Jay Warrick

Managing evaporation for more robust microscale assays Part 1. Volume loss in high throughput assays

Evaporation is a well known issue when handling small liquid volumes. Here we present a review of microscale assays prone to evaporation and methods to make them more robust. Applications for these assays span from combinatorial chemistry to cell-biology where the stability of concentrations and osmolarity can be critical. A dimensionless evaporation number Ev is presented and used to characterize volume loss in short term and long term microscale assays. Ev can be used both as a design tool and as an analysis parameter. The advantageous use of evaporation in some applications is also discussed.

An adaptable hydrogel array format for 3-dimensional cell culture and analysis

Hydrogels have been commonly used as model systems for 3-dimensional (3-D) cell biology, as they have material properties that resemble natural extracellular matrices (ECMs), and their cell-interactive properties can be readily adapted in order to address a particular hypothesis. Natural and synthetic hydrogels have been used to gain fundamental insights into virtually all aspects of cell behavior, including cell adhesion, migration, and differentiated function. However, cell responses to complex 3-D environments are difficult to adequately explore due to the large number of variables that must be controlled simultaneously. Here we describe an adaptable, automated approach for 3-D cell culture within hydrogel arrays. Our initial results demonstrate that the hydrogel network chemistry (both natural and synthetic), cell type, cell density, cell adhesion ligand density, and degradability within each array spot can be systematically varied to screen for environments that promote cell viability in a 3-D context. In a test-bed application we then demonstrate that a hydrogel array format can be used to identify environments that promote viability of HL-1 cardiomyocytes, a cell line that has not been cultured previously in 3-D hydrogel matrices. Results demonstrate that the fibronectin-derived cell adhesion ligand RGDSP improves HL-1 viability in a dose-dependent manner, and that the effect of RGDSP is particularly pronounced in degrading hydrogel arrays. Importantly, in the presence of 70mum RGDSP, HL-1 cardiomyocyte viability does not decrease even after 7 days of culture in PEG hydrogels. Taken together, our results indicate that the adaptable, array-based format developed in this study may be useful as an enhanced throughput platform for 3-D culture of a variety of cell types.

Cellular observations enabled by microculture: paracrine signaling and population demographics.

The cellular microenvironment plays a critical role in shaping and directing the process of communication between the cells. Soluble signals are responsible for many cellular behaviors such as cell survival, proliferation and differentiation. Despite the importance of soluble signals, canonical methods are not well suited to the study of soluble factor interactions between multiple cell types. Macro-scale technology often puts cells into a convective environment that can wash away and dilute soluble signals from their targets, minimizing local concentrations of important factors. In addition, current methods such as transwells, require large numbers of cells and are limited to studying just two cell types. Here, we present data supporting the use of microchannels to study soluble factor signaling providing improved sensitivity as well as the ability to move beyond existing co-culture and conditioned medium paradigms. In addition, we present data suggesting that microculture can be used to unmask effects of population demographics. In this example the data support the hypothesis that a growth promoting subpopulation of cells exists in the mouse mammary gland.

High-throughput microfluidics: improved sample treatment and washing over standard wells

Fluid flow in microchannels is used to treat or wash samples and can be incorporated into high-throughput applications such as drug screening, which currently use standard microtiter wells for performing assays. This paper provides theoretical and experimental data comparing microchannels and standard wells on the metrics of sample washing and experimental error in treatment concentrations. It is shown numerically and experimentally that microchannel concentration can be approximated with an inverse linear relationship to input volume. The experimentally supported mathematical approximation and error propagation methods are used to compare the accuracy and precision of treatments in microchannels vs. standard wells. Mathematical results suggest microchannels can provide 10 or more times the treatment precision of standard wells for volume ratios typical of high-throughput screening. Passive-pumping and diffusion are utilized to improve microchannel accuracy and precision even further in a treat-wait-treat method. The advantages of microchannels outlined here can have large-scale effects on cost and accuracy in screening applications.

Managing evaporation for more robust microscale assays Part 2.† Characterization of convection and diffusion for cell biology‡

Cell based microassays allow the screening of a multitude of culture conditions in parallel, which can be used for various applications from drug screening to fundamental cell biology research. Tubeless microfluidic devices based on passive pumping are a step towards accessible high throughput microassays, however they are vulnerable to evaporation. In addition to volume loss, evaporation can lead to the generation of small flows. Here, we focus on issues of convection and diffusion for cell culture in microchannels and particularly the transport of soluble factors secreted by cells. We find that even for humidity levels as high as 95%, convection in a passive pumping channel can significantly alter distributions of these factors and that appropriate system design can prevent convection.

A negative selection methodology using a microfluidic platform for the isolation and enumeration of circulating tumor cells

Circulating tumor cells (CTCs) exist in the peripheral blood stream of metastatic cancer patients at rates of approximately 1 CTC per billion background cells. In order to capture and analyze this rare cell population, various techniques exist that range from antibody-based surface marker positive selection to methods that use physical properties of CTCs to negatively exclude background cells from a CTC population. However, methods to capture cells for functional downstream analyses are limited due to inaccessibility of the captured sample or labeling techniques that may be prohibitive to cell function. Here, we present a negative selection method that leverages a Microfluidic Cell Concentrator (MCC) to allow collection and analysis of this rare cell population without needing cell adhesion or other labeling techniques to keep the cells within the chamber. Because the MCC is designed to allow collection and analysis of non-adherent cell populations, multiple staining steps can be applied in parallel to a given CTC population without losing any of the population. The ability of the MCC for patient sample processing of CTCs for enumeration was demonstrated with five patient samples, revealing an average of 0.31 CTCs/mL. The technique was compared to a previously published method - the ELISPOT - that showed similar CTC levels among the five patient samples tested. Because the MCC method does not use positive selection, the method can be applied across a variety of tumor types with no changes to the process.

A Microfluidic Cell Concentrator

Cell concentration via centrifugation is a ubiquitous step in many cell culture procedures. At the macroscale, centrifugation suffers from a number of limitations, particularly when dealing with small numbers of cells (e.g., less than 50,000). On the other hand, typical microscale methods for cell concentration can affect cell physiology and bias readouts of cell behavior and function. In this paper, we present a microfluidic concentrator device that utilizes the effects of gravity to allow cells to gently settle out of a suspension into a collection region without the use of specific adhesion ligands. Dimensional analysis was performed to compare different device designs and was verified with flow modeling to optimize operational parameters. We are able to concentrate low-density cell suspensions in a microfluidic chamber, achieving a cell loss of only 1.1 ± 0.6% (SD, n = 7) with no observed loss during a subsequent cell staining protocol which incorporates ∼36 complete device volume replacements. This method provides a much needed interface between rare cell samples and microfluidic culture assays.

Pipette-friendly laminar flow patterning for cell-based assays

Laminar flow patterning (LFP) is a characteristic method of microfluidic systems that allows two (or more) different solutions to flow side-by-side in a channel without convective mixing. This fluid behavior can be used to pattern cell suspensions, particles, and treatments as well as to create chemical gradients. LFP is typically implemented using syringe pumps and, for this reason, is most effective in constant flow scenarios such as long-term gradient generation. However, the complexity of using syringe pumps for patterning cell suspensions typically makes it a less attractive option than other standard patterning methods. We present a passive microfluidic method that enables short-term LFP of multiple fluids using a single pipette and allows each sample to be loaded in any sequence, at any point in time relative to one another. The proposed method is well-suited for cell-based assays, reduces the complexity of LFP to be on a similar level as other cell patterning methods, can be scaled to include more than two streams of fluid, and enables arrays of individually addressable devices for LFP on a single chip.

Infection on a chip: a microscale platform for simple and sensitive cell-based virus assays

The plaque assay has long served as the “gold standard” to measure virus infectivity and test antiviral drugs, but the assay is labor-intensive, lacks sensitivity, uses excessive reagents, and is hard to automate. Recent modification of the assay to exploit flow-enhanced virus spread with quantitative imaging has increased its sensitivity. Here we performed flow-enhanced infection assays in microscale channels, employing passive fluid pumping to inoculate cell monolayers with virus and drive infection spread. Our test of an antiviral drug (5-fluorouracil) against vesicular stomatitis virus infections of BHK cell monolayers yielded a two-fold improvement in sensitivity, relative to the standard assay based on plaque counting. The reduction in scale, simplified fluid handling, image-based quantification, and higher assay sensitivity will enable infection measurements for high-throughput drug screening, sero-conversion testing, and patient-specific diagnosis of viral infections.

Screening the Cellular Microenvironment: A Role for Microfluidics

The cellular microenvironment is an increasingly discussed topic in cell biology as it has been implicated in the progression of cancer and the maintenance of stem cells. The microenvironment of a cell is an organized combination of extracellular matrix (ECM), cells, and interstitial fluid that influence cellular phenotype through physical, mechanical, and biochemical mechanisms. Screening can be used to map combinations of cells and microenvironments to phenotypic outcomes in a way that can help develop more predictive in vitro models and to better understand phenotypic mechanisms from a systems biology perspective. This paper examines microenvironmental screening in terms of outcomes and benefits, key elements of the screening process, challenges for implementation, and a possible role for microfluidics as the screening platform. To assess microfluidics for use in microenvironmental screening, examples and categories of micro-scale and microfluidic technology are highlighted. Microfluidic technology shows promise for simultaneous control of multiple parameters of the microenvironment and can provide a base for scaling advanced cell-based experiments into automated high-throughput formats.