Hugo Lavoie

Regulation of RAF protein kinases in ERK signalling

RAF family kinases were among the first oncoproteins to be described more than 30 years ago. They primarily act as signalling relays downstream of RAS, and their close ties to cancer have fuelled a large number of studies. However, we still lack a systems-level understanding of their regulation and mode of action. The recent discovery that the catalytic activity of RAF depends on an allosteric mechanism driven by kinase domain dimerization is providing a vital new piece of information towards a comprehensive model of RAF function. The fact that current RAF inhibitors unexpectedly induce ERK signalling by stimulating RAF dimerization also calls for a deeper structural characterization of this family of kinases.

Inhibitors that stabilize a closed RAF kinase domain conformation induce dimerization

RAF kinases play a prominent role in cancer. Their mode of activation is complex, but critically requires dimerization of their kinase domains. Unexpectedly, several ATP-competitive RAF inhibitors were recently found to promote dimerization and transactivation of RAF kinases in a RAS-dependent manner and as a result undesirably stimulate RAS/ERK-mediated cell growth. The mechanism by which these inhibitors induce RAF kinase domain dimerization remains unclear. Here we describe BRET-based biosensors for the extended RAF family enabling the detection of RAF dimerization in living cells. Notably, we demonstrate the utility of these tools for profiling kinase inhibitors that selectively modulate RAF dimerization as well as for probing structural determinants of RAF dimerization in vivo. Our findings, which appear generalizable to other kinase families allosterically regulated by kinase domain dimerization, suggest a model whereby ATP-competitive inhibitors mediate RAF dimerization by stabilizing a rigid closed conformation of the kinase domain.

Increased Respiration in the sch9Δ Mutant Is Required for Increasing Chronological Life Span but Not Replicative Life Span

ABSTRACT Loss of the protein kinase Sch9p increases both the chronological life span (CLS) and the replicative life span (RLS) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by mimicking calorie restriction, but the physiological consequences of SCH9 deletion are poorly understood. By transcriptional profiling of an sch9Δ mutant, we show that mitochondrial electron transport chain genes are upregulated. Accordingly, protein levels of electron transport chain subunits are increased and the oxygen consumption rate is enhanced in the sch9Δ mutant. Deletion of HAP4 and CYT1, both of which are essential for respiration, revert the sch9Δ mutant respiratory rate back to a lower-than-wild-type level. These alterations of the electron transport chain almost completely blocked CLS extension by the sch9Δ mutation but had a minor impact on the RLS. SCH9 thus negatively regulates the CLS and RLS through inhibition of respiratory genes, but a large part of its action on life span seems to be respiration independent and might involve increased resistance to stress. Considering that TOR1 deletion also increases respiration and that Sch9p is a direct target of TOR signaling, we propose that SCH9 is one of the major effectors of TOR repression of respiratory activity in glucose grown cells.

Inhibition of RAS function through targeting an allosteric regulatory site

RAS GTPases are important mediators of oncogenesis in humans. However, pharmacological inhibition of RAS has proved challenging. Here we describe a functionally critical region, located outside the effector lobe of RAS, that can be targeted for inhibition. We developed NS1, a synthetic binding protein (monobody) that bound with high affinity to both GTP- and GDP-bound states of H-RAS and K-RAS but not N-RAS. NS1 potently inhibited growth factor signaling and oncogenic H-RAS- and K-RAS-mediated signaling and transformation but did not block oncogenic N-RAS, BRAF or MEK1. NS1 bound the α4-β6-α5 region of RAS, which disrupted RAS dimerization and nanoclustering and led to blocking of CRAF-BRAF heterodimerization and activation. These results establish the importance of the α4-β6-α5 interface in RAS-mediated signaling and define a previously unrecognized site in RAS for inhibiting RAS function.

Dimerization-induced allostery in protein kinase regulation

The ability of protein kinases to switch between inactive and active states is critical to control the outputs of cellular signaling pathways. In several protein kinases, the conformation of helix αC is a key hub on which regulatory inputs converge to induce catalytic switching. An emerging mechanism involved in regulating helix αC orientation is the allosteric coupling with kinase domain surfaces involved in homo- or heterodimerization. In this review, we discuss dimerization-mediated regulation of the rapidly accelerated fibrosarcoma (RAF) and eIF2α kinase families and draw parallels with the analogous behavior of the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and serine/threonine-protein kinase endoribonuclease 1 (IRE1)/ribonuclease L (RNAse L) kinase families. Given that resistance to RAF-targeted therapeutics often stems from dimerization-dependent mechanisms, we suggest that a better understanding of dimerization-induced allostery may assist in developing alternate therapeutic strategies.

The R1 subunit of herpes simplex virus ribonucleotide reductase has chaperone-like activity similar to Hsp27.

HSV‐2 R1, the R1 subunit of herpes simplex virus (HSV) ribonucleotide reductase, protects cells against apoptosis. Here, we report the presence in HSV‐2 R1 of a stretch exhibiting similarity to the α‐crystallin domain of the small heat shock proteins, a domain known to be important for oligomerization and cytoprotective activities of these proteins. Also, the HSV‐2 R1 protein, which forms multimeric structures in the absence of nucleotide, displayed chaperone ability as good as Hsp27 in a thermal denaturation assay using citrate synthase. In contrast, mammalian R1, which does not contain an α‐crystallin domain, has neither chaperone nor anti‐apoptotic activity. Thus, we propose that the chaperone activity of HSV‐2 R1 could play an important role in viral pathogenesis.

Interdomain allosteric regulation of Polo kinase by Aurora B and Map205 is required for cytokinesis

Aurora B phosphorylation of the Polo kinase activation loop disrupts its binding to Map205 and central spindle microtubules, allowing it to be recruited to the site of cytokinesis.

Cancer: A drug-resistant duo

The efficacy of the anticancer drug vemurafenib, which is used to treat metastatic melanoma, is plagued by acquired resistance. A picture of how such resistance develops is emerging. See Letter p.387 Although recent clinical trials have shown the efficacy of B-RAF inhibitors in the treatment of melanomas with activating B-RAF mutations, the patients inevitably develop resistance. David Solit and colleagues now identify a mechanism of acquired resistance conferred by a structural change in B-RAF itself. The expression of a 61-kilodalton splice variant of mutant B-RAF leads to enhanced B-RAF dimerization, rendering it resistant to kinase inhibitors. This variant was found to be expressed in 6 of 19 patients who had developed resistance to the B-RAF inhibitor PLX4032.

Time-resolved Phosphoproteome Analysis of Paradoxical RAF Activation Reveals Novel Targets of ERK

Small molecules targeting aberrant RAF activity, like vemurafenib (PLX4032), are highly effective against cancers harboring the V600E BRAF mutation and are now approved for clinical use against metastatic melanoma. However, in tissues showing elevated RAS activity and in RAS mutant tumors, these inhibitors stimulate RAF dimerization, resulting in inhibitor resistance and downstream “paradoxical” ERK activation. To understand the global signaling response of cancer cells to RAF inhibitors, we profiled the temporal changes of the phosphoproteome of two colon cancer cell lines (Colo205 and HCT116) that respond differently to vemurafenib. Comprehensive data mining and filtering identified a total of 37,910 phosphorylation sites, 660 of which were dynamically modulated upon treatment with vemurafenib. We established that 83% of these dynamic phosphorylation sites were modulated in accordance with the phospho-ERK profile of the two cell lines. Accordingly, kinase substrate prediction algorithms linked most of these dynamic sites to direct ERK1/2-mediated phosphorylation, supporting a low off-target rate for vemurafenib. Functional classification of target proteins indicated the enrichment of known (nuclear pore, transcription factors, and RAS-RTK signaling) and novel (Rho GTPases signaling and actin cytoskeleton) ERK-controlled functions. Our phosphoproteomic data combined with experimental validation established novel dynamic connections between ERK signaling and the transcriptional regulators TEAD3 (Hippo pathway), MKL1, and MKL2 (Rho serum-response elements pathway). We also confirm that an ERK-docking site found in MKL1 is directly antagonized by overlapping actin binding, defining a novel mechanism of actin-modulated phosphorylation. Altogether, time-resolved phosphoproteomics further documented vemurafenib selectivity and identified novel ERK downstream substrates.

RAF inhibitors promote RAS-RAF interaction by allosterically disrupting RAF autoinhibition

First-generation RAF inhibitors paradoxically induce ERK signaling in normal and tumor cells exhibiting RAS activity. Compound-induced RAF dimerization through stabilization of the RAF ON/active state by inhibitors has emerged as a critical contributing factor. RAF inhibitors also enhance RAS−RAF association. Although this event is thought to play a key role in priming RAF activation, the underlying mechanism is not known. Here we report that RAF inhibitors induce the disruption of intramolecular interactions between the kinase domain and its N-terminal regulatory region independently of RAS activity. This provides a molecular basis to explain the induction of RAS−RAF association by RAF inhibitors, as well as the co-operativity observed between RAS activity and RAF kinase inhibitors in driving RAF activation. Profiling of second-generation RAF inhibitors confirmed their improved mode of action, but also revealed liabilities that allowed us to discern two properties of an ideal RAF inhibitor: high-binding affinity to all RAF paralogs and maintenance of the OFF/autoinhibited state of the enzyme.RAF family kinases transmit signals from activated RAS at the plasma membrane to downstream kinases to control cell proliferation, differentiation and survival. Here the authors shed light on the molecular mechanisms whereby small molecule RAF inhibitors induce RAS-RAF association and paradoxical RAF activation.