J.P.M. Lenssen

Does disturbance favour weak competitors? Mechanisms of changing plant abundance after flooding

Abstract Question: Does disturbance reduce competition intensity and thus favour weak competitors that are presumably less affected by disturbance than strong competitors? Methods: We used a single flooding event with increasing duration to simulate disturbance with increasing intensity. Six flood-plain grass species, typical of different flood regimes were grown in monocultures and in an additive species mixture. Flooding took place early in the first growing season and changes were monitored until the end of the second growing season. Results: Longer flooding durations initially decreased competition, but only a single species (Agrostis) increased its abundance in mixtures after flooding. The two weakest competitors in our selection (Poa trivialis and Elytrigia repens) failed to benefit from flooding because direct losses from flooding exceeded gains from reduced competition. Accordingly, we found no trade-off between flooding tolerance and competitive ability indicating that floods affect strong and weak competitors equally, although some species tolerated floods better than others. Conclusions: Since competition is only temporarily weakened after disturbance, increased competitive ability relative to other species may provide a more effective strategy for persistence in flood-disturbed sites. Above-ground runners seem an important prerequisite for enhanced competitive ability of clonal species in flood-disturbed sites. Nomenclature: van der Meijden (1996). Abbreviations: lnRR = natural log of the response ratio; LT50 = number of days (‘lethal time’) after which 50% of individuals had died.

EXPERIMENTAL RAMET AGGREGATION IN THE CLONAL PLANT AGROSTIS STOLONIFERA REDUCES ITS COMPETITIVE ABILITY

Spatial models predict that long-distance dispersal of offspring provides competitive superiority in open environments. We tested this prediction by artificially aggregating ramets of the spreading clonal species Agrostis stolonifera in an undisturbed environment and in an environment where flooding increased open space. We compared the competitive response of this manipulated Agrostis with both the natural ramet distribution of Agrostis and with the naturally aggregated clonal species Alopecurus pratensis. Our phenotypic manipulation of ramet dispersal significantly increased aggregation of clonal offspring, without altering the number of offspring, and thus provided an adequate test of spatial effects. Regardless of flooding, both Alopecurus and the aggregated Agrostis were more suppressed in species mixtures than the natural dispersed form of Agrostis. This demonstrates that long distance dispersal of ramets enhances competitive ability, at least in early stages of succession.

Selection on phenotypic plasticity of morphological traits in response to flooding and competition in the clonal shore plant Ranunculus reptans

Adaptive evolution of phenotypic plasticity requires that plastic genotypes have the highest global fitness. We studied selection by spatial heterogeneity of interspecific competition and flooding, and by temporal heterogeneity of flooding on morphological plasticity of 52 genotypes of the clonal shore plant Ranunculus reptans. Competition reduced clone size, rosette size, leaf length and stolon internode thickness. Flooding had similar effects and reduced competition. Differences in selection between environments imply potential for either local adaptation or for indirect evolution of phenotypic plasticity. We also detected direct selection for plastic reductions in internode length in response to flooding and for a plastic increase in internode length in response to competition. Plastic responses of some morphological traits to flooding were in line with selection thereon, suggesting that they indeed are adaptive and might have evolved in response to direct selection on plasticity.