Jack Tarleton

Evaluation of mental retardation: Recommendations of a consensus conference

A Consensus Conference utilizing available literature and expert opinion sponsored by the American College of Medical Genetics in October 1995 evaluated the rational approach to the individual with mental retardation. Although no uniform protocol replaces individual clinician judgement, the consensus recommendations were as follows: 1. The individual with mental retardation, the family, and medical care providers benefit from a focused clinical and laboratory evaluation aimed at establishing causation and in providing counseling, prognosis, recurrence risks, and guidelines for management. 2. Essential elements of the evaluation include a three-generation pedigree: pre-, peri-, and post-natal history, complete physical examination focused on the presence of minor anomalies, neurologic examination, and assessment of the behavioral phenotype. 3. Selective laboratory testing should, in most patients, include a banded karyotype. Fragile X testing should be strongly considered in both males and females with unexplained mental retardation, especially in the presence of a positive family history, a consistent physical and behavioral phenotype and absence of major structural abnormalities. Metabolic testing should be initialed in the presence of suggestive clinical and physical findings. Neuroimaging should be considered in patients without a known diagnosis especially in the presence of neurologic symptoms, cranial contour abnormalities, microcephaly, or macrocephaly. In most situations MRI is the testing modality of choice. 4. Sequential evaluation of the patient, occasionally over several years, is often necessary for diagnosis, allowing for delineation of the physical and behavioral phenotype, a logical approach to ancillary testing and appropriate prognostic and reproductive counseling.

Longitudinal study of cognitive abilities and adaptive behavior levels in fragile X males: A prospective multicenter analysis

Retrospective longitudinal studies have noted declines in IQ scores in many but not all fra(X) (fragile X) males and females. We report on a prospective investigation of longitudinal changes in cognitive ability (IQ) and adaptive behavior (DQ) in 24 fra(X) males from four test sites. Individuals who were tested ranged in age from 3-15 years. To determine cognitive ability, all males were administered the Stanford-Binet test (4th Edition). To assess adaptive behavior, all males were evaluated using the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. Mean interest interval was 2.3 years. Using identical DNA protocols, all subjects were identified as bearing the fra(X) mutation. Results showed declines in IQ scores in 18/24 (75%) males. Four males showed no change in scores. Declines in DQ scores were noted in 22/24 (92%) of those tested. DQ scores were higher than IQ scores in 20/24 (83%) subjects. From a descriptive cohort analysis, decreases in IQ scores appear to follow a well-defined, negatively decelerating function. Declines in DQ were steeper and more nearly linear. Declining scores are not indicative of regression of intellectual and/or social skills, but of a relative inability to keep pace with their age-normed cohort. We conclude that the fra(X) mutation affects cognitive abilities in a uniform, nonlinear manner comparable to outcomes observed in earlier retrospective studies. Adaptive behavior also declines, but in a more linear fashion.

Fragile X syndrome and deletions in FMR1: New case and review of the literature

The fragile X syndrome phenotype of mental retardation is almost always caused by abnormal CGG trinucleotide amplification within the FMR1 gene. Occasionally fragile X syndrome results from point mutations or deletions within or around the FMR1 locus. We have identified a mentally retarded African American male with typical fragile X phenotype and a 300-400 base pair intragenic deletion near the CGG repeat segment, present in his peripheral blood lymphocytes with no apparent mosaicism. His mother, who is not retarded, has a full FMR1 CGG expansion mutation with 700-900 repeats. A review of 23 published cases with FMR1 gene deletions shows full FMR1 mutation in the mother of only 1 other propositus, a male with FMR1 full mutation/premutation/deletion mosaicism of his cultured skin fibroblasts and peripheral blood lymphocytes. The various deletions within FMR1 and their clinical significance are reviewed.

Carrier testing in the fragile X syndrome: Attitudes and opinions of obligate carriers

This study surveyed obligate carriers of the fragile X syndrome fra(X) to ascertain opinions and attitudes regarding carrier testing. Female carriers of fra(X) syndrome were recruited during their visits to the Fragile X Clinic at Duke University Medical Center. Twenty-eight obligate carriers completed a 48 question structured interview and a visual analog scale (VAS). Strong trends in the responses were identified. Fra(X) syndrome was viewed as a very serious problem and the risk to offspring high. Subjects reported that prior knowledge of carrier status would have changed their reproductive plans. All felt that relatives should be informed about the inheritance of fra(X) syndrome; the mean age given for preferred age to inform their children of the inheritance of fra(X) syndrome was 12 years, and mean age given for optimal timing of carrier testing was 10 years. The women interviewed indicated that growing up with knowledge of their carrier status would have been preferable to learning this information as adults and they endorsed an aggressive approach to informing and testing their children. Further investigation is warranted to determine the psychological consequences of carrier testing for fra(X) syndrome in order to develop appropriate guidelines for testing and informing individuals at risk for fra(X) syndrome.

Studies of age-correlated features of cognitive-behavioral development in children and adolescents with genetic disorders.

Studies of age‐related features of cognitive‐behavioral deficits produced by genetic mutations permit us to draw inferences about how brain development may be related cognitive ability as the child ages. Except for Down syndrome (DS) and the fragile X mutation (FRAXA), little is known about the longitudinal changes in cognitive‐behavioral development in individuals with genetic abnormalities producing learning disabilities (LD) or mental retardation (MR). The purpose of this prospective study was to compare and contrast age related to cognitive abilities, adaptive and maladaptive behaviors in children and adolescents in the same age range, diagnosed with one of three genetic disorders: the FRAXA mutation, Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) or Williams–Beuren syndrome (WBS). We also sought to examine whether cognitive‐behavioral abilities associated with these three genetic disorders were related systematically to age. We examined 108 children, ages 4–15 years, with FRAXA, WBS, or NF1. Results show that there is a significant negative correlation between age and IQ, and between age and adaptive behavior (DQ) scores, in children with FRAXA and WBS, but not in children with NF1. All three groups of children have unusually high proportions of maladaptive behavior, ranging from 1/6 children with NF1 to 2/3 children with FRAXA. Cognitive and adaptive behavior profiles of children with FRAXA and WBS were also surprisingly similar. Our findings suggest the need for examining longitudinal developmental cognitive‐behavioral changes in children and adolescents with all genetic disorders that produce LD or MR.

Development of Genomic Reference Materials for Cystic Fibrosis Genetic Testing

The number of different laboratories that perform genetic testing for cystic fibrosis is increasing. However, there are a limited number of quality control and other reference materials available, none of which cover all of the alleles included in commercially available reagents or platforms. The alleles in many publicly available cell lines that could serve as reference materials have neither been confirmed nor characterized. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention-based Genetic Testing Reference Material Coordination Program, in collaboration with members of the genetic testing community as well as Coriell Cell Repositories, have characterized an extended panel of publicly available genomic DNA samples that could serve as reference materials for cystic fibrosis testing. Six cell lines [containing the following mutations: E60X (c.178G>T), 444delA (c.312delA), G178R (c.532G>C), 1812-1G>A (c.1680-1G>A), P574H (c.1721C>A), Y1092X (c.3277C>A), and M1101K (c.3302T>A)] were selected from those existing at Coriell, and seven [containing the following mutations: R75X (c.223C>T), R347H (c.1040G>A), 3876delA (c.3744delA), S549R (c.1646A>C), S549N (c.1647G>A), 3905insT (c.3773_3774insT), and I507V (c.1519A>G)] were created. The alleles in these materials were confirmed by testing in six different volunteer laboratories. These genomic DNA reference materials will be useful for quality assurance, proficiency testing, test development, and research and should help to assure the accuracy of cystic fibrosis genetic testing in the future. The reference materials described in this study are all currently available from Coriell Cell Repositories.

DNA methylation analysis with respect to prenatal diagnosis of the Angelman and Prader–Willi syndromes and imprinting

The Angelman (AS) and Prader–Willi syndromes (PWS) are clinically distinct neurobehavioural syndromes resulting from loss of maternal (AS) or paternal contributions (PWS) of imprinted genes within the chromosomal 15q11‐q13 region. The molecular diagnosis of both syndromes can be made by a variety of techniques, including DNA methylation, DNA polymorphism and molecular cytogenetic analyses. DNA methylation analysis at three major loci (ZNF127, PW71 and 5′ SNRPN) has been successfully used for the postnatal diagnosis of AS and PWS. Methylation analysis, in contrast to other techniques, can reliably be used to diagnose all three major molecular classes (deletion, uniparental disomy and imprinting mutation) of PWS, and three of the four major classes of AS. In this study we demonstrate that methylation analysis can also be successfully used in prenatal diagnosis, by examining specimens obtained from amniocentesis and chorionic villus sampling. Correct prenatal diagnoses were obtained in 24 out of 24 samples using the 5′ SNRPN locus; 4 out of 15 using the ZNF127 locus; and 10 out of 18 using the PW71 locus. Therefore, our data indicate that although the DNA methylation imprints of ZNF127 and 5′ SNRPN arise in the germline and are present in brain, only 5′ SNRPN maintains the imprint in tissues suitable for the prenatal diagnosis of AS and PWS. Copyright

Quality assurance for Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy genetic testing: development of a genomic DNA reference material panel.

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD/BMD) are allelic X-linked recessive disorders that affect approximately 1 in 3500 and 1 in 20,000 male individuals, respectively. Approximately 65% of patients with DMD have deletions, 7% to 10% have duplications, and 25% to 30% have point mutations in one or more of the 79 exons of the dystrophin gene. Most clinical genetics laboratories test for deletions, and some use technologies that can detect smaller mutations and duplications. Reference and quality control materials for DMD/BMD diagnostic and carrier genetic testing are not commercially available. To help address this need, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention-based Genetic Testing Reference Material Coordination Program, in collaboration with members of the genetic testing and the DMD/BMD patient communities and the Coriell Cell Repositories, have characterized new and existing cell lines to create a comprehensive DMD/BMD reference material panel. Samples from 31 Coriell DMD cell lines from male probands and female carriers were analyzed using the Affymetrix SNP Array 6.0 and Multiplex Ligation-Dependent Probe Amplification (MRC-Holland BV, Amsterdam, the Netherlands), a multiplex PCR assay, and DNA sequence analysis. Identified were 16 cell lines with deletions, 9 with duplications, and 4 with point mutations distributed throughout the dystrophin gene. There were no discordant results within assay limitations. These samples are publicly available from Coriell Institute for Medical Research (Camden, NJ) and can be used for quality assurance, proficiency testing, test development, and research, and should help improve the accuracy of DMD testing.

The course of cognitive-behavioral development in children with the FMR1 mutation, Williams–Beuren syndrome, and neurofibromatosis type 1: The effect of gender†

The course of cognitive‐behavioral development in children with intellectual disabilities produced by genetic disorders has only recently begun to be examined systematically. Unfortunately, these studies are few in number. Previously, we examined cognitive‐behavioral development in children with the fragile X (FMR1) mutation and found longitudinal decreases in both IQ and adaptive behavior (DQ) scores in most males and females with the full mutation. In this study, we examine longitudinal changes in IQ and DQ in children with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) and Williams–Beuren Syndrome (WBS) by examining differences in composite IQ and DQ scores between the first test (T1) and retest (T2), and compare their developmental trajectory to children with the FMR1 mutation. Sixty‐five children with the FMR1 mutation, or NF1, or WBS, ages 4–16 years, were retested two years after initial testing with the Stanford‐Binet 4th Edition (SBFE) and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale (VABS). In addition to significant longitudinal declines in IQ and DQ noted previously in children with the FMR1 mutation, we found significant decreases in IQ in males compared to females in the remainder of our sample. We also observed statistically significant decreases in DQ scores among children the FMR1 mutation, as noted previously, but not among children with NF1 or WBS. Moreover, significant declines were found only among males with the FMR1 mutation. Unlike declines in IQ scores, decreases in DQ were not significantly different between males and females.

Developmental Trajectories in Syndromes with Intellectual Disability, with a Focus on Wolf-Hirschhorn and Its Cognitive-Behavioral Profile.

Few studies exist of developmental trajectories in children with intellectual disability, and none for those with subtelomeric deletions. We compared developmental trajectories of children with Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome to other genetic disorders. We recruited 106 children diagnosed with fragile X, Williams-Beuren syndrome, or Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome, assessing their intellectual and adaptive behavior abilities. We retested 61 children 2 years later. We compared Time 1 and Time 2 difference scores related to genetic disorder, age, initial IQ, or adaptive behavior composite. Results show genetic disorder and initial IQ score were significant factors for IQ differences, but only genetic disorder affected adaptive behavior differences. Results suggest different gene-brain-behavior pathways likely exist for these genetic disorders. Different developmental trajectories will influence the type and intensity of intervention implemented by caregivers.