Isabelle A. Siegler

Effects of Vestibular Rotatory Accelerations on Covert Attentional Orienting in Vision and Touch

Peripheral vestibular organs feed the central nervous system with inputs favoring the correct perception of space during head and body motion. Applying temporal order judgments (TOJs) to pairs of simultaneous or asynchronous stimuli presented in the left and right egocentric space, we evaluated the influence of leftward and rightward vestibular rotatory accelerations given around the vertical head-body axis on covert attentional orienting. In a first experiment, we presented visual stimuli in the left and right hemifield. In a second experiment, tactile stimuli were presented to hands lying on their anatomical side or in a crossed position across the sagittal body midline. In both experiments, stimuli were presented while normal subjects suppressed or did not suppress the vestibulo-ocular response (VOR) evoked by head-body rotation. Independently of VOR suppression, visual and tactile stimuli presented on the side of rotation were judged to precede simultaneous stimuli presented on the side opposite the rotation. When limbs were crossed, attentional facilitatory effects were only observed for stimuli presented to the right hand lying in the left hemispace during leftward rotatory trials with VOR suppression. This result points to spatiotopic rather than somatotopic influences of vestibular inputs, suggesting that cross-modal effects of these inputs on tactile ones operate on a representation of space that is updated following arm crossing. In a third control experiment, we demonstrated that temporal prioritization of stimuli presented on the side of rotation was not determined by response bias linked to spatial compatibility between the directions of rotation and the directional labels used in TOJs (i.e., left or right first). These findings suggest that during passive rotatory head-body accelerations, covert attention is shifted toward the direction of rotation and the direction of the fast phases of the VOR.

Self-motion perception during a sequence of whole-body rotations in darkness

Abstract. The main aim of this study was to examine how postrotatory effects, induced by passive whole-body rotations in darkness, could alter the perception of motion and eye movements during a subsequent rotation. Perception of angle magnitude was assessed in a reproduction task: blindfolded subjects were first submitted to a passive rotation about the earth-vertical axis on a mobile robot. They were then asked to reproduce this angle by controlling the robot with a joystick. Stimulus rotations ranged from 80° to 340°. Subjects were given one of two delay instructions: after the stimulus, they either had to await the end of postrotatory sensations before starting reproduction (condition free delay, FD), or they had to start immediately after the end of the stimulus rotation (no delay, ND). The delay in FD was used as an incidental measure of the subjective duration of these sensations. Eye movements were recorded with an infrared measuring system (IRIS). Results showed that in both conditions subjects accurately reproduced rotation angles, though they did not reproduce the stimulus dynamics. Peak velocities reached in ND were higher than in FD. This difference suggests that postrotatory effects induced a bias in the perception of angular velocity in the ND condition.

The “ways” we look at dreams: evidence from unilateral spatial neglect (with an evolutionary account of dream bizarreness)

Despite decades of research, the question of whether the rapid eye movements (REMs) of paradoxical sleep (PS) are equivalent to waking saccades and whether their direction is congruent with visual spatial events in the dream scene is still very controversial. We gained an insight into these questions through the study of a right brain damaged patient suffering attentional neglect for the left side of space and drop of the optokinetic nystagmus (OKN) with alternating rightward slow/leftward fast phases evoked by rightward optic flow. During PS the patient had frequent Nystagmoid REMs with alternating leftward slow/rightward fast phases and reported dreams with visual events evoking corresponding OKN such as a train running leftward. By contrast, just as in waking OKN, Nystagmoid REMs with alternating rightward slow/leftward fast phases were virtually absent. REMs followed by staring eye position or by consecutive REMs were also observed: these showed no asymmetry comparable to that of Nystagmoid ones. The selective disappearance of Nystagmoid REMs in one horizontal direction proves, for the first time, that in humans different types of REMs exists and that these are driven by different premotor mechanisms. Concomitant drop of OKN and Nystagmoid REMs toward the same horizontal direction demonstrates that phylogenetically ancient oculomotor mechanisms, such as the OKN, are shared by waking and PS. On this evidence and converging findings from animal, neuropsychological and brain imaging studies, a new evolutionary account of dream bizarreness is proposed. Classification and labelling of the different types of REMs are also provided.

The vestibulo-ocular reflex and angular displacement perception in darkness in humans: adaptation to a virtual environment

The vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) and angular displacement perception were measured in 25 healthy humans in darkness before and after exposure to incoherent visual-vestibular stimulation (VVS): 45 min of repeated passive 180 degrees whole-body rotations around the vertical axis concurrent with only 90 degrees rotation in a visual virtual square room. Large inter-individual variability was observed for both VOR gain and turning estimates. The individual VOR gains were not correlated with perceived angles of rotation either before or after VVS. After VVS, the angular displacement perception decreased by 24+/-16% while the VOR gain did not change significantly. The results suggest that adaptive plasticity in turning perception and adaptive plasticity in VOR might be independent of one another.

Learning new perception-action solutions in virtual ball bouncing

How do humans discover stable solutions to perceptual-motor tasks as they interact with the physical environment? We investigate this question using the task of rhythmically bouncing a ball on a racket, for which a passively stable solution is defined. Previously, it was shown that participants exploit this passive stability but can also actively stabilize bouncing under perceptual control. Using a virtual ball-bouncing display, we created new behavioral solutions for rhythmic bouncing by introducing a temporal delay (45°–180°) between the motion of the physical racket and that of the virtual racket. We then studied how participants searched for and realized a new solution. In all delay conditions, participants learned to maintain bouncing just outside the passively stable region, indicating a role for active stabilization. They recovered the approximate initial phase of ball impact in the virtual racket cycle (half-way through the upswing) by adjusting the impact phase with the physical racket. With short delays (45°, 90°), the impact phase quickly shifted later in the physical racket upswing. With long delays (135°, 180°), bouncing was destabilized and phase was widely visited before a new preferred phase gradually emerged, during the physical downswing. Destabilization was likely due to the loss of spatial symmetry between the ball and physical racket motion at impact. The results suggest that new behavioral solutions may be discovered and stabilized through broad irregular sampling of variable space rather than through a systematic search.

Shift of the beating field of vestibular nystagmus: an orientation strategy?

We investigated in humans whether the shift of the beating field, which is often observed during vestibular nystagmus, could be related to some strategy of orientation. Eye movements were measured with an infrared system during an experiment on self-motion perception in the dark. Subjects were asked to rotate, by means of a joystick, a mobile robot on which they were seated in order to reproduce a previously imposed passive rotation. We suggest that the shift of the ocular beating field is the manifestation of two different orientation strategies based on allocentric and egocentric reference frames, respectively. It is also proposed that subjects who preferably used the first strategy exhibited large shifts of the beating field, while the others who probably used egocentric memory did not exhibit any shift.

Eye deviation during rotation in darkness in trait anxiety: an early expression of perceptual avoidance?

BACKGROUND Patients with dizziness and patients with panic disorder and agoraphobia share a common symptomatology. Numerous studies have investigated a potential link between anxiety and the vestibular system, but few of them have addressed the specific topic of spatial representation. METHODS Passive whole-body rotations in the horizontal plane were imposed on two groups of subjects who differed in their level of trait anxiety. Subjects were seated on a mobile robot in darkness. After each passive rotation, subjects were asked to reproduce the stimulus by driving the robot with a joystick and to perform a rotation of the same magnitude. Eye movements were recorded and analyzed. RESULTS No difference in either perception (accuracy in the reproduction task) or in VOR gain was found between the two groups of subjects. Mean eye deviation, caused by fast phases of the nystagmus, differed in the two groups. It was typically in the anticompensatory direction in the non-anxious group, and in the compensatory direction the anxious group. Such compensatory movement may be explained by an egocentric orientation strategy, that may in turn indicate a lack of interest toward the visual surroundings. CONCLUSIONS An egocentric strategy for self-orientation exhibited at a level below the threshold of awareness could reveal the existence of a physiological mode of processing leading to agoraphobic avoidance.

Passive vs. Active Control of Rhythmic Ball Bouncing: The Role of Visual Information

The simple task of bouncing a ball on a racket offers a model system for studying how human actors exploit the physics and information of the environment to control their behavior. Previous work shows that people take advantage of a passively stable solution for ball bouncing but can also use perceptual information to actively stabilize bouncing. In this article, we investigate (a) active and passive contributions to the control of bouncing, (b) the visual information in the balls trajectory, and (c) how it modulates the parameters of racket oscillation. We used a virtual ball bouncing apparatus to manipulate the coefficient of restitution alpha and gravitational acceleration g during steady-state bouncing (Experiment 1) and sudden transitions (Experiment 2) to dissociate informational variables. The results support a form of mixed control, based on the half-period of the balls trajectory, in which racket oscillation is actively regulated on every cycle in order to keep the system in or near the passively stable region. The mixed control mode may be a general strategy for integrating passive stability with active stabilization in perception-action systems.

A common mechanism for the control of eye and head movements in humans

How the human brain controls the subtle coupling between eye and head movements is still debated. The brain could either coordinate two separate (eye and head) networks or use a single system involved in gaze (eye + head) control. In a recent report, a total transfer from eye to head movements was observed in a patient with congenital ophthalmoplegia. This led the authors to hypothesize that such transfer resulted from a long‐term adaptation between oculomotor and head movement systems. We report on a patient in whom a similar transfer was observed but at the acute stage of an acquired ophthalmoplegia. This case demonstrates that the transfer between head and eye movements does not necessarily require long‐term adaptation and supports the hypothesis of a common unique gaze motor command in which eye and head movements would be rapidly exchangeable. Ann Neurol 2000;47:819–822

'Mixed' control for perception and action: timing and error correction in rhythmic ball-bouncing

The task of bouncing a ball on a racket was adopted as a model system for investigating the behavioral dynamics of rhythmic movement, specifically how perceptual information modulates the dynamics of action. Two experiments, with sixteen participants each, were carried out to definitively answer the following questions: How are passive stability and active stabilization combined to produce stable behavior? What informational quantities are used to actively regulate the two main components of the action—the timing of racket oscillation and the correction of errors in bounce height? We used a virtual ball-bouncing setup to simultaneously perturb gravity (g) and ball launch velocity (vb) at impact. In Experiment 1, we tested the control of racket timing by varying the ball’s upward half-period tup while holding its peak height hp constant. Conversely, in Experiment 2, we tested error correction by varying hp while holding tup constant. Participants adopted a mixed control mode in which information in the ball’s trajectory is used to actively stabilize behavior on a cycle-by-cycle basis, in order to keep the system within or near the passively stable region. The results reveal how these adjustments are visually controlled: the period of racket oscillation is modulated by the half-period of the ball’s upward flight, and the change in racket velocity from the previous impact (via a change in racket amplitude) is governed by the error to the target.