J.G. Nijhuis

Are there behavioural states in the human fetus

The aim of this study was to search for the existence of behavioural states in the human fetus and to describe their developmental course. In a longitudinal study, 14 low-risk fetuses were studied at 2-week intervals from 32 weeks of gestation onward. Fetal body movements as well as fetal eye movements, visualized by means of real-time ultrasonic imaging, and fetal heart rate patterns, recorded by means of a cardiotocograph, were used as state variables. At 38 and 40 weeks, four distinct behavioural states, named states 1F through 4F and corresponding respectively to states 1 through 4 of the neonate, could be identified. That these constellations of parameters represented true behavioural states was demonstrated by the stability of association of parameters for prolonged periods and by the simultaneity of change of parameters at state transitions. There is evidence for episodes of wakefulness in the fetus. Before 36 weeks, cycles were present in each of the state variables and combinations of parameters typical of particular states were observed. However, the relatively short durations of these combinations and the lack of simultaneity of change in the three state variables support the conclusion that these periods of coincidence occurred by chance and did not represent organized behavioural states.

Intrapartum fetal pulse oximetry: fetal oxygen saturation trends during labor and relation to delivery outcome.

OBJECTIVES Our purpose was to study fetal arterial oxygen saturation trends by continuous pulse oximetry during labor in subjects with normal and abnormal delivery outcomes. STUDY DESIGN Continuous fetal arterial oxygen saturation was measured during labor with a noninvasive reflectance pulse oximeter designed for fetal application. Averaged arterial oxygen saturation values were compared between stage 1 and stage 2 of labor, with stage 1 further subdivided into early (< or = 4 cm), middle (5 to 7 cm), and late (8 to 10 cm) phases. Delivery outcome was considered to be abnormal for any of the following conditions: gestational age < 37 weeks, maternal oxygen administration, delivery by cesarean section, 5-minute Apgar score < 7, umbilical artery pH < 7.10, birth weight < 2500 gm, or newborn intensive care unit admission. RESULTS A total of 291 subjects were studied: 142 in Provo, 90 in Nijmegen and 59 in San Francisco. Subjects with delivery complications (n = 125) were evaluated separately from those with normal delivery outcomes (n = 160). Fetal arterial oxygen saturation was 58% +/- 10% (mean +/- SD) during the cumulative period of study for the normal-outcome group. A significant decrease (paired t test, p < 0.001) in fetal arterial oxygen saturation occurred from stage 1 (59% +/- 10%) to stage 2 (53% +/- 10%) labor. When stage 1 was subdivided into early (< or = 4 cm), middle (5 to 7 cm), and late (8 to 10 cm) phases, a gradual decreasing trend in fetal arterial oxygen saturation was observed: 62% +/- 9%, 60% +/- 11%, and 58% +/- 10%. CONCLUSIONS With the use of reflectance pulse oximetry, a statistically significant decrease in fetal arterial oxygen saturation was observed during labor in women with normal and abnormal delivery outcomes.

Behavioural states in growth-retarded human fetuses

Behavioural state observations were carried out on 12 fetuses which subsequently had birthweights below the 10th percentile. Their gestational ages at the time of study ranged from 32 to 40 weeks. Real-time ultrasound scanning was used to detect fetal body and eye movements, and the fetal heart rate was continuously recorded using a clinical fetal monitor. None of these fetuses was severely acidemic or depressed at birth. Findings in the growth-retarded fetuses were compared with those obtained in the fetuses of 14 low risk nulliparae and 14 low risk multiparae by means of the same techniques (van Vliet et al. (1985) Early Hum. Dev., 12, 121-135.; Nijhuis et al. (1982) Early Hum. Dev., 6, 177-195). The appearance of states seemed to be delayed in the growth-retarded fetuses. States were present in only three of eight growth-retarded fetuses studied at 40 weeks, whereas only one of 16 low risk fetuses did not show states at this age. Also at 40 weeks, the proportion of discordant association of the state variables was increased in the growth-retarded fetuses in comparison to the low risk group. There were no consistent differences between the two groups in the occurrence of defined combinations of parameters of the state variables at earlier ages. The growth-retarded fetuses showed differences in the quality and quantity of somatic motility in comparison to low risk fetuses of equivalent gestational age. These observations suggest that some aspects of central nervous system function are disturbed in growth-retarded fetuses, even in the absence of fetal distress.

HUMAN-FETAL EYE-MOVEMENTS - DETECTION IN UTERO BY ULTRASONOGRAPHY

Eye movements of the human fetus were detected in utero by means of real-time B-scan and M-mode ultrasonography. In 14 low-risk fetuses studied between 32 weeks menstrual age and term either rapid or slow eye movements or a mixture of both types were detected in 60 +/- 10% (mean +/- SD) of 558 2 min scoring epochs. A comparison of direct echoscopic detection of eye movements in a 3-day-old neonate confirmed that the movements observed in the orbital region with the real-time scanner corresponded well with eye movements seen directly. Thus eye movements can be added to the list of phenomena which can be observed noninvasively for the study of human fetal behaviour.

Behavioural states in the fetuses of nulliparous women

Behavioural state observations were carried out serially on the fetuses of 14 low risk nulliparae. They were observed serially at 2-weekly intervals between 32 weeks gestational age and delivery at term. Two real-time ultrasound B-scanners were used to visualize fetal body, eye and breathing movements. Fetal heart rate patterns were recorded simultaneously by means of a clinical fetal monitor. States appeared to be present transiently in three fetuses at 34 weeks. States were definitely present in five of 13 fetuses studied at 38 weeks and six of seven observed at 40 weeks. In comparison to the fetuses of low risk multiparae studied earlier, the fetuses in the present study showed a somewhat lower proportion of quiescence (coincidence 1F) and higher percentage of activity (coincidence 2F); however, most of these differences were not statistically significant. In the fetuses which showed states, the distribution and durations of the states at 38 and 40 weeks were not different from those found previously in the fetuses of multiparae. We conclude that the development of behavioural states is generally similar in the fetuses of low risk nulliparae and multiparae, but that states appear at a somewhat later gestational age in the fetuses of nulliparae.

The rhythmicity of fetal breathing varies with behavioural state in the human fetus

The rhythmicity of human fetal breathing movements was studied during two different behavioural states (1F and 2F, respectively), using real-time B-scan-directed M-mode ultrasound recordings. The mean breath-to-breath interval durations and the standard deviations (SD), and the standard deviations of the interval differences (SDDSI) were calculated. The mean breath-to-breath interval duration was not significantly shorter during 1F than during 2F. SD and SDDSI, however, showed significantly lower values during 1F, demonstrating that the fetal breathing rhythm is more regular during state 1F than during state 2F epochs. Regular fetal breathing is thus a concomitant of state 1F.

The umbilical artery blood flow velocity waveform in relation to fetal breathing movements, fetal heart rate and fetal behavioural states in normal pregnancy at 37 to 39 weeks

In 19 normal pregnancies between 37 and 39 weeks of gestation, the blood flow velocity waveform (FVW) of the umbilical artery was studied in relation to fetal breathing movements, fetal heart rate (FHR) and the fetal heart rate patterns (FHRPs) A and B. FHRP A is stable, with a narrow oscillation bandwidth, FHRP B shows a wider oscillation bandwidth. Although for state-assessment it is necessary to record three variables simultaneously, the linkage of these variables in the near-term healthy fetus is such, that FHRP A and B may be used for the assignment of behavioural states 1F and 2F. The FVW was characterized by the Pulsatility-Index (PI). Presence of fetal breathing movements strongly disturbed the regularity of the FVW. A significant inverse relationship between FHR and PI was established. A weighted regression coefficient was calculated: PI decreases 0.0075 with an increase of FHR of 1 beat per minute (PI140 = PI / 0.0075(FHR - 140]. The PI was higher during periods of FHRP A as compared to FHRP B. However, this difference disappeared, when the influence of FHR was taken into account by normalising all PIs to a standard heart rate level of 140 bpm. One should perform the umbilical artery blood flow measurements in absence of fetal breathing--(causing irregularity of the FVW) and body movements (because of accompanying FHR accelerations) and FHR should be taken into account when evaluating the FVWs.

The association between fetal body movements, eye movements and heart rate patterns in pregnancies between 25 and 30 weeks of gestation

Fetal eye movements, fetal body movements and fetal heart rate patterns were studied in healthy fetuses between 25 and 30 weeks of gestation in 21 recordings with a mean recording time of 83.5 min. In contrast with the older fetus, prolonged periods of absence as well as presence of fetal eye or body movements were uncommon. Especially absence of body movements for more than 15 min is extremely rare at this age. These findings emphasize that for the interpretation of fetal biophysical tests, gestational age should be taken into account. A linkage was demonstrated between fetal eye movements and fetal heart rate pattern and between fetal body movements and fetal heart rate pattern, but not between fetal eye movements and fetal body movements. The existence of fetal behavioural states could not be demonstrated.

A SINUSOIDAL-LIKE FETAL HEART-RATE PATTERN IN ASSOCIATION WITH FETAL SUCKING - REPORT OF 2 CASES

A sinusoidal heart-rate pattern (SHR) is usually considered to signify fetal distress. Two cases are reported in which a sinusoidal-like fetal heart-rate pattern was caused by fetal sucking movements as observed by real-time ultrasonography. The patterns observed in these two fetuses were similar to that found in the neonate during suckling.

Effects of maternal glucose ingestion on human fetal breathing movements at weeks 24 and 28 of gestation

The incidence of human fetal breathing movements was studied in normal pregnancies before and after administration of 50 g glucose or a placebo (water) at 24 and 28 weeks. Glucose or water was given to the same women on two separate days in a randomised order. No significant differences were present among the results on the placebo-day and the control period of the glucose-day at either gestational age. On the glucose-day, the incidence rose significantly from 3.6 to a maximum of 11.6% at 24 weeks, and from 6.7 to 30.2% at 28 weeks. At both ages the maximum was found 90-120 min after the intake of glucose. It is concluded that already at 24 weeks gestation the human fetus reacts with an increase of fetal breathing movements after the administration of glucose to the mother.