James T. Stevens

Chronic effects of atrazine on estrus and mammary tumor formation in female Sprague-Dawley and fischer 344 rats

The chronic effects of dietary administration of atrazine at levels as high as 400 ppm on selected endocrine and tumor profiles were evaluated in Fischer 344 and Sprague-Dawley female rats. The study showed that lifetime dietary administration of atrazine at a maximum tolerated dose (MTD) to Sprague-Dawley female rats caused (1) lengthening of the estrous cycle, (2) increased number of days in estrus or under the influence of exposure to estrogen, (3) earlier onset of galactocele formation, and (4) earlier onset of mammary and pituitary tumor formation but not an increased incidence of mammary and pituitary tumors when compared to concurrent control rats. Fischer 344 female rats fed atrazine at an MTD exhibited slightly lengthened estrous cycles, but no effects were observed on estradiol or progesterone levels, or on the onset or incidence of mammary tumors. These results support a hypothesis that high-dose atrazine administration in Sprague-Dawley females is related to an acceleration of age-related endocrine changes leading to an earlier onset and/or increased incidence of mammary tumors. This endocrine-mediated response, which appears to be unique to the Sprague-Dawley female rat, occurs only at or above a threshold dose (the MTD) that interferes with normal estrous cycling, promoting prolonged exposure to endogenous estrogen.

Hypothesis for mammary tumorigenesis in Sprague-Dawley rats exposed to certain triazine herbicides

The symmetrical triazine herbicides have been used for the preemergence control of broadleaf weeds for nearly three decades. Recently, certain members of this class, primarily the chlorotriazines (substituted in the 2 position), have been shown to evoke an increased incidence of mammary tumors in female Sprague-Dawley rats. This response was noted when these chemicals were administered in the diet for 2 yr, and most often at dietary feeding levels at or above the maximum tolerated dose (MTD). At levels exceeding the MTD the health of these animals was compromised, as manifested by toxicity-related reduced survival that was not associated with the occurrence of mammary tumors. Mammary tumors in rats frequently occur as a result of the influence of endogenous estradiol and prolactin. Those hormones, as well as progesterone, growth-stimulating, luteinizing, and follicle-stimulating hormones, were measured after 24 mo of dietary administration of the chlorotriazine, simazine. The plasma hormone pattern seen in aged female Sprague-Dawley rats administered 1000 ppm simazine in the diet for 24 mo resembled that noted for aged female controls, except that the difference was more pronounced in the simazine-treated group. These results suggest that prolonged exposure of Sprague-Dawley females to excessive levels of triazines affects the neuroendocrine system, which in turn alters the pathology of the mammary gland. These changes are comparable to those that occur naturally as the rat ages. Changes in neuroendocrine control could result in the expression of an earlier onset and/or an increased incidence of mammary tumors, which already occur at a high spontaneous rate in aging Sprague-Dawley female rats.

Chloro‐s‐triazine antagonism of estrogen action: Limited interaction with estrogen receptor binding

In an accompanying article (see pp. 183-196), it was reported that administration of very high doses of the chlorotriazine herbicides atrazine, simazine, and diaminochlorotriazine (DACT), a common metabolite, expressed antiestrogenic activity in uteri of female Sprague-Dawley rats without expressing intrinsic estrogenic activity. In the present article, studies of chlorotriazine interaction with rat uterine estrogen receptors (ER) are reported. Under equilibrium conditions, none of the triazine compounds showed an ability to compete against binding of radiolabeled estradiol to ER. A weak competition was evident only if cytosols were preincubated with triazines at 25 degrees C prior to introduction of tracer. Competition was very weak, with kl estimates of 10-100 microM. A limited Scatchard analysis suggested a competitive type of inhibition. Sucrose gradient analysis of cytosol incubations showed that triazine interaction with the 4S isoform of ER may be greater than with the 8S form. When administered to ovariectomized rats for 2 d at 300 mg/kg/d, atrazine, simazine, or DACT all reduced uterine ER binding capacity by approximately 30%. Results from the receptor binding studies indicated that triazine competition against ER binding occurred to a much lesser degree than inhibition of estrogen-mediated responses reported in accompanying articles. This suggests that the complete responses to triazines may include inhibition of events other than or in addition to ER binding of estrogen.

Endocrine Modulation of Reproduction

The ability of foreign compounds to affect the functioning of various endocrine systems is currently thought responsible for a wide variety of effects. The presentations in this Symposium reviewed the evidence for and against the involvement of endocrine systems in several different aspects of reproduction. The mechanism behind the ability of a triazine herbicide to cause enhanced appearance of mammary tumors in one strain of female rats is reviewed by Stevens. The data suggest that enhanced aging, not direct mammary modulation, is responsible. Dietary phytoestrogens, the mediators of their actions, their effects in various biological systems, and the relationships between phytoestrogen producers and consumers are all provocatively and succinctly reviewed by Hughes. Kelce presents the strategy used to dissect the mode and mechanisms of action of a fungicide that opened a new awareness in reproductive toxicology: the possibility of xenobiotics being antiandrogens. Finally, to heighten our understanding of the interplay among hormonal systems in vivo, Hess reviews the data that show that androgens are not the only hormones important in the development of the male reproductive system: the pituitary is shown to play a critical role at specific stages of development. The breadth of these presentations, and the implications of their findings, should make us pause and realize how much there is still to discover about the interaction between the reproductive system and anthropogenic compounds.

Possible antiestrogenic properties of chloro-s-triazines in rat uterus.

Several published reports have indicated that certain chloro-s-triazine herbicides may alter endocrine function in rats, possibly by androgen receptor binding. In direct tests of estrogenic bioactivity, oral doses of up to 300 mg/kg/d of atrazine, simazine, or the common metabolite diaminochlorotriazine (DACT) did not significantly increase uterine weight of ovariectomized Sprague-Dawley female rats. The highest dose, which was approximately 10% of the LD50 for these compounds, did cause body weight loss. When administered concomitantly with sc injections of estradiol (2 micrograms/kg), 300 mg/kg of orally administered chlorotriazines significantly reduced uterine weight in comparison to animals given estrogen alone. Neither atrazine, simazine, nor DACT, at oral doses up to 300 mg/kg/d, stimulated incorporation of [3H]thymidine into uterine DNA of immature Sprague-Dawley female rats. However, oral treatment at doses of 50 mg/kg and higher significantly reduced thymidine incorporation into uterine DNA extracted from immature rats given a single injection of 0.15 microgram estradiol. Oral doses of 300 mg/kg of atrazine, simazine, or DACT significantly reduced expression of progesterone receptor binding in cytosol fractions prepared from uteri of ovariectomized rats injected sc with 1 microgram estradiol; 50 mg/kg triazine was not effective in this case. Uterine progesterone receptor levels were not stimulated in rats given oral doses up to 300 mg/kg of these triazines without estradiol injections. These results suggest that atrazine, simazine, and DACT possess no intrinsic estrogenic activity but that they are capable of weak inhibition of estrogen-stimulated responses in the rat uterus. This inhibition may play a role in the previously observed disruptive actions of chlorotriazines on reproductive endocrine function of female rats.

Short‐term effects of chlorotriazines on estrus in female Sprague‐Dawley and Fischer 344 rats

Atrazine or simazine (s-chlorotriazines) was administered by gavage daily for 2 wk to female Sprague-Dawley and Fischer 344 rats at oral doses of 100 or 300 mg/kg to evaluate effects on body, ovary, uterus, and adrenal weights, estrous cycle stages, vaginal cytology, and plasma hormone (estradiol, progesterone, prolactin, and corticosterone) levels. Significant reductions in body weights of both Sprague-Dawley and Fischer 344 female rats at both dose levels were accompanied by a significant reduction in ovarian and uterine weights, and a decrease in circulating estradiol levels. The magnitudes of the effects were less in Fischer 344 rats than in Sprague-Dawley rats, and the effects of simazine were less pronounced than those of atrazine at the same dose. A maximum tolerated dose (MTD: > or = 10% body weight reduction) was estimated to be 100 mg/kg for atrazine and 300 mg/kg for simazine for both stains. The Sprague-Dawley female rats exhibited a treatment-related lengthening of the estrous cycle and an increased number of days characterized by cornified epithelial cells. This resulted in a greater percent of the cycle days spent in estrus and reduction in the percent of the cycle days spent in diestrus. Atrazine-dosed Fischer 344 females also exhibited a significant trend toward cycle lengthening, but this was due to reduction in the percent of cycle spent in estrus and a concomitant increase in diestrual days. These findings suggest that treatment with doses of triazine at or above the MTD may result in prolonged exposure to endogenous estrogen in the Sprague-Dawley but not the Fischer 344 rat. These changes may account for the observed earlier onset and/or increased incidence of mammary tumors in chlorotriazine-treated female Sprague-Dawley rats. This strain of rat is already known to be prone to a substantial development of mammary tumors with advancing age, while the Fischer 344 strain is not as likely to exhibit this response.

A RISK CHARACTERIZATION FOR ATRAZINE: ONCOGENICITY PROFILE

An extensive safety database has been developed for the chlorotriazine herbicide, atrazine. The results from five oncogenicity studies conducted in the Sprague-Dawley rat, two studies in the Fischer 344 rat, and two studies in the CD-1 mouse were reviewed. No increase in the incidence of tumors of any type was observed in male or female Fischer 344 rats, male or female CD-1 mice, or male Sprague-Dawley rats fed atrazine at a maximum tolerated level in their diet for 24 mo. Female Sprague-Dawley rats fed atrazine at levels of 400, 500, and 1000 ppm developed mammary tumors earlier than did the control group. The incidence of female Sprague-Dawley rats with mammary tumors after 24 mo of treatment was statistically increased at feeding levels of > or = 70 ppm in 1 study and at 400 ppm in a second study, whereas there were no significant differences between the treated and the control group in 3 other studies. No increase in tumors of any type was observed in ovariectomized female Sprague-Dawley rats after 24 mo of atrazine treatment at the highest level tested, 400 ppm. Therefore, the mammary tumor response in female Sprague-Dawley rats following the administration of high levels of atrazine appears to be due to an acceleration of the normal reproductive aging process resulting in increased exposure to endogenous estrogen and prolactin. The Sprague-Dawley rat differs from the Fischer 344 rat, the CD-1 mouse, and humans in the endocrine control mechanisms affecting reproductive senescence and the development of the mammary tumors during aging. These data indicate that the carcinogenic effect of high doses of atrazine observed in the female Sprague-Dawley is a strain-, sex-, and tissue-specific response that does not have biological relevance to humans.

The mammary tumor response in triazine-treated female rats: a threshold-mediated interaction with strain and species-specific reproductive senescence.

Triazine herbicides are among the most heavily used agricultural pesticides. Although they possess a very low acute toxicity in animals, a mammary tumor response has been consistently observed in Sprague-Dawley (SD) female rats following chronic oral dosing of atrazine and simazine at and above maximum tolerated doses. However, a substantial collection of detailed research has clearly shown that triazines are not genotoxic or mutagenic, nor do they possess estrogenic agonist activity that might promote mammary tumor growth. Examination of estrous cycling records of atrazine-treated SD rats revealed a premature appearance of persistent estrous episodes, beyond the prevalent occurrence normally seen in untreated, aging SD rats. A significant correlation has been found between early or severe estrous cycle disruption of atrazine-treated rats and the early appearance of mammary tumors. In studies using SD female rats fed atrazine for 6 months, then ovariectomized and administered an estrogen-containing silastic s.c. implant, a deficient luteinizing hormone surge was observed at a 400 parts per million (ppm) dose, but not at 25 or 50 ppm. Because SD rats exhibiting persistent estrus also have a prolonged elevation of estrogen secretion, it is proposed that the triazine-associated mammary tumor response is promoted by the test animals own estrogen from ovarian follicles that fail to ovulate because gonadotropin surge sufficiency is blocked by the high dose of herbicide. It is further proposed that, because reproductive senescence in SD rats is fundamentally different from menopause in women, the animal response to dosing, as well as the enormous requisite dosing level, establishes a safety margin of very low risk to human health from this mode of action.

Teratological evaluations of atrazine technical, a triazine herbicide, in rats and rabbits.

Atrazine technical was evaluated for its embryotoxic, fetotoxic, and teratogenic potential in both rats and rabbits. The compound was orally administered at doses of 0, 10, 70, or 700 mg/kg.d to groups of rats on gestational d 6-15, while rabbits were administered doses of 0, 1, 5, or 75 mg/kg.d on gestational d 7-19. Maternal toxicity was observed at doses greater than or equal to 70 mg/kg.d in rats and at doses greater than or equal to 5 mg/kg.d in rabbits. Minor fetal effects, concurrent with maternal toxicity, were observed in rats at doses greater than or equal to 70 mg/kg.d. Among rabbits, fetal effects concurrent with severe maternal toxicity were only observed at the 75 mg/kg.d dose level. There were no adverse maternal or fetal effects in either rats or rabbits at the low dose levels. These findings indicated that pregnant rabbits were more sensitive than pregnant rats to the effects produced by atrazine technical and the compound was not teratogenic at maternally toxic dose levels in either species.

CHAPTER 66 – Symmetrical and Asymmetrical Triazine Herbicides

This chapter explores triazines chemistry and formulation, uses, and risk characterization. Triazines have been used extensively as selective herbicides in agriculture in the United States and other parts of the world for more than 35 years. The triazines inhibit photosynthesis. These inhibitors of photosynthesis include the asymmetrical triazines or triazinones, such as metribuzin and the symmetrical triazine herbicides. Mode of action of the triazine and triazinones herbicides is inhibition of photosynthetic electron transport in most plants and generally has low toxicity to animals. The chapter presents, in tabular form, the modes of action and the uses of various triazine and triazinone based chemicals. Evaluation of hazard profiles of the triazine herbicides revealed that these products are relatively nontoxic, well tolerated when administered to animals over a long duration of time, not developmental or reproductive toxins, and are neither mutagenic nor carcinogenic in mice or male rats. The chloro-s-triazines appear to produce an earlier onset or an excess of mammary tumors in female S-D rats at high doses. Because of the unique nature of reproductive aging in female S-D rats, the carcinogenic response in this strain of rat is not considered relevant for human risk assessment.