James M. Suttie

Deer antlerogenic periosteum: a piece of postnatally retained embryonic tissue?

This article reviews the research findings on the piece of periosteum overlying the lateral crest of prepubertal deer frontal bone, known as antlerogenic periosteum (AP). AP was initially discovered by Hartwig and Schrudde in 1974 when searching for the tissue that gives rise to antlers. In their experiment, when AP was transplanted elsewhere on the deer body it formed ectopic antlers. This clearly shows that AP possesses full self-differentiating ability, an attribute that can only be paralleled by embryonic tissue in mammals, like lateral plate mesoderm (LPM). Studies along this line by Goss in the 1980s further demonstrated that AP also holds the patterning information for antler formation. In the 1990s, our group carried out a series of studies on this unique tissue. The results showed that some of the critical features of AP resemble those of embryonic tissues, such as the astonishing growth potential in vivo and in vitro, and rich glycogen content. Histological observations and cell lineage tracing using a genetic marker convincingly demonstrate that pedicles and antlers are the derivatives of AP. Based on these findings, we advanced a hypothesis that AP is a piece of postnatally retained embryonic tissue. Morphological and histological examinations on the presumptive antler growth regions in deer prenatal life showed that the growth of primordial pedicles is initiated in the early pregnant stage (about 55 days) but then ceases (about 100 days) and is subsequently repressed at the late stage of pregnancy. The epidermis overlying the primordial pedicles resembles the apical ectoderm ridge (multicellular layer). These results strongly support our hypothesis. The results from the specific comparison between deer antler formation (from AP in postnatal) and mammalian limb development (from LPM in prenatal) showed that the ontogeny of antlers and limbs are comparable, and that deer antler has the same level of regulative properties as mammalian limbs. We believe that revealing the mechanism underlying the retention of embryonic tissue properties by AP until deer postnatal life will have important implications in biomedical research. Antler formation from AP offers an ideal model to work with in investigating how a self-differentiating system functions.

Sampling technique to discriminate the different tissue layers of growing antler tips for gene discovery.

The utilization of a deer antler model to study gene expression in tissues undergoing rapid growth has been hampered by an inability to sample the different tissue types. We report here a standardized procedure to identify different tissue types in growing antler tips and demonstrate that it can help in the classification of expressed sequence tags (ESTs). The procedure was developed using observable morphological markers within the unstained tissue at collection, and was validated by histological assessments and virtual Northern blotting. Four red deer antlers were collected at 60 days of growth and the tips (top 5 cm) were then removed. The following observable markers were identified distoproximally: the dermis (4.86 mm), the subdermal bulge (2.90 mm), the discrete columns (6.50 mm), the transition zone (a mixture of discrete and continuous columns) (3.22 mm), and the continuous columns (8.00 mm). The histological examination showed that these markers corresponded to the dermis, reserve mesenchyme, precartilage, transitional tissue from precartilage to cartilage, and cartilage, respectively. The gene expression studies revealed that these morphologically identified layers were functionally distinct tissue types and had distinct gene expression profiles. We believe that precisely defining these tissue types in growing antler tips will greatly facilitate new discoveries in this exciting field. Anat Rec 268:125–130, 2002.

Expression of obese mRNA in genetically lean and fat selection lines of sheep

Genetically separate lines of Coopworth sheep have been bred by selecting for (fat genotype) or against (lean genotype) backfat depth. Typically, the total fat content, adjusted for carcass weight, is 21.2 and 29.3% for the lean and fat lines, respectively. As a homologue of the obese gene, which shows altered expression in several forms of obesity, is also expressed in sheep, it was decided to determine whether the obese gene was differentially expressed in each line of sheep. The relative level of expression of obese mRNA was approximately twofold higher in the fat line compared with the lean line in back, omental and perirenal fat depots of ram lambs fed ad libitum or fasted for 48 h. This elevation in the fat line is most likely a secondary consequence of obesity rather than a cause. Fasting for 48 h decreased obese mRNA levels by 8.9-, 8.5-, and 4.2-fold in back, omental and perirenal fat, respectively, in the lean line, and by 8.3-, 5.7-, and 3.5-fold in back, omental and perirenal fat, respectively, in the fat line. The lean and fat lines of sheep, therefore, responded in a similar way to fasting.

Effects of testosterone on pedicle formation and its transformation to antler in castrated male, freemartin and normal female red deer (Cervus elaphus).

Pedicles and antlers are male deer secondary sexual characters. As such, development of these structures is under the control of androgen hormones. Pedicle growth is caused by increasing and elevated plasma testosterone (T) levels, whereas first antler transformation from a fully formed pedicle occurs when the T levels are decreasing. Castration prior to pedicle initiation abrogates future pedicle and antler formation. Female deer also have the potential to develop pedicles and antlers, but they do not normally express this phenotype due to lack of sufficient androgen stimulation. Previous studies have shown that female white-tailed deer could be readily induced to grow pedicles as well as antlers by singular administration of exogenous androgens (EA), but in red deer (Cervus elaphus) singular or irregular EA treatment could only stimulate castrated male, normal or ovariectomised females to grow pedicles, but not antlers. The present study was set out to test whether these EA-induced pedicles in red deer failed to give rise to antlers was because they were constitutively incapable of doing so, or because the plasma T profile naturally exhibited in intact stags was not achieved by the androgen treatment used in these previous studies. Eight castrated red deer stag calves, 3 freemartins (females which were born co-twin to males), and 3 normal female red deer were used in the present study and treated with EA, either as biweekly injections for the castrates or as implants for freemartin and females until the late stage of pedicle growth. Blood sampling was carried out biweekly for the analyses of plasma T and IGF1 concentration. The results showed that the natural plasma T profile in the experimental deer was successfully mimicked through regular EA treatment and subsequent withdrawal at late pedicle growth stage. All castrated males, 2 out of 3 freemartin, and 1 out of 3 normal female red deer formed not only pedicles, but also antlers. Based on these results, we conclude that EA-induced pedicles at least in red deer of the genus Cervus, like those in the genus Odocoileus, are constitutively capable of giving rise to antlers, if they are of sufficient height.

Histological studies of pedicle skin formation and its transformation to antler velvet in red deer (Cervus elaphus)

Deer antlers and their antecedent pedicles are made up of two components, interior osseocartilage and exterior integument. In a previous study, we described that histogenesis of the interior osseocartilage proceeds through four ossification stages. These are intramembranous (IMO), transition (OPC), pedicle endochondral (pECO), and antler endochondral (aECO). In the present study, we used histological techniques to examine pedicle skin formation and its transformation to antler velvet. The results showed that pedicle skin initiated from the apex of a frontal lateral crest and was formed through three distinctive stages. These stages are 1) compression of the subcutaneous loose connective tissue at the OPC stage, 2) stretching of the undulated epidermis at the early pECO stage, and 3) neogenesis of the skin and its associated appendages at the mid pECO stage. Transformation into antler velvet, which occurs at the late pECO stage, is mainly associated with alteration in the skin appendages. This alteration includes the loss of arrector pili muscle and sweat glands, and the gain of the large bi‐ or multi‐lobed sebaceous glands. These results suggest that pedicle skin expansion occurs to release the mechanical tension created by underlying forming antlerogenic tissue, initially in response to it by mechanical stretch, and then by neogenesis of skin. In turn, the stretched pedicle skin may exert mechanical pressure on the underlying antlerogenic tissue causing it to change in ossification type. Antler velvet generation may be accomplished by both mechanical stimulation and chemical induction from the underlying pECO stage antlerogenic tissue. If this hypothesis is correct it is likely that mechanical stimulation would drive skin formation and chemical induction then determine skin type. Furthermore, asynchronous transformation of the interior and exterior components during pedicle formation and antler generation may result from the delayed chemical induction and the way antler velvet initially generates. The results from both mitotic cell labelling of the basal layer and ultrastructure of the basement membrane of the apical skin in the study support these hypotheses. Anat Rec 260:62–71, 2000.

Detection of growth factors and proto-oncogene mRNA in the growing tip of red deer (Cervus elaphus) antler using reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)

Deer antler is a unique mammalian organ that has an annual cycle of regeneration. The antler grows very rapidly from the tip at up to 1 cm/day in red deer for a 90- to 120-day period. It is hypothesised that locally produced growth factors are required to control and stimulate this growth. The tip of the growing antler from animals whose antlers had been growing for 30, 60, or 90 days was dissected into four zones: epidermis/dermis, reserve mesenchyme, precartilaginous, and cartilaginous. Total RNA was extracted, and the presence of various growth factors and proto-oncogenes was detected using RT-PCR, IGF-I, IGF-II, TGF beta 1, TGF beta 2, c-fos, c-myc, and beta-actin were all present as single bands of the expected molecular weight in the four zones of the antler at each stage of growth. There were higher levels of IGF-I, TGF beta 2, and c-myc relative to beta-actin in the epidermis/dermis layer than in the other three zones. There were no differences in the expression of any of the genes between the three stages of growth. The presence of TGF beta 3 cannot be confirmed since multiple bands were seen in all antler tissues. A single band of the expected size for TGF alpha was seen only in the epidermal/dermal layer of the antler, with multiple bands of different molecular weight being detected in the other zones of the antler. This work has demonstrated the presence of multiple growth factors in the growing deer antler and supports the hypothesis that paracrine/autocrine stimulation is important for regulating antler growth.

Genetically lean and fat sheep differ in their growth hormone response to growth hormone-releasing factor.

The aim of this study was to compare the ovine growth hormone (oGH) responses of 5 genetically lean and 5 genetically fat 9 month old ram lambs (selected on the basis of their ultrasonic backfat thickness) given two 0.3 micrograms kg-1 liveweight intravenous injections of synthetic human pancreatic GH releasing factor analogue Nle27 hGHRF29 -NH2 (GRF-29) 150 minutes apart. Plasma oGH response curves were analysed using an exponential 2 compartmental model and comparisons made through parallel curve analysis. Plasma oGH levels over 200 ng ml-1 were detected in response to GRF-29. Exponential model parameters indicated that lean lambs had a significantly higher rate of oGH release into the plasma after both consecutive GRF-29 injections, and a significantly lower rate of oGH clearance from the plasma after the second GRF-29 injection only. Significantly smaller peak oGH responses to the second GRF-29 injection were shown by the fat lambs. These results suggest that oGH release is impaired in genetically fat lambs and that either the synthesis of releasable oGH is reduced or the inhibitory tone is greater in the fat lambs. The lean and fat sheep may provide a useful model for the study of hormonal control of factors affecting leanness and fatness.

Nerve Growth Factor mRNA Expression in the Regenerating Antler Tip of Red Deer (Cervus elaphus)

Deer antlers are the only mammalian organs that can fully regenerate each year. During their growth phase, antlers of red deer extend at a rate of approximately 10 mm/day, a growth rate matched by the antler nerves. It was demonstrated in a previous study that extracts from deer velvet antler can promote neurite outgrowth from neural explants, suggesting a possible role for Nerve Growth Factor (NGF) in antler innervation. Here we showed using the techniques of Northern blot analysis, denervation, immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridization that NGF mRNA was expressed in the regenerating antler, principally in the smooth muscle of the arteries and arterioles of the growing antler tip. Regenerating axons followed the route of the major blood vessels, located at the interface between the dermis and the reserve mesenchyme of the antler. Denervation experiments suggested a causal relationship exists between NGF mRNA expression in arterial smooth muscle and sensory axons in the antler tip. We hypothesize that NGF expressed in the smooth muscle of the arteries and arterioles promotes and maintains antler angiogenesis and this role positions NGF ahead of axons during antler growth. As a result, NGF can serve a second role, attracting sensory axons into the antler, and thus it can provide a guidance cue to define the nerve track. This would explain the phenomenon whereby re-innervation of the regenerating antler follows vascular ingrowth. The annual growth of deer antler presents a unique opportunity to better understand the factors involved in rapid nerve regeneration.

Effects of melatonin implants on insulin-like growth factor 1 in male red deer (Cervus elaphus)

Red deer stags have a seasonal pattern of growth, alternating between periods of summer weight gain and winter weight loss that are influenced by photoperiod and by exogenous melatonin. A seasonal pattern of plasma insulin-like growth factor 1, also influenced by photoperiod, underlies the seasonal growth pattern. The present studies aimed to determine the influence of exogenous melatonin, administered at various times of the year, on plasma IGF1 in adult red deer stags in New Zealand at 45 degrees S. In one study, 7-year-old stags (N = 9) were allocated to one of three treatment groups, either control or subcutaneous melatonin (3 x 18-mg coated implants (Regulin) per month) from November to February or from December to February. Blood was sampled, the stags were weighed, and antler status was recorded over 17 months. Melatonin treatment advanced the seasonal patterns of rise and fall of plasma IGF1 and of weight gain and loss. The cessation of melatonin treatment in February produced early antler casting and a second (out-of-season) antler and increased IGF1. In a second study, 4-year-old stags (N = 30) were allocated to one of six treatment groups as follows: three melatonin implants per months for 6 consecutive months beginning on 22 June, i.e., winter solstice, 4 August, 16 September, and 23 October; three melatonin implants per month for 12 months beginning on 22 June; and an untreated group. All animals were sampled as before for 12 months. Melatonin treatment beginning in July and August did not prevent the seasonal peak in IGF1, but the amplitude was lowered and antler casting delayed.

Effect of diet energy density and season on voluntary dry-matter and energy intake in male red deer.

Food intake and growth of red deer is lower in winter than in spring and this reduces the efficiency of venison production. Rumen capacity is also lower during winter and this may contribute to the reduced food intake and therefore growth. In the present study, we investigated the ability of deer to regulate food intake during winter and spring by feeding diets of differing energy densities. Six groups of eight male red deer calves were housed indoors in separate pens. Each group was given, ad libitum , a pelleted diet of a different energy density (8·5, 9·0, 9·5, 10·0, 10·5 and 11·0 MJ metabolizable energy (ME) per kg dry matter (DM) for groups 1 to 6 respectively) but the same amount of protein (156 g/kg DM). Food intake of each group was recorded every 2nd day and animals were weighed every 6 days from 17 May to 9 December. For seasonal comparisons, winter was defined as 24 May to 31 August and spring as 1 September to 9 December. There was no difference ( P > 0·05) between the mean live weights of the groups at any time during the study. Live-weight gain (LWG) reached a minimum on 4 July and was lower in winter than spring (161 v. 308 g/day, s.e.d. = 10·0, P P 0·75 per day) and ME intake (MJ ME per kg M 0·75 per day) decreased until 16 July and increased thereafter. Mean DM intake was lower in winter than spring (83·5 v. 97·2 g/kg M 0·75 per day, s.e.d. = 2·05, P P P P > 0·005) and was lower in winter than spring (0·82 v. 0·95 MJ/kg M 0·75 per day, s.e.d. = 0·25, P m ) across groups and seasons was calculated to be 0·45 (s.e. 0·22) MJ ME per kg M 0·75 and the energy requirement for LWG (ME f ) was 53 (s.e. 8·5) MJ/kg LWG. ME f was related ( P In summary, deer consuming diets with a wide range of energy densities, altered their DM intake, resulting in similar energy intakes and growth rates on all diets. Animals seemed less able to achieve this compensation in winter compared with spring when food intake increased to support the natural rise in growth rate at that time. These results indicate that deer have target growth rates and/or energy intakes that change with season, and are defended by adjusting food intake.