Hughlett L. Morris

Correspondence between Nasalance Scores and Listener Judgments of Hypernasality and Hyponasality

The relationship between nasalance scores and perceptual judgments of hypernasality and hyponasality was examined for 74 subjects (51 with cleft palate and 23 noncleft controls). Twenty-nine of the 51 subjects with cleft palate had received pharyngeal flap surgery. Predictive analyses were performed to assess the sensitivity, specificity, and efficiency of the Nasometer as a screening instrument. The overall relationship between perceptual judgments of hypernasality and nasalance scores was good for the nonflap subjects when a nasalance cutoff score of 26 was used. A sensitivity coefficient of 0.87 and a specificity coefficient of 0.93 were obtained. Ninety-one percent of the nasometry-based classifications accurately reflected listener judgments of hypernasality. The correspondence between nasalance scores and clinical judgments of hyponasality was also good for the nonflap subjects when a nasalance cutoff score of 50 was used. Ninety-one percent of these classifications were consistent with the listener judgments. Efficiency of nasometry was poorer for the flap subjects.

Late Results of Primary Veloplasty: The Marburg Project

Forty-five randomly selected patients with unilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate, all operated upon by Dr. Wolfram Schweckendiek were evaluated by three American specialists to assess the validity of primary veloplasty. Examination revealed an unusually high incidence of short palate and poor mobility of the soft palate. Facial growth was found to be highly acceptable in the majority of the patients. Unusually high incidence of velopharyngeal incompetence was found in these patients.

Clinical results of pharyngeal flap surgery: the Iowa experience.

Sixty-five patients with cleft palate, with or without cleft lip, who received previous pharyngeal flap surgery for chronic velopharyngeal dysfunction in our department, were examined for velopharyngeal status, speech production patterns, and evidence of nasal airway obstruction. Of the 65 subjects, 54 (83.1 percent) showed velopharyngeal function within normal limits, 43 (66.1 percent) showed normal or near-normal speech production, and 58 (89.2 percent) reported snoring sometimes or often. Of the 58 reporting snoring, electrocardiogram (ECG) data for 33 were examined for evidence of right ventricular hypertrophy. Only one (3 percent) of the 33 showed such possible indication. We conclude that by our methods, pharyngeal flap surgery is an effective treatment for velopharyngeal dysfunction. After surgery, patients may report symptoms of nasal airway obstruction during sleep but are not expected to show ECG changes in cardiac function resulting from oxygen deprivation.

Results of multidisciplinary management of bilateral cleft lip and palate at the Iowa Cleft Palate Center

Bilateral cleft of the lip and palate is by many standards the most complex and severe form of the defect. The complexity and severity of the defect require an unusual degree of cooperation among all specialists and especially between the surgeon and the orthodontist. There are no published findings that we know about in which comprehensive data from a number of disciplines are reported for the same group of bilateral cleft patients. Fifty randomly selected patients with bilateral complete clefts were examined by the Iowa team and two orthodontists from other institutions. The evaluations revealed that a large number of patients over the age of 10 have multiple residual problems requiring further treatment. Only 23 percent of the older patients studied were judged to have had treatment completed by the surgeon, speech pathologist, and orthodontist. It is very difficult to state whether the results obtained by our team can be considered satisfactory because there are no comparable studies that have attempted to evaluate the same parameters in multidisciplinary management.

Multidisciplinary treatment results for patients with isolated cleft palate.

Fifty-eight patients with cleft palate only who had received treatment in the Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery at the University of Iowa were examined for treatment results. Forty-one (70.7 percent) of the 58 patients showed a syndrome or suggestive factors. An unusually high percentage (36 percent) of the 58 patients required secondary surgery for velopharyngeal dysfunction or showed indications for surgery at examination. Some but not all of the relatively low success rate appears related to surgical experience. Speech proficiency, hearing acuity, and dental status were within normal limits or nearly so. The 20 patients with pharyngeal flap surgery were doing well, with minimal indications of functional obstruction.

Long-term speech results of cleft palate patients with primary palatoplasty.

This investigation examined the influence of cleft type, type of surgery, age at surgery, and gender on speech proficiency of 204 patients with cleft palate who required only primary palatoplasty. Speech measures were obtained for each subject from at least three annual examinations between the ages of 4 and 16 years. Neither age at surgery nor type of surgery were discriminating factors. The less extensive cleft type, i.e., soft palate only, was associated with greater rates of change in the performance variables than were the other three cleft types. Females showed greater rate changes than males.

Communication Status following Laryngectomy: The Iowa Experience 1984–1987

Data regarding treatment and outcome for a consecutive series of 73 total laryngectomy patients were collected from clinical records with a follow-up period of 30 to 78 months postoperatively. Notable findings were that 27% were women; 75% reported hoarseness or a voice change as an early symptom; and 22% reported combined heavy use of both cigarettes and alcohol. Of the 73 patients, 38 (52%) died during the follow-up period; 18 of the 38 died within 1 year postoperatively. Thirty-nine (53%) of the 73 had received a surgical tracheoesophageal fistula (TEF) for voice restoration, as either a primary or a secondary procedure. Of the 39, 75 % were using the TEF at last examination, with no failures attributed to sphincter spasm. Of the total group, the primary communication modality was reported to be use of a TEF by 44% and use of an electrolarynx by 50%. Limitations of the study and directions for future investigations are discussed.

Velar-pharyngeal status in cleft palate patients with expected adenoidal involution.

This study was designed to provide information about whether cleft palate patients with hypertrophied adenoids maintain velarpharyngeal contact during the time of expected adenoidal atrophy. Thirty-nine subjects were selected from a large longitudinal study on the basis of availability of lateral still x-ray films taken in series from 5 to 16 years of age. Ratings of velar-pharyngeal contact and ratings of adenoid size were obtained from the films. The obtained data indicated the expected decrease in adenoid size but also, for the group, maintenance of velar-pharyngeal contact. However, three of the 39 subjects were judged to show loss of such contact during the period of study, and an additional four had surgery for velopharyngeal incompetence after the completion of the study. All seven appeared to show significant deterioration of velopharyngeal status in middle or late adolescence. Implications of these findings are discussed.

In utero cleft palate repair in the ovine model.

Cleft lip and palate defects assume many forms from mild to severe, but all may be associated with abnormal craniofacial development. Even the most expert and sophisticated methods of surgical repair are followed by scar contraction and fibrosis, which result in skeletal defects, dental abnormalities, cosmetic disfigurement, and speech impairment. Recent clinical and experimental observations that fetal cutaneous wounds heal without scarring are of great potential interest in the management of cleft lip and palate. The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of prenatal repair of iatrogenically produced cleft palate on scar formation in the fetal lamb model. Ten ewes were operated on ranging in gestation from 70 to 133 days. Fifteen lambs were studied (nine cleft palates produced and repaired in utero; one cleft produced in utero and not repaired, four normal, unoperated palates; and one cleft palate produced and repaired 1 week postnatally). The lambs were delivered normally at 145 to 147 days gestation and maintained with the ewe until 1 month of age. The lambs were euthanized, and the surgical area of the palates studied grossly and histologically. Animals operated at 112 days or later in gestation exhibited scars both clinically and histologically. The animals that had cleft palate produced and repaired at 70 days gestation did not have a visible palatal scar at 1 month of age. Histologically, there was evidence of minimal scarring without disruption of normal architecture. Studies are underway to determine the impact of reduced scarring on craniofacial growth after palatal repair during mid gestation in the ovine model.

A Comparison of Oral-Nasal Balance Patterns in Speakers Who Are Categorized as “Almost but Not Quite” and “Sometimes but Not Always”

Objective The purpose of this study was to determine whether amplitude or temporal patterns of oral-nasal balance differentiate speakers with cleft palate who are classified as belonging to the “almost but not quite” (ABNQ) and “sometimes but not always” (SBNA) subgroups of marginal velopharyngeal inadequacy. Design The nasal accelerometric vibrational index (NAVI) was used to measure amplitude and temporal aspects of oral-nasal balance during the productions of oral and nasal syllables, words, and sentences. NAVI measures obtained include mean amplitude, time integral (area under the curve), duration, rise time, and fall time. Setting Tertiary care center for patients with cleft palate–craniofacial anomalies. Participants Seventeen patients with repaired cleft palate who were assigned by perceptual assessment to the ABNQ subgroup and 17 patients who were assigned to the SBNA subgroup. Results No differences were found between the ABNQ and SBNA subgroups with regard to patterns of nasalization. Further analysis as a function of level of production and phonetic context revealed no differences between the subgroups. Conclusions Although clinicians may report perceived differences in the resonance patterns of speakers who fall within the category of marginal velopharyngeal inadequacy, further division into the ABNQ and SBNA subgroups has yet to be validated.