Hartley Stern

Regional collaborations as a tool for quality improvements in surgery: a systematic review of the literature

Background:A systematic review of the literature identifying regional collaborations in surgical practice examining practices related to quality improvement. Methods:The MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library databases, were searched for published reports of regional collaborations in the surgical community relating to initiatives to enhance quality improvement, quality of care, patient safety, knowledge transfer, or communities of practice. Results:Seven collaborative initiatives met the inclusion criteria and were included in the systematic review of the evidence. Motivations for initiating collaborations were often in response to external demands for performance data. Changes in the processes of clinical care and improvements in clinical outcomes were reported on the basis of the collaborative efforts. Significant improvements in clinical outcomes such as decreases in mortality rates, lower duration of postoperative intubations, and fewer surgical-site infections were reported. Quality improvement process measures were also reported to be improved across all of the collaborative initiatives. Success factors included (a) the establishment of trust among health professionals and health institutions; (b) the availability of accurate, complete, relevant data; (c) clinical leadership; (d) institutional commitment; and (e) the infrastructure and methodological support for quality management. Conclusions:A community of practice framework incorporating the success elements described in the systematic review of the literature can be used as a valuable model for collaboration amongst surgeons and healthcare organizations to improve quality of care and foster continuing professional development.

The apolipoprotein E gene and the serum low-density lipoprotein cholesterol response to dietary fiber☆

Our goal was to determine whether differences in apolipoprotein E (apo E) influenced the response to dietary changes aimed at reducing serum cholesterol levels, especially increases in fiber. Apo E phenotype and genotype were determined in 43 men and 24 women who had previously taken part in parallel 2-week metabolic dietary studies involving either wheat bran or oat bran supplementation at a level of 6.8 g fiber/1,000 kcal. Fasting blood lipid measurements had been made at the beginning and end of the 2-week metabolic period. Reductions in low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol levels across both oat and wheat bran diets were significantly different depending on the E allele (P = .048). The LDL cholesterol level reduction for E2 carriers (0.60 +/- 0.14 mmol/L, n = 13) was greater than that for E3 homozygotes (0.21 +/- 0.07 mmol/L, n = 38; P = .014) and E4 carriers (0.28 +/- 0.12 mmol/L, n = 16; P = .09). Only the change in dietary fiber on the oat bran diet was related significantly to the decrease in LDL cholesterol levels (r = -.47, P = .007; n = 32). No such relationship was seen on the wheat bran diet (r = -.010, P = .59; n = 33). Carriers of the E2 allele appear to be more responsive than noncarriers to a dietary change involving increased fiber intake. The data also support a lipid-lowering advantage of oat bran over wheat bran. Current dietary recommendations to reduce serum lipid levels may vary in effectiveness depending on distribution of apo E alleles in the different populations studied.

Development of communities of practice to facilitate quality improvement initiatives in surgical oncology.

Background The process of developing clinical guidelines and standards for cancer treatment and screening is well established in the Ontario health care system; however, the dissemination and implementation of such guidelines and standards are more recent undertakings. Traditional implementation strategies to improve surgical practice and the delivery of cancer care have not been consistently effective. There is a recognized need to develop integrated models that offer direct support for implementation strategies. Such a model should be feasible, adaptable, and open to evaluation across diverse surgical settings. Discussion Research suggests that successful implementation should consider tools and expertise from other disciplines. This article considers a community of practice (COP) model to provide a supportive infrastructure for quality improvements in cancer surgery. The COP model was adapted for cancer surgeons. It is supported by 5 enablers referred to as tools: communication system, project development support, access to data, access to evidence review, and accreditation with continued medical education and continued professional development. These tools need to be part of an infrastructure that is both provided and supported by a team of administrators and health care professionals, who have active roles and responsibilities. Therefore, the primary objective of this article is to describe our COP model in cancer surgery including the key success factors necessary for providing the infrastructure and tools. The secondary objective is to offer the integrated COP model as a basis for future research and the evaluation of various collaborative improvement projects. Summary Building on knowledge management concepts, we identified the 4 essential processes that should be targeted by implementation strategies. A common COP evaluation framework uses the outcomes of 4 knowledge conversion modes—organizational memory, social capital, innovation, and knowledge transfer—as proxies for actual provider and organizational behavior. Insights from different collaborative improvement projects described in a consistent way could inform future research and assist in the collation of systematic reviews on this topic.

Management of Persistent or Locally Recurrent Epidermoid Cancer of the Anal Canal with Abdominoperineal Resection

We retrospectively evaluated the outcome of 22 patients with epidermoid cancer of the anal canal who underwent surgical salvage after failure of primary chemoradiotherapy. Patients who required surgery had significantly more advanced T-stage than those who did not fail chemoradiotherapy. Eighteen patients failed surgical salvage. Invasion through the muscle wall of the bowel was present in 16 of 18 patients compared with two of four patients who have no evidence of disease (follow-up 5-10 years). Failure occurred only in the pelvis in 13 of the patients who died of disease. The mean time to death after surgery was 19 months. We confirm the overall poor results of conventional abdominoperineal resection in those patients who have failed previous therapy. Most failures occur in the pelvis. Transanorectal ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may allow better selection of patients for exenterative procedures and identify those not amenable to successful salvage.We retrospectively evaluated the outcome of 22 patients with epidermoid cancer of the anal canal who underwent surgical salvage after failure of primary chemoradiotherapy. Patients who required surgery had significantly more advanced T-stage than those who did not fail chemoradiotherapy. Eighteen patients failed surgical salvage. Invasion through the muscle wall of the bowel was present in 16 of 18 patients compared with two of four patients who have no evidence of disease (follow-up 5-10 years). Failure occurred only in the pelvis in 13 of the patients who died of disease. The mean time to death after surgery was 19 months. We confirm the overall poor results of conventional abdominoperineal resection in those patients who have failed previous therapy. Most failures occur in the pelvis. Transanorectal ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may allow better selection of patients for exenterative procedures and identify those not amenable to successful salvage.

Manipulation of fecal pH by dietary means

Epidemiological and animal studies suggest that colonic fermentation and fecal pH may be risk factors for colorectal cancer. To modify these factors, we sought to develop a simple instrument for use in intervention studies. Three 14-day studies with 32, 40, and 30 healthy volunteers maintained on their regular diet were carried out to evaluate the effect of various food supplements on fecal pH. The interventions tested included supplementary lactulose, Metamucil, oat bran, wheat bran, or no supplement. The results showed that it is possible to provide a simple intervention to reduce fecal pH by 0.4 unit with oat bran administered at 75-100 g/day over a 14-day period, using a wheat combination, equivalent in macronutrients and fiber, as a control.

Compartmental analysis of the pharmacokinetics of radioiodinated monoclonal antibody B72.3 in colon cancer patients

Sixteen patients with colorectal cancer were administered 37-74 MBq (1 mg) of radioiodinated B72.3 monoclonal antibody. Pharmacokinetic analysis was carried out on plasma and urine samples. Elimination from the plasma was biexponential with a mean T1/2 alpha of 3.7 h and T1/2 beta of 62.4 h. The plasma clearance was fit to a two-compartmental model. This was combined with a previously reported model for radioiodine to construct a composite model. There was a good correlation (r = 0.952) between the model-predicted and observed excretion of radioiodine suggesting that the composite model is compatible with the pharmacokinetics of the radiolabelled antibody.

Radioimmunodetection of Colorectal Cancer Metastases with 131I-Labeled Monoclonal Antibody B72.3: A Pilot Study to Determine Efficacy of Detection and Pharmacokinetics

We performed radioimmunoscintigraphy (RIS) and/or pharmacokinetic (PCK) studies in 12 patients with primary or metastatic colorectal carcinoma, utilizing an intravenous administration of 1-4 mCi (1 mg) of 131I-B72.3 monoclonal antibody. Metastatic lesions were correctly identified in 4/8 patients by RIS. Two patients with small lesions (> 2 cm diameter) had a false-negative RIS scan. Two patients had a true-negative RIS scan. Optimal images were obtained at 1 week postinjection. PCK studies showed that the plasma clearance of 131I-B72.3 was biexponential with an alpha-phase half-life ranging from 0.5 to 7.1 hr and a beta-phase half-life ranging from 47.5 to 85.3 hr. Systemic and renal clearance data indicated that 131I-B72.3 was cleared very slowly and almost entirely by deiodination. This pilot study was conducted to gain an understanding of the pharmacokinetics of this radiolabeled antibody. On the basis of these data, we are now studying second-generation antibodies as part of our long-range objectives to incorporate them in early detection and treatment protocols.

Long-Term Effects of Dietary Calcium on Risk Markers for Colon Cancer in Familial Polyposis Patients

There is a conflicting evidence regarding the benefit of calcium in colon cancer prevention. In this study we evaluated the effect of long term calcium supplementation on colon cancer risk markers in homogeneous group of familial polyposis patients. Thirty-one patients, post subtotal colectomy, were randomized to two groups and received placebo or calcium 1200g daily. Intervention lasted 9 months, in which they underwent four 3 monthly evaluations that included food records, fecal pH, calcium and bile acids and rectal biopsy for thymidine labelling. Labelling index of placebo and calcium groups was similar before intervention and was significantly reduced after 3 months in the two groups. After 9 months it did not differ from the starting point in either group. In a long term intervention study with homogeneous group of familial polyposis patients, supplemental dietary calcium did not affect mucosal risk factors for colon cancer.