Harvey J. Sagar

Hallucinosis in idiopathic Parkinson’s disease

BACKGROUND Hallucinosis is a complication of the treatment of idiopathic Parkinson’s disease commonly thought to afflict older, chronically medicated, cognitively impaired patients. However, patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease of short duration experiencing hallucinosis on relatively low doses of dopaminergic medication have been found. The aim, therefore, was to investigate the homogeneity of a population of patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease and hallucinosis. METHODS The clinical, demographic, and cognitive correlates of hallucinosis were investigated in a sample of 129 patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease. RESULTS There were two subgroups of patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease experiencing hallucinosis. In patients with a disease duration of five years or less, hallucinosis was associated with rapid progression of the motor component of the disease but not cognitive impairment. In patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease of longer than five years duration, hallucinosis was associated with postural instability, global cognitive impairment, and lack of depressive affect. In all patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease, hallucinosis was more prevalent when they were treated with a direct acting dopamine receptor agonist. Hallucinosis was not associated with age at onset of idiopathic Parkinson’s disease or dosage of dopaminergic medication. CONCLUSION Hallucinosis in idiopathic Parkinson’s disease is heterogeneous, falling into two groups. The difference in the pathophysiological basis of hallucinosis in these two groups of patients is discussed.

A data-driven approach to the study of heterogeneity in idiopathic Parkinson's disease: identification of three distinct subtypes

Idiopathic Parkinsons disease (IPD) has been subclassified on the basis of predominant motor symptomatology, age at disease onset, depressive affect, and cognitive performance. However, subgroups are usually arbitrarily defined and not reliably based on qualitatively distinct neuropathology. We explored heterogeneity in IPD in a data‐driven manner using comprehensive demographic, motor, mood, and cognitive information collected from 176 patients with IPD. Cluster analysis revealed three subgroups of patients at a disease duration of 5.6 years and two subgroups at 13.4 years. The subgroups may represent the clinical progression of three distinct subtypes of IPD. The “motor only” subtype was characterized by motor symptom progression in the absence of intellectual impairment. Equivalent motor symptom progression was shown by the “motor and cognitive” subtype which was accompanied by executive function deficits progressing to global cognitive impairment. The “rapid progression” subtype was characterized by an older age at disease onset and rapidly progressive motor and cognitive disability. There was no relationship between the motor and cognitive symptoms in any subtype of IPD. We conclude that the clinical heterogeneity of IPD is governed by distinct neuropathologic processes with independent etiologic influences.

A deficit profile of executive, memory, and motor functions in schizophrenia

This study examined the neuropsychological deficits associated with schizophrenia and the interrelationships among multiple dissociable cognitive and motor functions. The tests were selected for their previously demonstrated sensitivity to circumscribed brain pathology and included four functional domains: executive functions, short-term memory and production, motor ability, and declarative memory. Each test composite was divided according to verbal versus nonverbal material or left- versus right-hand performance; this distinction permitted functions principally subserved by the left or right cerebral hemispheres to be tested separately. Data reduction was theoretically driven by the test selection and was achieved first by standardizing the scores of each test for age-related differences observed in the normal control group, and then by calculating test composite scores as an average of the age-corrected Z-scores of the tests comprising a functional composite. The schizophrenic group was impaired equivalently on all composites for both cerebral hemispheres; on average, the Z-scores of the patients were 1 standard deviation below those of the control group. The cognitive test composite scores were highly intercorrelated but showed only weak associations with motor ability. Multiple regression analyses suggested that symptom severity was a significant predictor of the Declarative Memory and Short-Term Memory/Production composite scores after accounting for disease duration, whereas disease duration uniquely contributed to the Executive Functions composite scores after controlling for symptom severity. Even though the schizophrenics as a group showed an equivalent level of deficit across all test composites, 1) the deficits were associated with different aspects of psychiatric symptomatology, 2) the motor deficit was independent of the cognitive deficits, and 3) each neuropsychological domain contributed independently to the deficit pattern. Thus, what appears to be a generalized functional deficit in schizophrenia may actually be, at least in part, combinations of multiple specific deficits.

Short-term memory and temporal ordering in early Parkinson's disease : effects of disease chronicity and medication

Studies of Parkinsons disease (PD) have shown impaired temporal ordering but interpretation may be confounded by task requirements and the effects of medication. We examined item recognition and recency discrimination in PD in relation to treatment and performance on other tests. Patients showed increased response latency and impaired recency discrimination only at short retention intervals. The deficits were greater in chronically medicated patients but treatment with levodopa, bromocriptine or anticholinergic drugs did not affect performance of newly diagnosed cases. The short-term memory deficits correlated with scores on tests of working memory, attention and executive function. These results do not indicate a generalised temporal ordering deficit in PD but suggest that much of the cognitive impairment in the disorder arises from attentional deficits affecting short-term and working memory.

Olanzapine in the treatment of hallucinosis in idiopathic parkinson’s disease: a cautionary note

BACKGROUND Hallucinosis is a dopaminergic dose limiting complication of the treatment of idiopathic Parkinson’s disease. Typical neuroleptic medications cannot be used for suppressing hallucinosis because the extrapyramidal side effects worsen parkinsonian motor control. Olanzapine is a novel atypical antipsychotic drug with few reported extrapyramidal side effects which may be more suitable for controlling hallucinosis in these patients. METHODS Olanzapine was given to five patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease and the dosage was titrated until a clinically meaningful reduction in hallucinosis was achieved. The commercially available 5 mg, 7.5 mg and 10 mg tablets were used. RESULTS After an initial 9 days of treatment, hallucinosis frequency was significantly reduced, an effect which was maintained with continued treatment. However, during this early phase of treatment, parkinsonian motor disability increased, which resulted in two of the patients discontinuing medication. CONCLUSIONS Olanzapine is effective in the suppression of hallucinosis in patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease but the currently available dose increments may result in an unacceptable exacerbation of motor disability.

Patterns of content, contextual, and working memory impairments in schizophrenia and nonamnesic alcoholism.

This study used tests of content memory (item recognition of words and abstract designs), context memory (order recognition of verbal and nonverbal items), and working memory (recognition at a short retention interval) to examine patterns of performance in 27 schizophrenic patients, 52 chronic alcoholic patients, and 66 healthy control participants. When performance was age- and IQ-adjusted the schizophrenia group was significantly impaired in item and order recognition of verbal and nonverbal material; the alcoholic group was impaired only in order recognition for both material types. Item- and order-recognition deficits in the schizophrenia group were greatest at the shortest retention intervals, a pattern previously observed in patients with Parkinsons disease, suggesting a prominence of a working memory deficit in schizophrenia.

Cognitive components of reaction time in Parkinson's disease.

Studies of reaction time in Parkinsons disease (PD) have suggested a selective deficit in simple reaction time (SRT), compared with choice reaction time (CRT). This finding has been interpreted as a deficit in motor preprogramming but could involve other factors, such as attentional focussing and stimulus predictability. Moreover, not all studies show the same selective deficit, possibly because of differences in patient selection and treatment effects. The neurochemical basis of RT deficits in PD remains unclear. Accordingly, the contribution of cognitive factors to impaired RT was assessed in a large group of PD patients, including early untreated cases, and performance was examined in relation to clinical variables and the effect of treatment in longitudinal study. Motor output was constant in both SRT and CRT tasks. In the SRT task, all stimuli required a response; in the CRT task, subjects were required to respond to only one of the two possible stimuli. Attentional focussing on SRT was examined by variation of the interval between cue and stimulus; effects of stimulus uncertainty were evaluated from a comparison of SRT and CRT; temporal predictability of the stimulus was examined from a comparison of conditions in which the interval between warning signal and imperative stimulus was constant or variable. The PD patients showed similar deficits in SRT and CRT, but normal effects of cue-stimulus interval and temporal predictability. Reaction time correlated with measures of global cognitive capacity and frontal-lobe function, as well as motor disability. Treatment had no effect on SRT or CRT, despite clinical benefit. These findings indicate that RT deficits in PD are not due to impaired attentional focussing or stimulus predictability but are compatible with a deficit in higher-order processes concerned with the orientation of both cognitive and motor responses to a stimulus. These processes are not substantially dopamine-dependent but may be served by non-dopaminergic neurotransmission.

Encoding Deficits in Untreated Parkinson's Disease

Short-term memory deficits are prominent in untreated Parkinsons Disease (PD) and speed of central processing is known to be abnormal. To investigate the relationship between these findings, a modification of the Brown-Peterson paradigm was given to newly diagnosed, untreated patients and healthy control subjects (HCS). The PD patients were impaired under conditions of long stimulus exposure but not when study time was short. Although patients displayed deficits in immediate recall, they were more impaired at longer test delays. They achieved fewer encoding operations per unit time, resulting in a divergence of group performance with increasing duration of stimulus exposure. Performance in the PD group did not associate with motor disability, disease duration or rating of depression. These results are discussed in terms of a unifying reduced central processing deficit that is evident in PD but is independent of physical symptoms.

Autobiographical Memory in Normal Ageing and Dementia

Autobiographical memories in young and elderly normal subjects are drawn mostly from the recent past but elderly subjects relate a second peak of memories from early adulthood. Memory for remote past public events is relatively preserved in dementia, possibly reflecting integrity of semantic relative to episodic memory. We examined recall of specific, consistent autobiographical episodes in Alzheimers disease (AD) in response to cue words. Patients and control subjects drew most memories from the recent 20 years: episode age related to anterograde memory function but not subject age or dementia. Subjects also related a secondary peak of memories from early adulthood; episode age related to subject age and severity of dementia. The results suggest that preferential recall of memories from early adulthood is based on the salience of retrieval cues, altered by age and dementia, superimposed on a temporal gradient of semantic memory. Further, AD shows behavioural similarity to normal ageing.