Iva Urbankova

Evaluating Alternative Materials for the Treatment of Stress Urinary Incontinence and Pelvic Organ Prolapse: A Comparison of the In Vivo Response to Meshes Implanted in Rabbits.

PURPOSE Serious complications can develop with the mesh implants used for stress urinary incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse surgery. We evaluated 2 materials currently in clinical use and 2 alternative materials using a rabbit abdominal model to assess host response and biomechanical properties of the materials before and after implantation. MATERIALS AND METHODS Poly-L-lactic acid and polyurethane meshes were electrospun to be compared to commercially available polypropylene and polyvinylidene fluoride meshes. A total of 40 immunocompetent full-thickness abdominal wall defect rabbit models were used, including 8 in each of the poly-L-lactic acid, polyurethane, polyvinylidene fluoride and polypropylene experimental groups, and sham controls. Two 20 mm defects were created per animal and primarily repaired. The experimental groups then underwent onlay of each repair material while sham controls did not. Four rabbits per group were sacrificed at days 30 and 90. Abdominal wall specimens containing the defect with or without repair material were explanted to be assessed by histology (hematoxylin and eosin staining, and immunohistochemistry) and biomechanical testing at 30 and 90 days. RESULTS At 90 days of implantation tissues repaired with all 4 materials showed biomechanical properties without significant differences. However, polypropylene and polyvinylidene fluoride meshes demonstrated a sustained chronic inflammatory response profile by 90 days. In contrast, poly-L-lactic acid and polyurethane meshes integrated well into host tissues with a decreased inflammatory response, indicative of constructive remodeling. CONCLUSIONS Poly-L-lactic acid and polyurethane alternative materials achieved better host integration in rabbit models than current synthetic repair materials.

Tissue response to collagen containing polypropylene meshes in an ovine vaginal repair model.

UNLABELLED Pelvic Organ Prolapse (POP) is the herniation of pelvic organs into the vagina. Despite broad acceptance of mesh use in POP surgical repair, the complication rate is unacceptable. We hypothesized that collagen-containing polypropylene (PP) mesh types could modulate mesh-tissue integration and reduce long-term inflammation, thereby reducing mesh-associated complications. This study compared the long-term tissue response to an unmodified PP mesh and two collagen containing meshes in an ovine model which has similar pelvic anatomy and vaginal size to human. Three commercially available macroporous PP meshes, uncoated PP mesh (Avaulta Solo) (PP), the same textile PP mesh layered with a sheet of cross-linked porcine acellular matrix (Avaulta Plus) (PP-ACM) and a different yet also macroporous PP (Sofradim) mesh coated with solubilized atelocollagen (Ugytex) (PP-sCOL) were implanted in the ovine vagina and tissue explanted after 60 and 180days. The macrophage phenotype and response to implanted meshes, and vascularity were quantified by immunostaining and morphometry. We quantified changes in extracellular matrix composition biochemically and collagen organisation and percentage area around the interface of the mesh implants by Sirius Red birefringence and morphometry. PP-ACM induced a more sustained inflammatory response, indicated by similar CD45(+) leukocytes but reduced CD163(+) M2 macrophages at 60days (P<0.05). PP-sCOL increased Von Willebrand Factor (vWF)-immunoreactive vessel profiles after 60days. At the micro-molecular level, collagen birefringence quantification revealed significantly fewer mature collagen fibrils (red, thick fibrils) at the mesh-tissue interface than control tissue for all mesh types (P<0.001) but still significantly greater than the proportion of immature (green thin fibrils) at 60days (P<0.05). The proportion of mature collagen fibrils increased with time around the mesh filaments, particularly those containing collagen. The total collagen percent area at the mesh interface was greatest around the PP-ACM mesh at 60days (P<0.05). By 180days the total mature and immature collagen fibres at the interface of the mesh filaments resembled that of native tissue. In particular, these results suggest that both meshes containing collagen evoke different types of tissue responses at different times during the healing response yet both ultimately lead to physiological tissue formation approaching that of normal tissue. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE Pelvic organ prolapse (POP) is the descent of the pelvic organs to the vagina. POP affects more than 25% of all women and the lifetime risk of undergoing POP surgery is 19%. Although synthetic polypropylene (PP) meshes have improved the outcome of the surgical treatment for POP, there was an unacceptable rate of adverse events including mesh exposure and contracture. It is hypothesized that coating the PP meshes with collagen would provide a protective effect by preventing severe mesh adhesions to the wound, resulting in a better controlled initial inflammatory response, and diminished risk of exposure. In this study we assessed the effect of two collagen-containing PP meshes on the long-term vaginal tissue response using new techniques to quantify these tissue responses.

Immediate postoperative changes in synthetic meshes – In vivo measurements

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE Immediate post-operative structural changes in implanted synthetic meshes are believed to contribute to graft related complications. Our aim was to observe in vivo dimensional changes at the pore level. METHOD Two different polyvinylidine fluoride (PVDF) meshes, CICAT and ENDOLAP (Dynamesh, FEG Textiltechnik) were implanted in 18 female Sprague Dawley (n=9/group). The meshes (30×25mm(2)) were overlaid on a full thickness incision (2×1cm(2)) and sutured on the abdominal wall. All animals underwent microCT imaging (res. 35µm/px) at day 1 and 15 postsurgery. A customized procedure was developed to semi-automatically detect the pore centers from the microCT dataset. Horizontal (transverse) and vertical (cranio-caudal) inter-pore distances were then recorded. The overall mesh dimensions were also noted from 3D models generated from in vivo microCT datasets. Inter-pore distances and the overall dimensions from microCT images of the meshes set in agarose gel phantom were used as controls. Mann-Whitney U test was done to check for significant differences. RESULTS Number of measurable vertical and horizontal inter-pore distances was 56.5(10.5) and 54.5(14.5) [median (IQR)] per animal. At day 1, we observed a 4.3% (CICAT) and 4.6% (ENDOLAP) increase in vertical inter-pore distance when compared to controls (p<0.001, p=0.003, respectively). Measurements fell back to phantom values by day 15 (3.7% and 4.9% decrease compared to day 1, p<0.001 for both). The horizontal inter-pore distances for ENDOLAP increased by 1.4% (p=0.003) during the two weeks period. The overall mesh dimensions did not change significantly day 1 and day 15. The in vivo measurement of the overall mesh dimensions demonstrated a 15.9% reduction in mesh area as compared to that in phantom controls. CONCLUSION We report for the first time, in vivo changes in pore dimensions of a textile implant. This study clearly demonstrates the dynamic nature of a textile implant during the tissue integration process. For studied PVDF meshes, the process of tissue integration leads to limited but significant reduction over time as observed at the pore level. Remarkably the extent of this reduction does not account for the change in overall mesh dimensions.

Physiologic musculofascial compliance following reinforcement with electrospun polycaprolactone-ureidopyrimidinone mesh in a rat model

PURPOSE Electrospun meshes may be considered as substitutes to textile polypropylene implants. We compared the host response and biomechanical properties of the rat abdominal wall following reinforcement with either polycaprolactone (PCL) modified with ureidopyrimidinone-motifs (UPy) or polypropylene mesh. METHODS First we measured the response to cyclic uniaxial load within the physiological range both dry (room temperature) and wet (body temperature). 36 rats underwent primary repair of a full-thickness abdominal wall defect with a polypropylene suture (native tissue repair), or reinforced with either UPy-PCL or ultra-light weight polypropylene mesh (n = 12/group). Sacrifice was at 7 and 42 days. Outcomes were compliance of explants, mesh dimensions, graft related complications and semi-quantitative assessment of inflammatory cell (sub) types, neovascularization and remodeling. RESULTS Dry UPy-PCL implants are less stiff than polypropylene, both are more compliant in wet conditions. Polypropylene loses stiffness on cyclic loading. Both implant types were well incorporated without clinically obvious degradation or herniation. Exposure rates were similar (n = 2/12) as well as mesh contraction. There was no reinforcement at low loads, while, at higher tension, polypropylene explants were much stiffer than UPy-PCL. The latter was initially weaker yet by 42 days it had a compliance similar to native abdominal wall. There were eventually more foreign body giant cells around UPy-PCL fibers yet the amount of M1 subtype macrophages was higher than in polypropylene explants. There were less neovascularization and collagen deposition. CONCLUSION Abdominal wall reconstruction with electrospun UPy-PCL mesh does not compromise physiologic tissue biomechanical properties, yet provokes a vivid inflammatory reaction.

Comparative Anatomy of the Ovine and Female Pelvis

Background: Pelvic organ prolapse affects half of vaginally parous women. Several animal models are used to study its pathophysiology and treatment. Sheep are interesting because they develop spontaneously prolapse with similar risk factors as women and can be used for vaginal surgery. This study describes ovine pelvis anatomy and compares it to womens pelvis to provide anatomical tools for translational researchers. Methods: MRI, pelvic dissections, and histology were used for detailed macro- and microscopic analysis of relevant anatomical structures in 6 nulliparous ewes. Results: Although sheep are quadrupeds, the gross and microscopic anatomies are similar to the female pelvis. Principal differences are the shape and its orientation, the absence of the sacrospinous ligament and the internal obturator. The levator ani (except for the puborectalis) and the coccygeus muscle are present, yet the latter is more developed - coinciding with the tail. The dimensions and morphology of the ovine vagina is comparable. The retropubic and the rectovaginal space are accessible transvaginally. There is a wide expression of estrogen receptors with low or absent immunoreactivity in the urethral epithelium, bladder, anus and internal anal sphincter. Conclusion: The ovine pelvic floor has many anatomical and ultrastructural similarities to the female pelvic floor.

First delivery and ovariectomy affect biomechanical and structural properties of the vagina in the ovine model

Introduction and hypothesisAnimal models are useful for investigating the genesis of pelvic floor dysfunction and for developing novel therapies for its treatment. There is a need for an alternative large-animal model to the nonhuman primate. Therefore we studied the effects of the first vaginal delivery, ovariectomy and systemic hormonal replacement therapy (HRT) on the biomechanical and structural properties of the ovine vagina.MethodsWe examined the gross anatomical properties of nulliparous, primiparous, ovariectomized multiparous, and ovariectomized hormone-replaced multiparous sheep (six animals per group). We also harvested mid-vaginal and distal vaginal tissue to determine smooth muscle contractility and passive biomechanical properties, for morphometric assessment of the vaginal wall layers, to determine collagen and elastin content, and for immunostaining for α-smooth muscle actin and estrogen receptor-α.ResultsThere were no regional differences in the nulliparous vagina. One year after the first vaginal delivery, stiffness and contractility of the distal vagina were decreased, whereas the elastin content increased. The mid-vagina of ovariectomized sheep was stiff, and its epithelium was thin and lacked glycogen. HRT decreased the stiffness of the mid-vagina by 45% but had no measurable effect on contractility or elastin content, and increased epithelial thickness and glycogen content. HRT also increased the epithelial thickness and glycogen content of the distal vagina. At this location, there were no changes in morphology or stiffness.ConclusionIn sheep, life events including delivery and ovariectomy affect the biomechanical properties of the vagina in a region-specific way. Vaginal delivery mainly affects the distal region by decreasing stiffness and contractility. HRT can reverse the increase in stiffness of the mid-vagina observed after surgical induction of menopause. These observations are in line with scanty biomechanical measurements in comparable clinical specimens.

Assessment of Electrospun and Ultra-lightweight Polypropylene Meshes in the Sheep Model for Vaginal Surgery

BACKGROUND There is an urgent need to develop better materials to provide anatomical support to the pelvic floor without compromising its function. OBJECTIVE Our aim was to assess outcomes after simulated vaginal prolapse repair in a sheep model using three different materials: (1) ultra-lightweight polypropylene (PP) non-degradable textile (Restorelle) mesh, (2) electrospun biodegradable ureidopyrimidinone-polycarbonate (UPy-PC), and (3) electrospun non-degradable polyurethane (PU) mesh in comparison with simulated native tissue repair (NTR). These implants may reduce implant-related complications and avoid vaginal function loss. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS A controlled trial was performed involving 48 ewes that underwent NTR or mesh repair with PP, UPy-PC, or PU meshes (n=12/group). Explants were examined 60 and 180 d (six per group) post-implantation. INTERVENTION Posterior rectovaginal dissection, NTR, or mesh repair. OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Implant-related complications, vaginal contractility, compliance, and host response were assessed. Power calculation and analysis of variance testing were used to enable comparison between the four groups. RESULTS There were no visible implant-related complications. None of the implants compromised vaginal wall contractility, and passive biomechanical properties were similar to those after NTR. Shrinkage over the surgery area was around 35% for NTR and all mesh-augmented repairs. All materials were integrated well with similar connective tissue composition, vascularization, and innervation. The inflammatory response was mild with electrospun implants, inducing both more macrophages yet with relatively more type 2 macrophages present at an early stage than the PP mesh. CONCLUSIONS Three very different materials were all well tolerated in the sheep vagina. Biomechanical findings were similar for all mesh-augmented repair and NTR. Constructs induced slightly different mid-term inflammatory profiles. PATIENT SUMMARY Product innovation is needed to reduce implant-related complications. We tested two novel implants, electrospun and an ultra-lightweight polypropylene textile mesh, in a physiologically relevant model for vaginal surgery. All gave encouraging outcomes.