Jack R. Carlson

Environmental modeling framework invasiveness: Analysis and implications

Environmental modeling frameworks support scientific model development by providing model developers with domain specific software libraries which are used to aid model implementation. This paper presents an investigation on the framework invasiveness of environmental modeling frameworks. Invasiveness, similar to object-oriented coupling, is defined as the quantity of dependencies between model code and a modeling framework. We investigated relationships between invasiveness and the quality of modeling code, and also the utility of using a lightweight framework design approach in an environmental modeling framework. Five metrics to measure framework invasiveness were proposed and applied to measure dependencies between model and framework code of several implementations of Thornthwaite and the Precipitation-Runoff Modeling System (PRMS), two well-known hydrological models. Framework invasiveness measures were compared with existing common software metrics including size (lines of code), cyclomatic complexity, and object-oriented coupling. Models with lower framework invasiveness tended to be smaller, less complex, and have less coupling. In addition, the lightweight framework implementations of the Thornthwaite and PRMS models were less invasive than the traditional framework model implementations. Our results show that model implementations with higher degrees of framework invasiveness also had structural characteristics which previously have been shown to predict poor maintainability, a non-functional code quality attribute of concern. We conclude that using a framework with a lightweight framework design shows promise in helping to improve the quality of model code and that the lightweight framework design approach merits further attention by environmental modeling framework developers.

IAEA Isotope-enabled coupled catchment–lake water balance model, IWBMIso: description and validation†

ABSTRACT The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Water Balance Model with Isotopes (IWBMIso) is a spatially distributed monthly water balance model that considers water fluxes and storages and their associated isotopic compositions. It is composed of a lake water balance model that is tightly coupled with a catchment water balance model. Measured isotope compositions of precipitation, rivers, lakes, and groundwater provide data that can be used to make an improved estimate of the magnitude of the fluxes among the model components. The model has been developed using the Object Modelling System (OMS). A variety of open source geographic information systems and web-based tools have been combined to provide user support for (1) basin delineation, characterization, and parameterization; (2) data pre-processing; (3) model calibration and application; and (4) visualization and analysis of model results. In regions where measured data are limited, the model can use freely available global data sets of climate, isotopic composition of precipitation, and soils and vegetation characteristics to create input data files and estimate spatially distributed model parameters. The OMS model engine and support functions, and the spatial and web-based tool set are integrated using the Colorado State University Environmental Risk Assessment and Management System (eRAMS) framework. The IWBMIso can be used to assess the spatial and temporal variability of annual and monthly water balance components for input to water planning and management.