Ian M. Hastings

Mutation and selection within the individual

Selection within the individual may have played a critical and creative role in evolution, boosting the survival chances of mutations beneficial to the cell and the individual, hindering the spread of deleterious mutations, and reducing the genetic load imposed on the population. We review the literature and present new results to describe the effects of cell-lineage selection on the rate and fixation probability of new mutations. Cell-lineage selection can alter these quantities by several orders of magnitude. Cell-lineage selection is especially important in the case of rare recessive mutations, which are hidden from selection at the individual level but may be exposed to selection at the cellular level. Because selection within the individual acts as a sieve eliminating deleterious mutations and increasing the frequency of beneficial ones, mutations observed among progeny will have been pre-selected and are more likely to increase cell proliferation than would randomly generated mutations. Although many authors have focused on the potential conflict between selection at the cellular and individual levels, it must be much more common that the two levels act concordantly. When selection at the cell and individual levels act in a cooperative manner, increased rather than decreased opportunity for germline selection will be favored by evolution.

Manifestations of sexual selection may depend on the genetic basis of sex determination

A variant of the ‘handicap’ model of sexual selection is described which predicts that the evolution of ornate male traits occurs more easily in species where females are the heterogametic sex. The process occurs even when the alleles conferring high paternal ‘fitness’ remain advantageous for only a short time due to a rapidly changing physical or biotic environment: the timescale of this advantage may approach the gestation time of the organism. This provides an explanation as to why sexual selection in species where females are heterogametic (such as birds) occurs mainly by the elaboration of ornate male secondary sexual characteristics, whereas in species where females are homogametic (such as mammals) sexual selection results predominantly in inter-male rivalry and the evolution of traits such as horns, antlers and large body size. An analogy between the evolution of elaborate male traits and the evolution of warning coloration is noted.

The genetic basis of response in mouse lines divergently selected for body weight or fat content. I. The relative contributions of autosomal and sex-linked genes

Lines of mice have been divergently selected for over forty generations on either body weight or fat content. Reciprocal crosses were made between the divergent lines and the offspring backcrossed to the parental lines. The resulting data allowed us to investigate the genetic basis of response, including two features of particular interest: (i) the relative contribution of autosomal and sex-linked genes and whether any significant Y chromosome or cytoplasmic effects were present (ii) the mechanism of gene action, whether predominantly additive or whether significant dominance effects were present. A large additive sex-linked effect was observed in lines selected on body weight which accounted for approximately 25% of the divergence. The remaining 75% of the divergence appeared to be autosomal. There was no apparent sex-linked effect in lines selected on fat content and the response appeared to be entirely autosomal and additive.

Analysis of lines of mice selected for fat content. 2. Correlated responses in the activities of enzymes involved in lipogenesis.

Estimates of the activities (Vmax) of six enzymes involved in de novo fat synthesis were made in replicated lines of mice differing in fat content. These lines had been selected high and low for 20 generations with three replicates each of Fat, Control and Lean lines and for a further eight generations high and low as an unreplicated line. The activities of ATP-citrate lyase (ACL), acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC), fatty acid synthetase (FAS), cytoplasmic malate dehydrogenase (MDH), malic enzyme (ME) and pyruvate kinase (PK) were determined in vitro in both liver and gonadal fatpad tissues taken at ages five and ten weeks. The activities of ACL, ACC, FAS and ME were significantly higher in the Fat than the Lean lines, and the differences were more pronounced at the earlier age and in the gonadal fatpad where activities in the Fat lines were higher by factors of 3.5, 2.4, 2.5 and 3.5 respectively. The activity of PK was unchanged in each tissue. MDH activity was significantly lower in adipose tissue in the Fat lines than the Lean lines at age ten weeks but not at age five weeks or in liver tissue. Results from replicates indicated that random genetic drift affected enzyme activities but nevertheless significant changes in activity were associated with the direction of selection. The changes in enzyme activity reported here are similar to those known to be associated with major mutations causing obesity in mice.

Behavioural changes as a correlated response to selection

Lines of mice have been selected for up to 50 generations on the following traits: high body weight, low body weight, high fat content or low fat content. The lines selected for high or low body weight differ by a factor of 2.5 and those selected for high or low fat content differ by a factor of five, both traits measured in 10 week old males. A set of behavioural traits was measured to ascertain whether this selection had caused correlated responses in behaviour: studies included feeding behaviour, open field behaviour, ultrasound calling rates of pups, and the response to the introduction of a novel physical object. Alterations in behavioural patterns which were expected a priori were observed but there appeared to be no changes in behaviour associated with any one selection criterion. Estimates of the genetic correlations between selected and behavioural traits were, with one exception, generally less than 0.1 in magnitude and not significantly different from zero (the exception was food intake in lines selected on body weight). Assuming that mice are accurate models for commercial species, then these results have important implications for animal welfare: they demonstrate that large scale behavioural changes do not arise as an inevitable consequence of intense long-term selection on traits of economic importance in commercial species.

Effects of thyroid hormone deficiency on mice selected for increased and decreased body weight and fatness

A study was undertaken to test whether the elimination of metabolic pathways strongly involved in growth and fatness, comprising thyroid hormones (TH) and growth hormone (GH), is responsible for a substantial part of the genetic change produced by selection. Lines used in this study have been selected for about 50 generations for high (PH) and low (PL) body weight at 10 weeks and for high (F) and low fat content (L) at 14 weeks, producing a 3-fold difference in body weights and a 5-fold difference in fat content. Thyroid ablation was achieved by repeated backcrossing into the four selection lines of a transgene comprising the HSV1-tk gene coupled to the promoter of the thyroglobulin gene. Hemizygous pregnant dams were treated with ganciclovir leading to thyroid-ablated dams and offspring and therefore to a lack of TH and subsequently of GH. In the absence of TH and GH, lines still differ in body weight over the period studied (10 d to about 100 d; e.g. at the end PH = 32.1 g vs PL = 10.2 g) and in fat content (F = 16.2% vs L = 3.8%); the corresponding values for the wild-type controls were PH = 49.9 g vs PL = 17.4 g and F = 27.5% vs L = 4.8%. The effect of the transgene depended on the genetic background for body weights at most ages and for relative gonadal fat pad weights, but less for fat content. The L line showed the lowest growth depression. The lit gene, which causes GH but not TH deficiency, was also transferred by repeated backcrosses into three of these lines (PH, PL, F). The combined deficiency of TH and GH had bigger effects on body weights at earlier ages than did GH deprivation. The data show that changes in the TH- and GH-systems are not the only cause of line differences in growth and fatness resulting from long-term selection, but both are involved to a significant extent. The interactions between the effects of the transgene and of the lit gene and the genetic background were, nevertheless, relatively small and therefore these results support a polygenic model of selection response.