Igor Papalia

On the use of the grasping test in the rat median nerve model: a re-appraisal of its efficacy for quantitative assessment of motor function recovery.

The quantitative assessment of motor function is an important requirement for studies on peripheral nerve injury and repair. So far, most studies on peripheral nerves have been performed on the sciatic nerve model using walking track analysis for assessing motor function. Alternatively, the employment of the median nerve model, which allows motor function evaluation by means of a simple behavioural test named grasping test (GT), have been more recently proposed. In this paper, the efficacy of the GT for the quantitative assessment of motor function recovery is re-appraised and a modified device for its carrying out is described. Finally, the rationale for the employment of the median nerve model as an alternative to the sciatic nerve model is critically discussed.

Functional and morphological assessment of a standardized crush injury of the rat median nerve

The availability of effective experimental models for investigating nerve regeneration and designing new strategies for promoting this unique repair process is important. The aim of this study was to standardize a rat median nerve crush injury model using a non-serrated clamp exerting a compression force of 17.02 MPa for a duration of 30s. Results showed that functional recovery, evaluated by grasping test, was already detectable at day-12 and progressively increased until day-28 after which animal performance plateaued until the end of testing (day-42), reaching a range of 75-80% of pre-operative values. Morphological analysis on the median nerve segments, distal to the crush lesion, which were withdrawn at the end of the experiment showed that regenerated nerve fibers are significantly more numerous and densely packed; they are also smaller and have a thinner myelin sheath compared to controls. Together, these results provide a baseline characterization of the crush median nerve injury experimental model for its employment in the investigation of nerve regeneration research, especially when a reproducible regeneration process is required, such as for the study of biological mechanisms of peripheral nerve fiber regeneration or development of new therapeutic agents for promoting posttraumatic nerve repair.

Chapter 4 Methods and Protocols in Peripheral Nerve Regeneration Experimental Research: Part I—Experimental Models

This paper addresses several basic issues that are important for the experimental model design to investigate peripheral nerve regeneration. First, the importance of carrying out adequate preliminary in vitro investigation is emphasized in light of the ethical issues and with particular emphasis on the concept of the Three Rs (Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement) for limiting in vivo animal studies. Second, the various options for the selection of the animal species for nerve regeneration research are reviewed. Third, the two main experimental paradigms of nerve lesion (axonotmesis vs. neurotmesis followed by microsurgical reconstruction) are critically outlined and compared. Fourth, the various nerve models that have most commonly been employed are overviewed focusing in particular on forearm mixed nerves and on behavioural tests for assessing their function: the ulnar test and the grasping test which is useful for assessing both median and radial nerves in the rat. Finally, the importance of considering the influence of various factors and diseases which could interfere with the nerve regeneration process is emphasized in the perspective of a wider adoption of experimental models which more closely mimic the environmental and clinical conditions found in patients.

Chapter 1 Peripheral Nerve Repair and Regeneration Research: A Historical Note

Although the most significant advances in nerve repair and regeneration have been acquired over the last few decades, the study of nerve repair and regeneration potential dates back to ancient times namely to Galen in the second century A.D. This brief historical note outlines the milestones which have guided us to our present knowledge. In particular, we focus on the nineteenth century and the first decades of the twentieth century, an age in which the fathers of neurosurgery and neurobiology established the basis for most of the nerve repair and regeneration concepts used today. Finally, we shine a light on the most current history to show how recent pressure to use modern interdisciplinary and translational approach represents a sort of rediscovery of the scientific habits of the fathers of modern biomedicine, who used to carry out research from an integrated and broad point of view rather than from a super-specialized and specific one as it is often used today.

The ulnar test: a method for the quantitative functional assessment of posttraumatic ulnar nerve recovery in the rat.

The assessment of recovery of the neuromuscular function following nerve lesion and repair is one of the main goals of peripheral nerve researchers. The forelimb model has recently seen an increase in its employment for experimental nerve repair studies especially because of the availability of the grasping test for assessing the functional recovery of one of its major nerves, the median nerve. Nerve repair studies sometimes require the use of more than one nerve to simulate severe clinical situations and, in this case, the ulnar nerve is often used together with the median nerve. However, a test for assessing ulnar nerve functional recovery is yet not available. To fill this gap, we have developed and experimentally tested a method for the functional assessment of posttraumatic ulnar nerve recovery in the rat. Animal testing using this method is simple, quick and provides the animal with minimal distress. The method proved to be effective in detecting the date on which recovery starts after ulnar nerve impairment and in following its improvement, over time. The availability of this new test is expected to further increase the employment of forelimb experimental nerve models instead of the more disabling hindlimb models.

Repairing nerve gaps by vein conduits filled with lipoaspirate-derived entire adipose tissue hinders nerve regeneration.

In spite of great recent advancements, the definition of the optimal strategy for bridging a nerve defect, especially across long gaps, still remains an open issue since the amount of autologous nerve graft material is limited while the outcome after alternative tubulization techniques is often unsatisfactory. The aim of this study was to investigate a new tubulization technique based on the employment of vein conduits filled with whole subcutaneous adipose tissue obtained by lipoaspiration. In adult rats, a 1cm-long defect of the left median nerve was repaired by adipose tissue-vein-combined conduits and compared with fresh skeletal muscle tissue-vein-combined conduits and autologous nerve grafts made by the excised nerve segment rotated by 180°. Throughout the postoperative period, functional recovery was assessed using the grasping test. Regenerated nerve samples were withdrawn at postoperative month-6 and processed for light and electron microscopy and stereology of regenerated nerve fibers. Results showed that functional recovery was significantly slower in the adipose tissue-enriched group in comparison to both control groups. Light and electron microscopy showed that a large amount of adipose tissue was still present inside the vein conduits at postoperative month-6. Stereology showed that all quantitative morphological predictors analyzed performed significantly worse in the adipose tissue-enriched group in comparison to the two control groups. On the basis of this experimental study in the rat, the use of whole adipose tissue for tissue engineering of peripheral nerves should be discouraged. Pre-treatment of adipose tissue aimed at isolating stromal vascular fraction and/or adipose derived stem/precursor cells should be considered a fundamental requisite for nerve repair.

Chapter 14 End‐to‐Side Nerve Regeneration: From the Laboratory Bench to Clinical Applications

Translation of laboratory results to the patient is a critical step in biomedical research and sometimes promising basic science and preclinical results fail to meet the expectations when translated to the clinics. End-to-side (ETS) nerve regeneration is an example of an innovative neurobiological concept, which, after having generated great expectations in experimental and preclinical studies, provided very conflicting results when applied to clinical case series. A number of basic science studies have shown that ETS neurorrhaphy, in fact, is able to induce collateral sprouting from donor nerves axons, allowing for massive repopulation of the distal nerve stump. Experimental studies have also shown that ETS neurorrhaphy can recover voluntary control of skeletal muscles and that voluntary motor function recovery can be achieved both with agonistic and antagonistic donor nerves, thus widening the potential clinical indications. However, clinical case series reported so far, did not meet these promises and results have been rather conflicting, especially regarding repair of proximally located mixed nerves. In contrast, ETS reconstruction of distal sensory nerve lesions led to a more positive outcome and, most importantly, consistent results among international centers carrying out clinical trials. Concluding, ETS is a promising microsurgical approach for nerve coaptation, based on a convincing and innovative neurobiological concept. However, conflicting clinical results and disagreement among surgeons regarding its employment suggest that this technique should still be considered an ultima ratio, reserved for cases where no other repair technique can be attempted. New data coming from neurobiological research will help further enlarge the clinical indications of ETS nerve reconstruction, explain the different results found in laboratory animals and humans, and contribute to new treatments and rehabilitation strategies aimed at improving the efficacy of nerve regeneration after ETS neurorrhaphy.

Lack of topographic specificity in nerve fiber regeneration of rat forelimb mixed nerves

Multiple nerve repair by means of a Y-shaped nerve guide represents a good model for studying the specificity of peripheral nerve fiber regeneration. Here we have used it for investigating the specificity of axonal regeneration in mixed nerves of the rat forelimb model. The left median and ulnar nerves, in adult female rats, were transected and repaired with a 14-mm Y-shaped conduit. The proximal end of the Y-shaped conduit was sutured to the proximal stump of either the median nerve or the ulnar nerve. Ten months after surgery, rats were tested for functional recovery of each median and ulnar nerve. Quantitative morphology of regenerated myelinated nerve fibers was then carried out by the two-dimensional disector technique. Results showed that partial recovery of both median and ulnar nerve motor function was regained in all experimental groups. Performance in the grasping test was significantly lower when the ulnar nerve was used as the proximal stump. Ulnar test assessment showed no significant difference between the two Y-shaped repair groups. The number of regenerated nerve fibers was significantly higher in the median nerve irrespectively of the donor nerve, maintaining the same proportion of myelinated fibers between the two nerves (about 60% median and 40% ulnar). On the other hand, nerve fiber size and myelin thickness were significantly larger in both distal nerves when the median nerve was used as the proximal donor nerve stump. G-ratio and myelin thickness/axon diameter ratio returned to normal values in all experimental groups. These results demonstrate that combined Y-shaped-tubulization repair of median and ulnar nerves permits the functional recovery of both nerves, independently from the proximal donor nerve employed, and that tissue, and not topographic, specificity guides nerve fiber regeneration in major forelimb mixed nerves of rats.

Functional, morphological and biomolecular assessment of posttraumatic neuro-muscular recovery in the rat forelimb model.

Over the last five years, we have used the rat forelimb model for investigating neuromuscular recovery after microsurgical nerve reconstruction of median and ulnar nerves by end-to-side neurorrhaphy and muscle-vein-combined tubulization (using both straight and Y-shaped guides). The outcome of nerve repair at different postoperative times was assessed by functional, morphological and biomolecular analysis. Results showed that both end-to-side and tubulization repair of rat median and ulnar nerves led to successful axonal regeneration along the severed nerve trunk as well as to a partial recovery of the lost function as assessed by grasping test. Biomolecular analysis by means of reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) demonstrated early overexpression during nerve regeneration of the gliotrophic factor NRG1 and two of its receptors: erbB2 and erbB3. Finally, our experience also suggests that the rat forelimb experimental model is particularly appropriate for the study of microsurgical reconstruction of major mixed nerve trunks. Furthermore, since the forelimb model is less compromising for the animal, it should be preferred to the hindlimb model for many research purposes.

Experimental and Clinical Employment of End-to-Side Coaptation: Our Experience

The last 15 years have seen a growing interest regarding a technique for nerve repair named end-to-side coaptation. Since 2000, we have carried out experimental studies on end-to-side nerve repair as well as employed this technique to a series of selected clinical cases. Here we report on the results of this experience.For experimental studies, we have used the model represented by median nerve repair by end-to-side coaptation either on the ulnar (agonistic) or the radial (antagonistic) nerve. For time course assessment of median nerve functional recovery we used the grasping test, a test which permits to assess voluntary control of muscle function. Repaired nerves were processed for resin embedding to allow nerve fibre stereology and electron microscopy. Results showed that, in either experimental group, end-to-side-repaired median nerves were repopulated by axons regenerating from ulnar and radial donor nerves, respectively. Moreover, contrary to previously published data, our results showed that voluntary motor control of the muscles innervated by the median nerve was progressively recovered also when the antagonistic radial nerve was the donor nerve.As regards our clinical experience, results were not so positive. We have treated by end-to-side coaptation patients with both sensory (n = 7, collateral digital nerves) and mixed (n = 8, plexus level) nerve lesions. Results were good, as in other series, in sensory nerves whilst they were very difficult to investigate in mixed nerves at the plexus level.Take together, these results suggest that clinical employment of end-to-side coaptation should still be considered at the moment as the ultima ratio in cases in which no other repair technique can be attempted. Yet, it is clear that more basic research is needed to explain the reasons for the different results between laboratory animal and humans and, especially, to find out how to ameliorate the outcome of end-to-side nerve repair by adequate treatment and rehabilitation.