Harry W. Duckworth

Quantitative evaluation of protein-protein and ligand-protein equilibria of a large allosteric enzyme by electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry.

A mass spectrometer coupling electrospray ionization with time-of-flight mass spectrometry (ESI-TOFMS) has been used to investigate the oligomeric species of Escherichia coli citrate synthase, and to determine the effect of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH), an allosteric inhibitor of this enzyme, on the equilibrium between the oligomeric forms. An equilibrium mixture of dimers (M = 95,770 Da) and hexamers (M = 287,310 Da) was found under the conditions used (KA = 6.9 x 10(10) M-2), and NADH was observed to bind selectively to the hexamer (KD = 1.1 microM), shifting the equilibrium to the latter form. The power of ESI-TOFMS to measure ions of very large mass-to-charge ratio (up to m/z approximately 10,000 in this case) is shown to be a valuable tool for obtaining accurate information about compositions of noncovalent complexes and equilibrium constants. The measured constants agree with those determined by conventional means.

Catalase-peroxidases (KatG) Exhibit NADH Oxidase Activity

Catalase-peroxidases (KatG) produced by Burkholderia pseudomallei, Escherichia coli, and Mycobacterium tuberculosis catalyze the oxidation of NADH to form NAD+ and either H2O2 or superoxide radical depending on pH. The NADH oxidase reaction requires molecular oxygen, does not require hydrogen peroxide, is not inhibited by superoxide dismutase or catalase, and has a pH optimum of 8.75, clearly differentiating it from the peroxidase and catalase reactions with pH optima of 5.5 and 6.5, respectively, and from the NADH peroxidase-oxidase reaction of horseradish peroxidase. B. pseudomallei KatG has a relatively high affinity for NADH (Km = 12 μm), but the oxidase reaction is slow (kcat = 0.54 min-1) compared with the peroxidase and catalase reactions. The catalase-peroxidases also catalyze the hydrazinolysis of isonicotinic acid hydrazide (INH) in an oxygen- and H2O2-independent reaction, and KatG-dependent radical generation from a mixture of NADH and INH is two to three times faster than the combined rates of separate reactions with NADH and INH alone. The major products from the coupled reaction, identified by high pressure liquid chromatography fractionation and mass spectrometry, are NAD+ and isonicotinoyl-NAD, the activated form of isoniazid that inhibits mycolic acid synthesis in M. tuberculosis. Isonicotinoyl-NAD synthesis from a mixture of NAD+ and INH is KatG-dependent and is activated by manganese ion. M. tuberculosis KatG catalyzes isonicotinoyl-NAD formation from NAD+ and INH more efficiently than B. pseudomallei KatG.

Mass spectrometric study of the Escherichia coli repressor proteins, IcIR and GcIR, and their complexes with DNA

In Escherichia coli, the IclR protein regulates both the aceBAK operon and its own synthesis. Database homology searches have identified many IclR‐like proteins, now known as the IclR family, which can be identified by a conserved C‐terminal region. We have cloned and purified one of these proteins, which we have named GclR (glyoxylate carboligase repressor). Although purification is straightforward, both the IclR and GclR proteins are difficult to manipulate, requiring high salt (up to 0.6 M KCl) for solubility. With the advent of nanospray ionization, we could transfer the proteins into much higher concentrations of volatile buffer than had been practical with ordinary electrospray. In 0.5 M ammonium bicarbonate buffer, both proteins were stable as tetramers, with a small amount of dimer. In a separate experiment, we found that IclR protein selected from a random pool a sequence which matched exactly that of the presumed binding region of the GclR protein, although IclR does not regulate the gcl gene. We designed a 29 bp synthetic DNA to which IclR and GclR bind, and with which we were able to form noncovalent DNA‐protein complexes for further mass spectrometry analysis. These complexes were far more stable than the proteins alone, and we have evidence of a stoichiometry which has not been described previously with (protein monomer : dsDNA) = (4 : 1).

Structure of the Clade 1 catalase, CatF of Pseudomonas syringae, at 1.8 Å resolution

Catalase CatF of Pseudomonas syringae has been identified phylogenetically as a clade 1 catalase, closely related to plant catalases, a group from which no structure has been determined. The structure of CatF has been refined at 1.8 Å resolution by using X‐ray synchrotron data collected from a crystal flash‐cooled with liquid nitrogen. The crystallographic agreement factors R and Rfree are, respectively, 18.3% and 24.0%. The asymmetric unit of the crystal contains a whole molecule that shows accurate 222‐point group symmetry. The crystallized enzyme is a homotetramer of subunits with 484 residues, some 26 residues shorter than predicted from the DNA sequence. Mass spectrometry analysis confirmed the absence of 26 N‐terminal residues, possibly removed by a periplasmic transport system. The core structure of the CatF subunit was closely related to seven other catalases with root‐mean‐square deviations (RMSDs) of 368 core Cα atoms of 0.99–1.30 Å. The heme component of CatF is heme b in the same orientation that is found in Escherichia coli hydroperoxidase II, an orientation that is flipped 180° with respect the orientation of the heme in bovine liver catalase. NADPH is not found in the structure of CatF because key residues required for nucleotide binding are missing; 2129 water molecules were refined into the model. Water occupancy in the main or perpendicular channel of CatF varied among the four subunits from two to five in the region between the heme and the conserved Asp150. A comparison of the water occupancy in this region with the same region in other catalases reveals significant differences among the catalases. Proteins 2003;50:423–436.

Chimeric allosteric citrate synthases: construction and properties of citrate synthases containing domains from two different enzymes.

The citrate synthases of the gram-negative bacteria, Escherichia coli and Acinetobacter anitratum, are allosterically inhibited by NADH. The kinetic properties, however, suggest that the equilibrium between active (R) and inactive (T) conformational states is shifted toward the T state in the E. coli enzyme. We have now manipulated the cloned genes for the two bacterial enzymes to produce two chimeric proteins, in which one folding domain of each subunit is derived from each enzyme. One chimera (the large domain from A. anitratum and the small domain from the E. coli enzyme) is designated CS ACI::eco; the other is called CS ECO::aci. Both chimeras are roughly as active as the wild type parents, but their Km values for both substrates are lower than those for the E. coli enzyme, and NADH inhibition is markedly sigmoid, while that for E. coli citrate synthases is hyperbolic. Curve-fitting to the allosteric equation suggests that these differences are the result of the destabilization of the T state in the chimeras. The ACI::eco chimera exists almost entirely as a hexamer, like the A. anitratum enzyme, while the ECO::aci chimera, like the E. coli synthase, forms three major bands on nondenaturing polyacrylamide gels, two of them hexamers of different net charge, and one a dimer. These findings indicate that subunit interactions leading to hexamer formation in allosteric citrate synthases of gram-negative bacteria involve mainly the large domains. The chimeras are also used to show that the NADH binding site of E. coli citrate synthase is located entirely in the large domain. Sensitivity of the chimeras to denaturation by urea, to which the A. anitratum enzyme is much more resistant than the E. coli enzyme, is determined by the large domains. Sensitivity to inactivation by subtilisin is intermediate between those shown by the E. coli (very sensitive) and A. anitratum (quite resistant) synthases. This result suggests that digestibility by subtilisin is determined by conformational factors as well as the amino acid sequences of the target regions.

Isolation and properties of cytochrome c-553, cytochrome c-550, and cytochrome c-549, 554 from Nitrobacter agilis

Abstract Three c -type cytochromes isolated from Nitrobacter agilis were purified to apparent homogeneity: cytochrome c -553, cytochrome c -550 and cytochrome c -549, 554. Their amino acid composition and other properties were studied. Cytochrome c -553 was isolated as a partially reduced form and could not be oxidized by ferricyanide. The completely reduced form of the cytochrome had absorption maxima at 419, 524 and 553 nm. It had a molecular weight of 25 000 and dissociated into two polypeptides of equal size of 11 500 during SDS gel electrophoresis. The isoelectric point of cytochrome c -553 was pH 6.8. The ferricytochrome c -550 exhibited an absorption peak at 410 nm and the ferrocytochrome c showed peaks at 416, 521 and 550 nm. The molecular weight of the cytochrome estimated by gel filtration and by SDS gel electrophoresis was 12 500. It had an E m(7) value of 0.27 V and isoelectric point pH 8.51. The N-terminal sequence of cytochrome c -550 showed a clear homology with the corresponding portions of the sequences of other c -type cytochromes. Cytochrome c -549, 554 possessed atypical absorption spectra with absorption peaks at 402 nm as oxidized form and at 419, 523, 549 and 554 nm when reduced with Na 2 S 2 O 4 . Its molecular weight estimated by gel filtration and SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis was 90 000 and 46 000, respectively. The cytochrome had an isoelectric point of pH 5.6. Cytochrome c -549, 554 was highly autoxidizable.

Multiple equilibria of the Escherichia coli chaperonin GroES revealed by mass spectrometry

Nanospray time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry has been used to study the assembly of the heptamer of the Escherichia coli cochaperonin protein GroES, a system previously described as a monomer–heptamer equilibrium. In addition to the monomers and heptamers, we have found measurable amounts of dimers and hexamers, the presence of which suggests the following mechanism for heptamer assembly: 2 Monomers ↔ Dimer; 3 Dimers ↔ Hexamer; Hexamer + Monomer ↔ Heptamer. Equilibrium constants for each of these steps, and an overall constant for the Monomer ↔ Heptamer equilibrium, have been estimated from the data. These constants imply a standard free‐energy change, ΔG0, of about 9 kcal/mol for each contact surface formed between GroES subunits, except for the addition of the last subunit, where ΔG0 = 6 kcal/mol. This lower value probably reflects the loss of entropy when the heptamer ring is formed. These experiments illustrate the advantages of electrospray mass spectrometry as a method of measuring all components of a multiple equilibrium system.

Mass Spectrometry in Noncovalent Protein Interactions and Protein Assemblies

Publisher Summary Mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as an important tool in the research of proteins and their interactions over the past several years. Electrospray (ESI) provides a gentle ionization method that does not disrupt the weak bonds found in noncovalent complexes, and the adoption of nanospray technology. Mass spectrometry measures the ratio of the mass (m) to the charge (z) of an ion. A small opening in the plate connects this region to the second pumping stage where the ions oscillate in the two-dimensional potential well produced by the RF quadrupole and are cooled to near-thermal energies by collisions with the ambient gas. Choose a concentration that is close to the ionic strength of the preparative buffer and prepare the protein at a high concentration so that both it and the buffer can be diluted during the experiment. Dithiothreitol can be added to limit oxidation. If possible, the exact protein concentration should be determined from the known molar extinction coefficient and measurement of UV absorbance of an aliquot.

Molecular cloning of the structural gene for Acinetobacter citrate synthase

The structural gene for citrate synthase of Acinetobacter anitratum has been cloned in Escherichia coli in a form which expresses the enzyme. A library of EcoRI fragments of Acinetobacter genomic DNA was prepared in the vector lambda gt10, and clones were screened by hybridization with an E. coli citrate synthase clone under conditions of reduced stringency. A 6.5 kbp clone was obtained which was subcloned into pBR322, and shown to direct the formation of Acinetobacter citrate synthase in E. coli hosts. The promoter was located within a BglII fragment, and from this information the orientation of the gene was deduced.

Enzyme-substrate complexes of allosteric citrate synthase: Evidence for a novel intermediate in substrate binding.

The citrate synthase (CS) of Escherichia coli is an allosteric hexameric enzyme specifically inhibited by NADH. The crystal structure of wild type (WT) E. coli CS, determined by us previously, has no substrates bound, and part of the active site is in a highly mobile region that is shifted from the position needed for catalysis. The CS of Acetobacter aceti has a similar structure, but has been successfully crystallized with bound substrates: both oxaloacetic acid (OAA) and an analog of acetyl coenzyme A (AcCoA). We engineered a variant of E. coli CS wherein five amino acids in the mobile region have been replaced by those in the A. aceti sequence. The purified enzyme shows unusual kinetics with a low affinity for both substrates. Although the crystal structure without ligands is very similar to that of the WT enzyme (except in the mutated region), complexes are formed with both substrates and the allosteric inhibitor NADH. The complex with OAA in the active site identifies a novel OAA-binding residue, Arg306, which has no functional counterpart in other known CS-OAA complexes. This structure may represent an intermediate in a multi-step substrate binding process where Arg306 changes roles from OAA binding to AcCoA binding. The second complex has the substrate analog, S-carboxymethyl-coenzyme A, in the allosteric NADH-binding site and the AcCoA site is not formed. Additional CS variants unable to bind adenylates at the allosteric site show that this second complex is not a factor in positive allosteric activation of AcCoA binding.