Henrik Aggerbeck

Improved ELISA for determination of anti-diphtheria and/or anti-tetanus antitoxin antibodies in sera

Double‐antigen ELISAs for detection and quantification of anti‐tetanus or anti‐diphtheria antibodies in serum have been developed. The assays showed good correlations with established toxin neutralizing assays and were functionally specific for IgG antibodies. The double‐antigen set‐up allows specific antibodies to bind to antigen‐coated microtitre wells with one arm and the free arm to bind to biotin‐labelled antigen. The amount of antibodies able to bind labelled antigen was assessed by adding enzyme‐conjugated streptavidin and colour substrate followed by measurement of the colour using an ELISA reader. The double‐antigen principle makes it possible to compare samples of different species on the same plate, permitting the direct use of existing international references of animal or human origin. The double‐antigen ELISAs showed a detection limit of 0.00002 IU/ml for both antibodies and were suitable for quantifying antibodies in blood samples collected on filter paper as well as in serum. The assays required no special equipment compared to traditional ELISA.

Simultaneous quantitation of diphtheria and tetanus antibodies by double antigen, time-resolved fluorescence immunoassay

A dual, double antigen, time-resolved fluorescence immunoassay (DELFIA) for the simultaneous detection and quantitation of diphtheria (D) and tetanus (T) antibodies in sera has been developed. In the double antigen format one arm of the antibody binds to antigen coated microtitre wells and the other arm binds to labelled antigen to provide a fluorescent signal. This assay was found to be functionally specific for IgG antibodies and showed a good correlation with established toxin neutralization assays. Furthermore, the double antigen set-up was species independent, permitting the direct use of existing international references of animal origin to measure protective antibody levels in humans in international units (IU/ml). The detection limit corresponded to 0.0003 IU/ml with Eu(3+)-labelled toxoids and to 0.0035 IU/ml using Sm(3+)-labelled toxoids. The assay was fast with a high capacity making it a suitable method for serological surveillance studies.

Intranasal booster vaccination against diphtheria and tetanus in man

The booster responses of three different formulations of intranasal (i.n.) diphtheria-tetanus (D-T) vaccines were determined in military recruits and compared with a conventional subcutaneous D-T vaccine. The vaccines for mucosal delivery were sprayed into one nostril and contained D and T toxoids in an enhancer mixture of polysorbate and caprylic/capric glycerides. All of the vaccines gave rise mainly to a systemic IgG response. Among 51 persons with anti-D antibody concentrations in serum below a protective level of 0.01 international units (IU ml-1) before vaccination, all except two attained protective antibody concentrations 4 weeks after vaccination. The median increase in anti-D antibody concentration was 113-fold with the most efficient i.n. formulation. The median increase in anti-T antibody level was 2.4-fold, however, the pre-vaccination levels for this antigen were very high. Within the examined levels, the booster response depended mainly on the dose of the antigen in the vaccine rather than on the concentration of the vehicle mixture. Compared with the parenteral D-T vaccine containing aluminium hydroxide as an adjuvant, all of the tested i.n. formulations showed somewhat lower immunogenicity in man as well as in pre-clinical guinea-pig studies. Among 215 persons immunized i.n., 61% preferred this route of administration rather than a parenteral injection, although the formulations were all associated with varying local symptoms, frequently stinging and pronounced, nasal secretion.

European sero-epidemiology network: standardisation of the results of diphtheria antitoxin assays.

A European Sero-Epidemiological Network (ESEN) was established with the aim to co-ordinate and harmonise serological surveillance of immunity to communicable diseases in Europe. In this study the inter-laboratory standardisation of diphtheria toxin antibody measurements is reported. A standard panel of 162 sera was tested by the participating laboratories using an in vitro assay of their choice: VERO cell toxin neutralisation assay (NT), double-antigen delayed time-resolved fluorescence immuno-assay (DA-DELFIA), double-antigen enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (DAE), toxin binding inhibition test (ToBI) and an indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The results were standardised using regression against the NT. The variations due to inter-laboratory and inter-assay variation, which would otherwise make it difficult directly to compare the main serum bank results by the different laboratories and the various assays were successfully minimised by the standardisation. The regression equations obtained will be used to transform the respective local results of testing the main serum bank into the reference test unitages. This study also gave the opportunity to compare the various assays within and between laboratories. This demonstrated a very high correlation between DA-DELFIA, DAE, ToBI and the NT. The ELISA showed a good correlation, too, however sera below some 0.1 IU/ml were overestimated.

Booster vaccination against diphtheria and tetanus in man. Comparison of three different vaccine formulations—III

Adverse reactions and antibody levels were compared following a booster vaccination of 177 Danish military recruits with a plain, an aluminium hydroxide (0.5 mg Al per human dose, HD) and a calcium phosphate (0.25 mg Ca per HD) adsorbed diphtheria-tetanus (D-T) vaccine. The calcium phosphate adsorbed vaccine was given in a HD of 3 Lf of D and T toxoids and proved to be of equal efficacy as the aluminium hydroxide adsorbed vaccine which was injected in a dose containing twice the antigen amount. The calcium phosphate vaccine caused fewer adverse reactions than the one adsorbed to aluminium hydroxide. The plain vaccine (6 Lf per HD of D and T toxoid) had the highest efficacy with a similar low occurrence of adverse reactions as the calcium phosphate adsorbed vaccine. Potency assays in mice were in accordance with these immunogenicity results in man if a two dose immunization schedule was followed, but not if the vaccines were compared after a single immunization as requested by the procedure for potency testing according to current WHO and European Pharmacopoeia requirements. Both of the adsorbed vaccines primed mice for specific IgE antibody formation. This could be detected after a second immunization with either of the adsorbed vaccines or with the plain D-T vaccine. Also in humans, immunization with the plain vaccine boosted specific IgE formation to a detectable level. This may be ascribed to adjuvant priming during the primary vaccination series some 20 years previously.

Booster vaccination against diphtheria and tetanus in man. Comparison of calcium phosphate and aluminium hydroxide as adjuvants--II.

Diphtheria and tetanus antibody levels were measured before and four weeks after booster vaccination of 313 Danish military recruits participating in a clinical trial to compare aluminium hydroxide and calcium phosphate as adjuvants in diphtheria-tetanus vaccines (DT). Twenty-eight percent of the men had a diphtheria pre-vaccination content below a protective level of 0.01 IU ml-1. The calcium phosphate adsorbed vaccine showed the highest efficacy for both antigens. Adverse reactions were rare but more frequent in the calcium group than in the aluminium group. No correlation was found between pre- or post-vaccination levels and adverse reactions and both vaccines gave rise to specific IgE formation. The results show that calcium phosphate is more effective but not a safer alternative to aluminium hydroxide when compared in vaccines containing 1.0 mg ml-1 of Ca or of Al.

Adjuvanticity of aluminium hydroxide and calcium phosphate in diphtheria-tetanus vaccines—I

The potencies of two diphtheria-tetanus vaccines (DT) adsorbed to either aluminium hydroxide or calcium phosphate were compared in mice and guinea pigs. The vaccines were made from the same batches of purified toxoids and contained the same amounts of antigens. Immunizations were done once or twice with different doses of vaccine injected undiluted, diluted in saline or diluted in the corresponding adjuvant. The various potency assays showed that the adjuvanticity of calcium phosphate was lower than or equal to aluminium hydroxide. Despite the range of potency assays done, none of the methods reflected the efficacy of these vaccines in revaccination of humans. A simplified potency assay is suggested for release of final vaccine formulations to reduce the number of animals in quality control.

Improvement of a Vero cell assay to determine diphtheria antitoxin content in sera

Diphtheria antitoxin content in sera were determined automatically in Vero cell assay by spectrophotometric determination of the equivalence point between toxin and antitoxin followed by computer analysis of absorption values. The method was more accurate than visual reading and made handling of many samples easy.

Sensitivity of C-Tb: a novel RD-1-specific skin test for the diagnosis of tuberculosis infection

C-Tb, a novel Mycobacterium tuberculosis and 6-kDa early secretory antigenic target/10-kDa culture filtrate protein (ESAT-6/CFP-10)-specific skin test, has high specificity in bacille Calmette–Guerin-vaccinated healthy controls. However, the sensitivity of C-Tb has hitherto not been determined. The objective was to determine the sensitivity of C-Tb in patients with active tuberculosis (TB) in comparison with the tuberculin skin test (TST) and QuantiFERON-TB Gold In-Tube (QFT-GIT). C-Tb and TST were randomly administered in a double-blinded fashion to one or the other forearm in 253 patients with active TB with or without HIV co-infection. QFT-GIT testing was performed prior to skin testing. Using a receiver operating characteristic curve-derived cut-point of 5 mm, C-Tb sensitivity was similar to QFT-GIT (73.9 (95% CI 67.8–79.3) versus 75.1 (95% CI 69.3–80.2)), and similar in HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected patients (76.7 (95% CI 69.0–83.3) versus 69.5 (95% CI 59.2–78.5)). However, sensitivity was significantly diminished in HIV-infected patients with CD4 counts <100 cells·mm–3. C-Tb and QFT-GIT combined had significantly higher sensitivity than C-Tb alone (p<0.0001). C-Tb was safe with no significant adverse events. The 5 mm cut-point corresponded to that found in the previously published specificity study (TESEC-04). C-Tb has similar sensitivity compared with QFT-GIT for the diagnosis of M. tuberculosis infection. Sensitivity was reduced only in HIV-infected patients with severe immunosuppression. Further studies in different settings are required to validate the proposed 5 mm cut-point. C-Tb has similar sensitivity compared with QFT-GIT for the diagnosis of M. tuberculosis infection http://ow.ly/TtFf6

Randomised clinical trial investigating the specificity of a novel skin test (C-Tb) for diagnosis of M. tuberculosis infection.

Background Tuberculin skin testing is simple and relatively inexpensive, but the specificity of PPD is affected by BCG vaccination. Objective Determine optimal dose and specificity of recombinant ESAT-6 and CFP-10 (C-Tb) produced in Lactococcus lactis for diagnosis of M. tuberculosis infection. Methods In a dose finding phase I trial 0.01 or 0.1 µg preserved and unpreserved C-Tb was injected by Mantoux technique in 38 patients with active tuberculosis and induration responses measured. In a phase II specificity trial in 151 uninfected, BCG vaccinated participants 0.1 µg C-Tb was compared to 2 TU PPD. Results 0.1 µg C-Tb gave a median induration of 15 mm after 2 days. Phenol preservation did not affect the response. The specificity of C-Tb was 99.3% (95% CI 96–100%) regarding indurations ≥5 mm as a positive outcome. This was higher than the specificity of PPD (63% using a cut-off of 5 mm or 92% using a cut-off of 15 mm to adjust for non-specific BCG responses). Local adverse reactions following C-Tb injection included transient itching and discomfort as expected components of the immune response. Conclusion C-Tb offers a simple and convenient skin test to diagnose M. tuberculosis infection using a single, universal cut-off unaffected by BCG vaccination. Trial Registration ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01033929 and NCT01241188.