Herman E. Brockman

Chlorophyllin: a potent antimutagen against environmental and dietary complex mixtures.

Chlorophyllin, the sodium and copper salt of chlorophyll, was tested for its ability to inhibit the mutagenic activity of a variety of complex mixtures--extracts of fried beef, fried shredded pork, red grape juice, red wine, cigarette smoke, tobacco snuff, chewing tobacco, airborne particles, coal dust and diesel emission particles--in strain TA98 of Salmonella typhimurium. Chlorophyllin was highly effective against the mutagenicity (90-100% inhibition) of 8 of these 10 mixtures. The mutagenicity of the other 2 mixtures was inhibited 75-80% at the highest concentration of chlorophyllin studied. Control and reconstruction experiments showed that chlorophyllin was not toxic to Salmonella at the concentrations used. The antimutagenic activity of chlorophyllin was heat-stable. The mechanism of the antimutagenicity of chlorophyllin in these experiments is not known; however, chlorophyllin is an antioxidant. Scavenging of radicals and/or interaction with the active group of mutagenic compounds may be responsible for its antimutagenic activity. The data reported here indicate that chlorophyllin is potentially useful as an antimutagenic agent.

Specific-locus mutations induced in eukaryotes (especially mammalian cells) by radiation and chemicals: a perspective.

In the course of discovering the first mutagen (X-rays) just over 60 years ago, Herman J. Muller asked whether X-rays induced single-gene mutations and/or chromosomal (multiple-gene) mutations. To a large extent, his question has set the agenda for mutagenesis research ever since. We explore historically the answers to this question, with special emphasis on recent developments in the field of mammalian cell mutagenesis. Studies indicate that ionizing radiation and many chemical mutagens/carcinogens induce both gene and chromosomal mutations; however, only certain genetic systems permit the recovery and analysis of both classes of mutations. Few chemical mutagens induce only gene mutations in mammalian cells; instead, most mutagens appear to induce both classes of mutations, with chromosomal mutations (especially multilocus deletions) predominating at high doses. These results have implications regarding the mechanisms of mutagenesis, the role of chromosomal mutations in carcinogenesis and hereditary disease, and the type of data required for risk assessment of physical and chemical mutagens/carcinogens.

Activity profiles of antimutagens: in vitro and in vivo data

In this review, retinol, chlorophyllin, and N-acetylcysteine are examined and compared with regard to their antimutagenic activity against some promutagens and a group of direct-acting alkylating agents. The promutagens included aflatoxin B1, certain polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (e.g., benzo[a]pyrene), and certain heterocyclic amines (e.g., food pyrolysates). Results of antimutagenicity testing selected from data surveyed in the published literature are displayed graphically as activity profiles of antimutagens showing both the doses tested and the extent of inhibition or enhancement of mutagenic activity. All three antimutagens are discussed in terms of their putative mechanisms of action in vitro and in vivo with emphasis on the xenobiotic metabolizing enzyme systems.

Comparative antimutagenicity of 5 compounds against 5 mutagenic complex mixtures in Salmonella typhimurium strain TA98

Using the Ames Salmonella/microsome assay, we compared the antimutagenic activities of chlorophyllin, retinol, beta-carotene, vitamin C, and vitamin E against solvent extracts of coal dust, diesel emission particles, airborne particles, fried beef, and tobacco snuff. The results show that chlorophyllin inhibited 69% of the mutagenic activity of tobacco snuff and over 90% of that of the other 4 complex mixtures. Retinol inhibited 29-48% of the mutagenic activity of all 5 complex mixtures. beta-Carotene, vitamin C, and vitamin E inhibited, if any, less than 39% of the activity of the complex mixtures studied. Vitamin C enhanced the mutagenicity of airborne particles. These results indicate that for these dietary and environmental complex mixtures chlorophyllin is a more effective antimutagen than retinol, beta-carotene, vitamin C, and vitamin E.

Antimutagenicity profiles of some natural substances

Selected antimutagenicity listings and profiles have been prepared from the literature on the antimutagenicity of retinoids and the carotenoid beta-carotene. The antimutagenicity profiles show: (1) a single antimutagen (e.g., retinol) tested in combination with various mutagens or (2) antimutagens tested against a single mutagen (e.g., aflatoxin B1). Data are presented in the profiles showing a dose range for a given antimutagen and a single dose for the corresponding mutagen; inhibition as well as enhancement of mutagenic activity is indicated. Information was found in the literature on the testing of selected combinations of 16 retinoids and carotenoids vs. 33 mutagens. Of 528 possible antimutagen-mutagen combinations, only 82 (16%) have been evaluated. The most completely evaluated retinoids are retinol (28 mutagens), retinoic acid and retinol acetate (7 mutagens each), and retinal and retinol palmitate (6 mutagens each). beta-Carotene is the most frequently tested carotenoid (15 mutagens). Of the remaining retinoids and carotenoids, 8 were evaluated in combination with a single mutagen and the other 2 were tested against only 2 or 3 mutagens. Most of the data on antimutagenicity in vitro are available for S. typhimurium strains TA98 and TA100. Substantial data also are available for sister-chromatid exchanges in vitro and chromosome aberrations in vitro and in vivo. This report emphasizes the metabolic as well as the antimutagenic effects of retinoids in vitro and in vivo.

Use of four short-term tests to evaluate the mutagenicity of municipal water.

Some ways in which four short-term tests may be used to evaluate the mutagenicity of drinking water were explored by testing raw and treated water from Lake Bloomington, which serves the town of Bloomington, Illinois (population, 44,000). The water was collected from February 1976 to October 1977 and was concentrated by evaporation or by use of XAD-2 resin. The water was tested for the ability to induce reverse mutation in a prokaryote, Salmonella typhimurium; forward mutation in a mold, Neurospora crassa; mitotic gene conversion in a yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae; and reverse mutation in maize, Zea mays. Because of the large number of water samples (54) and the limited amounts of the samples, it was not possible to test all samples in all four tests by all the protocols. Thus, the sensitivities of the four tests to potential mutagens in the water samples could not be rigorously compared. However, the results do show that lake and tap water samples collected during 1976 were toxic but not mutagenic in N. crassa and neither toxic nor genotoxic in S. cerevisiae; lake water collected during 1977 was mutagenic in one line of Z. mays and slightly mutagenic in S. typhimurium strain TA1536 in the presence of rat liver S9. The results suggest that tests that detect a variety of genetic end points should be used when testing complex mixtures such as drinking water. The advantages and disadvantages of the tests and protocols are discussed in terms of their applicability to the study of the mutagenicity of drinking water.

Two N-hydroxylaminopurines are highly mutagenic in the ad-3 forward-mutation test in growing cultures of heterokaryon 12 of Neutospora crassa

3 purine analogs were tested for their mutagenic activities in the ad-3 forward-mutation test in heterokaryon 12 (H-12) of Neurospora crassa. In growing cultures of H-12, the N-hydroxylaminopurines 2-amino-6-N-hydroxylaminopurine (AHA) and 6-N-hydroxylaminopurine (HAP) are potent and strong mutagens, respectively, whereas 2-aminopurine (AP) is a weak mutagen. AHA and HAP are about equally mutagenic at low doses, but AHA is more mutagenic than HAP at high doses. Despite their potent mutagenicity in growing cultures, AHA and HAP are not mutagenic in nongrowing conidia under the conditions of our experiments. AHA is the most potent mutagen tested in the ad-3 forward-mutation test in N. crassa. At the highest dose tested (30 micrograms/ml), it gave an ad-3 mutant frequency of 0.7 X 10(-2), about a 12,000-fold increase over the average spontaneous ad-3 mutant frequency. The potent mutagenicity of AHA may make it (and possibly HAP) especially useful for obtaining specific-locus mutations in other organisms.

The efficacy of neurospora in detecting agents that cause aneuploidy

A total of 110 agents, 109 chemicals plus gamma-rays, has been tested in a Neurospora pseudowild-type selection system for their ability to induce meiotic aneuploidy. 11 agents were positive, 47 were negative, and 52 were inconclusively tested. The system has a possible role as a short-term test for environmental agents causing human aneuploidy. The advantages of the system are its simplicity and ease of use. Disadvantages are its high variability of aneuploid frequency and an inability to distinguish mechanisms of aneuploidy.

Qualitative differences in the spectra of genetic damage in 2-aminopurine-induced ad-3 mutants between nucleotide excision-repair-proficient and -deficient strains of Neurospora crassa

The mutagenic effects of 2-aminopurine (2AP) have been compared in the adenine-3 (ad-3) region of two-component heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa: nucleotide excision repair-proficient (uvs-2+/uvs-2+) heterokaryon 12 (H-12) and nucleotide excision repair-deficient (uvs-2/uvs-2) heterokaryon 59 (H-59). This forward-mutation, morphological and biochemical, specific-locus assay system permits the recovery of ad-3A and/or ad-3B mutants in 3 major classes: gene/point mutations, multilocus deletion mutations, and unknowns, and 3 different subclasses of multiple-locus mutations. Previous studies (Brockman et al., Mutation Res., 218 (1989) 1-11) showed that 2AP treatment of growing cultures of H-12 and H-59 gave no difference between ad-3 forward-mutation frequencies over a wide range of 2AP concentrations in each strain. In the present experiments, genetic analyses of ad-3 mutants recovered from these experiments has demonstrated qualitative differences between the spectra of the 3 main classes of ad-3 mutations. In H-12, 84.2% (203/241) resulted from gene/point mutation, 11.6% (28/241) from multilocus deletion mutation, and 4.1% (10/241) were unknowns. In contrast, in H-59, 43.0% (99/230) resulted from gene/point mutation, 55.7% (128/230) from multilocus deletion mutation, and 1.3% (3/230) were unknowns. In addition, quantitative differences were also found between the spectra of ad-3 mutations in 1 subclass of multiple-locus mutations, but not 2 additional subclasses. The first subclass consisted of 1.7% (4/241) and 9.6% (22/230) gene/point mutations with a closely linked recessive lethal mutation, in H-12 and H-59, respectively. The second two subclasses consisted of (a) 0.4% (1/241) and 0.4% (1/230) multilocus deletion mutations with a closely linked recessive lethal mutation, and (b) 13.3% (32/241) and 15.2% (35/230) gene/point mutations with a separate recessive lethal mutation elsewhere in the genome, in H-12 and H-59, respectively. Data from studies by others have shown that 2AP inhibits adenosine deaminase, resulting in nucleotide precursor pool inbalance, and that 2AP can saturate the mismatch repair system. As a consequence of either effect of 2AP, the spectrum of 2AP-induced mutation could include frameshift mutations and chromosome aberrations such as multilocus deletions in addition to base-pair substitutions. The defect in DNA repair due to the uvs-2 allele, which has been shown to be a deficiency in pyrimidine dimer excision (Worthy and Epler, 1974), most probably has some other excision-repair deficiency (Macleod and Stadler, 1986; Baker et al., 1991).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Molecular dosimetry of the chemical mutagen ethyl methanesulfonate. Quantitative comparison of the mutagenic potency in Neurospora crassa and Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Extending previous work with E. coli and mammalian cells in culture, forward-mutation frequencies induced by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) were quantitatively compared in Neurospora crassa and Saccharomyces cerevisiae under standardized conditions. Concomitantly, the actual dose to DNA was measured by determining the amount of radioactivity bound to DNA after treatment with tritium-labeled EMS. After exposure to EMS (2.5-50 mM), alkylation levels in N. crassa and S. cerevisiae were similar to those previously determined in E. coli and cultured mammalian cells. Consistently, there was a slightly less than proportional increase of the DNA alkylation level with the exposure concentration of the mutagen. Forward mutagenesis induced in yeast and N. crassa showed exponential kinetics with exponents of 1.5 and 2.6, respectively. These results are similar to those previously reported with E. coli, which differed from the results with cultured mammalian cells, where a linear dose-effect relationship between exposure and genetic effect was observed. These differences may reflect differences in the fate of EMS-induced adducts by cellular DNA repair systems, but are not due to initial differences in DNA alkylation levels. The fate and persistence of specific DNA adducts potentially responsible for pre-mutagenic changes are under investigation.