Heidrun Golla

Non-cancer patients in specialized palliative care in Germany: what are the problems?

To determine the role of non-cancer palliative care in inpatient services in Germany, data from the Hospice and Palliative Care Evaluation (HOPE) were analysed. Since 1999, a three-month census has been conducted annually in German palliative care units. Pooled data from 2002–2005 were tested for differences between non-cancer patients (NCs) and cancer patients (Cs). A total of 4182 patients (NC: 3.5%; C: 96.5%) were documented; functional status (using Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) measures) in NCs was lower compared to Cs (p = 0.009). NCs suffered more often from dyspnoea (40%; C: 29%; p = 0.004), weakness (92,3%; C: 84,5%; p = 0.011) and tiredness (75.4%; C: 66.7%; p = 0.03) and less from nausea (17.1%; C: 28.9%; p = 0.002), vomiting (8.2%; C: 19.4%; p = 0.001) or loss of appetite (55.5%; C: 67.9%; p = 0.002). There were no differences in pain and constipation. Other problems (nursing, psychological) were more frequent for NCs, in particular the need for support in the activities of daily life (90.3%; C: 72.8%; p < 0.001) and disorientation/confusion (32.1%; C: 17.2%; p < 0.001). There were no differences in social problems. NCs are still rare in specialized inpatient palliative care institutions in Germany. The palliative care needs in patients with non-malignant disease will challenge the health care system as the workload for these services will grow over proportionally.

Unmet needs of severely affected multiple sclerosis patients: The health professionals’ view

Background: Research has only started recently to specifically concentrate on the group of patients severely affected by multiple sclerosis (MS). Aim: The aim of this study was to assess the perception on patients’ unmet needs by healthcare professionals. Methods: Focus groups and expert interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim and analysed by qualitative content analysis. Results: Unmet needs were identified in four main categories (‘support from family/friends’; ‘healthcare services’; ‘managing everyday life’; ‘maintaining biographical continuity’). Whereas physicians assessed most unmet needs in the category ‘healthcare services’, nurses and social workers focussed on unmet needs in the categories ‘support from family/friends’ and ‘maintaining biographical continuity’. Although the study focused on unmet needs of patients, professionals also voiced their unmet needs when caring for these patients. The group of professionals identified more subcategories than patients and included unmet needs of relatives. Conclusion: Adding professionals’ perspective to that of patients is essential to gain a holistic view on patients’ unmet needs and to further optimize their care. The perspective of palliative care might contribute to meet unmet needs of severely affected MS patients.

Multiple sclerosis and palliative care - perceptions of severely affected multiple sclerosis patients and their health professionals: a qualitative study.

BackgroundIn Germany, patients severely affected by Multiple Sclerosis (MS) do not routinely come into contact with palliative care, even if possibly beneficial. This study was aimed at investigating how severely affected MS patients and their health professionals perceive palliative care to determine how to better approach these patients in Germany about this topic.Methods15 patients feeling severely affected by MS and 23 health professionals experienced with MS patients (3 social workers, 7 nurses, and 13 physicians) in both in-/outpatient and rural/ urban settings participated in this qualitative study in Germany. Semi-structured interviews (patients, health professionals) and focus groups (health professionals) were conducted, transcribed verbatim and analyzed via qualitative content analysis.ResultsMS patients were mostly unfamiliar with the term “palliative care” or were aware of it only in relation to cancer and dying. They did not view it as relevant to themselves. Health professionals predominantly associated palliative care with dying cancer patients, if familiar with it at all. Most physicians doubted its relevance for neurological patients and denied MS as a cause of death. Nevertheless, most felt they already offered their patients sufficient palliative care, or thought that it could not meet MS patients’ complex needs. Most nurses and social workers recognized deficits in existing care structures and regarded palliative care as an opportunity for MS patients.ConclusionMS patients’, and health professionals’ restricted, death-associated awareness of palliative care leads to discomfort, fear or rejection of this idea. Therefore, a defined concept of palliative care emphasizing opportunities for severely affected MS patients and considering early integration should be spread throughout the German MS community as an additional layer of support for this patient group.

Feeling severely affected by Multiple Sclerosis: What does this mean?

Background: The situation for people feeling severely affected by Multiple Sclerosis (MS) remains largely unexamined and the term ‘severe MS’ is not clearly defined. Aim: Our study describes this sub-group of patients utilizing exclusively a subjective inclusion criterion to analyse their reasons for feeling severely affected and document their perceived unmet needs. Design: A questionnaire with open- and closed-ended items addressing only patients feeling severely affected was sent out nationwide. Expanded Disability Status Score (EDSS) and subjectively severe affectedness were analysed for correlation. After dichotomizing both scores by a median split, the answers were allocated to these groups and tested for significant differences. Setting/participants: 1,110 questionnaires were analysed regarding the closed-ended questions while a subsample of 40% (n = 445) was analysed regarding the open-ended questions. Average age of participants was 51.87 years. Average time since diagnosis was 16.6 years. Main course of the disease was secondary progressive (35.5%). Results: The most frequently mentioned reasons for feeling severely affected were lack of mobility (56.4%) and fatigue (27.4%). Significant percentages for unmet needs were seen in the categories of funding services (31.0%), better social integration (24.7%) and medical support (25.2%). A significant correlation was observed between EDSS and subjectively felt affectedness (p ≤ 0.01). Motor disorders explained differences in patient needs behind a higher EDSS score; higher severe affectedness referred to other issues like dependency and immobility. Conclusions: EDSS is insufficient for usage as the sole instrument for measuring severe affectedness as it does not take into account other potential reasons. Complex patient needs necessitate multi-professional care as offered by palliative medicine.

A palliative care hotline for multiple sclerosis: A pilot feasibility study

OBJECTIVE Research findings suggest that patients severely affected by multiple sclerosis benefit from palliative care. Our objectives were to (1) implement a pilot palliative care counseling hotline for severely affected multiple sclerosis patients and their caregivers in order to connect them to palliative care, and (2) evaluate its preliminary feasibility through a pilot study. METHOD The hotline was designed in cooperation with the local state association of the German Multiple Sclerosis Society and based on a review of the literature. The initial study setting for the hotline was the broader region of the cities Cologne and Bonn in Germany. The hotline was introduced through a magazine published by the German Multiple Sclerosis Society and leaflets sent to local healthcare providers. Calls were conducted using a semistructured interview guide and documented by a standardized case report form. Measures to assess feasibility were both quantitative (e.g., number of calls) and qualitative (e.g., criteria for eligibility for palliative care). RESULTS During its pilot year, the hotline received 18 calls. Some 15 callers were included in the analysis, and 10 of these 15 were deemed eligible for palliative care due to such criteria as medical characteristics, care or nursing conditions, caregiver strain, and concerns regarding death and dying. Access to palliative care services could be provided for all 10 callers. SIGNIFICANCE OF RESULTS Based on our pilot feasibility study, the hotline seems to be a valuable service for patients severely affected by multiple sclerosis (MS) and their caregivers in order to gain information about and access to palliative care. It will be extended on a nationwide scale through a grant of the German Multiple Sclerosis Society. Awareness of the hotline needs to be enhanced in order to attract and support a significant number of new callers.

Self-rating makes the difference: identifying palliative care needs of patients feeling severely affected by multiple sclerosis.

OBJECTIVE People feeling severely affected by multiple sclerosis (MS) comprise a heterogeneous group, and this heterogeneity leads to very distinct needs and makes planning for needs difficult. To provide optimal care, it is important to identify specific needs in specific subgroups. Our objective was to identify the specific palliative care (PC) needs of patients who felt severely affected by the disease by analyzing their feeling (1) more or (2) less severely affected and their possible differences in expressed care needs. METHOD A self-report questionnaire with 25 needs categories including 7 categories pertaining to care was applied to patients who felt severely affected by MS. An additional single question identified patients feeling more (≥7, median-split) and less (<7) severely affected. Differences were analyzed by chi-squared and Mann-Whitney U tests. The sample (N = 573) was composed of respondents who replied to an invitation by the German Multiple Sclerosis Society to participate in a survey on unmet needs of severely affected patients. RESULTS Of 573 patients (median age 51), 358 (62.48%) felt more severely affected. Compared to patients feeling less severely affected, they found the stress on their next of kin to be higher (p < 0.001), were in greater need of home visitation (p < 0.001), did not have permanent neurologists (p = 0.016), and felt that they visited them too rarely (p < 0.0001). They also needed more emotional support from their nursing care service (p = 0.006). SIGNIFICANCE OF RESULTS A self-rating scale can identify two groups of patients with different care needs. These data may help shaping patient-centered support structures. Palliative care, with its multidisciplinary approach, might be one further option to meet the specific needs of patients and their relatives.

Clinical routine assessment of palliative care symptoms and concerns and caregiver burden in glioblastoma patients: an explorative field study

The implementation of self-reported outcome measurements into clinical routine was tested to help facilitate early access to palliative care (PC) for glioblastoma (GBM)-patients. Measures detail PC symptoms and concerns and caregiver burden. Between January 2014 and December 2016, a total of 337 GBM-patients were discussed during meetings of the neuro-oncology tumor board to examine further treatment options. Each patient, along with their caregivers, was requested to participate in self-assessment using the palliative outcome scale (POS) and the Zarit Burden Interview (ZBI). Analyses encompassed summary statistics, non-parametric tests, visual graphic analysis, content analysis and assessing the utilization of the specialized PC consulting service (SPCCS). Ninety-five (28%) GBM-patients and 71 (21%) caregivers completed the self-assessment. Of these, 20 patients and 12 caregivers repeated the assessment at least once more during follow-up. POS total scores were similar in the group of patients with initial diagnosis [10 (0–31)] and those with later disease stages like recurrent diagnosis [9 (0–25)], but ZBI total scores differed [14 (0–51) vs. 24 (2–62)]. Single item analysis demonstrated that anxiety and worries about the future predominated. Caregivers were torn between high engagement in caring and feeling overburdened. Still, requests for the SPCCS showed no increase. Actual implementation of measures like POS and ZBI for detecting PC concerns and caregiver burden with GBM-patients in the field remains challenging as indicated by the limited response rate and lack of increased requests for the SPCCS. Modified clinical routines including strengthening awareness of PC, and allowing proxy-assessment might help to overcome barriers.

Needs of people with advanced dementia in their final phase of life: A multi-perspective qualitative study in nursing homes:

Background: People with advanced dementia present an important target group for palliative care. They suffer a range of symptoms, and their verbal communication abilities are highly restricted. At present, little is known about their needs in the final phase of life. Aim: To identify the needs of people with advanced dementia in their final phase of life and to explore the aspects relevant to first recognize and then meet these needs. Design: Multi-perspective qualitative study using grounded theory methodology conducting group discussions, individual interviews, and participant observation. Setting/participants: The study encompassed nursing homes and involved health professionals, relatives, and residents with advanced dementia. Results: Data were collected in six nursing homes. Nine group discussions and three individual interviews were conducted comprising 42 health professionals and 14 relatives. Participant observations aided in giving the perspective of 30 residents with advanced dementia. Data analysis generated a total of 25 physical, psychosocial, and spiritual needs divided into 10 categories. Physical needs were classified as follows: “food intake,” “physical well-being,” and “physical activity and recovery.” Categories of psychosocial needs were classified as follows: “adaptation of stimuli,” “communication,” “personal attention,” “participation,” “familiarity and safety,” as well as “self-determination.” Spiritual needs addressed “religion.” The results revealed a multitude of key aspects for recognizing and meeting these needs, stressing the importance of personhood. Conclusion: People with advanced dementia in their final phase of life have a multitude of individual and complex needs. This evidence contributes to narrowing the current research gap, offering an orientation framework for research and practice.

Spiritualität im höheren Lebensalter als dynamische Alter(n)saufgabe

ZusammenfassungHintergrundEine Vielzahl von Studien belegt den positiven Einfluss von Spiritualität im Umgang mit schwierigen Lebenssituationen. Studien zur Spiritualität im höheren Lebensalter stellen in der deutschsprachigen gerontologischen Forschungslandschaft allerdings eine Ausnahme dar. In der Theorie der Gerotranszendenz von Tornstam finden sich jedoch Hinweise darauf, dass spirituelle Selbst- und Weltdeutung gerade im höheren Lebensalter aufgrund einer Perspektivverschiebung von besonderer Relevanz auch für die Aufrechterhaltung von Lebenszufriedenheit ist. Ziel der ArbeitDiese Arbeit verfolgt die Forschungsfragen, wie sich Spiritualität in der Hochaltrigkeit (80 Jahre und älter) präsentiert und inwiefern diese Ausprägung spezifisch für das höhere Lebensalter ist.Material und MethodeEs wurden problemzentrierte Interviews mit 20 Hochaltrigen durchgeführt, die mittels qualitativer Inhaltsanalyse ausgewertet wurden.ErgebnisseSpiritualität selbst stellt kein Spezifikum des höheren Alters dar. In ihrer Ausprägung ist sie jedoch als existenzieller Prozess der Transformation und Wandlung durch Sozialisationsprozesse und biografische Erlebnisse und Erfahrungen über den Lebenslauf hinweg geprägt sowie durch Subjektivierungs- und Individualisierungsprozesse charakterisiert. Zudem kommt den mit ihr verbundenen existenziellen Fragen gerade im höheren Alter eine besondere Relevanz und Dringlichkeit zu, die sich auf affektiven, reflexiven und performativen Dimensionen ausdrückt und in ihren Antworten zwischen Fragilität und Kontinuität changiert.SchlussfolgerungSpiritualität hochaltriger Menschen ist als (Zwischen-)Ergebnis der über den Lebensverlauf gemachten Erfahrungen und Erlebnisse vor dem Hintergrund der jeweiligen Sozialisation und individuellen existenziellen Selbst- und Weltdeutung differenziert. Als entsprechend dynamisch und heterogen ist sie in Forschung und Praxis zur Förderung des Wohlbefindens im höheren Lebensalter wahrzunehmen.AbstractBackgroundA multitude of studies have demonstrated a positive effect of spirituality for dealing with difficult situations in life; however, specific studies on spirituality in older age are exceptionally rare within the German gerontological research landscape. The theory of gerotranscendence by Tornstam indicates that spirituality is of particular importance for maintaining life satisfaction especially in older age, due to a change in perspective.ObjectivesThis study looked into the research questions of how spirituality is presented in the oldest old (80 years and older) in Germany and to what extent its characteristics are specific to older age.Material and methodsProblem-centered interviews were conducted with 20 oldest old subjects and evaluated using qualitative content analysis.ResultsSpirituality in itself is not specific to very old age. Its shaping, however, as an existential process of transformation and redefinition, is specific in the oldest old due to their socialization and biographical experiences over the life course impregnated by processes of subjectification and individualization. In addition, its relation to existential questions gains increasing relevance and priority in very old age in an affective, reflective and performative dimension, and the answers change between fragility and continuity.ConclusionAs a heterogeneous (intermediate) result of experiences over the life course against the background of socialization and individual existential interpretation of “Self” and “World”, spirituality in the oldest old should be perceived in this diverse and dynamic manner in research and practice, in order to foster well-being in old age.

Severely Affected by Parkinson Disease: The Patient’s View and Implications for Palliative Care:

Introduction: People severely affected by Parkinson disease (PD)/atypical parkinsonism (AP) comprise a heterogeneous group with distinct needs, which so far remain largely unexamined. The aim of our study was to analyze reasons for feeling severely affected and document unmet needs in a patient subgroup severely affected by PD/AP using solely a subjective inclusion criterion. Methods: Patients feeling severely affected by PD/AP were recruited via a magazine published by the German Parkinson Association. A questionnaire was sent out nationwide. Besides analyzing the closed-ended questions, a subsample of 40% was analyzed regarding the open-ended questions using content analysis. Correlations between subjectively felt severe affectedness and objective criteria were calculated. Results: Eight hundred fourteen questionnaires were analyzed. Sample characteristics were: mean age 70 years; 60.3% male; time since diagnosis up to 37 years; and Hoehn and Yahr score (if known) 3 (44.6%), followed by 4 (23.9%). Significant associations were observed between subjectively felt severe affectedness and Hoehn and Yahr (P ≤ .05), poorer health ( P ≤ .01), higher nursing care level (P ≤ 0.01), and having no children ( P ≤ .05). Most common reasons for feeling severely affected were mobility impairment (34.9%), coordination problems (17.0%), speech problems (12.2%), and limited day-to-day activities (7.8%). Most often expressed unmet needs were support in everyday life (28.1%), medical treatment (15.2%), help with financial services (11.6%), and social integration (9.9%). Conclusions: To meet the complex needs, an integrated multidisciplinary and multiprofessional approach is indicated befitting palliative care principles. Herein, home-based services seem of special importance for patients in advanced disease stages.