J. M. García Páez

Comparison of the mechanical behaviors of biological tissues subjected to uniaxial tensile testing: pig, calf and ostrich pericardium sutured with Gore-Tex

The purpose of this study was to compare the mechanical behavior of calf pericardium, pig pericardium and ostrich pericardium when subjected to tensile testing. Tensile stress was applied to 108 tissue samples, 36 of each type of tissue, until rupture. Groups of three adjacent strips measuring 12 x 2 cm(2) were cut longitudinally. Each group consisted of an unsutured center sample, or control, and the two contiguous samples, that on the right sutured with Gore-Tex at a 90 degrees angle with respect to the longitudinal axis and that on the left sewn with the same suture material at 45 degrees angle. The sutured samples showed a statistically significant loss of resistance (p<0.001) when compared with the corresponding unsutured tissue. The mean stresses at rupture for sutured ostrich pericardium were 21.81 and 20.81 MPa in the samples sewn at 45 degrees and 90 degrees, respectively, higher than those corresponding to unsutured calf and pig pericardium, 14.0 and 11.49 MPa, respectively, at rupture. The analysis of the stress/strain curve shows a smaller difference between sutured and unsutured ostrich pericardium than those observed in the other two biomaterials. These results demonstrate that, in addition to its greater resistance, ostrich pericardium also presents a less pronounced interaction with the suture material. Its capacity to absorb the shearing stress produced by the suture is greater. This report also confirms that the method of selection using paired samples ensures their homogeneity and makes it possible to predict the behavior of a sample by determining that of the other half of the pair.

Resistance and elasticity of the suture threads employed in cardiac bioprostheses

The mechanoelastic features of five types of sutures were studied. The breaking stress for each was determined by means of tensile tests in which a constant strain rate was applied, and a tensile test with graduated stress and relaxation defined the elastic limit, i.e. the point beyond which deformation becomes irreversible. The study of the stress-strain curve during this elastic period enabled us to obtain the mathematical function that governs these reversible deformations, which shows excellence of fit (R2 > 0.98). The prime derivative at each point of the resulting functions is the elastic modulus, the best parameter for comparing the elasticities of the suture threads. Since breaking stress alone does not suitably define the mechanical quality of a suture, we propose the use of other parameters during the elastic period, such as percentage of elongation at a point 10 times lower than the elastic limit (safety coefficient of 10), and tensile stress and elastic modulus at the said point, which are more reliable in the assessment of the resistance and elasticity of these threads.

Comparison of elasticities of components of a cardiac bioprosthesis leaflet

The mechanoelastic behavior of calf pericardium employed in cardiac bioprostheses was compared with that of three types of thread (Nylon, Prolene, and silk) used to suture this biological tissue. The elastic limit (EL) of each material was determined by means of tensile tests and the mathematical functions that govern the stress/strain curves within the EL have been described. The first derivative of these functions for each point to the curves allowed the immediate calculation of the elastic modulus (EM), which was considered the best parameter for comparing the elasticities of the materials being assessed. It was observed that the deformation of the pericardium produced by the working stress of a pericardial leaflet was approximately 1000 times greater than that produced in the surgical threads. When the elasticities were compared on the basis of the EM, that of pericardium was 749.06, 626.95, and 1253.17 times greater than that of the Nylon, Prolene, and silk suture threads, respectively. These results demonstrate that the interaction between these materials (pericardium and the threads) could be generating detrimental forces that can diminish the durability of the leaflets of the bioprostheses constructed of calf pericardium.

Elastic behaviour of sutured calf pericardium: influence of the suture threads

The purpose of this study was to assess the elastic behaviour of calf pericardium used in the construction of cardiac bioprosthesis valve leaflets, sutured with different types of commercially available sutures: silk, Gore-Tex, Surgilene and nylon. Thirty-two samples (four series of eight samples each) were subjected to tensile strength testing to breakage. The breaking stress (MPa) ranged between 4.89 MPa for samples sutured with Gore-Tex and 5.22 MPa for those sewn with nylon. Three samples from each series were subjected to a stepwise stress test, involving increasing levels of stress followed by return to zero, to define the elastic limit (the cut-off point beyond which strain is no longer reversible). Analysis of the results provided the mathematical functions that govern the elastic behaviour (stress/strain) within the elastic range for each type of sutured sample. The series sutured with Surgilene presented the highest mean value (1.649 MPa). Finally, a statistical study was carried out to determine which series showed the greatest probability of having the least interaction between the thread and the pericardium. Allowing an interval of +/- 10%, Gore-Tex showed the best probability in this respect. However, real fatigue testing is necessary to definitively determine which is the best suture to use.

ANALYSIS OF SHEARING STRESS IN THE LIMITED DURABILITY OF BOVINE PERICARDIUM USED AS A BIOMATERIAL

The objective of the study was to determine the shearing stress exerted by the suture thread under conditions of normal working stress. Thirty-six samples of calf pericardium, similar to that employed in the manufacture of bioprosthetic cardiac valve leaflets, were subjected to tensile testing. Prior to the trial, a continuous suture was sewn in the central zone of each sample, at a 45° angle to the longest axis of the sample, using commercially-available threads (silk, Gore-Tex, Surgilene and nylon). Application of the Mohr circle for combined wear revealed that the shearing stress ranged between 2.68-fold greater (for samples sewn with silk) and 5.48-fold greater (for samples sewn with nylon) than the working tensile stress in the region of the suture. It is concluded that the shearing stress is responsible for the limited durability of sutured samples of calf pericardium prepared to simulate bioprosthetic cardiac valve leaflets.

Resistance and Stability of A New Method for Bonding Biological Materials Using Sutures and Biological Adhesives

The valve leaflets of cardiac bioprostheses are secured and shaped by sutures which, given their high degree of resistance and poor elasticity, have been implicated in the generation of stresses within the leaflets, contributing to the failure of the bioprostheses. Bioadhesives are bonding materials that have begun to be utilized in surgery, although there is a lack of experience in their use with inert tissues or bioprostheses. Tensile testing is performed until rupture in samples of calf pericardium, a biomaterial employed in the manufacture of bioprosthetic heart valve leaflets. One hundred and thirty-two trials are carried out in three types of samples: intact or control tissue (n = 12); samples transected and glued in an overlapping manner with a cyanoacrylate (n = 60); and samples transected, sewn with a commercially available suture material and reinforced at the suture holes with the same cyanoacrylate (n = 60). Seven days after their preparation, 12 samples from each group, including the controls, are subjected to tensile testing until rupture and the findings are compared. In the stability study, groups of 12 each of the remaining 48 glued and 48 sutured and glued samples underwent tensile testing until rupture on days 30, 60, 90, and 120, after their preparation. The results show that bonding with the adhesive provided a resistance ranging between 1.04 and 1.87 kg, probably insufficient for use in valve leaflets, but also afforded a high degree of elasticity. After 120 days, both the glued and the sutured and glued series show excellent elastic behavior, with no rigidity or hardening of the pericardium. These samples present reversible elongation, or strain, when they surpass their elastic limit at rupture. This finding may be due to a load concentration that is damaging to the pericardium, to the behavior of the tissue as an amorphous material, or perhaps to both circumstances. These results need to be confirmed in future studies as they may be of value in the design and manufacture of cardiac bioprostheses.

Mechanical effects of increases in the load applied in uniaxial and biaxial tensile testing. Part II. Porcine pericardium.

The authors analyzed the mechanical behavior of the calf pericardium employed in the construction of valve leaflets for cardiac bioprostheses. Forty samples of pericardium were subjected to uniaxial tensile testing, 20 as controls and 20 exposed to loads increasing stepwise until rupture, with a return to zero load between each new increment. Another 20 samples were used similarly in biaxial tensile tests involving loads increasing stepwise until rupture, again returning to zero load between steps. The ultimate stresses in the uniaxial study were very similar and were not influenced by the region of pericardial tissue being tested or the increments in load to which the tissue was exposed. The mean stresses at rupture in the stepwise biaxial assays were significantly greater (p<0.01). Using morphological and mechanical criteria for sample selection, it was possible to obtain mathematical fits for the stress/strain relationship in both types of assays, with excellent coefficients of determination (R 2>0.90). In uniaxial tests in which the selection criteria were not applied, the correlation improved as the load increased, a phenomenon that did not occur in the biaxial studies. The values varied throughout the different cycles, adopting exponential forms when the strain was greatest. These variations, which demonstrate that the increase in the energy consumed is a function of the stress applied and of the strain produced, should be good parameters for assessing the changes in the collagen fiber architecture of pericardial tissue subjected to cyclic stress, and may help to detect early failure.

Influence of stress on calcification of delipidated bovine pericardial tissue employed in construction of cardiac valves

Since the development of cardiac bioprostheses, numerous chemical treatments have been assayed to prevent mineralization. The effectiveness of chemical treatments that eliminate lipids from the tissue was tested by combining two models. First, handmade bovine pericardial bioprostheses, subjected to chemical treatment with chloroform/ methanol and glutaraldehyde or treated with glutaraldehyde alone for use as controls, were subjected to mechanical stress in a heart valve, accelerated wear tester (100 x 10(6) consecutive cycles). Then, the bioprostheses were unstitched and tissue samples were taken from the portion subjected to maximal stress (P1) and from that surrounding the sewing ring, which had not been subjected to mechanical stress (P2), for subcutaneous implantation. After 21 and 60 days of implantation, we observed calcification of the samples subjected to mechanical stress, even after delipidating treatment, with no significant differences with respect to the control group. However, the treated samples from the portion not subjected to mechanical stress presented a slighter accumulation of calcium after 60-day implantation (5.60 +/- 3.09 mg Ca2 +/g dry weight of tissue) versus the control group (47.17 +/- 20.4 mg Ca2+/g dry weight of tissue), the difference of which was statistically significant (p < 0.01). At the time of these medium-term studies, marked calcification was observed in tissue subjected to delipidating treatment in the zones that underwent mechanical stress.

Influence of the Selection of the Suture Material on the Mechanical Behavior of a Biomaterial to be Employed in the Construction of Implants. Part 1: Calf Pericardium

A hydraulic stress simulator was employed to study the mechanical behavior of the calf pericardium used in the construction of cardiac valve leaflets. One hundred eighty pairs of tissue samples were subjected to tensile testing to rupture. One of the two samples from each of 144 pairs (four series of 36 pairs each) was sutured with commercially available threads made of nylon, silk, Prolene or Gore-Tex, while the other sample in each of these pairs was left unsewn. The remaining 36 pairs were employed as controls in which neither of the two samples was subjected to suturing. The sutured tissue samples showed a significant decrease in tensile strength at rupture (range: 11.81 to 26.04 MPa) when compared with unsutured samples (range: 39.38 to 87.96 MPa; p < 0.01). The application of morphological and mechanical selection criteria to maximize the homogeneity of the samples provided excellent fit with respect to the stress/strain curves. This method made it possible to carry out a predictive study of the mechanical behavior of a sutured sample, based on that observed in the corresponding unsutured fragment. The interaction of the different suture materials with the pericardial tissue was also assessed by comparing the mechanical behavior of the sutured samples with that of the control samples. At stresses of less than 0.8 MPa, samples sewn with Gore-Tex were found to show the least difference with respect to the controls, indicating that this material presented the lowest degree of interaction with the pericardium. In conclusion, the degree of the loss of resistance to tearing of the sutured samples is of no value in the selection of the optimal suture material. The selection process applied makes it possible to predict the mechanical behavior in response to suturing of a given unsewn tissue specimen by determining that of its sutured mate. The similarity between the findings in samples sewn with Gore-Tex and in the unsutured controls indicates a lesser degree of interaction between thesuture material and the pericardium employed in the construction of cardiac valve leaflets.

Energy consumption as a predictor test of the durability of a biological tissue employed in cardiac bioprosthesis

The mechanical behavior of the young bull pericardium in a fatigue test has been studied. This material is a similar tissue to those used in valve leaflet construction for a cardiac bioprosthesis. The consumed energy on each test was evaluated and afterwards used as a predictor of the biomaterial strength. Two-hundred and nine samples were tested to cyclical fatigue. The cut-off point to determine the sample quality was whether or not they resisted at least 4500 cycles. Only 22 samples withstood over that point (10.52%). The samples were classified according to their fatigue behavior in excellent, undefined and unsuitable. By using as a reference the consumed energy in the first 25 cycles, we could distinguish correctly (between 93.2 and 96.1%) the unsuitable material and most of the excellent (between 78.1 and 95.2%). From the rejected material 77% was really detachable and from the accepted, only 50% was excellent, with an equal methodology. The receiver operating characteristics curve was employed to establish decision levels when selecting samples, being 0.85 the best area (theoretical maximum value of 1). It is concluded that the energy wasted is a good predictor of the strength of the tissue. More than 90% of the unsuitable material and 50% of the excellent material (5% of all the material) is detected with this method.