James E. Pope

Continuous 12-lead ST-segment recovery analysis in the TAMI 7 study. Performance of a noninvasive method for real-time detection of failed myocardial reperfusion.

BackgroundIf a practical, reliable, noninvasive marker of failed reperfusion was available in real time, the benefits of further therapy in this patient subgroup could be tested. We developed a method of 12-lead ST-segment recovery analysis using continuously updated reference points to provide such a marker. Methods and ResultsIn this study, our method was prospectively tested in 144 patients given thrombolytic therapy early in myocardial infarction. All patients had 12-lead continuous ST-segment monitoring and acute angiography, each analyzed in an independent, blinded core laboratory. ST-segment recovery and reelevation were analyzed up to the moment of angiography, at which time patency was predicted. Predictions were correlated to angiographic infarct artery flow, with TIMI flow 0 to 1 as occluded and TIMI flow 2 to 3 as patent. Infarct artery occlusion was seen on first injection in 27% of patients. The positive predictive value of incomplete ST recovery or ST reelevation by our method was 71%, negative predictive value 87%, with 90%o specificity and 64% sensitivity for coronary occlusion. ST recovery analysis predicted patency in 94% of patients with TIMI 3 flow versus 81% of patients with TIMI 2 flow and predicted occlusion in 57% of patients with collateralized occlusion versus 72% of patients with noncollateralized occlusion. In a regression model including other noninvasive clinical descriptors, ST recovery alone contained the vast majority of predictive information about patency. ConclusionIn a blinded, prospective, angiographically correlated study design, 12-lead continuous ST-segment recovery analysis shows promise as a practical noninvasive marker of failed reperfusion that may contribute substantially to currently available bedside assessment. Our data also suggest that patients with TIMI 2 flow or with collateralized occlusions may represent a physiological spectrum definable with ST-segment recovery analysis.

Continuously updated 12-lead ST-segment recovery analysis for myocardial infarct artery patency assessment and its correlation with multiple simultaneous early angiographic observations.

Early angiography may not adequately subgroup patients with myocardial infarction if cyclic changes in coronary flow occur frequently. From a pilot experience using a new 12-lead ST-segment monitor, a continuously updated, self-referenced ST-recovery analysis method was developed to quantify both instantaneous recovery, as a noninvasive marker of patency, and cumulative ST recovery over time, as a marker of the speed, stability and duration of reperfusion. In 22 patients with acute infarction in whom 44 observations of unique angiographic patency were noted within 6 hours of presentation, serial patency assessments simultaneous with all angiographic observations predicted coronary occlusion with 90% sensitivity and 92% specificity. Of the 22 patients, 11 (50%) had multiple ST trend transitions suggesting cyclic changes in coronary flow before catheterization. Speed, stability and duration of ST-segment recovery were defined by the time to first 50% ST recovery, total number of ST-trend transitions and patent physiology index (percentage of monitoring period showing ST recovery), respectively. Subgrouped angiographically, the median (interquartile range) for cumulative ST parameters with patent (n = 8) versus occluded (n = 14) arteries were, respectively--time to 50% recovery, 1.57 (1.16, 1.70) versus 0.17 (-0.47, 0.32) hours; number of reelevation/recovery events, 1.5 (1, 3) versus 3 (1, 3); and patent physiology index, 52 (47, 59) versus 50 (5, 73). Thus, continuous ST-segment recovery analysis appears to predict simultaneous angiographic patency over serial assessments, whereas cumulative parameters appear to contain independent information, probably because of patency changes before or after angiography.

The portable programmable microprocessor-driven real-time 12-lead electrocardiographic monitor: A preliminary report of a new device for the noninvasive detection of successful reperfusion or silent coronary reocclusion

Successful intravenous thrombolytic therapy early in myocardial infraction has the potential to reduce patient mortality without the additional risk and cost of aggressive invasive therapy. Noninvasive detection of successful reperfusion using resolution of chest pain, ST-segment changes assessed on static electrocardiograms, arrhythmia evolution, early isoenzyme peaking or changes in ventricular perfusion or function has been hampered by poor sensitivity or specificity, or inability to provide timely information. A newly available portable programmable microprocessor-driven real-time 12-lead electrocardiographic monitor has been introduced that may address these limitations. A continuously updated precise digital record of ST-segment activity at the bedside provides valuable information both in monitoring patients during reperfusion therapy to determine the efficacy of such treatment and in the subsequent hours to signal threatened reocclusion. This report describes the salient features of the monitor and presents 4 distinct situations in which the monitor detected timely information regarding coronary patency after reperfusion.

Comparison of continuous ST-segment recovery analysis with methods using static electrocardiograms for noninvasive patency assessment during acute myocardial infarction

Continuous ST-segment recovery analysis and 5 static methods using ST-segment comparison between a pre- and post-treatment electrocardiogram were compared for their ability to predict infarct-related artery patency in 82 patients with acute myocardial infarction who underwent angiography a median of 124 minutes after onset of thrombolytic treatment. Accuracy at the moment of angiography was 85% (95% confidence interval [CI] 77% to 93%) for the continuous method, and 68% (CI 57% to 78%), 78% (CI 69% to 87%), 83% (CI 74% to 91%), 82% (CI 73% to 90%), and 80% (CI 71% to 89%) for the static methods. At the moment of angiography the most accurate static method and the continuous method agreed in patency assessment in 90% of the patients (CI 84% to 97%). Agreement was reduced to 83% (CI 75% to 91%) of patients when a patency assessment was performed earlier at 90 minutes after treatment onset, and was only 77% (CI 68% to 86%), at 60 minutes. Early disagreement was mainly seen when the continuous ST recording showed ST recovery from a delayed peak ST elevation after the pretreatment static electrocardiogram or when dynamic ST changes suggesting cyclic reperfusion occurred. Continuous ST-segment recovery analysis appears to be as accurate as the most accurate static methods. Continuously updated reference points appear to give important additional information when ST recovery follows a delayed peak ST elevation or when re-elevation occurs, suggesting cyclic flow changes. Such findings appear to affect about half of patients with acute myocardial infarction treated with intravenous thrombolysis, particularly early after administration of therapy.

Simultaneous ST-segment measurements using standard and monitoring-compatible torso limb lead placements at rest and during coronary occlusion

Electrocardiographic recordings used to assess ST-segment deviation are performed using both standard and torso limb lead positions, where bony prominences give more artifact-free signal. Whereas significant QRS artifact can be introduced by such changes in lead location, the impact on ST-segment measurements has never been assessed. Digital electrocardiographic recordings were performed in 29 patients throughout elective angioplasty balloon inflation in the left anterior descending (n = 12), right coronary (n = 14), and circumflex (n = 3) arteries. In all cases, unipolar leads V1, V4, and V6 were affixed to the torso lead positions, allowing reconstruction of simultaneously acquired standard and modified 9-lead electrocardiograms (ECGs). ST levels in the 26 patients who had ST deviation during angioplasty were compared at both baseline and peak ischemia of up to 1,046 microV in the anterior, and 551 microV in the inferior leads. Differences in recorded ST levels for modified versus standard lead locations were all < 100 microV, even at peak ischemia. Although ST-segment elevation in the inferior leads appeared to show slightly more pronounced differences between lead sets than did anterior elevation, all differences were < 100 microV. Thus, measurement of ST-segment levels appears unlikely to be importantly affected by the intermixture of ECGs recorded with standard lead positions and ECGs recorded with monitoring-compatible lead positions on the torso. Recalibration of ST-segment measurements may be necessary for meticulous quantification of ischemia, infarct size, or other measurements that might be affected by variations < 100 microV.

Performance of the Automated Complete Selvester QRS Scoring System in Normal Subjects and Patients With Single and Multiple Myocardial Infarctions

The automated version of the complete Selvester QRS scoring system for estimation of myocardial infarct size was evaluated in 1,344 normal subjects, 706 patients with a single myocardial infarction (366 with inferior infarction, 277 with anterior infarction and 63 with posterolateral infarction) and 131 patients with combined inferior and anterior infarction. The presence and location were determined by angiographic and ventriculographic criteria. The performance of the overall 32-point system, each of the 19 criteria and the 13 criteria sets and each of the 35 criteria within the 13 sets was examined. The mean point scores were 1.7 for normal subjects, 3.7 for posterolateral infarction, 4.1 for inferior infarction, 6.3 for anterior infarction and 6.9 for multiple infarcts. A score greater than 4 yielded a sensitivity of 67% for anterior infarction, 41% for inferior infarction, 32% for posterolateral infarction and 72% for multiple infarcts. However, 7 of 32 criteria failed to achieve 95% specificity and 10 of 35 criteria in criteria sets had a sensitivity that was even lower than their false positive rate. The automated Selvester QRS scoring system currently has limitations that are attributable to development of the original system, which used manual scoring techniques and established criteria limits from middle-aged men. Future automated analysis should use gender- and age-dependent criteria limits.

Specificity and Sensitivity of QRS Criteria for Diagnosis of Single and Multiple Myocardial Infarcts

A subset of 3 criteria from the complete Selvester scoring system has been proposed earlier for electrocardiographic screening of healed myocardial infarcts. This subset yielded 95% specificity and high sensitivity for single anterior and inferior infarcts. In the present study, an automated version of these criteria was applied to 1,344 electrocardiograms from normal subjects (473 normal subjects as determined by cardiac catheterization and 871 apparently normal subjects by history and physical examination), to 706 from subjects with single myocardial infarction, and to 131 from subjects with combined anterior and inferior myocardial infarcts. Of the single infarcts, 366 had inferior, 277 anterior and 63 posterolateral locations. Presence and location of infarcts were judged from left ventriculograms and coronary angiograms. Overall specificity was only 86%, whereas overall sensitivity for the infarct population was 77%. Specificity was lower in men than in women; it was also lower in older than in younger subjects. One of the screening criteria (R greater than or equal to 40 ms in V1) may possibly be eliminated to augment specificity; this can be done with only minor loss of sensitivity. Differences in wave form measurements between the manual and computer methods account for a large part of the deterioration of specificity in this study compared with previously published results. Computer application of the screening criteria requires altered criteria limits in comparison with those used in manual application. Probably sex- and age-dependent criteria limits should be used.

Comparative prognostic significance of simultaneous versus independent resolution of ST segment depression relative to ST segment elevation during acute myocardial infarction.

OBJECTIVES We sought to determine the prognostic significance of simultaneous versus independent resolution of ST segment depression that occurs concomitant with ST segment elevation during acute myocardial infarction (AMI). BACKGROUND ST segment depression in leads other than those showing ST segment elevation during AMI is a common phenomenon. Whether this indicates adverse outcomes remains controversial. We hypothesized that the timing of ST segment depression resolution relative to ST segment elevation resolution might differentiate between a high risk group and a low risk group of patients. METHODS Continuous 12-lead ST segment monitoring was performed after thrombolytic therapy for AMI in 413 patients, 261 of whom met technical criteria for analysis. Blinded analysis of ST segment depression resolution patterns was used to group patients as follows: 1) no ST segment depression at any time (control group); 2) ST segment depression resolving simultaneously with ST segment elevation (simultaneous group); and 3) ST segment depression persisting after ST segment elevation resolution (independent group). These patterns were correlated with the outcomes-recurrent angina, reinfarction, heart failure and death-using chi-square analysis and the Fisher exact test for categoric variables and the Wilcoxon rank-sum test for continuous variables. RESULTS The incidence of recurrent angina, reinfarction and heart failure was similar among the three groups. In-hospital mortality, however, was significantly higher in the independent group (13%) than either the simultaneous group (1%, p < 0.001) or the control group (0%, p = 0.002). CONCLUSIONS Continuous analysis of ST segment resolution identifies, among patients with AMI with concomitantly occurring ST segment elevation and depression, a subgroup with increased in-hospital mortality. The pathogenic mechanism of increased mortality is not currently known.

Performance of an Automated Real-time ST-Segment Analysis Program to Detect Coronary Occlusion and Reperfusion

Continuously updated ST-segment recovery analysis has been shown to accurately predict infarct-related artery patency. Salient principles were converted into algorithms and incorporated into a portable ST monitor for optimal application. This study tested the automated programs ability to detect occlusion and reperfusion during balloon angioplasty. ST-segment recordings during 78 balloon occlusions in 31 patients were analyzed. The program requires at least one electrocardiogram with ST elevation of 200 microV or greater in the recording, caused by the current occlusion or by a previous occlusion, before it will yield a patency prediction. All 35 inflations causing peak ST elevation of 200 microV or more were indeed detected. All five inflations causing less than 200 microV ST elevation preceded by an inflation causing 200 microV or higher ST elevation were also detected. Occlusion was detected a median of 40 seconds after inflation, and reperfusion a median of 17 seconds after deflation. Peak ST elevation greater than 200 microV occurred in 19 of 26 left anterior descending artery inflations (73%), 1 of 22 left circumflex artery LCX inflations (5%), and 15 of 30 right coronary artery inflations (50%). Five different leads identified peak ST elevation through 12-lead surveillance. In this model of coronary occlusion during angioplasty balloon inflation, the automated patency assessment program appears to detect coronary angioplasty balloon occlusion and reperfusion within seconds in all occlusions causing a peak ST elevation of 200 microV or greater. Testing this automated patency assessment program as a noninvasive triage tool in myocardial infarction patients seems warranted.

Heuristic and logistic principles of ST-segment interpretation in the time domain: Evolution in the context of the TAMI 7 trial design

Sophisticated computer programming has focused on the translation of heuristic principles of ECG analysis into logistic variables in the development of computerized interpretative programs. While efforts continue to pursue the refinement of such programs, new microprocessor technology also affords the opportunity to further develop or rethink basic principles of ECG interpretation altogether. The development of new ECG principles depends to some degree on the design of new ECG devices, and vice versa. With simultaneous development, idiosyncracies of either concept or tool may subtly, and negatively, interact. We have looked to clinical trial design to help provide a context in which a new concept of ECG interpretation could be developed concomitantly with new ECG hardware and software, using a non-ECG variable as a point of reference. ST-segment abnormalities on a standard ECG are a well known element of classical ECG analysis. Over serial ECGs, the ST level can be examined in the time domain. Digital trends of ST level over time may be useful as a noninvasive means of determining infarct artery patency after thrombolytic therapy.‘,* The precise accuracy of such trends when analyzed heuristically, as compared with a “gold standard” such as angiographic patency, is not known. Similarly, the