Jayne S. Weiss

Ic3d Classification of Corneal Dystrophies—edition 2

Purpose: To update the 2008 International Classification of Corneal Dystrophies (IC3D) incorporating new clinical, histopathologic, and genetic information. Methods: The IC3D reviewed worldwide peer-reviewed articles for new information on corneal dystrophies published between 2008 and 2014. Using this information, corneal dystrophy templates and anatomic classification were updated. New clinical, histopathologic, and confocal photographs were added. Results: On the basis of revisiting the cellular origin of corneal dystrophy, a modified anatomic classification is proposed consisting of (1) epithelial and subepithelial dystrophies, (2) epithelial–stromal TGFBI dystrophies, (3) stromal dystrophies, and (4) endothelial dystrophies. Most of the dystrophy templates are updated. The entity “Epithelial recurrent erosion dystrophies” actually includes a number of potentially distinct epithelial dystrophies (Franceschetti corneal dystrophy, Dystrophia Smolandiensis, and Dystrophia Helsinglandica) but must be differentiated from dystrophies such as TGFBI-induced dystrophies, which are also often associated with recurrent epithelial erosions. The chromosome locus of Thiel-Behnke corneal dystrophy is only located on 5q31. The entity previously designated as a variant of Thiel-Behnke corneal dystrophy on chromosome 10q24 may represent a novel corneal dystrophy. Congenital hereditary endothelial dystrophy (CHED, formerly CHED2) is most likely only an autosomal recessive disorder. The so-called autosomal dominant inherited CHED (formerly CHED1) is insufficiently distinct to continue to be considered a unique corneal dystrophy. On review of almost all of the published cases, the description appeared most similar to a type of posterior polymorphous corneal dystrophy linked to the same chromosome 20 locus (PPCD1). Confocal microscopy also has emerged as a helpful tool to reveal in vivo features of several corneal dystrophies that previously required histopathologic examination to definitively diagnose. Conclusions: This revision of the IC3D classification includes an updated anatomic classification of corneal dystrophies more accurately classifying TGFBI dystrophies that affect multiple layers rather than are confined to one corneal layer. Typical histopathologic and confocal images have been added to the corneal dystrophy templates.

The IC3D Classification of the Corneal Dystrophies

BACKGROUND The recent availability of genetic analyses has demonstrated the shortcomings of the current phenotypic method of corneal dystrophy classification. Abnormalities in different genes can cause a single phenotype, whereas different defects in a single gene can cause different phenotypes. Some disorders termed corneal dystrophies do not appear to have a genetic basis. PURPOSE The purpose of this study was to develop a new classification system for corneal dystrophies, integrating up-to-date information on phenotypic description, pathologic examination, and genetic analysis. METHODS The International Committee for Classification of Corneal Dystrophies (IC3D) was created to devise a current and accurate nomenclature. RESULTS This anatomic classification continues to organize dystrophies according to the level chiefly affected. Each dystrophy has a template summarizing genetic, clinical, and pathologic information. A category number from 1 through 4 is assigned, reflecting the level of evidence supporting the existence of a given dystrophy. The most defined dystrophies belong to category 1 (a well-defined corneal dystrophy in which a gene has been mapped and identified and specific mutations are known) and the least defined belong to category 4 (a suspected dystrophy where the clinical and genetic evidence is not yet convincing). The nomenclature may be updated over time as new information regarding the dystrophies becomes available. CONCLUSIONS The IC3D Classification of Corneal Dystrophies is a new classification system that incorporates many aspects of the traditional definitions of corneal dystrophies with new genetic, clinical, and pathologic information. Standardized templates provide key information that includes a level of evidence for there being a corneal dystrophy. The system is user-friendly and upgradeable and can be retrieved on the website www.corneasociety.org/ic3d .

UBIAD1 Mutation Alters a Mitochondrial Prenyltransferase to Cause Schnyder Corneal Dystrophy

Background Mutations in a novel gene, UBIAD1, were recently found to cause the autosomal dominant eye disease Schnyder corneal dystrophy (SCD). SCD is characterized by an abnormal deposition of cholesterol and phospholipids in the cornea resulting in progressive corneal opacification and visual loss. We characterized lesions in the UBIAD1 gene in new SCD families and examined protein homology, localization, and structure. Methodology/Principal Findings We characterized five novel mutations in the UBIAD1 gene in ten SCD families, including a first SCD family of Native American ethnicity. Examination of protein homology revealed that SCD altered amino acids which were highly conserved across species. Cell lines were established from patients including keratocytes obtained after corneal transplant surgery and lymphoblastoid cell lines from Epstein-Barr virus immortalized peripheral blood mononuclear cells. These were used to determine the subcellular localization of mutant and wild type protein, and to examine cholesterol metabolite ratios. Immunohistochemistry using antibodies specific for UBIAD1 protein in keratocytes revealed that both wild type and N102S protein were localized sub-cellularly to mitochondria. Analysis of cholesterol metabolites in patient cell line extracts showed no significant alteration in the presence of mutant protein indicating a potentially novel function of the UBIAD1 protein in cholesterol biochemistry. Molecular modeling was used to develop a model of human UBIAD1 protein in a membrane and revealed potentially critical roles for amino acids mutated in SCD. Potential primary and secondary substrate binding sites were identified and docking simulations indicated likely substrates including prenyl and phenolic molecules. Conclusions/Significance Accumulating evidence from the SCD familial mutation spectrum, protein homology across species, and molecular modeling suggest that protein function is likely down-regulated by SCD mutations. Mitochondrial UBIAD1 protein appears to have a highly conserved function that, at least in humans, is involved in cholesterol metabolism in a novel manner.

Schnyder's dystrophy of the cornea. A Swede-Finn connection.

Schnydes crystalline dystrophy is an uncommon hereditary disease in which there is abnormal deposition of cholesterol and/or lipid usually in the anterior stroma of the central and peripheral cornea. Four families with Schnyders dystrophy have been identified in central Massachusetts. Of the 173 living members of these pedigrees, 60 patients were examined by the author. Eighteen patients had Schnyders dystrophy. Affected individuals <23 years of age had bilateral, central disc-like corneal opacification. Those >23 years of age also demonstrated prominent arcus lipoides. By age 40, all affected individuals developed a diffuse stromal haze. Only 50% of affected individuals had corneal crystalline deposits. Abnormal cholesterol deposition affected the entire stromal thickness in the majority of patients. Although the four families said that they were not related to each other, all had ancestry from towns within a 100-k area on the southwest coast of Finland. Patients in this area of Finland were examined by the author and demonstrated signs of Schnyders dystrophy. This may represent the largest cohort of Schnyders dystrophy described to date.

The Bladder Tumor Suppressor Protein TERE1 (UBIAD1)Modulates Cell Cholesterol: Implications for Tumor Progression

Convergent evidence implicates the TERE1 protein in human bladder tumor progression and lipid metabolism. Previously, reduced TERE1 expression was found in invasive urologic cancers and inhibited cell growth upon re-expression. A role in lipid metabolism was suggested by TERE1 binding to APOE, a cholesterol carrier, and to TBL2, a candidate protein in triglyceride disorders. Natural TERE1 mutations associate with Schnyders corneal dystrophy, characterized by lipid accumulation. TERE1 catalyzes menaquinone synthesis, known to affect cholesterol homeostasis. To explore this relationship, we altered TERE1 and TBL2 dosage via ectopic expression and interfering RNA and measured cholesterol by Amplex red. Protein interactions of wild-type and mutant TERE1 with GST-APOE were evaluated by binding assays and molecular modeling. We conducted a bladder tumor microarray TERE1 expression analysis and assayed tumorigenicity of J82 cells ectopically expressing TERE1. TERE1 expression was reduced in a third of invasive specimens. Ectopic TERE1 expression in J82 bladder cancer cells dramatically inhibited nude mouse tumorigenesis. TERE1 and TBL2 proteins inversely modulated cellular cholesterol in HEK293 and bladder cancer cells from 20% to 50%. TERE1 point mutations affected APOE interactions, and resulted in cholesterol levels that differed from wild type. Elevated tumor cell cholesterol is known to affect apoptosis and growth signaling; thus, loss of TERE1 in invasive bladder cancer may represent a defect in menaquinone-mediated cholesterol homeostasis that contributes to progression.

The UBIAD1 Prenyltransferase Links Menaquione‐4 Synthesis to Cholesterol Metabolic Enzymes

Schnyder corneal dystrophy (SCD) is an autosomal dominant disease characterized by germline variants in UBIAD1 introducing missense alterations leading to deposition of cholesterol in the cornea, progressive opacification, and loss of visual acuity. UBIAD1 was recently shown to synthesize menaquinone‐4 (MK‐4, vitamin K2), but causal mechanisms of SCD are unknown. We report a novel c.864G>A UBIAD1 mutation altering glycine 177 to glutamic acid (p.G177E) in six SCD families, including four families from Finland who share a likely founder mutation. We observed reduced MK‐4 synthesis by UBIAD1 altered by SCD mutations p.N102S, p.G177R/E, and p.D112N, and molecular models showed p.G177‐mutant UBIAD1 disrupted transmembrane helices and active site residues. We show UBIAD1 interacts with HMGCR and SOAT1, enzymes catalyzing cholesterol synthesis and storage, respectively, using yeast two‐hybrid screening and immunoprecipitation. Docking simulations indicate cholesterol binds to UBIAD1 in the substrate‐binding cleft and substrate‐binding overlaps with GGPP binding, an MK‐4 substrate, suggesting potential competition between these metabolites. Impaired MK‐4 synthesis is a biochemical defect identified in SCD suggesting UBIAD1 links vitamin K and cholesterol metabolism through physical contact between enzymes and metabolites. Our data suggest a role for endogenous MK‐4 in maintaining cornea health and visual acuity.

Genetic analysis of 14 families with Schnyder crystalline corneal dystrophy reveals clues to UBIAD1 protein function

Schnyder crystalline corneal dystrophy (SCCD) is a rare autosomal dominant disease characterized by progressive corneal opacification resulting from abnormal deposition of cholesterol and phospholipids. Recently, six different mutations on the UBIAD1 gene on chromosome 1p36 were found to result in SCCD. The purpose of this article is to further characterize the mutation spectrum of SCCD and identify structural and functional consequences for UBIAD1 protein activity. DNA sequencing was performed on samples from 36 individuals from 14 SCCD families. One affected individual was African American and SCCD has not been previously reported in this ethnic group. We identified UBIAD1 mutations in all 14 families which had 30 affected and 6 unaffected individuals. Eight different UBIAD1 mutations, 5 novel (L121F, D118G, and S171P in exon 1, G186R and D236E in exon 2) were identified. In four families with DNA samples from both affected and unaffected individuals, the D118G, G186R, T175I, and G177R mutations cosegregated with SCCD. In combination with our previous report, we have identified the genetic mutation in UBIAD1 in 20 unrelated families with 10 (including 5 reported here), having the N102S mutation. The results suggest that N102S may be a mutation hot spot because the affected families were unrelated including Caucasian and Asian individuals. There was no genotype phenotype correlation except for the T175I mutation which demonstrated prominent diffuse corneal haze, typically without corneal crystals. Protein analysis revealed structural and functional implications of SCCD mutations which may affect UBIAD1 function, ligand binding and interaction with binding partners, like apo E.

Accumulation of HDL Apolipoproteins Accompanies Abnormal Cholesterol Accumulation in Schnyder's Corneal Dystrophy

Schnyders corneal dystrophy is an autosomal dominant disorder that results in clouding of the central cornea and premature development of peripheral arcus in the cornea. Previous studies showed that abnormal lipid accumulation is the basis for the corneal clouding. We examined whether apolipoproteins are involved in this disorder and characterized the lipid accumulation in the central portion of corneas removed from patients with Schnyders dystrophy. Our findings show that cholesterol and phospholipid contents increased greater than 10-fold and 5-fold, respectively, in affected compared with normal corneas. In addition, the percentage of cholesterol that was unesterified (63% versus 50%) and the molar ratio of unesterified cholesterol to phospholipid (1.5 versus 0.5) were higher in affected compared with normal corneas. Large multilamellar vesicles and electron-dense granules (100 to 300 nm in diameter) as well as cholesterol crystals accumulated in the extracellular matrix of affected corneas. Immunohistochemical analysis showed that apolipoprotein constituents of HDL (apoA-I, apoA-II, and apoE), but not apoB, a marker of LDL, accumulated in the affected cornea. Western blot analysis confirmed the increased amounts of these HDL apolipoproteins in affected corneas and showed that the apparent molecular weights of the apolipoproteins were normal. Our findings show for the first time that HDL apolipoproteins accumulate in the corneas of patients with Schnyders corneal dystrophy. Thus, this disorder influences the metabolism of HDL in the corneas of these patients.

IC3D classification of corneal dystrophies.

The International Committee for Classification of Corneal Dystrophies (IC3D) has provided an update of our knowledge on corneal dystrophies. This chapter gives the summary of clinical findings, onset, course, genetics, nosology, light and electron microscopy as well as immunohistochemistry for 25 different entities included as corneal dystrophies in this survey. A category number from 1 through 4 is assigned, reflecting the level of evidence supporting the existence of a given dystrophy.

Schnyder corneal dystrophy.

Purpose of review The present review of Schnyder corneal dystrophy (SCD) corrects the misconceptions in the published literature about this disease. Understanding the clinical findings facilitates diagnosis of the dystrophy. Recent findings Retrospective case series of 115 affected individuals from 34 SCD families identified since 1989 reports the clinical findings in a large cohort and the long-term visual morbidity of SCD. The configuration of the progressive corneal clouding is predictable on the basis of age and, contrary to many older publications, only 54% of affected patients were found to have corneal crystals. Penetrating keratoplasty was reported in 20 of 37 (54%) patients of at least 50 years and 10 of 13 (77%) patients of at least 70 years. Best corrected visual acuity 1 year prior to penetrating keratoplasty in 15 eyes (nine patients) ranged from 20/25 to 20/400 including seven eyes with other ocular disorders. Best corrected visual acuity in the remaining eight eyes was 20/25 to 20/70. These patients often complained of glare preoperatively, which most likely resulted from light scattering from the corneal cholesterol. Conclusion The literature on SCD must be changed to reflect new information about the disease. When present, corneal crystals facilitate disease diagnosis but the examiner must be aware that they are only present 54% of the time. Although scotopic vision remains good until old age, disproportionate loss of photopic vision with frequent complaints of glare necessitates penetrating keratoplasty in the majority of patients over 50 years of age.