Hiromi Yamagawa

Restoration of semi-natural forest after clearcutting of conifer plantations in Japan

We reviewed recent studies on the restoration of semi-natural forests after clearcutting of conifer plantations with specific reference to the importance of setting restoration goals, general and specific factors influencing restoration, and the prediction and judgment of successful restoration. For the restoration of semi-natural forests following the clearcutting of conifer plantations, recovery levels and appropriate restoration methods cannot be considered separately from the aims of restoration to provide ecosystem services. Restoration needs to be based on the setting of goals that correspond to the type and degree of ecosystem services targeted. When we aim to restore vegetation dominated by late-seral canopy trees within as short a period after the clearcutting of conifer plantations as possible, advanced regeneration in the pre-logged plantation is the most important and reliable source of post-logging regeneration, just as it is in the recovery of disturbed non-plantation forests. Advanced regeneration is not always present in plantations. Seedling establishment by seed rain from adjacent natural forest patches after a disturbance can contribute to late-seral or canopy species; however, the range of the edge effect is generally short, and the degree of the edge effect depends on the natural forest type and is more pronounced in deciduous forests, such as those in cool-temperate climates, or in forests with a complex forest structure. Thus, advanced regeneration is a better predictor of short-term forest recovery than measures based on seed rain from adjacent seed sources. However, restoration achieved only through advanced regeneration can simplify the species composition, and the recolonization processes of gradual species accession from seeds should be considered in the long-term context of restoration.

The role of different sources of tree regeneration in the initial stages of natural forest recovery after logging of conifer plantation in a warm-temperate region

We analyzed the role of regeneration type (surviving from advanced regeneration, resprouting from advanced regeneration, or newly recruited seedlings) in determining the quantity and quality of individuals in reestablishing a natural forest following clear-cutting of a conifer plantation. We experimentally clear-cut a plantation and undertook a detailed tree census before and after clear-cutting. After clear-cutting, a species composition partially representing warm-temperate evergreen broadleaf forest was present in the form of surviving and resprouted individuals originating from advanced regeneration that had established in the Chamaecyparis obtusa plantation. On the other hand, seedlings that established after clear-cutting were dominated by pioneer species, and the number of seedlings was far greater than the number of individuals originating from advanced regeneration. Our results suggest that the role of regeneration type would differ in relation to the objectives for forest recovery. When any kind of woody cover of the ground surface after clear-cutting would suffice, we suggest that the contribution of pioneer seedlings originating from buried seeds would be important. If the recovery objective is to form a simple evergreen broadleaf forest, such as a coppice woodland, all three sources of regeneration would play a similar role, provided the understory before clear-cutting was as well developed as the one in this study. If rapid establishment of a lucidophyllous forest with diverse species composition is desired, the role of the surviving and resprouting individuals originating from the advanced regeneration would be much more important.

Effects of topography and management history on natural forest recovery in abandoned forest after clear-cutting in Miyazaki, Japan

We investigated factors limiting the recovery of natural forest in former large-scale conifer plantations abandoned after clear-cutting in southwestern Japan. We analyzed forest recovery status (“recovered” sites covered by evergreen broad-leaved trees, and “unrecovered” sites covered by pioneer community or nonvegetated sites) using aerial photographs and field survey. We applied logistic regression analyses to evaluate the effects of topography, construction of harvesting roads, distance from remnant forest, stand condition before clear-cutting, and prior land-use history on forest recovery. Human factors, i.e., land use and clear-cutting age, were found to affect to forest recovery more than environmental factors such as topography. Harvesting roads had the strongest negative impact on forest recovery. Forest recovery after clear-cutting of young sugi plantations also took longer than after clear-cutting of old sugi plantations or evergreen broad-leaved forests. Furthermore, areas formerly utilized as meadows recovered less successfully than those that had been managed as coppices. The influences of these factors were thought to be promoted by the advance reproduction as the regeneration sources for forest recovery. The influence of stand age before logging suggested an effect of thinning, which might alter the abundance of advanced reproduction in the understory. However, distance from remnant forest appeared to be less important. An influence of topography was also detected, but this could be partly explained by the existence of advance reproduction in the understory in certain topographic positions. Thus, our analysis suggests that regeneration sources originating from advanced reproduction in plantations play a significant role for the recovery of natural forest after clear-cutting.

Early establishment of broadleaved trees after logging of Cryptomeria japonica and Chamaecyparis obtusa plantations with different understory treatments

We studied the effects of the amount of advanced regeneration before logging and different understory treatments on forest recovery, particularly the establishment of lucidophyllous (evergreen broadleaved) species, following the logging of conifer plantation with a focus on the sprouting ability. The establishment of lucidophyllous tree and shrub species originating from advanced regeneration was closely related to the total amount of these elements in the advanced regeneration, regardless of understory treatment. The understory-left treatment could preserve understory as surviving individuals by high proportion (60% or more of the understory) compared with the understory-cleared practice after logging. However, half of the surviving individuals were damaged to some extent by logging and skidding. Relatively large trees were likely to survive with no damage, indicating that they face a lower risk than smaller trees. In understory-cleared stands, a high proportion (60% or more) of the understory regenerated by resprouting. However, the resprouting ratio depended on tree size and species. Therefore, as well as the amount of the understory, the tree size of understory before logging would be also an important factor for early forest recovery. Further, the infrequent (low-density) species could easily disappear after logging because of their low resprouting ratio and low density. Thus, recovery from resprouting alone would risk simplification of the species composition after logging. We concluded that leaving the developed understory intact before logging can enhance the speed and biodiversity of forest recovery.