Hervé Philippe

The origin of red algae and the evolution of chloroplasts

Chloroplast structure and genome analyses support the hypothesis that three groups of organisms originated from the primary photosynthetic endosymbiosis between a cyanobacterium and axa0eukaryotic host: green plants (green algae + land plants), red algae and glaucophytes (for example, Cyanophora). Although phylogenies based on several mitochondrial genes support a specific green plants/red algae relationship, the phylogenetic analysis of nucleus-encoded genes yields inconclusive, sometimes contradictory results. To address this problem, we have analysed an alternative nuclear marker, elongation factor 2, and included new red algae and protist sequences. Here we provide significant support for a sisterhood of green plants and red algae. This sisterhood is also significantly supported by a multi-gene analysis of a fusion of 13 nuclear markers (5,171 amino acids). In addition, the analysis of an alternative fusion of 6 nuclear markers (1,938 amino acids) indicates that glaucophytes may be the closest relatives to the green plants/red algae group. Thus, our study provides evidence from nuclear markers for a single primary endosymbiosis at the origin of these groups, and supports a kingdom Plantae comprising green plants, red algae and glaucophytes.

How good are deep phylogenetic trees

Great interest is given to species emerging early in phylogenetic reconstruction because they are often assumed to represent an ancestor. Recent studies indicate, however, that species branching deep in molecular trees are often fast-evolving ones, misplaced because of the long-branch artefact. The detection of genuinely deep-branching organisms remains an elusive task.

The Rooting of the Universal Tree of Life Is Not Reliable

Abstract. Several composite universal trees connected by an ancestral gene duplication have been used to root the universal tree of life. In all cases, this root turned out to be in the eubacterial branch. However, the validity of results obtained from comparative sequence analysis has recently been questioned, in particular, in the case of ancient phylogenies. For example, it has been shown that several eukaryotic groups are misplaced in ribosomal RNA or elongation factor trees because of unequal rates of evolution and mutational saturation. Furthermore, the addition of new sequences to data sets has often turned apparently reasonable phylogenies into confused ones. We have thus revisited all composite protein trees that have been used to root the universal tree of life up to now (elongation factors, ATPases, tRNA synthetases, carbamoyl phosphate synthetases, signal recognition particle proteins) with updated data sets. In general, the two prokaryotic domains were not monophyletic with several aberrant groupings at different levels of the tree. Furthermore, the respective phylogenies contradicted each others, so that various ad hoc scenarios (paralogy or lateral gene transfer) must be proposed in order to obtain the traditional Archaebacteria–Eukaryota sisterhood. More importantly, all of the markers are heavily saturated with respect to amino acid substitutions. As phylogenies inferred from saturated data sets are extremely sensitive to differences in evolutionary rates, present phylogenies used to root the universal tree of life could be biased by the phenomenon of long branch attraction. Since the eubacterial branch was always the longest one, the eubacterial rooting could be explained by an attraction between this branch and the long branch of the outgroup. Finally, we suggested that an eukaryotic rooting could be a more fruitful working hypothesis, as it provides, for example, a simple explanation to the high genetic similarity of Archaebacteria and Eubacteria inferred from complete genome analysis.

Where is the root of the universal tree of life

The currently accepted universal tree of life based on molecular phylogenies is characterised by a prokaryotic root and the sisterhood of archaea and eukaryotes. The recent discovery that each domain (bacteria, archaea, and eucarya) represents a mosaic of the two others in terms of its gene content has suggested various alternatives in which eukaryotes were derived from the merging of bacteria and archaea. In all these scenarios, life evolved from simple prokaryotes to complex eukaryotes. We argue here that these models are biased by overconfidence in molecular phylogenies and prejudices regarding the primitive nature of prokaryotes. We propose instead a universal tree of life with the root in the eukaryotic branch and suggest that many prokaryotic features of the information processing mechanisms originated by simplification through gene loss and non-orthologous displacement.

Eubacterial phylogeny based on translational apparatus proteins

Lateral gene transfers are frequent among prokaryotes, although their detection remains difficult. If all genes are equally affected, this questions the very existence of an organismal phylogeny. The complexity hypothesis postulates the existence of a core of genes (those involved in numerous interactions) that are unaffected by transfers. To test the hypothesis, we studied all the proteins involved in translation from 45 eubacterial taxa, and developed a new phylogenetic method to detect transfers. Few of the genes studied show evidence for transfer. The phylogeny based on the genes devoid of transfer is very consistent with the ribosomal RNA tree, suggesting that an eubacterial phylogeny does exist.

The Root of the Tree of Life in the Light of the Covarion Model

Abstract. A few duplicated genes have been found useful to root the universal tree of life. Despite controversial results, the consensus led to locate the root in the eubacterial branch. However, we demonstrated (Philippe and Forterre 1999) that all these markers were in fact unsuitable for any firm conclusion, mainly because of their high level of mutational saturation, which masks a major part of the phylogenetic signal. But then, the very persistence of signal for events as early as the separation of the three domains becomes puzzling. This paradox was studied here for translation elongation factor proteins, EF-1α and EF-2, which appeared to be one of the least confusing markers. We showed that these proteins do not conform to a classical rate-across-sites pattern, as those modeled by a gamma law, but rather to a covarion-based model, because the evolutionary rate of a given position often changes between taxonomic groups. Conservation of the very ancient signal can thus be better explained by the covarion model: a substitution can occur in deep branches, and the position remains constant afterward, as ``fossilized by a change of covation. As no reconstruction method has up to now taken into account this complex model, we devised a simple method for extracting the phylogenetic signal, by considering the variability of sequence positions within predefined phylogenetic groups. We showed that noise quantitatively prevailed upon signal. Parsimony will produce erroneous topologies, because it has to minimize primarily the number of steps of the noise. In contrast, our method effectively concentrated the signal and was more suitable for inferring ancient events. We consequently found the eubacterial rooting to be presumably due to a long branch attraction artifact, because of the higher evolutionary rate of Eubacteria for these proteins. Among the two other rooting possibilities, the eukaryotic rooting appeared to be more supported, although not enough to be conclusive.

Comparison of molecular and paleontological data in diatoms suggests a major gap in the fossil record

Diatoms, unicellular eukaryotic algae with a siliceous skeleton, offer the rare advantage of displaying both an extensive fossil record and numerous extant species, thus providing the opportunity of confronting molecular and paleontological data in a protist group. A portion of the 28S ribosomal RNA was sequenced from 5 diatoms, the divergence times of which are well known. The nucleotide substitution rate was estimated in these unicellular eukaryotes and compared with the rate of multicellular eukaryotes, using a broad data base comprising metazoans and metaphytes. When using fossil record derived divergence times, our results show that the nucleotide substitution rate is about 5 times faster in diatoms than in chordates. But, when using the relative rate test, it is observed that, over a long time period, the nucleotide substitution rate may in fact have been slightly slower in diatoms than in chordates. For this contradiction, two possible explanations are proposed: (i) a failure of the relative rate test, (ii) a gap in the pre‐Jurassic diatom fossil record. We have checked that our results concerning the relative rate test were valid. Thus, the second hypothesis, which implies pre‐Jurassic diatom evolution, in fact already suggested by some non‐molecular evidences, is favoured. Decoupling of morphological differentiation from genetic speciation also appears to have occurred and may account in part for the underestimation of the dates of recent cladogenesis events.

The evolutionary history of ribosomal protein RpS14:: horizontal gene transfer at the heart of the ribosome

We thank P. Lopez for critical reading of the manuscript. Sequences made available prior to publication by Chicago University, The Institute of Genome Research, Joint Genome Initiative, Sanger Center and Washington Genome Initiative, Sanger Center and Washington University are acknowledged.

The pitfalls of molecular phylogeny based on four species, as illustrated by the Cetacea/Artiodactyla relationships

We study the reliability of phylogeny based on four taxa, when the internal, ancestral, branch is short. Such a quartet approach has been broadly used for inferring phylogenetic patterns. The question of branching pattern between the suborders Ruminantia and Suiformes (order Artiodactyla) and the order Cetacea is chosen as an example. All the combinations of four taxa were generated by taking on and only one species per group under study (three ingroups and one outgroup). Using real sequences, the analysis of these combinations demonstrates that the quartet approach is seriously misleading. Using both maximum parsimony and distance methods, it is possible to find a quartet of species which provided a high bootstrap proportion for each of the three possible unrooted trees. With the same set of sequences, we used all the available species simultaneously to construct a molecular phylogeny. This approach proved much more reliable than the quartet approach. When the number of informative sites is rather low, the branching patterns are not supported through bootstrap analysis, preventing us from false inference due to the lack of information. The reliable resolution of the phylogenetic relationships among Ruminantia, Suiformes, and Cetacea will therefore require a large number of nucleotides, such as the complete mitochondrial genomes of at least 30 species.

Identification of putative chromosomal origins of replication in Archaea.

Recently, Novak et al. (1998, Mol Microbiol 29: 1285±1296) reported their investigation on the phenomenon of penicillin tolerance in Streptococcus pneumoniae. A library of mutants in pneumococcal surface proteins was screened for the ability to survive in the presence of 10 ́ the minimum inhibitory concentration of antibiotic. A mutant harbouring an insertion in the known gene psaA was isolated among 10 candidate tolerance mutants. Inactivation of psaA was previously shown to result in reduced virulence of S. pneumoniae (as judged by intranasal or intraperitoneal challenge of mice) and in reduced adherence to A549 cells (type II pneumocytes), leading to the suggestion that PsaA was an adhesin (Berry and Paton, 1996, Infect Immun 64: 5255±5262). This gene is part of the psa locus (Fig. 1) that encodes an ATP-binding cassette (ABC) permease belonging to cluster 9, a family of ABC metal permeases (Dintilhac et al., 1997, Mol Microbiol 25: 727±740). Novak et al. (1998, Mol Microbiol 29: 1285±1296) reported that psa mutants displayed pleiotropic phenotypes: (i) reduced sensitivity to the lytic and killing effects of penicillin; (ii) growth in chains of 40±50 (psaC ) to 200±300 (psaD ) cells; (iii) autolysis defect and loss of sensitivity to low concentrations of deoxycholate (DOC), a species characteristic trait; (iv) absence of LytA, the major autolytic amidase; (v) almost complete loss of choline-binding proteins (ChBPs) (psaC and psaD ) and absence of CbpA; (vi) loss of transformability (except psaA); and (vii) manganese (Mn) requirement for growth in a chemically de®ned medium. Because penicillin tolerance was ®rst associated with an autolysis defect (Tomasz et al., 1970, Nature 227: 138± 140), the absence of LytA (phenotype iv) could itself explain phenotypes i and iii. Dysregulation of lytA could not be investigated because, according to Novak et al. (1998, Mol Microbiol 29: 1285±1296), the dif®culty in lysing psa mutant cells prohibited Northern analysis, although lysates of the psa mutants could be obtained for immunoblot analysis of LytA and of RecA and for Southern con®rmation of the psa mutations. Nevertheless, because expression of the lytA gene has been shown to be driven by three different promoters, including Pb which is the recA basal promoter (Mortier-BarrieÁre et al., 1998, Mol Microbiol 27: 159±170), and because wild-type levels of RecA were detected in the psa mutants (Novak et al., 1998, Mol Microbiol 29: 1285±1296), it seems dif®cult to account for the complete absence of LytA on the basis of altered expression. On the other hand, phenotypes i±iv are reminiscent of alterations observed after the replacement of choline (Ch) by ethanolamine (EA) in the cell wall of pneumococcus (Tomasz, 1968, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 59: 86±93). Similar phenotypes were also displayed by Ch-independent mutants of S. pneumoniae (Severin et al., 1997, Microb Drug Res 3: 391±400; Yother et al., 1998, J Bacteriol 180: 2093±2101). S. pneumoniae has a nutritional requirement for Ch that is incorporated by covalent bonds into the cell wall teichoic acids (TA) and in the membrane-bound lipoteichoic acid (LTA). Ch residues bound to TA (ChTA) were shown to be absolutely required for LytA activity (Holtje and Tomasz, 1975; J Biol Chem 250: 6072±6076). The action of LytA has long been thought to be restricted to pneumococcal cell walls because of this requirement. However, recent reports suggest that ChTA is required Molecular Microbiology (1999) 32(4), 881±891