J. L. Marsh

Fracture and dislocation classification compendium - 2007: Orthopaedic Trauma Association classification, database and outcomes committee.

The purpose of this new classification compendium is to republish the Orthopaedic Trauma Associations (OTA) classification. The OTA classification was originally published in a compendium of the Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma in 1996. It adopted The Comprehensive Classification of the Long Bones developed by Müller and colleagues and classified the remaining bones. In this compendium, the introductory chapter reviews new scientific information about classifying fractures that has been published in the last 11 years. The classification is presented in a revised format that is easier to follow. The OTA and AO classification will now have a unified alpha-numeric code eliminating the differences that have existed between the 2 codes. The code was significantly revised for the clavicle and scapula, foot and hand, and patella. Dislocations have been expanded on an anatomic basis and for most joints will be coded separately. This publication should stimulate new developments and interest in a unified language to code and classify fractures. Further improvements in classification will result in better patient care and clinical research.

External fixation and limited internal fixation for complex fractures of the tibial plateau.

Twenty-one complex fractures of the tibial plateau in twenty patients were treated with closed reduction, interfragmental screw fixation of the articular fragments, and application of a unilateral half-pin external fixator. The average duration of external fixation was twelve weeks (range, three to twenty weeks). The fixator was left in situ until the fracture had united in all but two patients. All of the fractures healed. The complications with this technique were attributable primarily to the proximal half-pins of the external fixator. Seven patients needed antibiotics for an infection at a pin site, and two had septic arthritis that necessitated arthrotomy and débridement. The average duration of follow-up was thirty-eight months. The range of motion of nineteen of the twenty-one knees was at least a 115-degree arc. Laxity was evident in seven knees, but no patient complained of instability of the knee. Radiographs showed malalignment of more than 6 degrees in three knees compared with the normal, contralateral knee and evidence of post-traumatic osteoarthrosis in five knees. The Iowa knee score, determined for nineteen patients, averaged 87 points (range, 55 to 100 points). The SF-36 general health survey demonstrated that most patients had function close to that of age-matched controls. We concluded that external fixation with limited internal fixation is a satisfactory technique for the treatment of selected complex fractures of the tibial plateau.

Use of an articulated external fixator for fractures of the tibial plafond

We performed a prospective study of forty-nine displaced fractures of the tibial plafond in forty-eight patients managed, at three centers, with an articulated external fixator placed medially across the ankle joint. Forty ankles had interfragmental screw fixation of a reduced articular fracture, and fourteen ankles had bone-grafting. The average duration of external fixation was twelve weeks. All of the fractures healed (one after delayed bone-grafting). There were no infections in any of the operative or traumatic wounds over the tibia. Two wound infections over the fibula resolved with treatment. Eight patients were managed with antibiotics for a pin-site infection, and two patients had curettage and débridement of a pin site in the hindfoot after removal of the fixator. Thirty patients (thirty-one ankles) completed two-year data sheets at an average of thirty months after the injury. The average ankle score was 67 points. Twenty-one patients had grade-0 or 1 osteoarthrosis and nine had grade-2 or 3. One ankle had been treated with an arthrodesis. These data suggest that the prevalence of early complications associated with severe fractures of the tibial plafond and their treatment can be decreased with use of an articulated external fixator combined with limited internal fixation. We concluded that this technique of external fixation is a satisfactory technique for the treatment of these fractures.

Ankle fractures in patients with diabetes mellitus

Diabetes mellitus is considered an indicator of poor prognosis for acute ankle fractures, but this risk may be specific to an identifiable subpopulation. We retrospectively reviewed 42 patients with both diabetes mellitus and an acute, closed, rotational ankle fracture. Patients were individually matched to controls by age, gender, fracture type, and surgical vs non-surgical treatment. Outcomes were major complications during the first six months of treatment. We contrasted secondarily 21 diabetic patients with and 21 without diabetic comorbidities. Diabetic patients and controls did not differ significantly in total complication rates. More diabetic patients required long-term bracing. Diabetic patients without comorbidities had complication rates equal to their controls. Diabetic patients with comorbidities had complications at a higher rate (ten patients; 47%) than matched controls (three patients; 14%, p = 0.034). A history of Charcot neuroarthropathy led to the highest rates of complication. An increased risk of complications in diabetic patients with closed rotational fractures of the ankle are specific to a subpopulation with identifiable related comorbidities.

Complications of Locking Plate Fixation in Complex Proximal Tibia Injuries

Objectives: To report the complications and pitfalls in the treatment of complex injuries of the proximal tibia when locking plates are used. Design, Setting, and Patients: This was a retrospective case series conducted at a university Level I trauma center. Thirty-seven patients with complex proximal tibia fractures (41C1, 41C2, 41C3, 41A2, 42A2) were treated with locking plates. Intervention: All fractures were treated with locking plates (Less Invasive Stabilization System (LISS); Synthes, Paoli, PA). Main Outcome Measurements: Healing, alignment, infection, and other complications. Results: Twelve fractures (32%) healed without any complications. Eight patients (22%) developed deep infections that required operative debridements, and 5 of them had a hardware removal; 1 eventually required an above-knee amputation. Eight cases (22%) had postoperative malalignment, with hyperextension as the most common deformity. Three cases (8%) had loss of alignment into varus during healing. Other complications were 1 superficial wound dehiscence, 1 delayed soft-tissue breakdown, 4 hardware irritations, 1 peroneal nerve injury at the distal part of a 9-hole plate, 1 tibial tubercle nonunion, and 1 postoperative compartment syndrome. Conclusion: The complication rate, particularly infection, was higher than in previous reports. Other complications such as hardware prominence, malalignment, and loss of alignment were similar to those of historical controls. Some of the complications may reflect the techniques that were used and should decrease with more experience; however, some may be inherent in the treatment of high-energy fractures using locking plates.

Assessment of the AO/ASIF fracture classification for the distal tibia.

OBJECTIVES The purpose of this study was to assess the interobserver reliability and intraobserver reproducibility of the AO/ASIF and Rüedi and Allgöwer classifications for fractures of the distal tibia, and to determine the benefit of a computed tomography (CT) scan and experience on observer agreement for several fracture characteristics, including classification. METHODS The radiographs of forty-three fractures of the distal tibia, fourteen of which had CT scans, were assessed by groups of experienced and less-experienced observers. Each case was classified according to the AO/ASIF and Rüedi and Allgöwer systems. Several other fracture characteristics also were assessed. The kappa coefficient of agreement was calculated and used to compare the interobserver reliability and intraobserver reproducibility of the classification systems and to determine the benefit of experience and CT scans. The intraclass correlation coefficient was used to assess noncategoric data. RESULTS Interobserver and intraobserver agreements were good when classifying fractures into AO/ASIF types and significantly better than that for the Rüedi and Allgöwer system. However, agreement was poor when classifying the fractures into AO/ASIF groups. For most assessments, the experienced group tended to have higher levels of interobserver agreement, but not intraobserver agreement. Viewing the CT scans improved agreement on the percentage of articular surface involved, but it did not improve interobserver reliability or intraobserver reproducibility for either of the classification systems. CONCLUSION The AO/ASIF classification for fractures of the distal tibia has good observer agreement at the type level, but poor agreement at the group level. Experience tends to improve interobserver agreement, but not intraobserver agreement. Viewing CT scans does not improve agreement on classification, but it tends to improve agreement on articular surface involvement.

Kinematic and contact stress analysis of posterior malleolus fractures of the ankle.

Objective: To determine if there are measurable dynamic contact stress aberrations and kinematic abnormalities (instability) that have not been observed in conventional static loading studies of posterior malleolar ankle fractures. Design: Cadaveric fracture model. Setting: Biomechanics laboratory. Intervention: Seven fresh cadaveric specimens were fixed in an unconstrained testing apparatus and loaded to one body weight. The ankle was moved from 25° of plantarflexion to 15° of dorsiflexion. The model included the intact ankle and four fracture simulations (50% fracture without internal fixation, 2 mm gap and step malreductions, and anatomically fixed). Main Outcome Measure: Motion at the ankle was monitored with an electromagnetic tracking device, and intra-articular contact stresses were measured using a real-time stress sensor. Results: There were no kinematic abnormalities suggestive of tibiotalar subluxation in any of the fracture simulations. There was no increase in peak contact stress in any of the fracture models compared with the unfractured model. However, there was a shift in the location of the contact stresses to a more anterior and medial location following the fracture. When summed over the range of motion, these areas of cartilage bore significantly higher cumulative contact stresses relative to the nonfracture situation. Conclusions: We found no talar subluxation and no increase in contact stresses near the articular incongruity, making it unlikely that these factors explain the increased incidence of arthrosis after trimalleolar fractures (OTA/AO classification 44 B3 fractures). Rather, we found that the joint remaining bears increased stress and that the center of stress shifts anteriorly, loading cartilage that normally sees little load.

Percutaneous reduction and fixation of displaced intra-articular calcaneus fractures.

Objectives: The purpose of this study is to assess the initial results of percutaneously reducing and fixing calcaneus fractures compared with a concurrent control group that was openly reduced and internally fixed through an extensile lateral approach. Design: Retrospective cohort study, consecutive series. Setting: Level I trauma center. Patients/Participants: One hundred twenty patients with 125 intra-articular calcaneus fractures were selected as a consecutive series with treatment method randomized by surgeon and time of presentation. Intervention: Patients treated with open reduction and internal fixation (OR group) had an extended lateral approach and fractures were fixed with plates and screws. Patients treated with percutaneous reduction (PR group) had small incisions with indirect fragment manipulation, and the reduction achieved was secured with screws alone. Main Outcome Measurement: Clinical and radiographic assessment. Results: There were 41 patients with 42 fractures in the OR group and 79 patients with 83 fractures in the PR group. There were no significant differences in sex, age, open fractures, fracture classification, or initial Bohlers angle between the two groups. Bohlers angle was improved after surgery by an average of 22.4° in the OR group and 25.3° in the PR group (P = 0.31). The average loss of reduction at healing (minimum 4 months postoperatively) was not significantly different between the two groups. Deep infection occurred in six of 42 of the OR group and zero of 83 of the PR group (P = 0.002). The incidence of minor wound complications was nine of 42 in the OR group and five of 83 in the PR group (P = 0.03). The need for late subtalar fusions (two of 26 and three of 41 with full 2-year follow-up) and implant removal (five of 42 and 10 of 83) was not significantly different. Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that in comparison to open reduction, this method of percutaneously reducing and fixing calcaneus fractures minimizes complications and achieves and maintains extra-articular reductions as well as the standard extensile open reduction and internal fixation. Further study of this technique is warranted. This should include assessment of articular reduction and longer follow-up of a larger number of patients.

Major open injuries of the talus.

Summary: Seventeen patients with 18 open talar fracture-dislocations or total dislocations of the talus were reviewed to determine the functional outcome and incidence of infection. Seven of 18 feet (38%) developed infection. Infection was associated with extrusion of the talar body through the open wound (p < 0.025). Final follow-up was achieved in 13 of 17 patients (14 of 18 feet) at an average of 7 years and 4 months after injury. According to the Boston Childrens Hospital ankle grading system, the overall results were considered excellent in one, good in five, fair in two, and failures in six feet. The data suggest a greater proportion of failures in the infected group compared with the non-infected group (p = 0.05).

Chronic infected tibial nonunions with bone loss. Conventional techniques versus bone transport.

Twenty-five patients with infected nonunions of the tibia and segmental bone loss were treated by one of two methods: resection and bone transport, or conventional treatment using less extensive debridement, external fixation, bone grafting, and soft-tissue coverage. The two groups were comparable except for gender distribution. Each group experienced similar rates of healing; eradication of infection; treatment time; final angulation; number of complications; and total number of surgical procedures. However, the final limb-length discrepancy was significantly less in the bone transport group.