bracketed by acceptable quality control. Accuracy and precision were assessed for six runs of each analyte at three concentrations established to represent the calibration range of the analytical method. Quality control acceptance criteria were evaluated using all data sets from each of the analytical methods collected during the course of running various numbers of real samples. The data suggest that the fixed interval bias criteria for accuracy was a more liberal method of accuracy assessment because three of the seven methods would have been rejected according to the significance testing criteria whereas all were acceptable by the fixed internal bias criteria. Precision can be effectively assessed for between- and within-run data by criteria set on unconfounded %RSD values or by separation of the sources of variation using an ANOVA approach applied to confounded data. The percentage of samples rejected for the 99% confidence interval applied to brackets, the multiple rules approach applied to the entire run, and the individual range chart approach applied to brackets were comparable and were found to be 7.0, 6.2 and 8.3 percent respectively. The ±20% fixed range criteria applied to the two-thirds of the run resulted in just 2.9% sample rejection and was not considered comparable to the other methods.

Investigation of endogenous blood plasma phospholipids, cholesterol and glycerides that contribute to matrix effects in bioanalysis by liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry.

Matrix effects caused by compounds endogenous to the biological sample are a primary challenge in quantitative LC/MS/MS bioanalysis. Many approaches have been developed to minimize matrix effects such as optimization of sample extraction procedures and use of isotopically labeled internal standards. Unexpected matrix components may still remain undetected, however, because of the selective mass transitions monitored during MS/MS analysis. Glycerophosphocholines are the major phospholipids in plasma that have been widely shown to cause significant matrix effects on electrospray ionization efficiencies for target analytes. The purpose of this work was to investigate potential matrix effects resulting from different endogenous lipid classes, including phospholipids, acylglycerols and cholesterols, in order to establish a library for the relative presence of these components in biological sample extracts obtained by commonly used sample preparation techniques. Thirteen compounds were selected which were representatives of eight phospholipids classes, mono, di, triacylglycerols, cholesterol and cholesterol esters. Post-column infusion experiments were carried out to compare relative ion suppression effects of these compounds. Chlorpheniramine and loratadine were selected as model test analytes. A Concentration Normalized Suppression Factor (%CNSF) was defined to allow comparison of ion suppression effects resulting from different endogenous lipids according to their typical concentrations in human plasma and erythrocytes. A simple LC/MS/MS method was developed to monitor these endogenous components in sample extracts and their extraction recoveries from a plasma pool were compared using protein precipitation, liquid-liquid extraction, supported-liquid extraction, solid phase extraction and Hybrid SPE-precipitation methods. Endogenous lipid components other than GPChos, such as cholesterols and triacylglycerols, may result in significant matrix effects and should be monitored during method development. No single extraction procedure was efficient in removing all of the various lipid components. Use of the results presented here, along with a consideration of analyte chemical structure, the type of matrix and the type of sample preparation procedure, may help a bioanalytical scientist to better anticipate and minimize matrix effects in developing LC/MS/MS-based methods.

Monitoring phospholipids for assessment of ion enhancement and ion suppression in ESI and APCI LC/MS/MS for chlorpheniramine in human plasma and the importance of multiple source matrix effect evaluations.

Biological matrix effects are a source of significant errors in both electrospray (ESI) and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI) LC/MS. Glycerophosphocholines (GPChos) and 2-lyso-glycerophosphocholines (2-lyso GPChos) are known to fragment to form ions at m/z 184 and m/z 104, respectively. Phospholipids were used as markers to evaluate matrix effects resulting in both ion suppression and enhancement using ESI and APCI modes in the determination of chlorpheniramine in human plasma. Results revealed that GPChos and 2-lyso GPChos demonstrated very low ionization efficiency in the APCI mode, post-column infusion experiments were performed to confirm that suppression and enhancement matrix ionization effects coincided with the elution profiles of the phospholipids. The mean matrix effect for chlorpheniramine using APCI was 75% less than the mean matrix effect in ESI, making APCI the ionization method of choice initially even though the absolute response was lower than in the ESI mode. The resulting APCI method showed acceptable results according to the FDA guidelines; however, a multiple source relative matrix effects study demonstrated variability. It was concluded that an absolute matrix effects study in one source of biological fluid may be not sufficient to ensure the validity of the method in various sources of matrix. In order to obviate the multiple matrix source variability, we employed an isotopically labeled internal standard for quantification of chlorpheniramine in the ESI mode. An additional validation was completed with the use of chlorpheniramine-d(6) as the internal standard. This method met all acceptance criteria according to the FDA guidelines, and the relative matrix affects study was successful.

Bioanalytical method validation for macromolecules in support of pharmacokinetic studies.

The development and validation of ligand binding assays used in the support of pharmacokinetic studies has been the focus of various workshops and publications in recent years, all in an effort to establish a guidance document for standardization of these bioanalytical methods. This summary report of the workshop from 2003 focuses on the issues discussed in presentations and notes points of discussion and areas of consensus among the participants.

Calibration and validation of linearity in chromatographic biopharmaceutical analysis

Calibration in chromatographic biopharmaceutical analysis is a major determinate of method performance and many methods have been proposed to evaluate an appropriate calibration model, to determine the linear range and to evaluate the goodness of fit. Ten chromatographic bioanalytical methods have been evaluated in this work by observation of concentration-response curves, linearity plots, calculation of concentration residuals, correlation coefficients and lack of fit analysis. These methods were applied to univariant linear regression, weighted regression, polynomial regression and power fit models in order to determine the most appropriate way to establish and evaluate calibration functions. It was found that weighted linear regression provided the most appropriate calibration function for eight of the 10 methods studied, whereas unweighted regression and the power fit model proved appropriate for one each of the other two methods. The choice of calibration function was best accomplished through observation of calculated concentration residuals. Linearity and sensitivity plots were of little value for assessment of linearity through the selected calibration range if conventional (+/- 5%) tolerance limits are employed. Validation of the calibration model can be accomplished by demonstrating the concentration residuals and the slope of the log concentration-log response plots are within reasonable tolerance limits or by lack of fit analysis. Correlation coefficients were demonstrated to be of little value for this purpose and the quadratic approach to linearity validation was in disagreement with other methods in four of the 10 methods evaluated.

Analytical methods validation: Bioavailability, bioequivalence and pharmacokinetic studies: Sponsored by the American Association of Pharmaceutical Chemists, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Fédération Internationale Pharmaceutique, Health Protection Branch (Canada) and Association of Official Analytical Chemists

Abstract This is a summary report of the conference on ‘Analytical Methods Validation: Bioavailability, Bioequivalence and Pharmacokinetic Studies.’ The conference was held from December 3 to 5, 1990, in the Washington, DC area and was sponsored by the American Association of Pharmaceutical Scientists, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Federation Internationale Pharmaceutique, Health Protection Branch (Canada) and Association of Official Analytical Chemists. The purpose of the report is to represent our assessment of the major agreements and issues discussed at the conference. This report is also intended to provide guiding principles for validation of analytical methods employed in bioavailability, bioequivalence and pharmacokinetic studies in man and animals. The objectives of the conference were: (1) to reach a consensus on what should be required in analytical methods validation and the procedures to establish validation; (2) to determine processes of application of the validation procedures in the bioavailability, bioequivalence and pharmacokinetic studies; and (3) to develop a report on analytical methods validation (which may be referred to in developing future formal guidelines). Acceptable standards for documenting and validating analytical methods with regard to processes, parameters or data treatments were discussed because of their importance in assessment of pharmacokinetic. bioavailability, and bioequivalence studies. Other topics which were considered essential in the conduct of pharmacokinetic studies or in establishing bioequivalency criteria, including measurement of drug metabolites and stereoselectivc determinations, were also deliberated.

Ultraviolet and Fluorescence Derivatization Reagents for Carboxylic Acids Suitable for High Performance Liquid Chromatography: A Review

Pre- and postcolumn derivatization with a suitable chromophore or fluorophore have often been utilized to enhance the sensitivity and selectivity of detection for analytes possessing a carboxyl group. The major classes of UV and fluorescent derivatization reagents include the coumarin analogues, alkyl halides, diazoalkanes, and amines. The derivatization reaction conditions, HPLC systems for separation of the conjugates and detection limits of various analytes are presented in this review. High mass sensitivity for various carboxylic acids have been achieved with the hydrazides, anthracenes, and diazoalkanes.

Effect of two administration schedules of an enteral nutrient formula on phenytoin bioavailability.

Summary: Continuous nasogastric (NG) administration of enteral nutrient formulas (ENFs) reportedly lowers phenytoin (PHT) concentrations. We studied the effects of two administration schedules of an ENF on the bioavailability of PHT. Eight healthy volunteers received 400 mg PHT suspension after fasting (A), with hourly Ensure (B), and with 4‐hourly Ensure (C) in a randomized, crossover design. Data obtained from 13 serum samples collected over 80 h were analyzed using ESTRIP. Area under the serum concentration‐time curve (AUC), time to maximum serum concentration (Tmax), and urinary excretion of 5‐(p‐hydroxyphenyl) 5‐phenylhydantoin (HPPH) were compared by analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Bonferroni t tests of differences between means. AUCs (mg x h/L) were not different (p > 0.05) for A (222.1 ± 86.9), B (233.9 ± 92.9), and C (226.0 ± 95.7). Tmax (h) was significantly shorter (p < 0.05) when PHT was administered with Ensure (B = 8.5 ± 3.0, C = 5.3 ± 2.0) than without Ensure (A = 18.5 ± 10.5). The HPPH excretion (mg/80 h) was not different (p > 0.05) for A (225.6 ± 48.5), B (238.6 ± 26.6), and C (229.9 ± 45.6). Clearance and maximum concentration correlated with AUC, obviating the need for analysis. Relative bioavailability was B/A = 1.07 ± 0.21, C/A = 1.01 ± 0.14. The bioavailability of PHT was not decreased by either ENF administration schedule. Factors other than direct contact may be responsible for the observed decreases in PHT concentrations by coadministered ENFs.

Determination of octreotide and assessment of matrix effects in human plasma using ultra high performance liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry

A selective UHPLC-MS/MS method for determination of the therapeutic peptide octreotide in human plasma was developed and validated. This assay used a UHPLC C(18) column with 1.7 μm particle size for efficient separation and an ion-exchange SPE for selective extraction. Octreotide and its labeled internal standard, [(13)C(6)Phe(3)] octreotide, were extracted from human plasma using a simple Oasis® WCX μElution SPE method and analyzed with a total chromatographic run time of 7.5 min. Matrix effects were studied during method development by direct monitoring of representative phospholipids. On-line removal of phospholipids using column switching and pre-column back-flushing was carried out to trap and remove any residual phospholipid matrix interferences. The UHPLC column provided baseline separation between the analyte and matrix peaks. The chromatographic conditions yielded optimal retention and excellent peak shape for both the analyte and internal standard. The assay was linear in the concentration range of 0.025-25.0 ng/ml, inter- and intra-assay precision and accuracy were within 6.1% and ±1.93%, respectively. Recovery was ∼73%. Post-extraction addition experiments showed that matrix effects were less than 4%. This method for octreotide in human plasma has been validated and utilized to support of clinical pharmacokinetic studies.

Microfluidic capillary system for immunoaffinity separations of C-reactive protein in human serum and cerebrospinal fluid.

A miniaturized system based on microfluidic capillaries is presented for point-of-care testing and clinical assessment. The approach relies on microsyringe pump-generated flow to deliver reagents and immunoaffinity chromatography to isolate the antigen from biological matrixes. Capillary sandwich immunoassays for C-reactive protein (CRP) were demonstrated in human serum and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), which are relevant matrixes for cardiovascular disease risk and meningitis research, respectively. Capillaries packed with antibody-coated silica beads were used to capture CRP from the matrix and a second, dye-labeled antibody was introduced to form a sandwich complex. An acidic elution buffer dissociated the antibody-antigen complexes, and the labeled antibody was detected with diode laser-induced fluorescence. Four parameter logistic functions and % relative error plots were used to model and assess the data. The calibration ranges for CRP were 0.05-3.0 microg/mL in 1:10 diluted serum and 0.01-30 microg/mL in undiluted CSF. The microfluidic apparatus employed a flow rate of 2 microL/min and a sample injection volume of 250 nL. Since it was not necessary to reach antibody-antigen reaction equilibrium and the assay platform dimensions were minimal, run times were as short as 10 min.