Jaewoong Sim

A performance analysis framework for identifying potential benefits in GPGPU applications

Tuning code for GPGPU and other emerging many-core platforms is a challenge because few models or tools can precisely pinpoint the root cause of performance bottlenecks. In this paper, we present a performance analysis framework that can help shed light on such bottlenecks for GPGPU applications. Although a handful of GPGPU profiling tools exist, most of the traditional tools, unfortunately, simply provide programmers with a variety of measurements and metrics obtained by running applications, and it is often difficult to map these metrics to understand the root causes of slowdowns, much less decide what next optimization step to take to alleviate the bottleneck. In our approach, we first develop an analytical performance model that can precisely predict performance and aims to provide programmer-interpretable metrics. Then, we apply static and dynamic profiling to instantiate our performance model for a particular input code and show how the model can predict the potential performance benefits. We demonstrate our framework on a suite of micro-benchmarks as well as a variety of computations extracted from real codes.

A Mostly-Clean DRAM Cache for Effective Hit Speculation and Self-Balancing Dispatch

Die-stacking technology allows conventional DRAM to be integrated with processors. While numerous opportunities to make use of such stacked DRAM exist, one promising way is to use it as a large cache. Although previous studies show that DRAM caches can deliver performance benefits, there remain inefficiencies as well as significant hardware costs for auxiliary structures. This paper presents two innovations that exploit the bursty nature of memory requests to streamline the DRAM cache. The first is a low-cost Hit-Miss Predictor (HMP) that virtually eliminates the hardware overhead of the previously proposed multi-megabyte Miss Map structure. The second is a Self-Balancing Dispatch (SBD) mechanism that dynamically sends some requests to the off-chip memory even though the request may have hit in the die-stacked DRAM cache. This makes effective use of otherwise idle off-chip bandwidth when the DRAM cache is servicing a burst of cache hits. These techniques, however, are hampered by dirty (modified) data in the DRAM cache. To ensure correctness in the presence of dirty data in the cache, the HMP must verify that a block predicted as a miss is not actually present, otherwise the dirty block must be provided. This verification process can add latency, especially when DRAM cache banks are busy. In a similar vein, SBD cannot redirect requests to off-chip memory when a dirty copy of the block exists in the DRAM cache. To relax these constraints, we introduce a hybrid write policy for the cache that simultaneously supports write-through and write-back policies for different pages. Only a limited number of pages are permitted to operate in a write-back mode at one time, thereby bounding the amount of dirty data in the DRAM cache. By keeping the majority of the DRAM cache clean, most HMP predictions do not need to be verified, and the self balancing dispatch has more opportunities to redistribute requests (i.e., only requests to the limited number of dirty pages must go to the DRAM cache to maintain correctness). Our proposed techniques improve performance compared to the Miss Map-based DRAM cache approach while simultaneously eliminating the costly Miss Map structure.

Transparent Hardware Management of Stacked DRAM as Part of Memory

Recent technology advancements allow for the integration of large memory structures on-die or as a die-stacked DRAM. Such structures provide higher bandwidth and faster access time than off-chip memory. Prior work has investigated using the large integrated memory as a cache, or using it as part of a heterogeneous memory system under management of the OS. Using this memory as a cache would waste a large fraction of total memory space, especially for the systems where stacked memory could be as large as off-chip memory. An OS managed heterogeneous memory system, on the other hand, requires costly usage-monitoring hardware to migrate frequently-used pages, and is often unable to capture pages that are highly utilized for short periods of time. This paper proposes a practical, low-cost architectural solution to efficiently enable using large fast memory as Part-of-Memory (PoM) seamlessly, without the involvement of the OS. Our PoM architecture effectively manages two different types of memory (slow and fast) combined to create a single physical address space. To achieve this, PoM implements the ability to dynamically remap regions of memory based on their access patterns and expected performance benefits. Our proposed PoM architecture improves performance by 18.4% over static mapping and by 10.5% over an ideal OS-based dynamic remapping policy.

Resilient die-stacked DRAM caches

Die-stacked DRAM can provide large amounts of in-package, high-bandwidth cache storage. For server and high-performance computing markets, however, such DRAM caches must also provide sufficient support for reliability and fault tolerance. While conventional off-chip memory provides ECC support by adding one or more extra chips, this may not be practical in a 3D stack. In this paper, we present a DRAM cache organization that uses error-correcting codes (ECCs), strong checksums (CRCs), and dirty data duplication to detect and correct a wide range of stacked DRAM failures, from traditional bit errors to large-scale row, column, bank, and channel failures. With only a modest performance degradation compared to a DRAM cache with no ECC support, our proposal can correct all single-bit failures, and 99.9993% of all row, column, and bank failures, providing more than a 54,000x improvement in the FIT rate of silent-data corruptions compared to basic SECDED ECC protection.

FLEXclusion: balancing cache capacity and on-chip bandwidth via flexible exclusion

Exclusive last-level caches (LLCs) reduce memory accesses by effectively utilizing cache capacity. However, they require excessive on-chip bandwidth to support frequent insertions of cache lines on eviction from upper-level caches. Non-inclusive caches, on the other hand, have the advantage of using the on-chip bandwidth more effectively but suffer from a higher miss rate. Traditionally, the decision to use the cache as exclusive or non-inclusive is made at design time. However, the best option for a cache organization depends on application characteristics, such as working set size and the amount of traffic consumed by LLC insertions. This paper proposes FLEXclusion, a design that dynamically selects between exclusion and non-inclusion depending on workload behavior. With FLEXclusion, the cache behaves like an exclusive cache when the application benefits from extra cache capacity, and it acts as a non-inclusive cache when additional cache capacity is not useful, so that it can reduce on-chip bandwidth. FLEXclusion leverages the observation that both non-inclusion and exclusion rely on similar hardware support, so our proposal can be implemented with negligible hardware changes. Our evaluations show that a FLEXclusive cache reduces the on-chip LLC insertion traffic by 72.6% compared to an exclusive design and improves performance by 5.9% compared to a non-inclusive design.

BSSync: Processing Near Memory for Machine Learning Workloads with Bounded Staleness Consistency Models

Parallel machine learning workloads have become prevalent in numerous application domains. Many of these workloads are iterative convergent, allowing different threads to compute in an asynchronous manner, relaxing certain read-after-write data dependencies to use stale values. While considerable effort has been devoted to reducing the communication latency between nodes by utilizing asynchronous parallelism, inefficient utilization of relaxed consistency models within a single node have caused parallel implementations to have low execution efficiency. The long latency and serialization caused by atomic operations have a significant impact on performance. The data communication is not overlapped with the main computation, which reduces execution efficiency. The inefficiency comes from the data movement between where they are stored and where they are processed. In this work, we propose Bounded Staled Sync (BSSync), a hardware support for the bounded staleness consistency model, which accompanies simple logic layers in the memory hierarchy. BSSync overlaps the long latency atomic operation with the main computation, targeting iterative convergent machine learning workloads. Compared to previous work that allows staleness for read operations, BSSync utilizes staleness for write operations, allowing stale-writes. We demonstrate the benefit of the proposed scheme for representative machine learning workloads. On average, our approach outperforms the baseline asynchronous parallel implementation by 1.33x times.

GraphPIM: Enabling Instruction-Level PIM Offloading in Graph Computing Frameworks

With the emergence of data science, graph computing has become increasingly important these days. Unfortunately, graph computing typically suffers from poor performance when mapped to modern computing systems because of the overhead of executing atomic operations and inefficient utilization of the memory subsystem. Meanwhile, emerging technologies, such as Hybrid Memory Cube (HMC), enable the processing-in-memory (PIM) functionality with offloading operations at an instruction level. Instruction offloading to the PIM side has considerable potentials to overcome the performance bottleneck of graph computing. Nevertheless, this functionality for graph workloads has not been fully explored, and its applications and shortcomings have not been well identified thus far. In this paper, we present GraphPIM, a full-stack solution for graph computing that achieves higher performance using PIM functionality. We perform an analysis on modern graph workloads to assess the applicability of PIM offloading and present hardware and software mechanisms to efficiently make use of the PIM functionality. Following the real-world HMC 2.0 specification, GraphPIM provides performance benefits for graph applications without any user code modification or ISA changes. In addition, we propose an extension to PIM operations that can further bring performance benefits for more graph applications. The evaluation results show that GraphPIM achieves up to a 2.4X speedup with a 37% reduction in energy consumption.

A Configurable and Strong RAS Solution for Die-Stacked DRAM Caches

The resiliency problem of die-stacked memory will become important because of its lack of serviceability. This article details how to provide practical and cost-effective reliability, availability, and serviceability support for die-stacked DRAM cache architectures. The proposed approach can provide varying levels of protection, from fine-grained single-bit upsets to coarser-grained faults within the constraints of commodity non-error-correcting code DRAM stacks.