J. Richard Thistlethwaite

Posttransplant lymphoproliferative disease in pediatric liver transplantation. Interplay between primary Epstein-Barr virus infection and immunosuppression.

The incidence, risk factors, and outcome of posttransplant lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD) were examined for 298 children undergoing liver transplantation. The overall incidence of PTLD was 8.4% (25 of 298). Intensity of immunosuppression was found to be a major risk factor for the development of PTLD. Cyclosporine and tacrolimus when used as primary immunosuppression were associated with the development of PTLD in 4.3% and 6.6% of cases (P=NS). OKT3 and tacrolimus, when used as rescue therapy for steroid-resistant rejection, were associated with a comparable increase in the risk of developing PTLD (10.9% and 11.1%, P=NS). Patients requiring both OKT3 and tacrolimus to treat refractory rejection were at significantly increased risk for PTLD (28.1% vs. 4.3% or 6.6%, P<0.0001). PTLD was more common in patients who received transplants for Langerhans cell histiocytosis relative to other indications for transplantation (66% vs. 8.4%, P=0.0005). The data also support an association between primary Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infections following transplantation and the development of PTLD. While only three patients were EBV seropositive before transplantation (14%), 19 patients were EBV seropositive at the time of diagnosis of PTLD (90%), confirming a high incidence of primary EBV infections in patients with PTLD (21 patients had both pre- and posttransplant EBV serologies). In this series, PTLD was associated with a mortality rate of 60%, and 12 of the 15 patients who died had persistent tumor at the time of death. Five of the 13 patients rendered disease-free developed ductopenic rejection. Of the four with severe liver dysfunction, two have undergone successful retransplantation and are alive without evidence of PTLD. In conclusion, intense immunosuppression using OKT3 and tacrolimus as rescue agents was associated with a significant increase in the incidence of PTLD. Primary EBV infection after transplantation further accentuated this risk. Independent of these risk factors, patients with Langerhans cell histiocytosis were at significantly increased risk for PTLD. The identification of high-risk patients should allow the development of protocols to screen patients for primary EBV infections and early indications of PTLD, as well as the institution of preemptive antiviral and antitumor therapies.

Inhibition Of Transplant Rejection Following Treatment With Anti-b7-2 And Anti-b7-1 Antibodies

Antigen-specific T cell activation depends initially on the interaction of the T cell receptor (TCR) with peptide/MHC. In addition, a costimulatory signal, mediated by distinct cell surface accessory molecules, is required for complete T cell activation leading to lymphokine production and proliferation. CD28 has been implicated as the major receptor on T cells responsible for delivering the costimulatory signal. Although two distinct ligands for CD28, B7-1 and B7-2, have been identified on antigen-presenting cells (APC), the co-stimulatory role of each molecule during a physiological immune response remains unresolved. In the present study, the relative roles of B7-1 and B7-2 interactions were evaluated in an allogeneic pancreatic islet transplant setting. In isolation, anti-B7-2 mAbs and, to a much lesser degree, anti-B7-1 mAbs suppressed T cell proliferative responses to allogeneic islets or splenic APC in vitro. Maximal inhibition of the allogeneic response was observed using a combination of the anti-B7-1 and anti-B7-2 mAbs. Administration of anti-B7-2 but not anti-B7-1 mAbs prolonged C3H allograft survival in B6 recipients, with a combination of both mAbs significantly prolonging rejection beyond either mAb alone. The immunosuppressive effects of the in vivo mAb treatment were not manifested in in vitro analyses as T cells isolated from suppressed mice responded normally to allogeneic stimuli in terms of both proliferation and lymphokine production. However, combined mAb therapy in vivo selectively delayed CD4+ T lymphocyte infiltration into the graft. These data suggest that both B7-1 and B7-2 costimulatory molecules are active in vivo, although B7-2 plays a clearly dominant role in this allograft model. The mechanism of immune suppression in vivo remains unresolved but may occur at sites distinct from the allograft.

A non-activating humanized anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody retains immunosuppressive properties in vivo

OKT3, a mouse anti-human CD3 mAb, is a potent immunosuppressive agent used in clinical transplantation to prevent or treat allograft rejection. Associated with this therapy is the systemic release of several cytokines that result in a series of adverse side effects. This release of cytokines is dependent on the cross-linking mediated by OKT3 between T cells and the FcγR-bearing cells. To generate an anti-human CD3 mAb with reduced activating properties as compared with OKT3, we have transferred the complementary determining regions of OKT3 onto human IgG frameworks and then performed point mutations that reduce the affinity of the “humanized” anti-CD3 mAbs for FcγRs. Initial, in vitro, studies showed that whereas OKT3 and the parental humanized anti-CD3 mAbs activated T cells similarly, a humanized Fc variant failed to do so. Both the Fc variant and the activating anti-CD3 mAbs induced comparable modulation of the TCR and suppression of cytolytic T cell activity, in vitro. In the current study, we exploited an experimental model in which human splenocytes from cadaveric organ donors were inoculated into severe combined immunodeficient mice (hu-SPL-SCID mice) to test the activating and immunosuppressive properties of these anti-human CD3 mAbs in vivo. Unlike injection of OKT3 or of the parental humanized mAb, administration of the Fc variant did not result in T cell activation in vivo, as evidenced by the lack of induction of surface markers of activation, and of systemic human cytokines, including IL-2. Importantly, similar prolongation of human allograft survival was achieved with all anti-CD3 mAbs, indicating that the nonactivating anti-CD3 mAbs retained significant immunosuppressive properties in vivo. Thus, the use of an Fc variant in clinical transplantation should result in fewer side effects than observed with OKT3, while maintaining its clinical efficacy.

Liver transplantation with reduced-size donor organs

Orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) of the pediatric patient is often limited by the availability of a size-matched donor organ. Use of reduced liver transplantation (RLT) can increase the proportion of candidates transplanted and may reduce overall mortality. We report herein the initial clinical application of RLT in the United States. Indications for RLT included fulminant hepatic failure (n=2), acute hepatic artery thrombosis (n=3), and chronic liver disease unresponsive to inpatient support and more than 30 days on transplant list (n=4). Donor hepatectomy was performed using standard techniques. Formal hepatic resection was performed ex-vivo to create a size-matched graft, from the larger donor organ, which was implanted in the orthotopic position. Between 11/84 and 4/87, 70 pediatric patients were evaluated for OLT, and 33 of these were transplanted. During this period only 5 patients (7%) died awaiting OLT. Of 33 patients treated at the University of Chicago, 5 received RLT. Donor: recipient weight ratios ranged from 2:1 to 8.1:1. For RLT median operative blood loss was 1.7 blood volumes (range 0.5–11.7) with an operative time of 9.3+3.5 hr. Acceptable early graft function was observed in five patients, all of whom were discharged from the hospital. Four of these five patients are alive between 2 and 48 months after transplantation. Marginal graft function with cholestasis and coagulopathy was associated with acute intracranial hemorrhage and neurologic death in one case. One patient died intraoperatively with non-function caused by the use of a liver from a donor with steatosis and a poor size match. Another patient died on day 5 with primary nonfunction and persistant hemorrhage. Systemic cytomegalovirus infection was the cause of death in the other two cases. RLT can provide life-sustaining liver function in urgent clinical settings. The graft can serve as a temporary or permanent liver replacement. With evolution of the technique RLT could eventually be offered to more elective candidates and increase the utilization of available donors by reducing size limitations in OLT.

Complications in 100 living-liver donors

OBJECTIVE A review of 100 living-liver donors was performed to evaluate the perisurgical complications of the procedure and thus to help quantify the risks to the donor. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA Despite the advantages of living-donor liver transplantation (LDLT), the procedure has received criticism for the risk it imposes on healthy persons. A paucity of data exists regarding the complications and relative safety of the procedure. METHODS One hundred LDLTs performed between November 1989 and November 1996 were reviewed. Donor data were obtained by chart review, anesthesia records, and the computerized hospital data base. Patient variables were compared by Fishers exact test and the Students t test. RESULTS There were 57 women and 43 men with a median age of 29. Donors were divided into two groups: group A (first 50 donors), and group B (last 50 donors). There were 91 left lateral segments and 9 left lobes. There were no deaths. Fourteen major complications occurred in 13 patients; 9 occurred in group A and 5 in group B. Biliary complications consisted of five bile duct injuries (group A = 4, group B = 1) and two cut edge bile leaks. Complications were more common in left lobe resections (55%) than in left lateral segment grafts (10%). Minor complications occurred in 20% of patients. A significant reduction in overall complications (major and minor) was observed between the groups (group A, n = 24 [45%] vs. group B, n = 10 [20%]). In addition, surgical time and hospital stay were both significantly reduced. CONCLUSIONS Although the procedure is safe, many LDLT donors have a perisurgical complication. Surgical experience and technical modifications have resulted in a significant reduction in these complications, however. To minimize the risks for these healthy donors, LDLT should be performed at institutions with extensive experience.

Portal vein thrombosis and stenosis in pediatric liver transplantation.

The aim of this study was to determine the outcome of venous conduits used in living donor liver transplantation (LDLT). We analyzed the portal vein complications in 66 LDLT recipients and 48 cadaveric reduced-size liver transplant (RLT) recipients performed from November 1989 through January 1995. Three different venous conduits were utilized in the LDLT recipients: Group 1, reconstructed vein from the living donor, n=18; Group 2, cadaveric cryopreserved iliac vein, n=37; and Group 3, cadaveric cryopreserved femoral vein, n=11. Overall, 47 percent of the patients were less than one year of age; the age distribution was not significantly different among the groups. The incidence of early thrombosis was significantly greater in LDLT Group 1, (33%) than any of the other groups (LDLT Group 2, 8%; LDLT Group 3, 9%; and RLT, 4%:P<0.0005 vs. reduced graft and < 0.03 vs. other LDLT groups). The incidence of late portal vein stenosis or thrombosis was significantly higher in the LDLT Group 2, (51%) than any of the other groups (LDLT 1, 16%; LDLT Group 3, 9%; RLT 4%;P<0.005 vs. cadaveric and < 0.02 vs. LDLT Group 1 and LDLT Group 3). Five year arterial graft and patient survival for patients who have experienced portal vein thrombosis or stenosis is 61% and 67%, respectively, versus 67% and 71% for those patients who have not experienced portal vein pathology, P=ns. Based on this experience, we recommend avoiding the use of cryopreserved iliac vein for portal vein reconstruction in liver transplantation. Every effort should be taken to eliminate the need for venous conduits in liver transplantation. If venous conduits must be utilized, cryopreserved femoral veins seem to provide superior patency rates. Careful clinical and ultrasonopraphic monitoring of patients at high risk for late venous thrombosis permits therapy with excellent graft and patient survival.

Complications and monitoring of OKT3 therapy

Complications of OKT3 therapy were studied in 122 treatment episodes in renal allograft recipients (83 for rejection treatment, 39 for immunosuppression induction). A febrile first-dose reaction to OKT3 was common; no severe pulmonary complications were encountered. Other toxicities of OKT3 therapy were observed later in the treatment course. Most severe were the occurrence of aseptic meningitis in four patients (3%), and seizures in eight (6%). Seizures occurred only when OKT3 was given to patients with nonfunctioning grafts due to acute tubular necrosis. Infections were the only significant late adverse sequelae of OKT3 therapy and occurred more frequently after multiple exposures to the drug (53%) than after a single exposure (22%). IgG antibodies to OKT3 developed after 45% of exposures to the drug in the 74 patients in whom appearance of anti-OKT3 antibodies was monitored. In two patients (3%), anti-OKT3 antibodies were detected before the end of the OKT3 treatment course, neutralizing the immunosuppressive property of the drug. In five patients (7%), strong anti-OKT3 antibody responses were present at the time of subsequent rejection, which precluded reuse of the drug. In 17 other cases, no or only a weak anti-OKT3 response was detectable at the time of rejection following initial OKT3 exposure. Retreatment with OKT3 was successful in reversing rejection in 15 cases (88%). No untoward sequelae were noted after reexposure to OKT3, except the high incidence of subsequent infections.

Hepatic artery thrombosis in infants : a comparison of whole livers, reduced-size grafts, and grafts from living-related donors

Hepatic artery thrombosis (HAT) is a major cause of patient morbidity and graft loss in pediatric liver transplantation (OLT). Although some grafts may be salvaged by arterial thrombectomy and reconstruction, many patients require retransplantation. Patient survival is reduced by HAT. It has been suggested that the incidence of HAT may be altered by the use of reduced-size grafts (RSG). We analyzed our series of infants receiving OLT to determine the frequency of HAT in full-size OLT, cadaveric RSG, and living-related RSG. The role of arterial anastomotic technique in the development of HAT was also examined. Between 10/1/84 and 12/7/90 433 liver transplants were performed. During this period 100 patients between 3 months and 2 years of age (mean 13 months) received 134 liver grafts. The mean weight at the time of transplant was 7.9 kg. (range: 1.9-15 kg). Of the 134 grafts, 60 were whole livers, 61 were cadaveric RSGs, and 13 were living-related RSGs. The cadaveric RSGs were 9 right lobe grafts, 21 left lobe grafts, and 31 left lateral segment grafts. Twenty-seven of the cadaveric RSGs were from split livers, while the other 34 were simple reductions. All 13 living-related RSGs were left lateral segments. HAT occurred in 15 of 60 (25%) whole livers, 9 of 61 (15%) cadaveric RSGs, and 3 of 13 (23%) of the living-related-donor RSGs (P = NS). Subdividing the cadaveric RSGs revealed that HAT occurred in 3 of 9 (33%) right lobe grafts, 3 of 21 (14%) left lobe grafts, and 3 of 31 (10%) left lateral segment grafts (P = NS). The site of the arterial anastomosis in the recipient correlated with the incidence of HAT (hepatic artery 21/86 [24%], celiac axis 1/9 [11%], aorta 2/32 [6%], P = 0.06). In conclusion, it appears that use of a cadaveric left lobe or left lateral segment graft and an aortic arterial anastomosis reduces the risk of hepatic artery thrombosis in liver transplant recipients less than 2 years of age.

A multicenter trial of FK506 (tacrolimus) therapy in refractory acute renal allograft rejection

A multicenter trial was conducted to evaluate the efficacy and safety of tacrolimus in the treatment of refractory renal allograft rejection. Renal transplant recipients experiencing biopsy-proven recurrent acute allograft rejection were eligible if the current rejection episode was refractory to corticosteroids. A total of 73 patients were enrolled, of whom 59 (81%) had previously received at least one course of antilymphocyte antibody as rejection therapy. One-year follow-up was available in 93% of patients. Median time to tacrolimus rescue therapy was 75 days after transplantation (range, 18-1448 days). Therapeutic responses to tacrolimus included improvement in 78% of patients, stabilization in 11%, and progressive deterioration in 11%. The risk of experiencing progressive deterioration was related to the pretacrolimus serum creatinine level: serum creatinine < or = mg/dl, 3%; 3.1-5 mg/dl, 16% (P < 0.04); > 5 mg/dl, 23% (P < 0.02). Twelve-month (from the time of initiation of tacrolimus therapy) actuarial patient and graft survival rates were 93% and 75%. Graft loss occurred in 19 patients (25%) at a median time of 108 days. Fourteen episodes of recurrent rejection were diagnosed in 10 patients (14%), at a median time of 101 days. Eleven episodes of recurrent rejection were treated (three patients underwent transplant nephrectomy), with resolution achieved in nine patients. Antilymphocyte antibody therapy was not used to treat recurrent rejection. Serum creatinine values improved during tacrolimus therapy: median serum creatinine level before tacrolimus, 3.2 mg/dl; median at 1 year after tacrolimus, 1.8 mg/dl. Twelve infections were documented in 11 patients (15%), including cytomegalovirus infection in three patients (4%). Posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorder was diagnosed in a single patient. Tacrolimus whole blood levels averaged 15.0 +/- 9.9 ng/ml at day 7 of tacrolimus therapy and 9.4 +/- 5.1 ng/ml at 1 year, and were consistent among individual centers. Treatment outcome did not correlate with tacrolimus blood levels. The most commonly observed adverse events were neurological and gastrointestinal. Seventy-four percent of patients received tacrolimus for at least 1 year. Tacrolimus therapy was discontinued in 18% of patients for rejection (11% for progressive, unrelenting rejection, and 7% for recurrent rejection). Tacrolimus therapy was discontinued in 8% of patients due to adverse events. In conclusion, tacrolimus rescue therapy provides (1) prompt, effective reversal of refractory renal allograft rejection, (2) good long-term renal allograft function, (3) a low incidence of recurrent rejection, and (4) an acceptable safety profile in renal allograft recipients experiencing refractory rejection.

The nondirected live-kidney donor: ethical considerations and practice guidelines: A National Conference Report.

Background. The success of kidney transplantation from a genetically unrelated living spouse or friend has influenced transplant physicians to consider the requests of individuals wishing to volunteer to be a kidney donor who have no intended recipient specified. Representatives of the transplant community gathered in Boston, MA, on May 31, 2001, to deliberate on the experience of live kidney donation from such volunteers, currently termed nondirected donors (NDD). Objective of Conference Participants. The objective of the conference was to recommend ethical and practice guidelines for health care professionals considering the transplantation of a kidney from a live NDD. Conference Participants. This conference was convened under the sponsorship of The National Kidney Foundation, with representation from The American Society of Transplantation and The American Society of Transplant Surgeons, The American Society of Nephrology, The United Resource Networks, The United Network for Organ Sharing, The Association of Organ Procurement Organizations, The National Institutes of Health, and The Division of Transplantation of the Health Resources and Services Administration (see Appendix). Conference Report. The suggested content of screening interviews, which provide information regarding the donation process, elicits pertinent medical and psychosocial history, and assesses NDD motivation are presented in this report. Approaches to identifying the center that would evaluate the suitability of the NDD, to performing the kidney recovery, and to selecting the NDD recipient are also proposed. Other ethical issues such as the use of prisoners as an NDD, compensation for the NDD, media involvement, and communication between the NDD and recipient are discussed. Conclusion. The willingness of health care professionals to consider NDD volunteers is driven by the compelling need to provide organs for an ever-expanding list of patients awaiting a kidney transplant. However, the psychological impact and emotional reward of donation has yet to be determined for NDD who may not have any relationship to the recipient or knowledge of the recipient’s outcome. Transplant centers that accept NDD should document an informed consent process that details donor risks, assures donor safety, and determines that the goals and expectations of the NDD and the recipient can be realized.