Irina N. Smirnova

Role of YidC in folding of polytopic membrane proteins

YidC of Echerichia coli, a member of the conserved Alb3/Oxa1/YidC family, is postulated to be important for biogenesis of membrane proteins. Here, we use as a model the lactose permease (LacY), a membrane transport protein with a known three-dimensional structure, to determine whether YidC plays a role in polytopic membrane protein insertion and/or folding. Experiments in vivo and with an in vitro transcription/translation/insertion system demonstrate that YidC is not necessary for insertion per se, but plays an important role in folding of LacY. By using the in vitro system and two monoclonal antibodies directed against conformational epitopes, LacY is shown to bind the antibodies poorly in YidC-depleted membranes. Moreover, LacY also folds improperly in proteoliposomes prepared without YidC. However, when the proteoliposomes are supplemented with purified YidC, LacY folds correctly. The results indicate that YidC plays a primary role in folding of LacY into its final tertiary conformation via an interaction that likely occurs transiently during insertion into the lipid phase of the membrane.

The Alternating Access Transport Mechanism in LacY

Lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY) is highly dynamic, and sugar binding causes closing of a large inward-facing cavity with opening of a wide outward-facing hydrophilic cavity. Therefore, lactose/H+ symport via LacY very likely involves a global conformational change that allows alternating access of single sugar- and H+-binding sites to either side of the membrane. Here, in honor of Stephan H. White’s seventieth birthday, we review in camera the various biochemical/biophysical approaches that provide experimental evidence for the alternating access mechanism.

The lactose permease of Escherichia coli: overall structure, the sugar‐binding site and the alternating access model for transport

Membrane transport proteins transduce free energy stored in electrochemical ion gradients into a concentration gradient and are a major class of membrane proteins, many of which play important roles in human health and disease. Recently, the X‐ray structure of the Escherichia coli lactose permease (LacY), an intensively studied member of a large group of related membrane transport proteins, was solved at 3.5 Å. LacY is composed of N‐ and C‐terminal domains, each with six transmembrane helices, symmetrically positioned within the molecule. The structure represents the inward‐facing conformation, as evidenced by a large internal hydrophilic cavity open to the cytoplasmic side. The structure with a bound lactose homolog reveals the sugar‐binding site in the cavity, and a mechanism for translocation across the membrane is proposed in which the sugar‐binding site has alternating accessibility to either side of the membrane.

Structure of sugar-bound LacY

Significance The lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY), a model for the major facilitator superfamily, catalyzes the symport of a galactopyranoside and an H+ across the membrane by a mechanism in which the sugar-binding site in the middle of the protein becomes alternately accessible to either side of the membrane. However, all X-ray structures thus far show LacY in an inward-facing conformation with a tightly sealed periplasmic side. Significantly, by using a double-Trp mutant, we now describe an almost occluded, outward-open conformation with bound sugar, confirming more than two decades of biochemical and biophysical findings. We also present evidence that protonated LacY specifically binds D-galactopyranosides, inducing an occluded state that can open to either side of the membrane. Here we describe the X-ray crystal structure of a double-Trp mutant (Gly46→Trp/Gly262→Trp) of the lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY) with a bound, high-affinity lactose analog. Although thought to be arrested in an open-outward conformation, the structure is almost occluded and is partially open to the periplasmic side; the cytoplasmic side is tightly sealed. Surprisingly, the opening on the periplasmic side is sufficiently narrow that sugar cannot get in or out of the binding site. Clearly defined density for a bound sugar is observed at the apex of the almost occluded cavity in the middle of the protein, and the side chains shown to ligate the galactopyranoside strongly confirm more than two decades of biochemical and spectroscopic findings. Comparison of the current structure with a previous structure of LacY with a covalently bound inactivator suggests that the galactopyranoside must be fully ligated to induce an occluded conformation. We conclude that protonated LacY binds d-galactopyranosides specifically, inducing an occluded state that can open to either side of the membrane.

Residues in the H+ Translocation Site Define the pKa for Sugar Binding to LacY

A remarkably high pKa of approximately 10.5 has been determined for sugar-binding affinity to the lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY), indicating that, under physiological conditions, substrate binds to fully protonated LacY. We have now systematically tested site-directed replacements for the residues involved in sugar binding, as well as H+ translocation and coupling, in order to determine which residues may be responsible for this alkaline pKa. Mutations in the sugar-binding site (Glu126, Trp151, Glu269) markedly decrease affinity for sugar but do not alter the pKa for binding. In contrast, replacements for residues involved in H+ translocation (Arg302, Tyr236, His322, Asp240, Glu325, Lys319) exhibit pKa values for sugar binding that are either shifted toward neutral pH or independent of pH. Values for the apparent dissociation constant for sugar binding (K(d)(app)) increase greatly for all mutants except neutral replacements for Glu325 or Lys319, which are characterized by remarkably high affinity sugar binding (i.e., low K(d)(app)) from pH 5.5 to pH 11. The pH dependence of the on- and off-rate constants for sugar binding measured directly by stopped-flow fluorometry implicates k(off) as a major factor for the affinity change at alkaline pH and confirms the effects of pH on K(d)(app) inferred from steady-state fluorometry. These results indicate that the high pKa for sugar binding by wild-type LacY cannot be ascribed to any single amino acid residue but appears to reside within a complex of residues involved in H+ translocation. There is structural evidence for water bound in this complex, and the water could be the site of protonation responsible for the pH dependence of sugar binding.

Protonation and sugar binding to LacY

The effect of bulk-phase pH on the apparent affinity (Kdapp) of purified wild-type lactose permease (LacY) for sugars was studied. Kdapp values were determined by ligand-induced changes in the fluorescence of either of two covalently bound fluorescent reporters positioned away from the sugar-binding site. Kdapp for three different galactopyranosides was determined over a pH range from 5.5 to 11. A remarkably high pKa of ≈10.5 was obtained for all sugars. Kinetic data for thiodigalactoside binding measured from pH 6 to 10 show that decreased affinity for sugar at alkaline pH is due specifically to increased reverse rate. A similar effect was also observed with nitrophenylgalactoside by using a direct binding assay. Because affinity for sugar remains constant from pH 5.5 to pH 9.0, it follows that LacY is fully protonated with respect to sugar binding under physiological conditions of pH. The results are consistent with the conclusion that LacY is protonated before sugar binding during lactose/H+ symport in either direction across the membrane.

Electrophysiological characterization of LacY

Electrogenic events due to the activity of wild-type lactose permease from Escherichia coli (LacY) were investigated with proteoliposomes containing purified LacY adsorbed on a solid-supported membrane electrode. Downhill sugar/H+ symport into the proteoliposomes generates transient currents. Studies at different lipid-to-protein ratios and at different pH values, as well as inactivation by N-ethylmaleimide, show that the currents are due specifically to the activity of LacY. From analysis of the currents under different conditions and comparison with biochemical data, it is suggested that the predominant electrogenic event in downhill sugar/H+ symport is H+ release. In contrast, LacY mutants Glu-325→Ala and Cys-154→Gly, which bind ligand normally, but are severely defective with respect to lactose/H+ symport, exhibit only a small electrogenic event on addition of LacY-specific substrates, representing 6% of the total charge displacement of the wild-type. This activity is due either to substrate binding per se or to a conformational transition after substrate binding, and is not due to sugar/H+ symport. We propose that turnover of LacY involves at least 2 electrogenic reactions: (i) a minor electrogenic step that occurs on sugar binding and is due to a conformational transition in LacY; and (ii) a major electrogenic step probably due to cytoplasmic release of H+ during downhill sugar/H+ symport, which is the limiting step for this mode of transport.

Crystal structure of a LacY–nanobody complex in a periplasmic-open conformation

Significance LacY catalyzes the coupled transport (symport) of a galactosidic sugar and an H+ and is the poster child for the major facilitator superfamily, the largest family of membrane transport proteins. A detailed mechanism has been postulated involving alternating access of sugar- and H+-binding sites to either side of the membrane that is driven by sugar binding and dissociation and independent of the H+ electrochemical gradient, which acts kinetically. To characterize structural intermediates in the transport cycle, stable conformers are essential, and camelid single-domain nanobodies (Nbs) are particularly useful in this context. Described herein is a structure of a LacY–Nb complex in which access to the sugar-binding site from the periplasmic cavity is diffusion-limited. The lactose permease of Escherichia coli (LacY), a dynamic polytopic membrane protein, catalyzes galactoside–H+ symport and operates by an alternating access mechanism that exhibits multiple conformations, the distribution of which is altered by sugar binding. We have developed single-domain camelid nanobodies (Nbs) against a mutant in an outward (periplasmic)-open conformation to stabilize this state of the protein. Here we describe an X-ray crystal structure of a complex between a double-Trp mutant (Gly46→Trp/Gly262→Trp) and an Nb in which free access to the sugar-binding site from the periplasmic cavity is observed. The structure confirms biochemical data indicating that the Nb binds stoichiometrically with nanomolar affinity to the periplasmic face of LacY primarily to the C-terminal six-helix bundle. The structure is novel because the pathway to the sugar-binding site is constricted and the central cavity containing the galactoside-binding site is empty. Although Phe27 narrows the periplasmic cavity, sugar is freely accessible to the binding site. Remarkably, the side chains directly involved in binding galactosides remain in the same position in the absence or presence of bound sugar.

Real-time conformational changes in LacY

Significance The lactose permease from Escherichia coli (LacY), a model for the major facilitator superfamily, catalyzes the symport of a galactopyranoside and an H+ across the membrane by a mechanism in which the sugar-binding site in the middle of the protein becomes alternately accessible to either side of the membrane. The global conformational change is dissected into events that occur on the cytoplasmic and periplasmic aspects of LacY. Rates of individual steps are measured directly during opening or closing of periplasmic or cytoplasmic cavities by utilizing changes in Trp-bimane fluorescence with LacY in a phospholipid membrane. The findings provide a better understanding of the alternating access mechanism. Galactoside/H+ symport across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli is catalyzed by lactose permease (LacY), which uses an alternating access mechanism with opening and closing of deep cavities on the periplasmic and cytoplasmic sides. In this study, conformational changes in LacY initiated by galactoside binding were monitored in real time by Trp quenching/unquenching of bimane, a small fluorophore covalently attached to the protein. Rates of change in bimane fluorescence on either side of LacY were measured by stopped flow with LacY in detergent or in proteoliposomes and were compared with rates of galactoside binding. With LacY in proteoliposomes, the periplasmic cavity is tightly sealed and the substrate-binding rate is limited by the rate of opening of this cavity. Rates of opening, measured as unquenching of bimane fluorescence, are 20–30 s−1, independent of sugar concentration and essentially the same in detergent or in proteoliposomes. On the cytoplasmic side of LacY in proteoliposomes, slow bimane quenching (i.e., closing of the cavity) is observed at a rate that is also independent of sugar concentration and similar to the rate of sugar binding from the periplasmic side. Therefore, opening of the periplasmic cavity not only limits access of sugar to the binding site of LacY but also controls the rate of closing of the cytoplasmic cavity.

Inferences about the catalytic domain of P-type ATPases from the tertiary structures of enzymes that catalyze the same elementary reaction

The machinery to catalyze elementary reactions is conserved, and the number of solved enzyme structures is increasing exponentially. Therefore, structures of enzymes that catalyze phosphate transfer are reviewed, and a supersecondary structure connecting the Walker A sequence to another sequence containing functional amino acids is proposed as an additional signature for the active site. The new signature is used to infer the identity of the P‐loop in P‐type biological pumps and may be useful in predicting targets for site‐directed mutagenesis in other enzymes of unknown structure like the AAA family and ABC transporters.