J. Hilgers

Summary Report on the ISOBM TD-4 Workshop: Analysis of 56 Monoclonal Antibodies against the MUC1 Mucin

Sixteen research groups participated in the ISOBM TD-4 Workshop in which the reactivity and specificity of 56 monoclonal antibodies against the MUC1 mucin was investigated using a diverse panel of target antigens and MUC1 mucin- related synthetic peptides and glycopeptides. The majority of antibodies (34/56) defined epitopes located within the 20-amino acid tandem repeat sequence of the MUC1 mucin protein core. Of the remaining 22 antibodies, there was evidence for the involvement of carbohydrate residues in the epitopes for 16 antibodies. There was no obvious relationship between the type of immunogen and the specificity of each antibody. Synthetic peptides and glycopeptides were analyzed for their reactivity with each antibody either by assay of direct binding (e.g. by ELISA or BiaCore) or by determining the capacity of synthetic ligands to inhibit antibody binding interactions. There was good concordance between the research groups in identifying antibodies reactive with peptide epitopes within the MUC1 protein core. Epitope mapping tests were performed using the Pepscan analysis for antibody reactivity against overlapping synthetic peptides, and results were largely consistent between research groups. The dominant feature of epitopes within the MUC1 protein core was the presence, in full or part, of the hydrophilic sequence of PDTRPAP. Carbohydrate epitopes were less easily characterized and the most useful reagents in this respect were defined oligosaccharides, rather than purified mucin preparations enriched in particular carbohydrate moieties. It was evident that carbohydrate residues were involved in many epitopes, by regulating epitope accessibility or masking determinants, or by stabilizing preferred conformations of peptide epitopes within the MUC1 protein core. Overall, the studies highlight concordance between groups rather than exposing inconsistencies which gives added confidence to the results of analyses of the specificity of anti-mucin monoclonal antibodies.

Survival in Early Breast Cancer Patients Is Favorably Influenced by a Natural Humoral Immune Response to Polymorphic Epithelial Mucin

PURPOSE Polymorphic epithelial mucin (PEM or MUC1) is being studied as a vaccine substrate for the immunotherapy of patients with adenocarcinoma. The present study analyzes the incidence of naturally occurring MUC1 antibodies in early breast cancer patients and relates the presence of these antibodies in pretreatment serum to outcome of disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS We measured immunoglobulin G (IgG) and immunoglobulin M (IgM) antibodies to MUC1 with an enzyme-linked immunoassay (PEM.CIg), which uses a MUC1 triple-tandem repeat peptide conjugated to bovine serum albumin, in pretreatment serum samples obtained from 154 breast cancer patients (52 with stage I disease and 102 with stage II) and 302 controls. The median disease-specific survival time of breast cancer patients was 74 months (range, 15 to 118 months). A positive test result was defined as MUC1 IgG or IgM antibody levels equal to or greater than the corresponding rounded-up median results obtained in the total breast cancer population. RESULTS A positive test result for both MUC1 IgG and IgM antibodies in pretreatment serum was associated with a significant benefit in disease-specific survival in stage I and II (P =.0116) breast cancer patients. Positive IgG and IgM MUC1 antibody levels had significant additional prognostic value to stage (P =.0437) in multivariate analysis. Disease-free survival probability did not differ significantly. However, stage II patients who tested positive for MUC1 IgG and IgM antibody and who relapsed had predominantly local recurrences or contralateral disease, as opposed to recurrences at distant sites in the patients with a negative humoral response (P =.026). CONCLUSION Early breast cancer patients with a natural humoral response to MUC1 have a higher probability of freedom from distant failure and a better disease-specific survival. MUC1 antibodies may control hematogenic tumor dissemination and outgrowth by aiding the destruction of circulating or seeded MUC1-expressing tumor cells. Vaccination of breast cancer patients with MUC1-derived (glyco)peptides in an adjuvant setting may favorably influence the outcome of disease.

Humoral immune response to polymorphic epithelial mucin (MUC-1) in patients with benign and malignant breast tumours

To investigate the clinical significance of an immune response to the MUC-1 encoded polymorphic epithelial mucin (PEM) breast cancer, circulating immune complexes containing PEM (PEM.CIC) were measured in sera from 96 healthy women, in pretreatment serum samples from 40 patients with benign breast tumours and from 140 patients with breast cancer and in serum samples from 61 breast cancer patients with recurrent or progressive disease. PEM.CIC were measured using a sandwich enzyme-linked immunoassay, and PEM serum levels were measured with CA 15.3 IRMA (Centocor Inc., Malvern, Pennsylvania, U.S.A.). Cut-off levels used for PEM.CIC and CA 15.3 were 120 Optical Density Units (O.D.) x 10(3) and 30 U/ml, respectively. In benign tumours, positivity for PEM.CIC was 37.5% (15/40). 36 of the 140 patients (25.7%) in the breast cancer pretreatment group had elevated PEM.CIC values. In patients with advanced metastatic disease, positivity for PEM.CIC was 18% (11/61). PEM.CIC was elevated in 32% (24/74) of node-negative patients, but only in 20% (12/59) of node-positive patients and absolute values were higher in node-negative patients (Mann-Whitney U test, two-tailed P = 0.0168). There was an inverse correlation between positivity for PEM.CIC and extent of disease: while 3 of the 6 patients with a carcinoma in situ were positive, only 1 of the 15 patients with more than five nodes involved had elevated levels of PEM.CIC. All 7 patients with distant metastases at first diagnosis were PEM.CIC negative. 28 out of 133 patients had a recurrence during the observation period (median 55 months, range 27-84 months). 23 of these 28 patients (82%) were PEM.CIC negative at the moment of first diagnosis. None of the patients with pretreatment elevation of both PEM.CIC and CA 15.3 (n = 13) relapsed. Our preliminary clinical results suggest that a humoral immune response to PEM protects against disease progression, and further support the idea of using synthetic peptides or glycopeptides containing the immunogenic core of the mucin as cancer vaccines.

Reactivity of natural and induced human antibodies to MUC1 mucin with MUC1 peptides and n‐acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) peptides

Antibodies (Abs) to MUC1 occur naturally in both healthy subjects and cancer patients and can be induced by MUC1 peptide vaccination. We compared the specificity of natural and induced MUC1 Abs with the objective of defining an effective MUC1 vaccine for active immunotherapy of adenocarcinoma patients. Serum samples, selected out of a screened population of 492 subjects for their high levels of IgG and/or IgM MUC1 Abs, were obtained from 55 control subjects and from 26 breast cancer patients before primary treatment, as well as from 19 breast cancer patients immunized with MUC1 peptides coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and mixed with QS‐21. The samples were tested with enzyme‐linked immunoassays for reactivity with (1) overlapping hepta‐ and 20‐mer peptides spanning the MUC1 tandem repeat sequence; (2) two modified 60‐mer peptides with substitutions in the PDTR (PDTA) or in the STAPPA (STAAAA) sequence of each tandem repeat; and (3) four 60‐mer glycopeptides with each 1, 2, 3 and 5 mol N‐acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) per repeat. More than one minimal epitopic sequence could be defined, indicating that Abs directed to more than one region of the MUC1 peptide core can coexist in one and the same subject. The most frequent minimal epitopic sequence of natural MUC1 IgG and IgM Abs was RPAPGS, followed by PPAHGVT and PDTRP. MUC1 peptide vaccination induced high titers of IgM and IgG Abs predominantly directed, respectively, to the PDTRPAP and the STAPPAHGV sequences of the tandem repeat. Natural MUC1 Abs from breast cancer patients reacted more strongly with the N‐acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) peptides than with the naked 60‐mer peptide, while reactivity with the GalNAc‐peptides was significantly reduced (2‐tailed p < 0.0001) in the MUC1 IgG and IgM Abs induced by MUC1 peptide vaccination. Whereas in cancer patients glycans appear to participate in epitope conformation, the epitope(s) recognized by MUC1 Abs induced by peptide vaccination are already masked by minimal glycosylation. Therefore, our results indicate that a MUC1 glycopeptide would be a better vaccine than a naked peptide. Int. J. Cancer 86:702–712, 2000.

Polymorphic epithelial mucin (MUC-1)-containing circulating immune complexes in carcinoma patients

Circulating immune complexes (CICs) containing polymorphic epithelial mucin (PEM/MUC-1) were found in sera of 24.5% of 151 primary breast carcinoma patients and 18-21.4% of patients with advanced ovarian (n = 56) and breast carcinomas (n = 61), 37% of patients with benign breast tumours, but in only 2.1% of 96 healthy individuals. The incorporation of PEM into CICs affects the detection of circulating PEM in commercial immunoassays such as the CA 15-3 assay, as suggested by a negative correlation between levels of PEM-containing immune complexes (PEM-CICs) and CA 15-3 values, and confirmed by isolation of PEM from CA 15-3-negative sera containing high levels of PEM-CICs. The amounts of PEM masked by human antibodies correspond to significant values of the CA 15-3 assay when monitoring patients for carcinoma. Most antibodies in PEM-CICs were of IgG class, suggesting their specific nature to the PEM epitopes.

Specificity and Affinity of 26 Monoclonal Antibodies against the CA 125 Antigen: First Report from the ISOBM TD-1 Workshop

The specificity of 26 monoclonal antibodies against the CA 125 antigen was investigated in two phases of the ISOBM TD-1 workshop. The binding specificity was studied using CA 125 immunoextracted by specific antibodies immobilized on various solid phases, or on the surface of human cell lines. Immunometric assays using all possible antibody combinations were used to study the topography of antibody binding sites on the antigen. We conclude that the CA 125 antigen carries only two major antigenic domains, which classifies the antibodies as OC125-like (group A) or M11-like (group B). One antibody, OV 197, showed binding specificity related to some of the OC125-like antibodies, but was classified into a separate group C. The OC125-like group of antibodies has four subgroups with different binding specificities. These are A1 = OC 125 and K 95, A2 = K 93, A3 = B43.13, and A4 = ZS 33, B27.1 and CCD 247. Binding of nonlabelled OC 125 or K 95 to CA 125 caused a marked increase in binding of labelled OV 197 to the complex. This conformational change was not observed with any other antibody combinations. Antibody B43.13 could form immunometric assay combinations particularly with antibodies of subgroup A4, indicating that the B43.13 epitope is in the periphery of the binding area of OC125-like antibodies. The M11-like group of antibodies is more homogenous with strong cross-inhibition between most antibodies. Only one antibody, ZR 38, would form an immunoassay combination with other M11-like antibodies and thus represents a distinct subgroup. The main group of M11-like antibodies are M 11, ZR 45, MA602-6, K 91, OV 185, K 101, K 90, K 96, K 97, K 102, CCD 242, 145-9, and 130-22. Antibody OV 197 binds to a domain designated C and is unique, as stated above. Antibody pairs from any two of the three groups may be used in immunometric assays. Three antibodies were not studied by complete cross-inhibition due to low affinity (OV 198 and K 100) or lack of material (MA602-1). OV 198 and K 100 are most likely OC125-like and MA602-1 is M11-like. Antibody affinity was estimated with labelled antigen in solution or with antigen absorbed on microtiter wells. Western blot analysis showed staining both in the stacking gel and corresponding to a molecule of 200 kDa. There was a marked difference between the antibodies in their ability to bind to CA 125 immobilized on a membrane. Strongest binding was observed with the M11-like antibodies, particularly M 11, K 96, K 97, MA602-6, 145-9. Antibodies belonging to the subgroup A4 were the only OC 125-like antibodies which reacted well with CA 125 in Western analysis. Digestion of CA 125 with proteolytic enzymes showed it to be particularly sensitive to trypsin cleavage. However, no low molecular weight fragments with preserved immunoreactivity were found.

Antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity can be induced by MUC1 peptide vaccination of breast cancer patients

Human polymorphic epithelial mucin (PEM, MUC1) is a high molecular weight transmembrane glycoprotein expressed on the apical cell surface of glandular epithelium and is over‐expressed and hypo‐glycosylated in adenocarcinomas. The extracellular part of the molecule consists mainly of a variable number of 20 amino acid repeats that contain cryptic epitopes exposed in malignancy. The objective of our study was to determine whether humanized MUC1 MAbs and Abs induced by vaccination of breast cancer patients with MUC1 peptides can effect an antibody‐dependent cell‐mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC). An in vitro assay has been set up in which the breast tumor cell line ZR‐75‐1 is used as target and PBMC of healthy donors as effector cells. Different target and effector cells, as well as various MUC1 MAbs were tested to optimize the efficacy of the in vitro assay. The humanized MAb HuHMFG‐1, which recognizes the PDTR sequence in the MUC1 tandem repeat, induced a strong cell‐mediated cytotoxicity. Nine MUC1‐expressing tumor cell lines, including 3 bone marrow‐derived cell lines, as well as 2 MUC1‐transfected cell lines were susceptible to different extent to MUC1 Ab‐dependent killing. Large variations in the killing capacity of PBMC from healthy donors were found. The NK cells were the essential effector cells for the MUC1 Ab‐dependent killing. Plasma samples with induced high levels of MUC1 Ab were obtained from breast cancer patients repeatedly immunized with a KLH‐conjugated 33‐mer or 106‐mer MUC1 tandem repeat. Pre‐ and post‐vaccinated plasma samples of these patients were compared in the ADCC assay and it could be clearly demonstrated that the induced MUC1 Abs can effect tumor cell killing. MUC1 Ab‐dependent cell‐mediated tumor cell killing may occur in vivo and the ADCC assay can be applied to monitor MUC1 vaccination trials.

An Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay for the Measurement of Circulating Antibodies to Polymorphic Epithelial Mucin (MUC1)

Introduction: About one-third of breast and ovarian carcinoma patients have circulating antibodies reactive with polymorphic epithelial mucin (MUC1), either free or bound to immune complexes. While the presence of these immune complexes has prognostic significance in breast cancer patients, the significance of free MUC1 antibodies is less clear. The objective of this study was to develop a reliable assay for the accurate determination of circulating free antibodies to MUC1. Material and Methods: We developed an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (PEM.CIg) employing a 60 mer peptide (a triple tandem repeat sequence of the MUC1 peptide core) conjugated to bovine serum albumin and peroxidase-labeled antihuman immunoglobulin G or M antibodies. The assay was standardized and its analytical performance evaluated. A total of 492 serum samples were obtained from 40 healthy men, from 201 healthy women (including 55 women without a history of pregnancy and 45 pregnant women), and (before primary treatment) from 62 benign breast tumor patients and 190 breast cancer patients. MUC1 serum levels were determined with commercial CA 15-3 tests. Results: Circulating antibodies to MUC1 are present both in healthy subjects and in breast cancer patients. The within- and between-assay coefficients of variation were, respectively, 2 and 12% for the IgG determinations and 1.2 and 3% for the IgM determinations. Correlation coefficients for serially diluted serum samples ranged from 0.9998 to 0.9920 for IgG and from 0.9996 to 0.9818 for IgM determinations. The reactivity of serum samples was partially blocked by the addition of various MUC1 peptides and by MUC1 mucin. The inhibiting effect of modified 60 mer peptides suggests the presence of antibodies directed to more than one epitope. Conclusions: The PEM. CIg assay is a reliable ELISA for measuring free MUC1 antibodies in serum. We are in the process of relating the results obtained in the breast cancer group to disease outcome to evaluate its prognostic significance. In addition, the assay may become a useful tool for vaccine therapy monitoring.

Immunohistochemical characterization of 22 monoclonal antibodies against the CA125 antigen: 2nd report from the ISOBM TD-1 workshop

We evaluated the immunohistological (IH) characteristics of 22 different antibodies that were submitted for study in the frame of the TD-1 ISOBM Workshop on monoclonal antibodies against CA125. Information on relative affinities and epitope similarities was obtained from a parallel immunochemical study. Antibodies were tested at concentrations of 10 and 1 micrograms/ml on frozen and paraffin sections. Paraffin sections were stained according to the streptavidin-biotin complex protocol, and frozen sections according to a two-step immunoperoxidase technique. Aminoethylcarbazole served as the chromogen. The tissues were from normal proliferative endometrium (formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded) material and clear-cell adenocarcinoma of the ovary (formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded and frozen material). Sections were scored for staining in epithelial cells, basal, apical and diffuse cytoplasmic and in stromal components. Intensity was graded as 1, 2 or 3 for epithelial cells and as -1, -2 or -3 for stroma. The cumulative scores for each antibody expressed the discriminative properties of specific epithelial staining against background. M11 and M11-like antibodies, as well as OC125 and OC125-like antibodies, in general showed good staining results. Although there was a trend for high-affinity antibodies to show higher scores, there was no clear relationship between affinity and staining result. For nine antibodies (ZR45, MA602-1, K102, K94, K90, OV185, K97, K96, OV198), the reactions in paraffin and frozen sections were of similar intensity. Most of these were of low affinity with one exception: antibody ZR45, a rat monoclonal antibody (MAb) which had a high relative affinity. For eight antibodies (M11, K101, MA602-6, ZS33, B27.1, B43.13, K93, OC125), a loss of specific staining was observed in frozen sections. All but two of these antibodies (MA602-6 and OC125) were of high relative affinity. With four antibodies (K91, ZR38, K95, K100), the reverse situation was observed. One (K100) was of low affinity, two (K95 and K91) of high affinity and the fourth (ZR38) was a rat MAb of high affinity. Mainly due to the increased cytoplasmic staining in carcinoma, the reactivity in paraffin sections was less extensive in normal endometrium compared to ovarian carcinoma for the majority of antibodies, irrespective of their affinity or epitope group. The IH characterization of these antibodies may be of help in selecting antibodies with specific properties for further comparative studies. The reactivity of normal endometrium with all useful antibodies makes it a good candidate for standard external IH tissue control.

Use of Serum Tumor Markers in the Differential Diagnosis between Ovarian and Colorectal Adenocarcinomas

In the search for a method to facilitate the preoperative discrimination of ovarian carcinomas from colorectal carcinomas serum levels of 6 tumor markers were measured in 47 patients presenting with ovarian cancer and compared to levels found in 24 female patients with advanced, untreated colorectal cancer. The markers studied were CA 125, CA 15.3, CA 19.9, CEA and two recently developed mucin markers, CA M29 and CA M26. Levels of CA 125, CA 15.3, CEA and CA M29 showed significant differences between both groups. In predicting ovarian cancer, sensitivity was highest for CA 125 at 94% (35 U/ml cutoff level). However, the specificity of CA 125 was at 71% low. Specificity increased significantly by using a combination of a CA 125-positive score (greater than 35 U/ml) and a simultaneous negative CEA score (less than or equal to 5 ng/ml) (specificity 100%, sensitivity 81%). A CA 125/CEA serum ratio greater than 25 resulted in the highest discriminative power with a specificity of 100% and a sensitivity of 91% resulting in an overall test accuracy of 94%. It is concluded that the serum tumor markers used, especially a combination of CA 125 and CEA, are helpful in the preoperative differential diagnosis between adenocarcinomas of ovarian and colorectal origin.