Hiromi Ohtani

The ZZ/ZW sex-determining mechanism originated twice and independently during evolution of the frog, Rana rugosa

The Japanese frog, Rana rugosa, has two distinct sex chromosome types, XX/XY and ZZ/ZW. These two types are found in localized groups, separated geographically by a boundary area predicted to lie somewhere around Lake Biwa in central Japan. To determine this precise boundary, the heterogametic sex of 18 populations around Lake Biwa was examined by genotyping sex-linked genes. Phylogenetic relationships between the populations were also analyzed using mitochondrial 12S rRNA gene. Results showed that the Suzuka-Kii mountain range located east of Lake Biwa separated the XX/XY populations from the ZZ/ZW populations. Unexpectedly, from a phylogenetic perspective, the ZZ/ZW populations around Lake Biwa belonged not to the main ZW group but to the XY group. The authors propose that the ZZ/ZW populations around Lake Biwa diverged secondarily from the XX/XY group through a change of heterogametic sex, eventually forming a new group. This group was thus named the ‘Neo-ZW group’. As the main ZW group inhabiting northwestern Japan is known to have a different male heterogametic origin, this finding shows that change of heterogametic sex from male to female may have occurred twice, and independently, during the frog speciation.

Role of aromatase and androgen receptor expression in gonadal sex differentiation of ZW/ZZ-type frogs, Rana rugosa

To elucidate the mechanisms of amphibian gonadal sex differentiation, we examined the expression of aromatase and androgen receptor (AR) mRNAs for days 17-31 after fertilization. The effects of inhibitors and sex steroid hormones were also examined. In ZZ males, expression of AR decreased after day 19, while aromatase expression was low throughout the sampling period. Males treated with 17beta-estradiol (E2) showed increasing aromatase expression after day 21, and formed ovaries. AR antagonist treatment also induced high-level aromatase expression and ovarian differentiation. In males co-treated with an aromatase inhibitor and E2, the undifferentiated gonads developed into testes despite high-level aromatase expression. Males treated with androgen and E2 before and during an estrogen sensitive period, respectively, also formed testes. In ZW females, AR expression persisted at a low-level, while aromatase expression increased after day 18. Short-term treatment with an aromatase inhibitor was ineffective in preventing ovarian differentiation, whereas long-term treatment resulted in testes developing from ovarian structure. Compared with the ZZ males and ZW females, WW females did not exhibit detectable expression of AR, suggesting that the active AR gene(s) itself, or a putative gene regulating AR gene expression, is located on Z chromosomes. From the time lag of aromatase expression between ZW females and ZZ males treated with E2 and the effect of AR antagonist, it was found that in males elevated AR expression suppresses aromatase expression directly or indirectly. Consequently, endogenous androgens, accumulated by blocking estrogen biosynthesis, induced testicular differentiation. The gonadogenesis of males is dependent on sex hormone, whereas that of females has evolved to hormone-independence.

Structural differences between XX and ZW sex lampbrush chromosomes in Rana rugosa females (Anura: Ranidae).

In this study we investigated the morphology and pairing behavior of sex lampbrush chromosomes of XX and ZW females ofRana rugosa from five localities in Japan. Whereas lampbrush chromosomes of XX females from Hiroshima and Isehara had subterminally located centromeres and showed remarkable similarity, those of XX females from Hamakita had the centromeres in the middle. Analysis of landmark configurations revealed that chromosome Xq of Hamakita females closely resembled a part of Xq of Hiroshima and Isehara females, whereas Xp of Hamakita females was inverted compared with the other part of Xq of Hiroshima and Isehara females. Z chromosomes from Kanazawa and Niigata closely resembled the Hiroshima X, whereas the W closely resembled the Hamakita X. XX pairings from Hiroshima, Iserara, and Hamakita were found to be joined by one to four chiasmata at various points all along the axis in both the short and long arms, whereas chromosomal pairs from Kanazawa and Niigata showed only one chiasma between Zp and the distal region of Wq. From these findings we conclude that (1) both the W and the Hamakita X must have evolved from the more primitive Hiroshima and Isehara X chromosomes by a series of pericentric inversions; and (2) females distributed in Hamakita possess two X chromosomes similar to the W, suggesting that either sex-determining or sexmodifying genes on the Hamakita X are clearly different from those on the Kanazawa and Niigata W chromosome.

Evidence for two successive pericentric inversions in sex lampbrush chromosomes of Rana rugosa (Anura: Ranidae)

Abstract.The objective of this study was to clarify the course of inversions by which a ZW sex chromosome dimorphism has become established in Rana rugosa. Fortunately, R. rugosa preserves three different forms of sex chromosomes in the several isolated populations. In both males and females, the homomorphic sex chromosomes from Hiroshima were closely similar to Z, while those from Isehara were slightly different from the Z. Females from Hirosaki demonstrated heteromorphic sex chromosomes. In this study, the configuration and pairing behavior of sex lampbrush chromosomes were examined in the female offspring produced from a cross between a female from Hiroshima and a male from Isehara, as well as the female offspring of a female from Hirosaki and the male from Isehara. For the sex lampbrush chromosomes from Hiroshima and Isehara, chiasmata were exclusively formed between the distal regions of the long arms of one sex chromosome and the terminal regions of the short arms of the other. As a result, landmarks arranged in reverse order were observed in the achiasmatic regions of these chromosomes. For the sex lampbrush chromosomes from Isehara and Hirosaki, on the other hand, chiasma formation was mainly confined to the lower half of the chromosomes corresponding to the long arms, and the landmarks in the achiasmatic regions of these chromosomes were disposed in the opposite direction to each other. These results seem to indicate that in the primitive sex chromosomes of the Hiroshima type two pericentric inversions occurred, leading to the differentiation of the W chromosomes. This is the first report to substantiate the process of sex chromosome differentiation experimentally.

The prototype of sex chromosomes found in Korean populations of Rana rugosa

The seventh largest chromosome in Japanese populations of the frog Rana rugosa morphologically evolved as a sex chromosome. The sex chromosome is XX/XY type in one geographic form and ZZ/ZW type in another. In contrast, the seventh chromosomes are still homomorphic between the sexes in the other two geographic forms: they are more subtelocentric in the Kanto form and subtelocentric in the western Japanese form. To identify a prototype of the sex chromosomes, we extended our investigation in this study to the Korean form, which is supposed to be close to the phylogenetic origin of this species. The karyotype, a sex-linked gene sequence, and mecha- nisms of sex determination and gonadal differentiation were all examined. In addition, phylogenetic analyses were performed based on mitochondrial gene sequences and the results of crossings between the Korean and Japanese forms. As a consequence, the more subtelocentric seventh chromosome, shared by the Korean and Japanese Kanto forms, was concluded to be the prototype of the sex chromosomes. Starting at the prototype, a whole process of morphological sex chromosome evolution was reconstructed.

Mechanism of chromosome elimination in the hybridogenetic spermatogenesis of allotriploid males between Japanese and European water frogs

Of 21 allotriploid males that possessed two genomes of Rana nigromaculata and one genome of Rana lessonae 10 produced a large number of spermatozoa in their testes. When 4 of these males were backcrossed with a female of R. nigromaculata, all of the resulting froglets were diploid in chromosome number and were completely R. nigromaculata type in appearance. These allotriploid males proved to have produced spermatozoa with one R. nigromaculata genome hybridogentically. Therefore, their germ line cells were investigated for the mechanism of elimination of their R. lessonae chromosomes. In histologicla sections of testes, the great majority of spermatogonia (approximately 104 cells) between mitotic prometaphase and anaphase appeared normal in chromosome behavior, whereas 17 spermatogonia showed several chromosomes whose behavior deviated from the normal course during the same period. These deviant chromosomes concentrated together near the equatorial plate and remained stationary at anaphase. In metaphase chromosome preparations made from spermatogonia, 67 and 185 of the 477 chromosome spreads were diploid and triploid, respectively. The rest were aneuploid. Notably, 8 triploid spreads consisted of 26 or more normal chromosomes and 13 or fewer degenerate chromosomes. From these results it is concluded that a set of R. lessonae chromosomes is eliminated from some, but not all spermatogonia by becoming degenerate during the mitotic period.

Alteration of the Sex Determining System Resulting From Structural Change of the Sex Chromosomes in the Frog Rana rugosa

Rana rugosa in Japan is divided into four geographical races on the basis of the karyotype of the sex chromosomes: one in which heteromorphic sex chromosomes occur in the female sex (ZW/ZZ-system), another in which they are present in males (XX/XY-system), and the remaining two in which no heteromorphism is seen in either sex. The last two inherit the XX/XY sex determining system. Y and Z chromosomes in the former two are of the same karyotype as the no. 7 chromosomes seen in one of the latter two, whereas X and W are caused by two inversions that occurred in the original Xs (no. 7). In this study, we first attempted to detect the structural difference between the resulting X and W by examining their chiasma formation. The chiasma distribution between X and W was closely similar to that between two Xs, suggesting that the W and X are identical in structure. Regarding the change from XX/XY- to ZW/ZZ-system, the simplest explanation is that the putative female-determining gene(s) on the W grew functionally stronger by inversions. Next, we examined the sex of triploids having two Xs and one Z. The data showed that the triploids with two original Xs and a Z were all male, whereas most of those with two resulting Xs and a Z developed into females as expected. We speculated that the female-determining gene(s) on the resulting X grew mildly stronger functionally by position effect, whereas those on the W grew much stronger for some other reason (e.g., duplication). J. Exp. Zool. 286:313-319, 2000.

Phyletic Diversity in the Frog Rana rugosa (Anura: Ranidae) with Special Reference to a Unique Morphotype Found from Sado Island, Japan

Abstract: We investigated a sample of apparently unique frogs from Sado Island, Japan. While being tentatively identified to Rana rugosa on the basis of general morphological resemblance, this form (yellow type) differs from the typical Japanese R. rugosa by showing deep yellow or orange coloration in abdomen and the ventral surfaces of legs, and by having much smoother skin on the entire body. For the Japanese populations of Rana rugosa, following four genetic forms are currently recognized: Kanto form (around Tokyo and northeastern Japan), Western Japan form (western Japan), XY form (central Japan), and ZW form (northwestern Japan). Of these, the latter two forms bear differentiated sex chromosomes of XX/XY and ZZ/ZW types, respectively, and are assumed to have originated through hybridizations between the former two forms. In order to infer the phylogenetic affinity of the yellow type from Sado Island, we examined the karyotype and also analyzed the mitochondrial gene sequences. Our results strongly suggested that the yellow type had originated from the ancestral lineage of the Kanto form early in the divergence of R. rugosa in Japan, achieving genetic characteristics of its own. Also, the results suggested distant affinity of the ZW form to the yellow type, despite their geographic proximity.

Evolutionary Changes in Sensitivity to Hormonally Induced Gonadal Sex Reversal in a Frog Species

The Japanese frog Glandirana rugosa is unique in that it shows geographic variation in sex chromosome differentiation and heterogametic sex determination. To elucidate the cause of interpopulation differences in gonadal sex differentiation, we investigated hormonally induced sex reversal and the expression patterns of genes associated with sex determination during early tadpole development. We found that sex reversal was easily induced in XX females and XY males of 2 forms (West-Japan and East-Japan) of G. rugosa with the ancestral homomorphic sex chromosomes under male heterogametic sex determination. During sex reversal, expression of CYP19 and/or FOXL2 was dependent on the phenotypic sex of the gonad. In contrast, sex reversal was not induced in ZW females of a population with a heteromorphic ZW sex chromosome system or in XX females or XY males in a population with a heteromorphic XY sex chromosome system. The latter 2 populations are evolutionarily derived forms. These results indicate an evolutionary direction for the gonadal sex differentiation mechanism. The original system was highly sensitive to sex hormones and allowed almost complete sex reversal. From this ancestral form, a new system evolved that was resistant to hormones and showed a change in the heterogametic sex and the sex chromosome differentiation mechanism.

Amphidiploidy recovers the viability of hybrids of European and east Asian water frogs.

Reciprocal diploid hybrids, artificially produced from crosses between Rana nigromaculata and Rana lessonae, die at the stage from neurula to tailbud. We found in a previous study that triploid hybrids having two R. nigromaculata genomes and one R. lessonae genome in R. nigromaculata cytoplasm grow into mature frogs, whereas triploid hybrids composed of the other combinations of genome and cytoplasm arrest before hatching. In this study, we made amphidiploid hybrids with two R. nigromaculata and two R. lessonae genomes in the cytoplasm of either species and examined their viability to discover the interaction between parental genomes in each cytoplasm. The amphidiploids with R. nigromaculata cytoplasm developed into mature frogs, whereas ones with R. lessonae cytoplasm arrested at almost the same embryo stage as the lethal triploid hybrids. These findings suggest that the arrest of the reciprocal diploid hybrids is not caused only by the incompatibility between the R. nigromaculata genome and the R. lessonae genome. Taking these together with the results of the triploid hybrids, we suppose that the lethality of the hybrids is mainly due to the incompatibility between the egg cytoplasm and foreign genome(s). With the R. nigromaculata cytoplasm, doubling the maternal genome can ease this incompatibility, but it cannot with the R. lessonae cytoplasm.