Hannes Konrad Buchholz

An Examination of the Phase Transition Thermodynamics of (S)- and (RS)-Naproxen as a Basis for the Design of Enantioselective Crystallization Processes

A detailed experimental analysis of the phase transition thermodynamics of (S)-naproxen and (RS)-naproxen is reported. Vapor pressures were determined experimentally via the transpiration method. Sublimation enthalpies were obtained from the vapor pressures and from independent TGA measurements. Thermodynamics of fusion which have been well-studied in the literature were systematically remeasured by DSC. Both sublimation and fusion enthalpies were adjusted to one reference temperature, T = 298 K, using measured heat capacities of the solid and the melt phase by DSC. Average values from the measurements and from literature data were suggested for the sublimation and fusion enthalpies. In order to prove consistency of the proposed values the vaporization enthalpies obtained by combination of both were compared to vaporization enthalpies obtained by the group-additivity method and the correlation-gas chromatography method. The importance of reliable and precise phase transition data for thermochemical calculations such as the prediction of solid/liquid phase behaviour of chiral compounds is highlighted.

Accurate lattice energies of organic molecular crystals from periodic turbomole calculations

Accurate lattice energies of organic crystals are important i.e. for the pharmaceutical industry. Periodic DFT calculations with atom‐centered Gaussian basis functions with the Turbomole program are used to calculate lattice energies for several non‐covalently bound organic molecular crystals. The accuracy and convergence of results with basis set size and k‐space sampling from periodic calculations is evaluated for the two reference molecules benzoic acid and naphthalene. For the X23 benchmark set of small molecular crystals accurate lattice energies are obtained using the PBE‐D3 functional. In particular for hydrogen‐bonded systems, a sufficiently large basis set is required. The calculated lattice energy differences between enantiopure and racemic crystal forms for a prototype set of chiral molecules are in good agreement with experimental results and allow the rationalization and computer‐aided design of chiral separation processes.

Correction to Thermochemistry of Racemic and Enantiopure Organic Crystals for Predicting Enantiomer Separation

The separation of an enantiomer from a racemic mixture is of primary relevance to the pharmaceutical industry. The thermochemical properties of organic enantiopure and racemate crystals can be exploited to design an enantioselective crystallization process. The thermodynamic difference between the two crystal forms is accessible by two cycles which give the eutectic composition in solution. The “sublimation cycle” requires calculating the lattice energy and phonon frequencies of the crystal structures. Experimental results from heat capacity and other thermodynamic measurements of enantiopure and racemic crystals are compared with a variety of molecular and crystal structure-based calculations. This is done for three prototypes of pharmaceutical-like molecules with different degrees of molecular flexibility. Differences in crystal packing result in varying temperature-dependent heat capacities and affect the sublimation thermodynamics, relative solubility, and eutectic composition. Many simplifying assumptions about the thermodynamics and solubilities of the racemic and enantiopure crystals are critically evaluated. We show that calculations and experimental information using the sublimation cycle can guide the design of processes to resolve enantiomers by crystallization.

Research ArticlePharmaceutics, Drug Delivery and Pharmaceutical TechnologyAn Examination of the Phase Transition Thermodynamics of (S)- and (RS)-Naproxen as a Basis for the Design of Enantioselective Crystallization Processes

A detailed experimental analysis of the phase transition thermodynamics of (S)-naproxen and (RS)-naproxen is reported. Vapor pressures were determined experimentally via the transpiration method. Sublimation enthalpies were obtained from the vapor pressures and from independent TGA measurements. Thermodynamics of fusion which have been well-studied in the literature were systematically remeasured by DSC. Both sublimation and fusion enthalpies were adjusted to one reference temperature, T = 298 K, using measured heat capacities of the solid and the melt phase by DSC. Average values from the measurements and from literature data were suggested for the sublimation and fusion enthalpies. In order to prove consistency of the proposed values the vaporization enthalpies obtained by combination of both were compared to vaporization enthalpies obtained by the group-additivity method and the correlation-gas chromatography method. The importance of reliable and precise phase transition data for thermochemical calculations such as the prediction of solid/liquid phase behaviour of chiral compounds is highlighted.